17 ms·
Why Credit Card Fraud Is Still a Thing
- stormdennis 6y agoI really wish the Krebs site rendered better on mobile browsers. It's a bit of a pain to read.
- mey 6y agoIf you are on Android, I suggest getting Firefox. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/view-articles-reader-view-firefox-android https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/view-articles-reader-vi... The article can be flipped over into Reader Mode and is easy to read in that way.
- 1ris 6y agoI suggest you don't. I switch away from firefox for this exact reason. Opera just displays the website correctly, no reader mode required. (Althoug aviable. I never use it and I think its only necessary for other browsers because their normal browsing feature is broken).
- StavrosK 6y agoDefine "correctly"? This is how both Firefox and Chrome display the site on my phone: https://imgz.org/ixAQ9mUp/ https://imgz.org/ixAQ9mUp/ That's what's "correct". If you mean that Opera forces reader mode on every site, you have an odd definition of correctness.
- 1ris 6y agoBy "correctly" I mean "doing what is indented". I feel that the ultimate goal of the user of a blog is to read it. So by "correctly" I mean readable. This is how it looks on my phone with opera: https://ibb.co/wgmNJxQ https://ibb.co/wgmNJxQ https://ibb.co/BLqwBH1 https://ibb.co/BLqwBH1 That is the correct way to display it. In contrast to Chrome, that gives this complete nonsensical output: https://ibb.co/sySqtgc https://ibb.co/sySqtgc Do you have any use for this picture? Does this have any utility to you? Because for me it does not. For me this "unreadable mode" and I don't need such a mode. If it is useful for you: How do you use this? And why?
- StavrosK 6y agoI double-tap on the text to zoom to it, which is what Opera does, or use reader mode to get an even better view of it.
- stormdennis 6y agoI am using firefox as it happens but there's no reader view on offer for that site unfortunately
- vel0city 6y agoThat's strange, on Firefox for Android v68.11.0 every article for krebsonsecurity.com can render in the reader mode. The main home page does not work for this, but individual articles work fine.
- inetknght 6y agoI really wish mobile browsers would follow better standards of user interfaces. They're a bit of a pain to use.
- lifeisstillgood 6y ago>>> BriansClub earned close to $104 million in gross revenue from 2015 to early 2019, and listed over 19 million unique card numbers for sale. 100M for selling card numbers - it actually defrauding just selling card numbers ... holy cow.
- grezql 6y agoAnd you have "Jokers stash" / jStash which is even bigger than Briansclub. Other mentions: YaleLodge UniCC Creditcard fraud is a big profiting business and has a huge ecosystem built around
- cortesoft 6y agoI wonder if the banks could save money on fraud prevention by just buying all their stolen credentials on the open market and cancelling them all. I know that would mess up with incentives to steal those credentials, but it still might be worth it.
- meowface 6y agoI believe many of them regularly do exactly that.
- marvinblum 6y agoOr, you could go for a debit card with a pin, like in good old Germany. Credit cards require artificial fraud protection just because it's literally unprotected once someone gets the details. Why is there no secret involved? Just for the few seconds it takes to enter a pin? [Edit] I'd like to add, that most German debit cards work differently from what some of you might consider a debit card. Here, the money is withdrawn from your bank account on the same day (most of the time), and you cannot go into debt. Of course, there are exceptions from this.
- amelius 6y agoAnd why not make the secret mandatory only for amounts > $THRESHOLD
- marvinblum 6y agoWell, that has become a practice already, even in countries like Germany where most people still prefer cash. I think it's < 50€ for my card, but even then I usually get asked for the pin.
- alkonaut 6y agoPin limit was raised from €20 to €40 for my card due to Corona (slightly higher risk to have fewer people touch the keypads).
- metaphor 6y agohttps://krebsonsecurity.com/all-about-skimmers/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/all-about-skimmers/ ...and if your bank happens to suck, then the loss of getting owned by one is now your problem, not theirs.
- alkonaut 6y agoDoes debit vs credit really matter? I have a pin for both my MC debit and credit cards (same with Visa earlier) and any online purchase requires 2FA (MasterCard SecureCode and VerifiedByVisa respectively). I wouldn’t make a transaction online without those 2FA measures and I wouldn’t make an in person transaction without pin. I haven’t checked actually but I assume the cards can’t be used without pin/2FA e.g if the details were leaked.
