31 ms·
Digikam 7.0: Open-source photo management
- williesleg 6y agoNice to see they love grabbing face data! Where's it go?
- blendergeek 6y agoI haven't tried this out yet, but from the release notes it sounds like the new facial recognition system will be better than I am. I am not good at recognizing faces and have been waiting for quite some time for a good open source tool to recognize faces with.
- agumonkey 6y agoNever thought of people with facial agnosia.. someone make an app !
- nqzero 6y agogoogle glass was gonna be heaven ...
- blendergeek 6y agoAccording to Wikipedia it is called prosopagnosia [1]. I have never been formally diagnosed, but I cannot even recognize the faces of my own family members to save my life. Having software that sorts faces will be great. Given that I only use open source software, I am quite excited for this new release. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosopagnosia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosopagnosia
- agumonkey 6y agoyeah I knew there was a proper term I just couldn't bother digging again. Do you think a software aiding you into recognizing would help your life ? or are you fine with that condition now ?
- blendergeek 6y agoI have learned to live with it. Basically whenever I meet someone I say, "hey, I can't recognize faces". I still recognize people but only by clothing, hair, facial hair or black thereof, etc. If someone gets a haircut, it completely throws me off. I mainly see software helping me organize my photos. I have always dreamed of a Google Glass like thing that would instantly tell me who everyone is, but I think everybody would find it creepy. Of course currently people find it weird that it takes me >15 seconds to recognize a friend when it seems to take everybody barely 2 seconds.
- throwaway189262 6y agoI've read you can train yourself to be decent. It would be interesting to use output from facial recognition software as "flashcards" for yourself. Look at it like recognizing stuff like cars and watches. Somebody really into the space can tell you the brand of either immediately, and sometimes the model. Definitely a learned skill rather than innate like faces are for most. Just saying, might be fun to try to train yourself to recognize your top X people, for science.
- takeda 6y ago> I have never been formally diagnosed, but I cannot even recognize the faces of my own family members to save my life. And I thought I had this disease. I think root of my issue most likely is that my brain is assuming that most people I see on the street or during parties I will never see again so it immediately forgets faces and names and only starts remembering when I encounter them few times. I would imagine the most famous people who were diagnosed with prosopagnosia probably have something closer to what I have than you.
- StavrosK 6y agoBut not recognizing faces of people you see at parties is different from not recognizing your own family. Do you have the latter too?
- takeda 6y agoLOL, after editing the comment I cut out the important part. What I meant to say is that I thought I had that disease, but after reading the comment I doubt I have it. I also suspect that many celebrities who claim that they have it probably just have a bad memory. They are normally meeting a lot of people so it's not easy to remember faces.
- morsch 6y agoCan I attach the face-tags to the RAW file (or the XMP, I guess) and use them in other applications, specifically darktable?
- Youden 6y agoYes but you need to configure Digikam to write metadata in its settings. Should be able to write to either EXIF or XMP.
- virtualmic 6y agoSorry for somewhat unrelated query: is Digikam a replacement for Darktable? If not what's a good workflow between the two? I am a hobbyist photo taker and have only recently started using Darktable and really enjoy using it. However, it isn't a very efficient photo manager in my opinion (I may very well be missing something).
- black_puppydog 6y agoI would say they're complementary. Digikam is more of an all-around organizer and has lots of import/export stuff, tagging, and now good face recognition too apparently (the old one was based on classic Haar cascades). Darktable is for selecting a series of shots, going through them, developing the ones you want to keep.
- virtualmic 6y agoThanks, I will try Digikam too.
- MR4D 6y agoWhich would you use to replace Picasa (on a Mac) ?
- morsch 6y agoDarktable's targets digital photography enthusiasts or professionals. The learning curve is steep. Picasa's target demographic was "everyone". So probably Digikam.
- distances 6y agoI can confirm. Every now and then I want to edit some of my photos and run Darktable, only then to remember it has zero automation and a hundred of sliders for individual adjustments. It definitely requires dedication to use, more of that than I have to give for holiday photo editing.
