16 ms·
Smartphone contact tracing has failed everywhere
- CivBase 6y ago"Contact tracing" was the new "blockchain" for a while. It is a technology with great potential, but I don't expect a truely effective, well-designed solution to be deployed at a large enough scale to be useful for years to come. I think it will eventually mature enough to be useful for future outbreaks - even for more benign disease. For now, though, I want to see the technology spend a little more time in the oven.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoReally? “Future outbreaks” of other diseases? You’re just going to go along with this? When they tell you there are completely new magical viruses that came from a feral iguana farting in a restaurant kitchen in Malaysia, you’re just going to believe that too? It still won’t occur to you that the virus was made in a lab to coerce you into accepting a new form of slavery? People like you need to be killed. I’m not joking. You narrative-perpetuating morons are more dangerous than anything else in the world right now. Anyone here with children they care about would certainly agree with me. Tell us your full name and home address.
- azinman2 6y agoDo you actually have specific criticisms or is this just a vague feeling? To say it’s not well thought out is a baseless accusation.
- CivBase 6y agoI don't think it's poorly thought out. I just think the tech is immature and the current incarnations will have to quickly improve or be superceded by something significantly better in the next few years.
- m3kw9 6y agoKorea did this successfully but you have to give up a lot more privacy. This protect my privacy, and expecting it to work great is some fallacy.
- bad_user 6y agoMaybe, but privacy is worth protecting, more than ever.
- andybak 6y agoOver lives?
- cheez 6y agothink of the children argument
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThis is the same argument as justifying the NSA's mass surveillance with terrorism. Because lives are involved, it's propagated like a killer argument. Fact is, you don't know if even worse things aren't going to be enabled with this technology.
- sanxiyn 6y agoCell location is already available to criminal investigation by law enforcement agency under warrant. It's a simple matter of legislating to make it available to epidemic investigation by health agency under warrant-like procedure. South Korea made such law after 2015 MERS epidemic. It does not enable NSA-like mass surveillance. Just do it now, so you can use it the next time.
- closeparen 6y agoAn important part of the NSA problem is that terrorist conspiracies are a largely imaginary boogeyman. The vast majority of its collection is unwarranted. But the pandemic is real, we know that the damage it does is directly related to the effectiveness of contact tracing, and we know that anyone having contacts outside the household is doing an unusual and extremely dangerous thing. This is more like tailing people who buy bombs and visit crowded public places with them.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoContact tracing has unfortunately also failed as in "is buggy": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23947323 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23947323 To be clear, I've installed the tracing app, having the idea that it can only help to isolate hotspots, which however is mainly the health authorities' task. And 16+ million downloads (of how many eligible smartphone owners?) in Germany still makes Corona Warn-App a chart breaker I guess.
- Lammy 6y agoGood. Why are people suddenly okay with building likely-permanent surveillance systems for temporary outbreaks? How would Apple ever reasonably remove this feature?
- jmull 6y agoWell, the Apple/Google mechanism is not useful for surveillance.
- cecja 6y agoWell all the nutjobs like the OP pretending it is not doesn't help the system as well.
- Lammy 6y agoIt’s optional and opt-in now. Do you trust it to stay that way once the framework is in 99% of people’s pocket? I sure don’t.
- andybak 6y agoYes I do - because everybody is watching. This feels like a "slippery slope" argument. If so then I would argue the situation demands us to take a small step further towards the start of the slope.
- cfmcdonald 6y agoIt doesn't matter, the technology doesn't provide any means for central tracking.
- jmull 6y agoIf Apple or Google are going to introduce a non-optional surveillance mechanism into their devices, there’s no particular need to build it off of their contact tracing platform. You’re thinking the contact tracing platform somehow paves the way for an actual surveillance system, but it doesn’t. If they want to build a surveillance system then they will, and the success/failure/adoption rate of their contact tracing platform won’t affect that at all.
- tehabe 6y agoIf the German app would have been less privacy aware, it wouldn't even had 16 million downloads in Germany. The decentralised approach was and is the only one which at least worked a little bit.
- sanxiyn 6y agoVery wrong. Smartphone contact tracing is successful. (e.g. in South Korea.) It's only decentralised smartphone contact tracing that failed.
- njarboe 6y ago"Only draconian access to personal data, as used in South Korea, seems to have brought any positive results." The article quickly glosses over this fact (and leaves out Taiwan) and labels this successful system for stopping COVID-19 spread as draconian. I imagine that the NSA/CIA/FBI already has such a system in place that maybe it would just needs to get scaled up to cover everyone in the US. It's too bad the people in the US can't trust their government to ramp up and use such a tool to stop COVID-19 and then shut down the system afterwords. The Patriot Act proved that once given special powers any limited time provisions just keep getting extended forever. Some people born after 9/11 are adults at this point.
