6 ms·
I know we have been gaslighted a lot by the right wing about climate change, but honestly, what can we do about it? The current lockdowns and limits on travel a
by EGreg 6y ago
I know we have been gaslighted a lot by the right wing about climate change, but honestly, what can we do about it? The current lockdowns and limits on travel achieved the largest drop in fossil fuel usage probably ever done in human history. As people choose to work from home, and as more people go vegan, these trends may continue. And?
We need carbon sequestration, maybe.
PS: will the sun entering a cooling period have any serious effect at all on Earth?
- zajd 6y agolol
- take_a_breath 6y ago==As people choose to work from home, and as more people go vegan, these trends may continue. And?== Neither of these things are guaranteed to continue after COVID passes. More Westerners going vegan doesn’t automatically lower emissions if people in developing countries continue to grow their meat intake. On the flip side, if people move out of urban cores and increase online shopping, those might have a negative impact on emissions. Edit: Seems like people are misinterpreting the "negative impact on emissions". By that phrase, I meant that more personalized delivery and suburban living may very well lead to an increase in emissions. Apologies for the confusion.
- zeroonetwothree 6y agoOnline shopping is way more efficient than in person shopping. Not only is the net transit time shorter, but stores are very costly in terms of energy use and logistics.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoCitations please. Delivery services driving items around, with laws even mandating full money-back without questions asked in eg Germany (inviting people to order clothes in a couple of candidate sizes and lots of retoure) are heavy on emissions as well.
- EGreg 6y agoPeople moving out of urban cores increases emissions, because they now have to build and heat/cool more homes, and most importantly — commute to work. Suburbia is probably one of the biggest contributors to fossil fuel usage.
- claydavisss 6y agoYet the ruling class continues to willfully induce a migration out of dense urban cores by permitting and accelerating their decay. Reduction in law enforcement is just one more move in that direction, following a decades-long regime of permissive attitudes towards homelessness. They want us out of cities, so we're out.
- take_a_breath 6y agoWe agree, it was a poorly written phrase. Please see the edit.
- Larrikin 6y agoHow does needing a car to go everywhere in a rural or suburban environment decrease emissions?
- take_a_breath 6y agoWe agree, it was poorly written. Please see the edit.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> More Westerners going vegan doesn’t automatically lower emissions if people in developing countries continue to grow their meat intake. But it's surely an improvement over Westerners not going vegan, and people in developing countries continuing to grow their meat intake.
- daliusd 6y agoAnd there are many more ideas what can be done: https://drawdown.org/solutions https://drawdown.org/solutions
- jl6 6y agoTwo kids max. Plant-based diet. Treat others kindly.
- gspr 6y ago> Two kids max. Luckily, it's becoming increasingly clear that that part will sort itself out without any kind of draconian China-style laws to forcibly limit family sizes: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30677-2 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30677-2 That the population is developing in manageable ways in most of the world is one of the good news that will really help us on our way. The recipe is well-known by now: give women control over their own bodies and their own lives, and provide a social safety net that at a minimum is strong enough that having a large amount of children as an insurance stops making sense. IT WORKS :-)
- raxxorrax 6y agoHe, this is realized in the country I live in and we import migrants to stabilize our heavily ailing pension system.
- lopmotr 6y agoIt's not manageable, it's below replacement which is a risk of disaster if it's not increased. It seems we need poverty to make new humans and we're running out of poverty.
- gspr 6y agoWhat? The Earth has plenty of humans. We're decades away from a falling population globally, and even then we probably have centuries to bring birth rates back up before disaster strikes (well, disaster with underpopulation as its cause). Also, bringing the rates back up should be easy enough when needed.
- jl6 6y ago2 is only just below replacement rate, which means a manageable gradual reduction rather than the demographic cliff-edge of 0 or 1 or the unsustainable boundless growth of 3+. At that rate it will be centuries before the world starts running out of people - plenty of time to anticipate and start planning more kids again.
- mistrial9 6y agoAccording to a 2017 Scoping Plan published by the California Air Resources Board, the overall challenge in this part of the world breaks down into activity sectors, and then change or mitigation on the activity in those sectors. Ironically, you are speaking your concern at a time when there is actually a new chance for movement in the positive direction. This particular report is easily found at the CARB website as scoping_plan_2017.pdf
- zentiggr 6y agoIt feels to me like too many conservatives identify with the goal of simply having or making the most money, and damn any other consequences. How do we demonize greed / powerlust, and make cooperative goals more attractive?
- alfred564 6y agoHow about teaching of Jesus? Would they listen?
- tannhaeuser 6y agoFor a start, we could look into investing corona-induced stimulus funds sustainably (rather than, say, subsidizing air travel). Only last year, Fridays for Future protests were a thing in many parts of the world. Today, it seems we're busy longing for yesterday. All the while the young FfF generation will have to pay back in one way or another. The perspective to take away something positive from coronavirus could go a long way towards political support for sustainability.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI fear it would require redefining the goals of our economies. I don't see that happening in reality though. A CO2 tax can help a bit, but even that would not change rising emission levels too much. The costs would just be countered by more growth. It isn't just that everything gets a little too hot, we also generally use too many resources: https://www.overshootday.org/ https://www.overshootday.org/ Working from home obviously helps, but transportation is almost inconsequential. I think it is responsible for around 15% of emissions and that includes every form of logistic emitter. Individual traffic doesn't help but wouldn't necessarily be an issue and people are dependent on it outside of the largest cities. Agriculture on the other hand is one of the largest factors next to power generation. If every developing country reaches the industrial stage, we will surely fail hard. So technological transfer to developing countries is a necessity, so they can skip this development state for greener alternatives. That is an obligation developed countries need to acknowledge. Technological progress can help too, but I don't think it is a good idea to depend on it alone.
- jeffbee 6y agoIn the USA transportation is 30% of carbon emissions and in California, where at least some nominal progress has been made toward carbon emissions from utilities, transportation is over 40%.
- raxxorrax 6y agoCrazy. Is there a breakdown for these? Maybe due to large airports or giant logistic centres? Or perhaps California emits few CO2 so that is has become a larger factor percentage wise?
- jeffbee 6y agoFor California it's the latter: the denominator has gotten smaller while transportation has stayed flat. It's a mistake to try to blame it on trucks and airports. Private passenger cars are the majority. Air travel is 25x smaller. https://ww3.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/pubs/reports/2000_2017/ghg_inventory_trends_00-17.pdf https://ww3.arb.ca.gov/cc/inventory/pubs/reports/2000_2017/g...
- bmn__ 6y ago> I know we have been gaslighted a lot by the right wing about climate change, but honestly, what can we do about it? Just don't listen to them? This isn't rocket surgery. Once you realise something is propaganda and false narratives, it becomes easy to avoid it or point out to others who might be more susceptible.
- ericvanular 6y agoHey EGreg, we're generating ideas, sharing feedback, and building climate solutions over at https://collective.energy https://collective.energy if you'd like to join a community of no-nonsense doers