11 ms·
In fact, life for the US working class these days is shitty, and it’s not by accident, it’s by design. It was called the Reagan-Thatcher neoliberal consensus, a
by Animats 6y ago
In fact, life for the US working class these days is shitty, and it’s not by accident, it’s by design. It was called the Reagan-Thatcher neoliberal consensus, and it was wrapped up with lots of high-flying rhetoric about this freedom and that dynamism and those flexibilities, but you don’t have to be that cynical to see it as good old-fashioned class war. It’s obvious who’s winning.
Yes. Back in the 1970s, the working class was winning. Working class wages were going up 3x faster than CEO wages. The average employee at an auto factory could afford a house, a car, a non-working wife, a college education for his kids, and a good retirement.
That had to stop. So a plan was put together by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Supreme Court Justice Lewis Powell.[1] This is the actual memo.[2] It's worth reading. Before this, businesses did not lobby much, except over narrow issues. This got the U.S. Chamber of Commmerce into lobbying for business vs labor on a broad front, with funding from big companies.
It worked. Near total victory over union power in the private sector has been achieved in the US. The 8 hour day, the 40 hour week, and the minimum wage have been made ineffective. Funded retirement plans are history. "If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever." became national policy. Marketed as "individual rights" and "opportunity", of course.
[1] https://billmoyers.com/content/the-powell-memo-a-call-to-arms-for-corporations/ https://billmoyers.com/content/the-powell-memo-a-call-to-arm...
[2] https://d1uu3oy1fdfoio.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/Lewis-Powell-Memo.pdf https://d1uu3oy1fdfoio.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/201...
- whymauri 6y ago>Marketed as "individual rights" and "opportunity", of course. This is what happens when the concept of "individual rights" is directly substituted for the "individual right to choose what you consume" without any regard for any other individual rights, even those which are supposedly hallmarks of the U.S. like voting rights. The more I think about this, the more I'm reminded of Chomsky's Manufacturing Consent.
- amatecha 6y agoPrecisely... for example, how about the right to privacy? It feels practically non-existent in North America (not so sure about elsewhere). As far as I've observed, it's essentially ignored in the vast majority of situations, to the degree that people treat you like you're paranoid if you even raise the subject.
- josephg 6y agoIf you want to learn more, I really enjoy listening to Mark Blyth talking about the history of this stuff. He's really funny and has an incredible amount of knowledge and data to tell the story. I think its too simplistic to say the system we had before Reagan/Thatcher was Good and the system now is Bad. But we are definitely seeing the shadow of the neoliberal capitalist system hurt people. And causing large scale social unrest, economic uncertainty, a generational wealth gap, and so on. Apparently some people are angry enough about the whole thing to vote for Trump just to get the neoliberals out of the white house. And of course, the democratic process should be forcing the government to correct course, but there's been so much capture by lobbyists and wealthy donors that its absolutely failing the people its supposed to serve. Occupy Wall Street, the 2009 economic crash, etc seemed to have no lasting impact on economic policy. This whole situation seems so central to the current economic and political situation - I don't understand why nobody knows and talks about this stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGuaoARJYU0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGuaoARJYU0
- entropea 6y agoMark Blyth is great and he's humorous. I really like his quick history of US neoliberalism. https://youtu.be/8rxrjhWTdv8 https://youtu.be/8rxrjhWTdv8
- arethuza 6y agoPeople tend to have a rather skewed memory for the Thatcher years in the UK - they weren't a time of any unusual growth in GDP: https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/gdp-growth-annual https://tradingeconomics.com/united-kingdom/gdp-growth-annua...
- DogOfTheGaps 6y agoI watched the whole video. Excellent stuff. Thanks for posting.
- mleonhard 6y agoThanks for sharing those articles. The [1] article says that business lobbying and campaign contributions ramped up in the 1970s as a response to the Labor movement. The advent of television meant that politicians could spend money to get elected. This shifted power to Business groups, who could out-spend the Labor groups.
- rmrfstar 6y agoAlan Greenspan, the economic "Godfather" of this era, viewed growing working insecurity as a positive development and expressed dismay that it may not continue indefinitely [1]. EDIT: Removed suggestion that Greenspan publicly expressed a specific intent to foster worker insecurity. [1] https://chomsky.info/20120508/ https://chomsky.info/20120508/ [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/hh/1997/february/testimony.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/hh/1997/february/te...
- shuckles 6y agoFWIW, the quote and interpretation as presented in your link is rated a “pants on fire” lie by Politifact: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2014/jul/21/facebook-posts/social-media-meme-says-alan-greenspan-said-insecur/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2014/jul/21/facebook-p...
- rmrfstar 6y agoFair point. Chomsky has a tendency to exaggerate, but it's a difference of degree. "Continued low levels of inflation and inflation expectations have been a key support for healthy economic performance...Looking ahead, the members of the FOMC expect inflation to remain low and the economy to grow appreciably further. However, as I shall be discussing, the unusually good inflation performance of recent years seems to owe in large part to some temporary factors, of uncertain longevity... Atypical restraint on compensation increases has been evident for a few years now and appears to be mainly the consequence of greater worker insecurity... The low level of work stoppages of recent years also attests to concern about job security. " [1] It is telling that Politifact left out that last sentence in its analysis of Chomsky's statement. [1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/hh/1997/february/testimony.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/hh/1997/february/te...