- salimmadjd 6y ago> the reliability of distance estimates using Bluetooth signal attenuation Take a look NOVID [0] the app CMU professor and graduate students built. It uses ultrasound to be accurate within 1m. It also approaches the utility of contact tracing in a completely different way. [0] https://www.novid.org/ https://www.novid.org/
- neuronic 6y agoMust be just lovely for pets at home or is it outside of the frequencies that cats can hear (up to 79 kHz)? Also this thread is filled with people complaining about bluetooth spying capabilities and now you post an app with bluetooth always on AND microphone always listening?
- poshenloh 6y agoThanks for asking. I'm the founder of NOVID. Our app has a pet mode if your pet does not like it. This doesn't seem to have been a problem. The microphone is also not always listening. It turns on for 2 seconds when needed. The complete app source code has been given to a university security research team for review, and they will see that the microphone is used only for its intended purpose: to process ultrasonic frequencies.
- michelledepeil 6y agoOut of curiosity, why not make the app source-available?
- poshenloh 6y agoThank you for sharing this. I'm the founder of NOVID. The problem has been that no other app provided direct value to the user. Other apps are designed to protect other people from you if you get exposed (they then tell you to isolate to protect others). NOVID directly protects you from others, by anonymously warning you of COVID's approach along your relationship network. This reversal of incentives is critical. On top of that, NOVID also actually demonstrates the necessary accuracy to function. It is the only app which dares to report estimated distances to every user on their screen. We are trying as hard as we can to let people know about these two major points of differentiation from the rest of the contact tracing app space. Thank you for helping!
- unholythree 6y agoThere has to be a clever way of doing this that isn’t super invasive. Having businesses record their customers and retain the only copy seems like a good compromise except something like personal phone numbers would be abused. Maybe best would be something identifiable only to the authorities but recorded and held only by businesses. Something like driver’s license date of issuance and first name. In theory that would be meaningless to my local coffee shop or grocer; but if I tested positive contact tracers could go there and get that info (maybe just the day of my visit, or afternoon, etc.) and then correlate and contact others who visited during that time.
- sanxiyn 6y agoSouth Korea already solved this problem: https://www.zdnet.com/article/south-korea-to-use-qr-codes-to-contain-covid-19/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/south-korea-to-use-qr-codes-to... There is QR code provider and QR code scanner. QR code provider includes Naver (Google in South Korea) and Kakao (WhatsApp in South Korea). QR code scanner is mandatory at venues. QR code is a random UUID. Venues keep UUID (but do not know real world identity), providers keep UUID-to-identity mapping (but do not know real world activity), KCDC gets feed from both venues and providers, join them, and do the contact tracing. In particular, it is legally mandated that only KCDC can do the join.
- neuronic 6y agoAsia has solved a lot of the issues surrounding the pandemic months ago. While American and European economies will be crushed by Corona (it's I bet it's not even half time) due to conspiracy theories, ignorance and egoists and adult babies crying about wearing a mask, Asia is getting back to ramp up their economies. They are far more capable of shutting new clusters down AND CONTROL IT. When we send people into quarantine in the West, we plea for them to stay home and everything is trust based because we want to keep our free society. Effectively, only very large local outbreak cases enjoy oversight by authorities. Taiwan's pandemic game was on point before WHO finally let the rest of the world know about what has been suppressed in China for weeks if not months. Due to China's pressure they aren't part of WHO or UN and had no "official" global way to tell the rest of the world. They did, but were dismissed due to the massive hubris in the West and the geopolitical game China is playing. SARS 1 is still on everyone's mind in Asia while many Americans outright deny Corona's existence even in July 2020. It's nuts.
- raverbashing 6y agoYou don't want to install a tracing app for "privacy reasons" fine. Just make sure you don't have any of: Google's location history turned on, any FB app (FB/Instagram/Whatsapp), TikTok, 4sq/swarm, Tinder, Happn, or any app that has fine-grained location permissions.
- danilocesar 6y agoThis! "I care so much about my privacy!!!1!!1 - Sent from my android phone. " go figure...
- Avamander 6y agoAh yes, the waterproof "some bad things are happening, it must mean that this other bad thing happening is also fine"-argument. "Most people infect their devices with malware from the internet, let's all preinstall malware to every device because it has the same end result."