- jhoechtl 6y agoKDE software is so great (digiKam, Kdenlive, Kate, Krita) unfortunately the KDE environment compared to Gnome is just so bug-ridden, especially when it comes to multi-monitoring, wayland-support and scaling. Gnome shines in these respecst. I wish thebest of both worlds!
- ekianjo 6y ago> especially when it comes to multi-monitoring, It's getting better on the multi monitor front at least
- brnt 6y agoI don't really have problems with multi monitor and KDE.
- beojan 6y agoNor do I.
- liotier 6y agoI would even venture to say that, as I discovered last month with several Debian setups, it is the best multi-monitor plug'n'play experience I have had so far.
- d4rti 6y agoSame here, running a pair of 1440p monitors off my Hades Canyon NUC, running Kubuntu 20.04. Largely now without tweaks, but it needed some when I originally got it to use Kisak-mesa. neofetch output: OS: Ubuntu 20.04 LTS x86_64 Host: NUC8i7HVK (REMOVED) Kernel: 5.4.0-42-generic Uptime: 5 hours, 7 mins Packages: 3266 (dpkg), 7 (snap) Shell: bash 5.0.17 Resolution: 2560x1440, 2560x1440 DE: Plasma WM: KWin Theme: Breeze [Plasma], Breeze [GTK2/3] Icons: breeze [Plasma], breeze [GTK2/3] Terminal: konsole CPU: Intel i7-8809G (8) @ 4.200GHz GPU: AMD ATI Radeon RX Vega M GH GPU: Intel HD Graphics 630 Memory: 8898MiB / 32031MiB
- berkut 6y ago
- techntoke 6y agoI'm currently using Google Photos for facial recognition, however since they broke their Google Drive integration I'd like to move away from it. For now I am using a combination of Syncthing, the Google Photos interface and rclone. Is there an API or potential to use this in headless for integration in other apps such as web or Android? What about the automated cards and animations that Google Photos creates? Is there anything like that for Digikam or another app that can be self-hosted?
- stalker314 6y agoNextcloud is self-hosted solution and there is plugin for it that allows you to recognize and cluster faces (to persons) using DLib: https://github.com/matiasdelellis/facerecognition https://github.com/matiasdelellis/facerecognition. This might be close to what you need (while Nextcloud is huge software on its own, it is not best photo management app)
- techntoke 6y agoThanks.
- andialo 6y agoHow reliable is the face recognition in 7.0? In older versions it was not as good as closed source software like picasa.
- chris_st 6y agoSee the "Deep-Learning Powered Faces Management" section of the linked document for a lot more information. Specifically, they mention that they replaced the old (OpenCV) algorithm with a new neural-net based one.
- stalker314 6y agoIf it is same software https://github.com/matiasdelellis/facerecognition https://github.com/matiasdelellis/facerecognition has been using (DLib, King's face model) - I can say it is very, very good! Yes, there can be lamppost here and there, but it is miles ahead of OpenCV haar cascade
- takeda 6y agoIn they link they said that previous version was about 80% successful, now it's 95% and doesn't have issues with blurred images, profiles, various obstructions, pet faces etc.
- gsich 6y agoMaybe they have now what Picasa did 7 years ago.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoThis comment seems mean, perhaps. But, Picasa's facial recognition was far better than Digikam's and I marveled at how Picasa could do so quickly, so long ago, what Digikam has failed to do (until now?). I've been a Digikam user for a long time now, it's really useful for me, but the whole face-tagging system has been really poor for a long time IMO (eg all faces recognised in one image as same person; all tags recognised as being the last person manually tagged). It's one thing I'd love to have donated to a bounty on as it saves a lot of time to have working tagging. I wonder if there are plans to add other types of tagging, object recognition or what-have-you.