- shuckles 6y ago"Insecurity" in that quote is describing a perception on the part of workers which, the quote discusses, doesn't seem to be validated by actual job market data. In particular, Greenspan is offering it as a reason why there isn't as much wage inflation given the relative tightness of the labor market. He says workers aren't changing jobs to capture increases because they'd rather stay put. It's worth asking why workers felt insecurity when the statistics suggested there shouldn't be any. A related, worthy question is why increasingly lower unemployment rates in the 90s (and even the 2010s) didn't show up in the Phillips Curve predicted increase in wages. My read of this quote is Greenspan speculating at an answer. I don't know if it's correct. I don't even know if economists today agree on an answer. In any case, he certainly doesn't seem to be cheering for precarity.
- shuckles 6y agoYou are making extremely strong claims with fairly weak evidence. The memo is a call to action for businesses to _catch up_ to the large lobbying influence created and wielded by unions in the 60s. As someone who moved to America to flee a totally barren economy run by labor unions, I am glad the business groups were able to rise to the challenge here. I simply don’t read the same vast conspiracy in the memo that you imply. In the early 70s, left-affiliated groups like SDS and Weathermen were probably producing internal organizing notes that read as equally self interested and myopic. Another weakness in your grand theory is that across housing, cars, single incomes, and retirement, many of the affordability concerns have just as much to do with non-corporate organizing as corporate organizing. Since when did the Fortune 500 coordinate to jack up tuition? Which S&P companies run local planning boards? Low income households in other countries can afford decent housing stock and higher education. Corporations aren’t the reason our low income residents can’t. As a quick point, this isn’t a mere matter of a shrunken state either, since our government spending as a % of GDP has steadily risen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_Uni...
- elygre 6y agoOut of curiosity, which “barren economy run by labor unions” do you speak of?
- shuckles 6y agoI would rather not say because it'll spur an entire subthread arguing over whether the root cause was unions, state corruption, foreign intervention, or any other host of plausible (or not) theories. I will concede that other people may explain that country's economic failures differently than I do. However, my view is not a fringe one, and since I have left, decreasing worker power has been correlated with a period of relative growth for the middle class.
- ido 6y agoI've made the jump in the other direction: from an almost-US-style hyper-capitalist country to relatively social democratic countries (first Austria then Germany) & my life here is astonishingly better than in my country of origin (level of economic development is similar, in fact I'd probably be earning more in the country I was born in while paying lower taxes). So whose anecdotal evidence do we take, yours or mine?
- zozbot234 6y ago> That had to stop. So a plan was put together ... Others have already addressed these specific claims, and I'll add that this whole way of thinking (where anything and everything is the outcome of shady "plans" being hatched somewhere) does not generally lead to a good understanding of social problems. But this is not to say that progress in working-class compensation hasn't clearly stalled since the 1970s. Part of the issue is of course that a lot of that putative income has been offset by the huge increase in healthcare and education costs. And that's probably something where policy interventions are warranted, if only to reduce existing market distortions that put consumers at a huge disadvantage.
- chii 6y ago> offset by the huge increase in healthcare and education costs These costs increase to the maximum amount the individual is willing to sacrifice to obtain these services. Because they are inelastic services - you cannot substitute healthcare. You can barely substitute education (esp. tertiary). And there's not a lot of economy of scale with these services, which makes it hard to lower the cost in competition (if there's even any).
- WalterBright 6y ago> you cannot substitute healthcare You can. For every health condition, there are a wide range of options varying in cost, efficacy, risk, time and pain. I recently went to the doctor over a problem I have, and got a rather broad array of options. I decided the risks of each option were worse than the problem, and decided to live with it. The notion that there is a one-to-one mapping of problem-to-solution is incorrect.
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> You can. For every health condition, there are a wide range of options varying in cost, efficacy, risk, time and pain. Broadly speaking: if you experience dire medical trauma — say you have a heart attack or get in a bad car accident — you need emergency care or you’ll probably die. If you have cancer, you need to treat it or you’ll die. If a vital organ stops working, you need to find a functional replacement or you’ll die. You may have multiple options for treatment, or you may not. But for many health conditions, the choice is ultimately binary: treat your ailment or die. That sounds to me like a service that cannot be substituted.
- qznc 6y agoHere is a recent discussion about "WTF Happened in 1971?" There are quite a few different opinions. https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMotte/comments/hyh565/wtf_happened_in_1971/.compact https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMotte/comments/hyh565/wtf_happen...