- raverbashing 6y ago> Ah yes, the waterproof "some bad things are happening, it must mean that this other bad thing happening is also fine"-argument. Ah yes the good strawman fallacy argument Funny how the contact tracing app requires no special permissions. None. Every extra data is completely optional. Sure it is your choice to not install the C.T. app and install other data-hoarding apps but know what you're doing.
- Avamander 6y ago> Ah yes the good strawman fallacy argument It isn't, that's literally what you said. That we should be okay with contact tracing if we have anything else that uses the fine-grained location permission.
- loraa 6y agoIt's not for now. It's for the future. At least we are figuring out how to build better oppression.
- starbugs 6y agoDid I miss something or are low adoption rates and bluetooth issues the only indicators that decentralized tracking has failed, as pointed out in the article? The lack of statistics about success/failure otherwise seems to imply more of a "we don't know for sure"?
- DangitBobby 6y agoSpecifically, it seems that adoption rates are so low as to render the application nearly useless.
- makomk 6y agoYeah, the overall conclusion is that smartphone contact tracing probably isn't working, but we can't know for sure because the megacorps who designed it did so in such a way that makes it almost impossible to measure if it's actually working. The only app we know has definitely been ineffective is Australia's centralized solution, in large part because they do actually have the ability to collect statistics on its effectiveness. We do also know that Germany's app was just outright failing to send alerts to users of many common, popular devices due to limitations on background tasks: https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-coronavirus-tracing-app-criticized-over-warning-failures/a-54305099 https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-coronavirus-tracing-app-criti... Obviously there's no way to know exactly how many people should've been sent a warning and weren't either, by design.
- zepto 6y agoIt’s trivial to tell whether it’s working with some ordinary surveys and research. No “megacorps” have done anything to make it impossible.
- anonytrary 6y agoIt's just like mask usage -- nearly useless unless a critical number of people are wearing them.
- 6y ago
- aboringusername 6y agoThis is looking at it from a technological angle. However, what about the social/financial aspects? If I am told to self isolate for any duration of time, will the government provide 100% of my lost wages? Will they support businesses who could be put in real trouble from someone having time off? What about potential repeated cases of isolation? Most people (including myself) will do anything to avoid being on their radar, and will not cooperate under any circumstance due to the reality that losing money is simply not an option for me, or my employers (where I could be replaced within a day, and that's my job gone). Sadly, most governments haven't got well thought out policies, thus reducing the potential pool of users who'd engage with contact tracing (whether done via smartphone or manual like the UK). We desperately need a UBI, for everyone, every month, forever, regardless of status (though, if you earn over a certain amount I'd agree with limiting the UBI, like for million/billionaires). Otherwise, as we saw recently, someone infected over 70 people because she didn't isolate, because she needs food and a roof, it was a case of infect people (and risk them dying) or...dying because she can't afford rent/basics? Yeah...This pandemic has exposed that capitalism is fucked, and during the worst virus outbreak this century there's no support for those that need it. Even if I wanted to isolate, I couldn't afford to. Therefore I cannot comply with any contact tracing efforts.
- azinman2 6y agoAll of this is true if you test positive with or without an app. The app helps you know you might be asymptomatic and spreading it to people that you know or don’t know, who can then die from it or otherwise be seriously injured.
- richk449 6y agoClassic collective action problem. For a while, China was paying people who tested positive as a solution.
- euix 6y agoIf you have google maps installed on your phone and location turned on, every time you visit a restaurant you already get the message of "how did you like xyz, please rate and help other visitors" You are already living in a surveillance state. The difference is unlike in other places in the world you can complain and shout about it.
- sanxiyn 6y agoAnother difference is that you aren't using this data (which are collected anyway) to contain the epidemic. I can't figure out why.
- nomel 6y agoMy hopeful guess is that their APIs and policies make the data impossible to access in anything but an aggregated format.
- IX-103 6y agoIt has to be policy. If they only had aggregate data, they couldn't do the whole timeline thing. They did release some results on peoples' movement patterns during the pandemic "lockdown" (https://www.google.com/covid19/mobility/ https://www.google.com/covid19/mobility/).
- petre 6y agoThey don't have the X is infected part and the data is also aggregated.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoAt least for now, I also have the choice to not have Google Maps on my phone and keep location disabled, which I do. So there's definitely room for things to get worse.
- bluedispatcher 6y agoJust because you chose to sacrifice your privacy for convenience doesn't mean it should become a baseline for what we expect. Especially nor for government services.