- black_puppydog 6y agoYeah, the the comment does sound mean. Not to blame you, since you indicate that you understand this. The digikam devs can be court at times, but that's mostly because many people show up with great expectations; mostly expectations of having someone else implement this or that. I shouldn't throw stones here really, I was one of those people a few years back. The project is huge and the core dev team quite small [1], essentially just two people and the occasional drive-by. This is one of those projects that I'd really like to see someone figure out a stable revenue stream. I'd guess that a lot of this is not "interesting" programming, but rather tedious "clocking in, clocking out" footwork. [1]: https://github.com/KDE/digikam/graphs/contributors https://github.com/KDE/digikam/graphs/contributors
- StavrosK 6y agoI think that comment is more "Picasa was amazing" than "Digikam is bad", and it's right, Picasa was amazing. Hopefully Digikam will reach those levels soon.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoI'm happy to hear this and hope it works. Apple's iPhoto used to do good face recognition but as soon as you exported photos the information was lost. I hope this can store the face rectangles and their IDs in the photo's metadata.
- williesleg 6y agoGotta grab the faces eh?
- notyourday 6y agoEvery year for at least last 5 years I have been trying Digikam. Every year like 99.9% of the reasonably complicated GUI-based single process multi-functional software written on Linux it would blow up while working with marginally large sets of files (~ 50k photos, roughly evenly split between 24 megapixel NEF files and random resolution jpegs ) It is just sad to see that the imaging/image processing/image organizing world is still stuck in 1990s paradigm rather than embrace that the computers have gobs of memory, a single application can be composed of dozen of individual components talking to each other over 127.0.0.1 and background jobs is a thing.
- akerro 6y agoI've been using it since 2011 and no problems with anything. Over 200k photos.
- notyourday 6y agoThe infamous "Works on my laptop"
- akerro 6y agoyup :)
- michaelmrose 6y agoConversely the a singular anecdote also doesn't mean it doesn't work either. I strongly suspect that when you have a largish body of people are using something without issue and one person is constantly experiencing problems there might be a reason why. - Maybe you are constantly trying it on the same distro that constantly has problems with its build for some reason or other. Consistent bad experience for the smaller number of users who conclude incorrectly that digikam is broken. For example suppose it uses out of date libraries that the software depends on. - Maybe your configuration is unusual in some fashion and because of this consistently hits the same bug. If nobody reports it then it never gets fixed if it doesn't also effect a developers machine. Neither of these is an indication that the projects low level architectural direction is problematic.
- sergiotapia 6y agoAre the people tags saved to the photo's file metadata somehow? I've thrown about 130,000 photos up to google photos for safe-keeping but want a second set of redundancy.
- unicornporn 6y agoXMP I assume.
- throwaway189262 6y agoJust so you know... Google Photos is full of dark patterns. For example there's no way to mass delete pictures. It simply doesn't exist. There's a janky browser script on GitHub that you inject into the page to delete your photos. That's what I had to use when I migrated to OneDrive. And some Android phones are configured to automatically upload to Google Photos to "save space" on the device. I recovered thousands of lost photos for my parents that got deleted from their phones and uploaded to Google without their knowledge. My Dad has been backing up his photos for years, but half were missing from the backup because I found them on Google photos. It took the browser automation script hours to delete all their photos after I got them out. Even worse, when I was trying to remove duplicates from the set, I found that Google alters the metadata of the photos you export. So when you try to compare them you can't use regular diff tools
- mceachen 6y agoNo. I'd love to be wrong, btw: please correct me if I'm wrong. (I've looked at the sidecars from takeout, and the API). You might be able to scrape the metadata via puppeteer, but that's brittle and janktastic.
- pmcjones 6y agoIf you use the Album>Write Metadata to Files command, it will do so. (I just tested adding a Face Tag to a photo. In Settings>Configure>Metadata, I also checked the box next to Face Tags under Write This Information to the Metadata. This latter action didn't seem to be enough by itself.)
- est31 6y agoI checked out Digikam recently because my camera didn't support PTP but instead a custom protocol and I wanted to copy pictures over (Dolphin had no support). Sadly, Digikam had to mess with the metadata of each picture and put its name inside. Which contribution has the program done other than download the picture from the camera? So I went to using an SD card reader instead.