- simonh 6y agoI see this quite differently. Yes returns on capital have blown up, while working and middle class incomes have stalled. This is a real issue and is driving a lot of problems across the developed world. I just think the factors behind this are somewhat different from the usual class war rhetoric - on both sides. I think the first effect is the introduction of hundreds of millions of workers in developing countries. China obviously, but also South Korea, Taiwan, also India particularly in financial and IT services. This has created a lot of downward pressure on labour prices in the developed world. I think another effect is the property market sweeping up huge swathes of individual wealth and income. By and large there's a limited stock of desirable property. We all need a place to live, and when we have families and children we want the best home we can afford for them and us. That means increasing proportions of our wages have been spent in a bidding war against each other over the available housing. Certainly here in the UK this is a huge problem. Massive state subsidies to help new home owners get into property has just exacerbated the problem, hugely inflating the price of low and mid level housing particularly. Preferential tax treatment of property investments (in the UK anyway) also encouraged huge numbers of people to invest in property and become landlords. I'm no economist so maybe I'm overestimating these shifts because I've seen and felt the effect of these factors personally, but I'm convinced they're having a considerable impact. On developing world labour I'm not sure much can be done about that, these people deserve jobs as much as anyone. I think things will even out though, I go to China regularly and wage growth over there has been staggering. As for property prices, it's about time we took a close look at the tax treatment of whats essential rental income and also inheritances. I think there's a shift needed favouring income from labour over capital. Don't get me wrong, I'm a thoroughgoing capitalist, but there's an imbalance there that needs redressing without resorting to class war eat the rich crap.
- WalterBright 6y agoYou're right that governmental attempts to artificially make things more affordable ends up blowing up the costs. For example in the US, education and health care. Prices for things with no government subsidy or interference have dropped to essentially zero - like software.
- 6y ago
- bluedino 6y ago>> Back in the 1970s, the working class was winning. On the other hand, There was a heroin epidemic, crime was skyrocketing, white flight was draining our cities of tax dollars, pollution was terrible, we had lines for gasoline Not to mention US engineering and manufacturing started to decline. American started getting lazy and Japan started entering markets with superior products, soon to be followed by China and Mexico, ready to pounce with cheaper alternatives.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe 2010s/20s had an opioid epidemic - funded by big pharma, so that's okay, I guess. Today corporate crime is endemic (ask the people involved in Greek bonds and 1MDB.) 500,000 people are bankrupted by the health care system every year, carbon pollution is literally endangering the entire planet, the US has some of the lowest educational standards and poorest social mobility in the developed world, and the US establishment solution to a relatively straightforward health threat like Coronavirus is an ongoing fiasco. And... the lines for gasoline were caused by OPEC constraints on gasoline, not by feckless poor people agitating for their rights.
- newacct583 6y ago... Are you blaming labor unions for the oil embargo?
- ChrisLomont 6y ago> Back in the 1970s, the working class was winning The working class today has higher wages and a higher quality of life. If you’re a woman or any kind of minority, things are vastly better for you than in the 1970s. If you’re skilled, things are vastly better for you. Unskilled white man labor was going to decline no matter what Reagan and Thatcher did as computers and automation changed production across the world.
- dillonmckay 6y agoSo, requiring two adult humans in a single household to work to be able to live comfortably, whereas before required only one, that is progress?
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoIf you want to live with the same standard of living as in the 1970s, it doesn't require two people to work.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoThe percent of one person households has nearly doubled since the 1970s, so the increasing household income is even more impressive. Your belief is opposite reality. https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2019/comm/one-person-households.html https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2019/comm/one-...
- ajuc 6y agoWow this memo reads like a caricature.
- christophilus 6y agoI read the first 15 pages of the memo, and have to run to a meeting. I don’t think it’s the slam dunk you think it is. I largely agree with it, knowing what I do about the US in the 1970s. It may be that the system has swung too far in favor of corporations. Certainly, today’s wealth inequality is destabilizing and needs to be addressed. But that memo, by and large, seems reasonable to me.
- specialist 6y agoThis history of the Business Roundtable blew my mind. It's among Caro's The Power Broker and Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States for clarity and myth busting. Lobbying America: The Politics of Business from Nixon to NAFTA https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17942038-lobbying-america https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17942038-lobbying-americ... "Lobbying America" tells the story of the political mobilization of American business in the 1970s and 1980s. Benjamin Waterhouse traces the rise and ultimate fragmentation of a broad-based effort to unify the business community and promote a fiscally conservative, antiregulatory, and market-oriented policy agenda to Congress and the country at large. Arguing that business's political involvement was historically distinctive during this period, Waterhouse illustrates the changing power and goals of America's top corporate leaders. Examining the rise of the Business Roundtable and the revitalization of older business associations such as the National Association of Manufacturers and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Waterhouse takes readers inside the mind-set of the powerful CEOs who responded to the crises of inflation, recession, and declining industrial productivity by organizing an effective and disciplined lobbying force. By the mid-1970s, that coalition transformed the economic power of the capitalist class into a broad-reaching political movement with real policy consequences. Ironically, the cohesion that characterized organized business failed to survive the ascent of conservative politics during the 1980s, and many of the coalition's top goals on regulatory and fiscal policies remained unfulfilled. The industrial CEOs who fancied themselves the "voice of business" found themselves one voice among many vying for influence in an increasingly turbulent and unsettled economic landscape. Complicating assumptions that wealthy business leaders naturally get their way in Washington, "Lobbying America" shows how economic and political powers interact in the American democratic system."