- jt2190 6y agoIgnoring the headline, it seems like the article equates quick, widespread adoption of these apps as “success”, and anything else as “failure”. Although it does note: > Conventional contact tracing methods also haven’t been faring well. Despite this, it doesn’t even bother to identify the many reasons tracing apps might not be widely adopted yet, in particular privacy concerns (although it does mention that “draconian” approaches are the only ones proven to work so far, as if that proves that privacy respecting approaches can’t be useful at all.) Even more fundamental than privacy, though, is do people even know that these apps exist? Personally I’ve only heard some rumblings about the Google/Apple api, and not much more, and I’m guessing I’m far more aware of the existence of these apps than many people. Ultimately, it’s far too early to declare “failure” on this front. Edit: According to 9to5 Mac, there are still no apps in the U.S. using the Apple/Google API as of June 18. https://9to5mac.com/2020/05/19/how-to-turn-on-off-covid-19-contact-tracing-iphone-ios/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/05/19/how-to-turn-on-off-covid-19-c...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe vision of smartphone tracing apps in April was that they were going to be a cheap and low-manpower silver bullet for contact tracing. If all they represent is a slow, limited, and mildly effective supplement to normal contact tracing, I don't think they're worth the privacy concerns in the first place.
- azinman2 6y agoThe privacy concerns were addressed in the design of the frameworks.
- hrktb 6y agoDuring the lockdown people were paying close attention to news and gov. got all the attention it wanted. In particular for France, regulations were passed to allow or deny activities, set curfew etc. with hefty fines associated, all of that at a few days notice at most. So, not closely following the news was not an option, and the tracing app got plenty of air time. Now, it came after a month or two of bullshit from the health dept (“you don’t need masks, also go vote in person, it’s fine”), which itself came after half a year of protests against the gov, so most people weren’t sold on gov’s good intents on not abusing the app, especially as Apple/Google’s privacy focused solution was not adopted.
- quicklime 6y agoI'm surprised this isn't mentioned in the article or any comments, and I'm wondering whether I'm missing something about the significance of this. But I thought the biggest problem was that Google and Apple didn't build a contract tracing app - they built a framework for local governments to build apps on top of. This leaves the work of marketing the app and driving adoption to each government (as well as building and operating the service, which is also significant). When I first heard about this, I thought they were going to build a pair of apps for Android and iOS. It would come as part of an OTA update, and everyone around the world would be presented with a yes/no dialog asking whether they wanted to participate. Local governments would then be provided access to a SaaS that would let their contact tracers enter the tokens of known positive cases. I'm fairly sure that this would've resulted in significantly higher adoption rates. I have no idea what the point was, to require every government build/market/operate their own version of the exact same app. Maybe so that the backends could be independent? If so, I imagine there would be other ways to work around that, like offering a cloud service and/or an open source backend implementation for governments to self-host.
- ponker 6y agoThey didn’t want the PR risk of owning the app
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thewebcount 6y agoExactly this! My spouse asked me the other day if Apple had released their contact tracing app yet. It was difficult to explain in lay terms that Apple was not releasing an app, just the tools to make an app.
- thetanil 6y agoAsk me if I will volunteer to give apple or google any more information than they already collect and my answer will always be no. I don't care what the reasoning. Germany did it right.
- 6y ago
- nxpnsv 6y agoI find it odd how many people get paranoid with tracing but still use Facebook or google products...
- cgearhart 6y ago> One of the potential advantages of a centralised model is that it would allow the use of machine learning to adapt thresholds to minimise error... This is a cop out. Machine learning isn’t magic. If the proximity measurement doesn’t really work without ML then it’s probably not going to start working with ML. Besides, if you really wanted to do it in a decentralized app you could use federated learning, no?
- Closi 6y agoML could be an overstretch, but centralised approaches definitely do allow for more analysis and a deeper rules-based approach.
- stevedotcarter 6y agoI live in Ireland and our contact tracing app (using Google+Apple tech) seems to be doing well. There was about 1 million install 1-2 days after it launched, currently standing at 1.4 million installs (population is 4.9 million), along with some positive contacts reported: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-53525712 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-53525712 It was also donated to open source. https://www.nearform.com/blog/ireland-donates-contact-tracing-app-to-linux-foundation/ https://www.nearform.com/blog/ireland-donates-contact-tracin... While that is useful I think each country will face its own challenges with adoption.
