16 ms·
Twitter bans 7k QAnon accounts, limits 150k others as part of broad crackdown
- arkitaip 6y agoRidiculous that it took Twitter this long to stop being used as a weapon by right-wing extremists. Now, if they could do something about the US president who spreads more white supremacist propaganda than any other account on the platform.
- Romanulus 6y agoCan you be more specific?
- zrail 6y agoAbout which part?
- jsnk 6y agoIsn't it obvious? A claim like "US president who spreads more white supremacist propaganda" needs to be substantiated with specific evidences.
- perl4ever 6y agoSuch a claim may well be doubted, but why do you? Producing counterexamples is relatively easy, comparing to proving a negative, so why don't you provide the ones you have in mind? I think it's an interesting question to ask, if there are people who aren't the President, who are worse, and are not ostensibly as privileged, what's going on? As I understand it, the system is supposed to prevent those who aren't world leaders from behaving badly.
- slouch 6y agoHe retweeted a video wherein a man yelled white power.
- prepend 6y agoI watched the video and it seemed pretty obvious that the old man responded mockingly to the other person accusing him of white power. I don’t think the driver was actually chanting white power as a claim that white power was his desire. Now, there’s certainly an argument for not making such a response and to channel anger better and not joke about such things. But I don’t think retweeting that video is a show of support for white power. Poor taste is much more likely.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dvtrn 6y agoPoor taste is much more likely. Was that not the very point of some people’s frustration? Why does the intentions of the person on the video need justification, rationalization or explanation?
- prepend 6y agoI agree but brought it up as OP stated that POTUS endorses racism and white power through the tweet. I think I may be automatically biased against his tweets. But if a regular person posted that video I wouldn’t consider it endorsement of white power. Perhaps if there’s more context on the person in the video that would help. It seems like a frustrated response pointing out absurdity. But if the person flies a nazi flag then that would change my mind.
- dvtrn 6y agoI don't care what the motivations of the person in the video are, they're irrelevant and I'm not interested in trying to unpack them; it was incredibly poor taste for POTUS to retweet it for any reason. That's the point.
- prepend 6y agoMy comment wasn’t whether it was poor taste or not. I think saying the president is clearly supporting white power because he tweeted this video is incorrect. This video does not support white power. I don’t think it’s intent is to further white power. I think representing its purpose as promoting white power is incorrect, or misleading, or confusing, or anything other than accurate and truthful. But I agree about the poor taste comment. But I think there’s a big distinction between a rude person and a white supremacist.
- DonHopkins 6y agoI think he's talking about Trump. Or do you suspect Obama is a White Supremacist, as well as not having been born in the United States?
- krapp 6y agoI mean, the Republicans did try to frame Obama as a radical black separatist and terrorist sympathiser with the whole Bill Ayers/Jeremiah Wright thing[0,1], but they realized calling him a crypto-Muslim (and terrorist sympathizer, and if you want to wonder if he's the Antichrist too we're not going to stop you) would be easier given his name[2]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ayers_2008_presidential_election_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ayers_2008_presidential_e... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremiah_Wright_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremiah_Wright_controversy [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barack_Obama_religion_conspiracy_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barack_Obama_religion_conspira...
- EdSharkey 6y agoBrrr ... so chilly in here!
- flippinburgers 6y agoThe phrase "more ... than any other account" is hyperbolic at best. The repetitive drumbeat to try to paint Trump as Hitler-esque is strange. Among other things his ability to communicate is severely lacking. Since we apparently are expressing wishes now, I wish that twitter just didn't exist in the first place.
- themark 6y agoArticle says that the Wayfair ordeal was a Qanon conspiracy. How was that attributed to them?
- bynormous 6y agoBy following the digital trail - https://www.insider.com/wayfair-human-trafficking-conspiracy-theory-tied-to-qanon-2020-7 https://www.insider.com/wayfair-human-trafficking-conspiracy...
- skindoe 6y agoThat's not the evidence you think it is. In sports analogies That would be the equivalent of brian windhorst tweeting out something and then you saying that it came "Directly from LeBron James". People are not responsible for what their ignorant fans say.
- catalogia 6y agoIs "QAnon" even a person? I am under the impression that is a moniker that has likely been used by numerous unrelated people. I know believers of this stuff think "QAnon" is a person, but I've not seen any evidence that leads me to believe this is the case and quite a bit of conjecture / circumstantial evidence that suggests at one point the name was being used by a cabal of imageboard moderators.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoThere was an account on 8chan which would sign posts with "Q" and a unique hash which could be used to prove the identity of a particular person or group posting. Last I looked this account/hash hadn't been heard from in some time though.
- skindoe 6y agoAll the posts are viewable at Qmap.pub he posted less than 2 days ago. Encourage you to check it out.
- hadrien01 6y agoThis Yahoo article is just a copy of that one: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/twitter-bans-7-000-qanon-accounts-limits-150-000-others-n1234541 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/twitter-bans-7-000-qa... And the NBC website doesn't have an impossible-to-opt-out GDPR popup
- stevebmark 6y agoIt's been encouraging to see companies grow a backbone and crack down on harassment and hate campaigns, and not hide behind cowardly cries of "free speech." Twitter has taken too much time to do this, but recently they've been doing it more. Even Reddit, notorious for powering and consciously allowing hate campaigns, has cracked down more. It's also been interesting that the proponents of allowing these campaigns to continue say that stopping them will indeed lead to totalitarian censorship of "free speech." Granted we must always be vigilant against social pressure going too far. For example, the mob that formed to find the Boston marathon bomber over-zealously targeted the wrong people, risking their lives. We must learn from things like this. But to jump from banning hate campaigns on private platforms, to total censorship, is an impressively intellectually dishonest juggling act.