- mysterypie 6y ago> Card-not-present accounts fetched a much steeper supplier commission of 80 percent, but mainly because these cards were in such high demand and low supply. Some part of that statement doesn't make sense. Normally if something is in high demand, then it is easier to sell it, therefore the seller can demand that the middleman i.e., BriansClub, accept a lower commission. In real estate for example, when there is a lot of demand for houses (in a "sellers' market), you as a seller can easily negotiate a lower commission from your brokerage agent. One clarification: When there's high demand and low supply, the end-buyer will pay a much higher price of course. But the middleman (like BriansClub) should be charging a lower commission as a percentage, though he or she might end up making more money because it's a higher priced item being sold. So Krebs's explanation of why they charge a higher commission for card-not-present doesn't make sense.
- alextheparrot 6y agoMy reading was that the card sellers had "negotiated" (Market equilibrium) a higher commission, meaning that the card sellers do get more money (Which makes sense, as the supply/demand for what they are selling is more in their favor).
- Donthatme 6y agoI read it as [BriansClub] pays 80% of the sale to the hackers for that data.
- superhuzza 6y agoYou're getting it totally backwards here. The supplier commission is how much of the card's value BriansClub is paying to the supplier: "On average, BriansClub paid suppliers commissions ranging from 50-60 percent of the total value of the cards sold." High demand + low supply of these cards means that the suppliers are getting a better "price" when selling them to BriansClub, the middleman.
- mysterypie 6y agoYou are right, thank you. It’s a non-standard way they used the word commission.
- krimeo 6y agoNow if only we had a payment method where the account credentials (ideally these credentials would be cryptographically verified, that is, it would be possible to transfer funds only if you have access to the private key) are not disclosed to anyone and also payments would be as easy as scanning a QR code.
- bluecalm 6y agoWhen I started my business I faced the problem of charge backs after sending goods to the scammer. I've looked for what Visa and MasterCard recommends to prevent it. Their advice: "contact the buyer to make sure it's not fraud". My question was: how I am supposed to contact the buyer if it's the scammer who actually filled in the contact info form. No answer to that. One very easy step preventing most of the fraud in my case and I imagine many others would be an option to request a registered email or phone contact to the actual card owner. "Hello it's bluecalm from org X, we have noticed your order and it's marked as suspicious by our system, can you please confirm you made that order? Yes - great, we are sending you the product right now. No? Well, contact your bank as your card info was stolen". It's such an easy and obvious step. Let me contact the actual card owner using the info they provided. I think the problem is lack of incentives. It's the seller who covers the cost. At least some of it should be on card companies to encourage them to actually do something about it. Right now they seem to just not care.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoWhat CC/Merchant system do you use? Have you looked at Stripe’s anti-fraud system?
- bluecalm 6y agoShopify with PayPal and Braintree. Shopify is usually quite good at flagging transactions. The problem if there are some false positives and just cancelling every flagged order would cost too much business.
- larrik 6y agoSo last Saturday I got a brand new credit card from a brand new bank that I opened because my main credit card got compromised and I wanted a backup. Saturday evening I verify receipt of the card, and then put the card on the counter and left it there. Sunday night / Monday morning, at 1am, I get a text that the new card was compromised as someone was attempting to use it to pay some scammer. I never left the house with the card, I never typed it into a computer beyond the verification process from my own home. Wat.
- stimpson_j_cat 6y agoI got a notification that my new card was used for fraud while it was in the mail on the way to me
- whitepoplar 6y agoWhich bank?
- stimpson_j_cat 6y agoI think it was US Bank but this was some years ago
- gruez 6y agodon't cards require activation prior to use?
- stimpson_j_cat 6y agoYes! Fraud dept told me it was someone entering random numbers. What does that explain?! shrug
- whitepoplar 6y agoWhich bank is it from? Name and shame!
- 6y ago
- ohduran 6y agoI was expecting a one liner: "because banks do not lose money if fraud happens, as they simply trickle down costs to their customers".
- manuelmagic 6y agoThat's an oversimplification that's simply not true everywhere in the world.
- rob-olmos 6y agoIt'd be cool if payment cards had a built-in LCD screen for the PIN as a TOTP. That shouldn't be much harder for consumers than the existing card verification/security code.