- cortesoft 6y agoSince this is an open source project, could you remove that part of the code?
- tokai 6y agoYou can configure what is added to the metadata in the settings.
- mceachen 6y agoIt's a dubious default, though. Why muck with tags from originals when you don't have to?
- lakeWater 6y agoNot really a default. When you start up Digikam for the first time a prompt asks if you would like information saved to the files or not. If you select no information is stored in a local Digikam DB.
- aorth 6y agoCan confirm: just installed digikam 7.0 and it asked me if I want to store information in photo metadata. I said no...
- indymike 6y agoDigikam has always been a gem. This sounds like a great improvement.
- tempodox 6y agoIt would be nice if it could display UTF-8 text. Apparently it only uses ISO 8859-1.
- skoskie 6y agoThe linked post specifically says it supports UTF-8. Might double check the settings.
- schoolornot 6y agoThe macOS version is distributed as a .pkg and isn't signed or notarized. That's a no-go for me. Any reason why they don't just ship a .app in a disk image?
- the_why_of_y 6y agoMost likely because nobody on the development team has the time to keep up with Apple's treadmill of ever changing Gatekeeper requirements. If you're knowledgeable about such matters, see it as your chance to contribute.
- gsich 6y agoSigning costs money, if you want it signed I guess you can donate that amount of money to them.
- BugWatch 6y agoSadly, even at version 7.0, it (Digikam) still doesn't support virtual albums/collections, and it insists on direct album-file_system_directory correlation. Unfortunently, it is useless to me as an image/photo organizer. (I don't really see tags as a substitute).
- tmp538394722 6y agoCan you help me understand what you’re looking for in a “virtual album” feature that isn’t achieved by tags?
- pmcjones 6y agoBeing able to specific a particular sequence for the photos in a "virtual album" that is different than, say, their capture date or filename.
- tobtoh 6y agoI wish there was photo management software which catered to non-enterprise multi-user environments. ie families, or small organizations where the photos (and database) would reside on a computer, but other users on their computers could access it via the local network. At the moment, this middle ground doesn't seem to exist. It's either single-user only photo management software or full-blown multi-user digital asset management software with enterprise-level pricing.
- gsich 6y agoMe too. My "solution" is to have the photo software running at one PC and use RDP (or whatever you like) to access it.
- mceachen 6y agoPhotoStructure is absolutely designed for self-hosted family-and-friends access of local photos and videos. You'll get installation instructions emailed to you shortly after you subscribe to the beta. https://PhotoStructure.com https://PhotoStructure.com (Disclaimer: I'm the author, and wished the same thing you did, so I quit my job to build it).
- alexktz 6y agoAny chance the website could show a screenshot or something? It’s just a generic thing right now and I have no interest in signing up to something I can’t see.
- mceachen 6y agoSure, I'll add some more prominently. https://photostructure.com/about/v-0-8/ https://photostructure.com/about/v-0-8/ has several. I added one on the home page, too.
- stanboyet 6y agoJust read your first blog post, I signed up. But +1 for the screenshots on your website, it does not work as an illustration of the product.
- aidenn0 6y agoIs it possible to get digikam to store files in a simple date based directory structure? I really wanted to like digikam, but ended up using rapid-photo-downloader instead because it was so easy to setup that way, and it keeps me from being too locked in to software that might go away.
- canada_dry 6y agoBah! I was really hoping Digikam's face recognition was going to work at least as well as the 10+ yr old Picassa that I'm trying to replace... but I'm not having any luck - pretty disappointing matching. Even with dozens of images manually identified it is failing to match the same person correctly in other pictures. Plus, the interface is confusing and not very efficient (in aiding the matching/identification process).
- BlackLotus89 6y agoThen you will be happy to know that they are working on exactly those problems right now (see the article part and look for summer of code). > As you can see, work is advancing very well and we expect to publish new code later this summer, probably for digiKam 7.2.0 when all implementations will be tested and ready for production.