- bbrazil 6y agoIndeed, and it's early days yet. From the article: > It also reveals that, whatever the people of Ireland have been told, their app is collecting centralised data on them. The signup flow has a very obvious and well written opt-in for collection of anonymised data to help track how well the app is working, which was mentioned by the BBC article linked. I don't think people are being mislead. I personally decided not to enable that, but did give the app my phone number to be shared in the event I'm a close contact. > it has been in use, it is claimed to have resulted in 91 “close contact exposure alerts”, which is remarkably few. That they know of, as those users either opted in to the anonymous tracking or (possibly) gave their phone number. It'd be useful to know how the install base per the usual Android/iOS stats compare with the anonymous tracking enablement, but those numbers haven't been shared as far as I'm aware. Right now our overall case numbers are low enough (around 20 per day) that it's likely hard to tell how effective the app is. However our R is currently estimated at 1.1, so even a little help from the app could help keep us below 1.
- markdown 6y agoDoes your Irish app require the app to be open on iOS?
- stevedotcarter 6y agoNot that I’m aware of. The app just reads the data your phone is already collecting. It’s making use of the api that Apple and Google added to iOS and Android. Which I believe once enabled is using Bluetooth beacons to keep a list of other phones you have been nearby. That’s all done by phone, not the app. If you test positive, then you are expected to use the app to upload the list of phones you were in contact with. Notifications will then be sent to all those phones through the app.
- johannes1234321 6y agoExample of the success of the German app: https://www.lra-bgl.de/t/das-landratsamt/aktuelles/details/news///zwei-neue-corona-faelle-im-berchtesgadener-land/ https://www.lra-bgl.de/t/das-landratsamt/aktuelles/details/n... (sorry German) In the region of Berchtesgaden a asymptomatic person for a warning from their app and was confirmed positive. Due to the app that person didn't spread further. Now we can argue how many of such cases we need for calling it a true success and then we can discuss if a single case makes the news if that's a bad sign ... on the later it's important to mind that certainly not every case makes that news and it's from a region with low virus load to begin with.
- usrusr 6y agoI disagree with the failure claims except for lack of adoption. How can unreliable distance measurements be an issue? Actual viral spread over distance is a much, much bigger uncertainty. Even improving distance measurements to the nanometer wouldn't make much of a difference considering transmission prediction. Sometimes the virus bridges tens of meters, other times it fails to make landfall in a prolonged skin on skin situation. Measuring impact is a simple polling research problem: if you want to know this kind of thing (and I think you should) you need to accompany your PCR tests with a tiny little questionnaire collecting data about why the test was done. Failure to collect that data is entirely unrelated to the app.
- denysvitali 6y agoThe thing that still blows my mind about the whole contact tracing solutions in Europe is that the servers do not federate with themselves, and that you can only keep a single country specific app active at the time. This leads to the situation where people that usually cross the country's borders will only use a single app which may not track all of the contacts. So far, the current solution is IMHO useless - but I keep on using it. In my case I just keep one app active at all time (the one from my home country), but it would be more effective if with a single app I was able to track the contacts with people from other countries too. Stupid simple example: I live in Switzerland (SwissCovid), and ideally when I cross the italian border I'll need to activate the italian contact tracing app (Immuni), but contacts with people that use a different app won't be counted even if they are infected - which totally misses the point of having a contact tracing in the first place :(
- wtmt 6y agoI was suspicious of the effectiveness of contact tracing apps, which have to rely on something as unreliable as Bluetooth to estimate distance across different kinds of hardware, different kinds of software drivers and in different situations. That got worse with some governments wanting to collect location information through the contact tracing apps 24/7 and centralize it. > It would appear that no government has thought this out properly yet. This seems to be true at least in India, where the app is a centralized one that doesn’t use the Apple/Google framework The app tracks the location of users at all times (it asks for that permission) and hence cannot use the APIs since Apple and Google prohibit such apps from collecting location information. Since it requires background location access and Internet connectivity, it’s a good addition to drain batteries quicker. The government also famously declared that the app would be open sourced so that it could be improved and issues fixed. That turned out to be a farce with the source released only for the Android version, and that too for an older version of the app with some code removed (the code on the Play Store was newer). They stopped releasing updates of the source. They didn’t release the source of the iOS app, which was supposed to be “shortly” (that was around two months ago). They didn’t fix the issues that people raised on GitHub. Yet the government claimed that the app was effective and put out some numbers on it being useful (without any backing data or any way to verify those claims). It gets even worse. The app being a platform for contact tracing is only one facet. The goal that wasn’t widely disclosed was to have private companies build on top of the app and its server side data to create platforms on health data collected from hundreds of millions of people. Note that India doesn’t have a data privacy or data protection law, leave alone anything to control health related data in the hands of crony capitalists and opportunists. Now all talk about contact tracing and its effectiveness is muted or nowhere to be seen, though the app is being pushed as a requirement to give people permission to travel and for other purposes. The platform has become, and is continuing to become, what some people feared...and that’s getting farther from handling COVID-19 or a public health crisis.
