6 ms·
The point is that if they administered tests daily at the daily capacity for testing (24h result turnaround) then many people who want to be tested would be tur
by sneak 6y ago
The point is that if they administered tests daily at the daily capacity for testing (24h result turnaround) then many people who want to be tested would be turned away, and become aware immediately of the testing bottlenecks.
It’s a form of bufferbloat.
I sometimes wonder how many fewer USians would have died in this pandemic had it occurred outside of an election year.
- maxerickson 6y agoDo you think the election being this year is the important parameter in how many people have died unnecessarily in the US?
- enraged_camel 6y agoThere should be zero doubt about it. Republicans are desperate to have the economy going again only because it is such a strong factor in elections. As Bill Clinton famously said, "it is the economy, stupid." (Indeed, the economy is the only issue/criteria in which Biden still trails Trump in polls, but even that margin has been decreasing.) This relentless push to reopen things has resulted in many, many more deaths.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIf true, this would mean that Republican senators and governors who aren't up for reelection in 2020 should be strongly pro-shutdown. Is that the pattern we're seeing?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- unnamed76ri 6y agoConsidering that most of the deaths are among the elderly population who tend to vote republican, that doesn’t make much sense. Unless you want to get really cynical and say there was a political motive in Democrat governors for sending positive patients into nursing homes and causing most of those deaths...
- alkonaut 6y agoI believe it's definitely a parameter. Not related to testing, but related to how an administration weighs short term economic goals to human lives.
- maxerickson 6y agoYes, my question admits that it is inevitably a factor. But the incompetent response was incompetent because it was incompetent, not because a sensible electoral strategy was pursued ahead of pandemic control. As things play out, responding incompetently and saying nice things about the economy looks like a really bad strategy through the electoral lens.
- alkonaut 6y ago> But the incompetent response was incompetent because it was incompetent, not because a sensible electoral strategy was pursued ahead of pandemic control. I don’t think this is an either/or situation. If incompetence and corruption is on the menu this administration seems to always take two scoops, one of each.
- makomk 6y agoI don't think there's any need for a deliberate conspiracy here; hard capping the number of tests at exactly the daily capacity would require quite complicated real-time feedback between the multiple sites taking samples and the labs processing them, and would be worse in that it couldn't prioritize cases which need test results most urgently. This problem isn't unique to the US either; back when the press in other countries was pointing to Germany's testing program as proof their country was falling behind, I even had a conversation with a German on here who was convinced their testing was the failure because of similar delays.
- maxerickson 6y agoPeople would be mad about it, but it would be reasonably straightforward to discard samples that were not urgent (so that testing for urgent samples remained prompt and available). There also seem to be some utilization problems. Some folks I know got tested after 1 person had enough symptoms. The person with symptoms got sampled several days before 3 other people and got their result last, probably because of which lab was used.
- sneak 6y agoIt wouldn't need to be hard-capped, just something less than the runaway "collect as many samples as there are test subject arrivals" now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- threatripper 6y ago> I sometimes wonder how many fewer USians would have died in this pandemic had it occurred outside of an election year. The time to judge the different strategies has not come yet. At the least, we need to wait until the pandemic is over and the counts are in. I don't trust any count until somebody takes a good look at the excess mortality. Right now it's just way too easy to manipulate the numbers in any direction until your hospitals overflow (and even then, the press might not report it). The real case numbers may be off by a factor of below 2 or over 10 and immunity in the population may already exist due to other corona viruses or maybe not, we don't know yet. Other counties which seem to be doing very well until now may still fail horribly. The economic impact may play out in vastly different ways. Currently it seems that hard containment is the best strategy but it requires coordination in a large area and high compliance in the population. In a few months, the vaccine could be available any day and it might work perfectly or very poorly.
- lostlogin 6y ago> counties which seem to be doing very well until now may still fail horribly Sweden was an example of this, but Australia is looking a bit sketchy now and us next door in New Zealand are feeling a little uncomfortable.
- threatripper 6y agoSweden seems to get it under control now. Cases and deaths are falling quickly. In the beginning they made some big mistakes (in retrospect) but now the strategy seems to work (for now at least, we will see in a few months when the people get tired and want to return to normal life). OZ has a problem. NZ is in a similar situation as VN where a local transmission appeared today without known infection chain. It only takes one error and you're back to square 1.
- lostlogin 6y ago> NZ is in a similar situation as VN where a local transmission appeared today without known infection chain. It only takes one error and you're back to square 1. Could you clarify this? I wasn't aware of any local transmission for months but I suspect an 'if' is missing from your sentence. I think that a full breakout takes a lot more than one error and it requires a whole chain of them and a lot of systems to fail. We have had errors like this. The battle now seems to be keeping those quarantine contained. There are near daily escape attempts and some are going to public places or covering significant distances.