- Symbiote 6y agoIt's not built-in, but an external device can generate an OTP (maybe a TOTP?). Some European banks have used this system for over 10 years, but others just use SMS or nothing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_Authentication_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_Authentication_Program
- dzhiurgis 6y agoWhy not use card itself as u2f? Most phones now has nfc reader now. Could be used for both - online purchases and bank logins.
- Symbiote 6y agoPerhaps the banks did't want to trust the security of the phone? Bear in mind these card readers were introduced in the UK and Sweden in 2007, around the same time as the first iPhone.
- dzhiurgis 6y agoYet literally every bank trusts the security of the phone + telco when sending you 2FA token via unencrypted SMS...
- ValentineC 6y ago> Why not use card itself as u2f? Most phones now has nfc reader now. Most budget Android phones don't, and the iPhone one is locked down. Some banks now have an in-app token. Many bank apps also have some form of jailbreak/root detection. If the detection is tripped, the app will either kill itself, or disable the in-app token.
- miketery 6y agoI think its because fraud justifies CC companies charging their fees - i.e. consumers want peace of mind, so they don't complain when CC takes 3-4% cut from merchants on transactions. If fraud was non existent then CC companies couldn't justify those fees (i.e. insurance).
- paulpauper 6y agoPpl steal Credit Cards not for the cash on the card, but for the credentials, which are used to register for services with a credit limit, and then the limit is spent. So a single credit card can be used on hundreds of services such as Amazon Cloud hosting ,Facebook ads, Google ads, etc. all without spending any money. The billing occurs only hfter the trial limit is spent. Google Ads will give a $400 credit limit on a new user.
- Alupis 6y agoI can only speak from the ecommerce industry, where you make online payments: Honestly, credit card fraud still exists because Visa/Mastercard/Amex/Discover et al have a near-zero liability for fraud. They foist it upon the merchant. It would be trivial for Visa to notice an account suddenly starts making purchases from out of the country, or exceeded some threshold of declines, etc. But, they don't care. If you, the merchant, accept a fraudulent order, even if it appears fine, you are on the hook for the chargeback + chargeback fee. Good luck winning one of these disputes - they're heavily weighed towards the customer. You practically will lose every claim, and be out all the money for the product, plus the chargeback fee. Everything can be perfect on the order, AVS, CVV2 code, etc... doesn't matter. This is why companies like Bolt Payments have sprung up - attempting to offload that risk from the merchant. They're making a business doing what Visa could do if they wanted to - pool card data together and look for illegitimate patterns, and block them.
- marcinzm 6y ago>It would be trivial for Visa to notice an account suddenly starts making purchases from out of the country, or exceeded some threshold of declines, etc. But, they don't care. I've had CC companies send me fraud alerts plenty of times and have had them block payments automatically as well. So please don't make straw man argument. Moreover, what I love when I go on a vacation to a foreign country is having my credit card stop working and trying to figure out how to make an international phone call to get it fixed. Credit card companies value improved customer experience over catching some larger percentage of fraud.
- Alupis 6y ago> So please don't make straw man argument. Your anecdata doesn't coincide with reality. Maybe your card company does - probably issued through a bank - but most people's don't, and Visa/Amex proper, etc certainly do not. You would be surprised by the number of fraudulent orders that are placed on major ecommerce sites daily. It's up to the ecommerce site to detect the fraud, and hopefully refund the order in full before a chargeback hits. Visa literally has all the transaction data for all issued Visa accounts. They can stop fraud dead, if they had a financial interest in doing so. As-is, they (and their issuers/gateways/processors) actually profit off fraud, via the chargeback fee. The millions of accounts Krebs mentions in the article? Did they all get fraud alerts when the "carding" transaction was processed on their card... to verify it was a live account and had available balance? Nope.
- StavrosK 6y agoI know I'm in the minority here, but I really really like cryptocurrency flows for this sort of thing. You open the wallet on your phone, scan a QR code, and you've paid, no need to fish for credit cards, enter additional info because your transaction looks weird, etc etc. I wish more sites supported it, and I try to support it on all of mine. I use/recommend OpenNode, though I wish they had Monero integration, but I guess everyone has their own pet cryptocurrency they'd like supported everywhere.
- iknowstuff 6y agoSee also: WeChat, Eurozone's [SCT Inst](https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-instant-credit-transfer https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-insta...), Blik
- eximius 6y agoBecause there isn't a secret required to use them? Chipped cards 'solve' physical card use fraud (assuming they actually do the crypto they can do - there was another article about it not always being enabled). If processing networks just allowed it to be easy to generate one-time codes to replace putting in CN, exp, and CVV, then online fraud would be solved too. We have the tools to solve the problem, card networks just haven't deployed them.