- ArkVark 6y agoContact Tracing is not recommended (and basically pointless) for mild respiratory illnesses like Coronaviruses because for the vast majority of people, they are asymptomatic or lowly symptomatic, and the spread can be extensive. Its only recommended for more serious viruses like Ebola.
- avivo 6y agoThis is completely missing what is likely the primary obstacle to adoption, at least in the US. Apple and Google require an entire state to commit exclusively to using a single app. Even though they use a protocol that would easily interoperate across jurisdictions and apps effectively. City governments which could move much faster are unable to do anything. States are on fire dealing with others things. They also all want some smaller scale trial to happen first, but no one can do that according to Apple/Google policies. So they are all stuck in a chicken and egg problem... (This is all according my sources working directly on such apps which were ready to deploy 3 months ago — but were completely stopped by the policy; I'm interested to hear if anyone is aware of reasons why this might not be accurate).
- whyever 6y agoI think this is intentional to prevent confusion/abuse. The national app also gets singled out on the Play Store.
- eecc 6y agoItaly’s Immuni wasn’t downloaded enough to be a significant sample; people are too worried about their bloody battery performance and “what if I’m flagged and gub’mint makes me isolate home”. The National Health Service’s effort to run a population wide serological sample was also declined because “what if I’m positive and I need to stay home”. The fucking chemical reagents expired in the meantime. It’s these times when I have to make an effort not to praise regimes for their efficiency in enforcement... or it’s just theater and marketing and human nature is rotting their process to the core as well..
- kevinpet 6y agoComments like "what if I’m flagged and gub’mint makes me isolate home" makes me think of people who object that the problem is idiot users who don't recognize a clearly superior product. If people don't trust the government, that's a failure of that government.
- toyg 6y agoWe’ve seen the same phenomenon across countries as different as Norway and Italy. Some fears are primal.
- smabie 6y agoJust pay each person a $100 if they download the app, or whatever. People react to incentives, and downloading the app brings no personal benefit. Change that.
- rossdavidh 6y agoReally, I bet $10 would be enough to get a high adoption rate.
- cwhiz 6y agoContact tracing apps were NEVER going to work. There are numerous fundamental technical problems but those aren’t even worth getting into, because people won’t use this shit. Smartphone contact tracing is an absurd silver bullet pipe dream from a bunch of hammers who see the world as full of nails. It won’t work, can’t work, and will not ever work. How much more effort are people going to waste on this?? Every time this comes up on HN the horde mass downvotes anyone who dares to dissent. It’s been almost five months now.
- junipertea 6y agoCan you name those fundamental technical problems? From my understanding, the problems are adoption and states being slow in implementing the apps. I don’t have any exact numbers, but I would say even with some false positives it will be much more directed unlike testing everyone daily.
- toyg 6y agoI agree that it won’t work in Europe or the US and it was absurdly over-hyped, but mobile-based helpers have been effective in Asia. The critical difference is that Asian countries can mandate this sort of thing, since their populations seem to be culturally more willing to accept a higher degree of illiberal state control over their lives (for the good of society at large). If the app had to be installed and configured in every smartphone sold, and you were forced to show it to police spot-checks on the streets, adoption rates wouldn’t be a problem. This is obviously unfeasible and undesirable in most Western countries (at the moment...) so we’re left with a voluntary scheme that is only as effective as typical voluntary schemes (i.e. not much).
- fomine3 6y agoGrouping as "Asisan countries" is wrong.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoNot possible until UWB is ubiquitous.
- KKKKkkkk1 6y agoThere's no mention of China in this article. China had a pretty large-scale tracing system using smartphones. Has that also failed?
- diebeforei485 6y agoIt's because the privacy-at-any-cost camp, like the EFF, raised hell and prevented Apple from making an app themselves. So only cash-starved state governments can make apps, which is unlikely to happen. They have blood on their hands.
- xfitm3 6y agoI'm pleased to see this. I'm privacy forward and there is no doubt this information will be abused by private and public entities. We simply need to deal with this another way without giving up yet another bit of privacy.