- noahtallen 6y agoYeah. Also, all of my chipped cards can be swiped if the merchant or network or PoS doesn’t support it. Not sure of the mechanics, but that alone seems to defeat the purpose entirely
- stmw 6y agoI am probably biased [1], but it seems that one-time credit card numbers for at least online transactions are the answer here. Chips and pins are helpful, but not for ecommerce... One way to do this is with Abine Blur (https://www.abine.com https://www.abine.com), which has a browser plugin that automatically creates a new CC number for you. [1] : co-founder of Abine
- strombofulous 6y agoHow does Abine differ from Privacy.com? I can't tell but from the pricing page I get the impression that you have to pay to use abine.
- carstenhag 6y agoSame here. Very confusing website. Also: I'm a German user and some parts of the page are randomly German, while most are English. Same on the checkout page which is a no go for me. Assets are pixelated, the page looks scammy in general.
- stmw 6y agoSorry for delay, missed the question. I'll pass on the feedback about the webpage, that's no good. In terms of comparisons, Abine Blur also does masked phone numbers, masked emails, password management and blocking tracking - in addition to masked credit cards. Here's a recent review, https://uk.pcmag.com/password-managers/38259/abine-blur-premium https://uk.pcmag.com/password-managers/38259/abine-blur-prem...
- ggm 6y agoEvery finance system that wants to remove your burdens has to arrive at a point where they ask if you permit them to do things with your money without your consent every time, or in every respect. It can be one-time or it can be repeat, but the third party actor quality here, is really strong. A ->wants money to go to -> B but money is vested through entity C and the transfer invokes entity D in front of B.. There are events here which are 'do I have your permission to do things with your money, through agents you don't know' which is really hard to remove. Even TTP intermediaries doing A <-> B introductions have this burden. It feels like its baked into the system than something 'optimising' here has '..except.. you can exploit it' baked-in.
- juancn 6y agoI still don't get why not all cards have two-factor purchases. Just have my bank or a Visa (or whatever) app send a push notification that I can approve or reject the charge.
- vinay_ys 6y agoIndia moved to chip and pin a long time ago and stopped magnetic stripe swiping soon after. And for all CNP, there's additional factor of authentication (majorly, SMS OTP from the issuing bank). These are mandated by the regulator (RBI) and everyone had to comply quite quickly. Yes, receiving SMS OTP for every CNP transaction is a hassle but for majority of the people this is the only way they have ever used cards, so they are okay with it. So, this killed the type of fraud that the author discusses. But there are other types of frauds (social engineering, ATM skimming etc) for which major defense in India is fixed rules based daily limits and mandatory SMS notifications of any deposit/withdrawal on your account. Of course it doesn't help very small account holders.
- xmprt 6y agoThat's an interesting system. Do prepaid cards work without SMS OTP? And how long do lines get if you have to wait for OTP every time you make a transaction? Lastly, are cash transactions still commonplace (almost all my transactions were cash when I was a kid)?
- ffpip 6y agoSMS OTP is only for online transactions (On the bank's website, amazon, etc) Physical Card + 4 digit PIN is at the ATM or the bank. So no long lines waiting for OTP.
- vinay_ys 6y agoFor majority of the people, cash is still the main mode of payment. A new mobile payment called UPI that supports P2P payments based on simple virtual payment handle (<yourhandle>@<pspbank>) and QR based P2M (merchant) payments is growing rapidly to replace cash. Government is giving free/basic bank account to everyone through a program called Jan Dhan Yojna. So anyone with a smartphone and a free/basic bank account or even more basic payment bank account (requires lesser kyc) can pay using UPI. (Of course KYC is still a challenge but way better than other countries due to a national biometric id system called Aadhaar and central kyc registries for financial institutions). And regulator is taking a very interesting approach to open banking through unbundling. For example, see https://sahamati.org.in https://sahamati.org.in for financial data unbundling.
- manuelmagic 6y agoI'm sorry to see how many people here on HN are commenting debit/credit card systems without really knowing the topic, spreading false notions, clichés, absolute conclusions from personal anecdotes or simply by stating easy stereotypes towards banks and financial institutions. I'm usually learning a lot from HN but I'm sad to say this discussion is full with low quality contents.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]