- skindoe 6y agoWhat has Qanon ever said that can be remotely considered hateful? Who determines what is hateful?
- yladiz 6y ago> Who determines what is hateful? In this case, Twitter.
- skindoe 6y agoSounds Orwellian
- flutterdude420 6y agoDoes it? There are other privately owned platforms you can use to accuse Hilary Clinton of pedophaelic blood rituals and satanic mind control. When Ingsoc comes in to ban reporters from asking unflattering questions at presidential news conferences then maybe we can talk.
- exogeny 6y agoGood thing many alternatives exist!
- newobj 6y agoSee? It's not so hard.
- alienhuman 6y ago...said the person when Hitler finally banned the dangerous and destructive Communists and then the Jews from public life. It’s amazing how few people understand the implications of banning people from public life. They think it’s easy and can’t understand why anyone would object. Total ignorance of history resulting in a total lack of awareness. If you think something as vital as free speech and censorship are simple and “not so hard” this is a good sign you’re missing something huge. In general, if you can’t convincingly argue the other side, you’re not sufficiently intelligent or informed and should educate yourself or refrain from advocating your clueless point of view.
- joshuamorton 6y agoPlease don't compare banning people from twitter and exterminating Jews. The two aren't comparable.
- allarm 6y agoThey are though. Please don’t deny that. The two are comparable.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI can't tell if you're being needlessly pedantic, but to clarify: no there are no similarities between the holocaust and getting banned from twitter. The two situations aren't similar, and comparing them is disgusting and shows a lack of empathy for people who have faced actual persecution. Sure, you can write the words that compare them. No, you should not.
- allarm 6y agoThe fact that you, young liberals, are praising censorship whenever it suits your agenda, amuses me. It’s only a matter of time before you start burning books. You already do that, in fact.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe average person isn’t capable enough to judge information for themselves; we need people in power to curate what is seen.
- ativzzz 6y agoPeople in power tend to curate content so as to consolidate and improve their power, not to make average people's lives better.
- sjtgraham 6y agoNo thank you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sixstringtheory 6y agoPeople are able to judge information they encounter. The problem is when there is so much information, that the amount of time it takes to get to a piece of information that is worthwhile to evaluate has long surpassed the amount of time people have to evaluate the information. So good info never even makes its way to them.
- codeddesign 6y agoThis is the exact same language totalitarian states use.
- manigandham 6y agoYes they are, they've done it for all of modern civilization. People in power telling us what to think doesn't end well. The issue is social media and the speed and scale of information without identity or verification. That's not going to be solved by curation.
- joe-collins 6y ago"A lie can get halfway around the world before the truth can even get its boots on", that old adage. But social has supercharged the whole affair, as you say, in speed and scale. Curation cannot solve it, but can it have some role in moderating it? What other tools do we have to throttle the damage? Do we need to axe social media entirely?
- amiga_500 6y agoThe USA is such a mess. Can't have free speech because too many voters are conspiracy nuts. Can't ban content because free speech. The level of ignorance has to be seen to be believed, on sites like 4chan. Education can clear this impasse, but is it too late?
- manigandham 6y agoFree speech the concept is different from the First Amendment, which is different from private companies and private property. The fringes will always be there, they're just more visible and vocal now. The real issue is whether a platform will choose to be moderated or not, and what tools it offers to users to control their experience. All major platforms are still working on that balance, especially as they become increasingly dominant mediums of expression.
- thephyber 6y ago> The fringes will always be there, they're just more visible and vocal now. And the fringes have enlisted bots to amplify their message, which includes accusations of serious criminal behavior with no evidence that would stand up in court. I suspect media platforms won't actually be able to fix these problems because they are codependent on the outrage that they create.
- manigandham 6y agoI agree. Communications have been mechanized and "social" has expanded in scale beyond any human limit.
- s5300 6y agoFor the uniformed: At least, long ago, in the beginning of 4chan, nobody believed this. They purposely made it up for fun and trolling. I seriously don't understand how there are some people unaware of this. They then purposely pushed it from 4chan to places it would be believed, other forms of social media like Facebook. The general populace (of social media users) are the ones who eat it up. They eat shit up from an anonymous image board that has always said that "The stories and information posted here are artistic works of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact." tl:dr "civil" society has quite literally proved it's simply not ready for the internet. Wonder if this will go down as the Great Filter.
- codeddesign 6y agoI’d like to see Antifa added to this growing list as well. The article states this group has “ties to dangerous real-world activities”. Does anyone know of any? Or is this just conjecture? The article’s statement was fairly vague.
- exogeny 6y agoCan you describe to me what you think Antifa is?
- revnode 6y agoA group of communists? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antifaschistische_Aktion
- Talanes 6y agoI think all time travelers should be welcomed on Twitter with welcome arms, be they from 1933 or 2933.
- totetsu 6y agoI say, could someone explain this preponderance of sharp signs?
- manux 6y agoFirst of all, from this link: > was a militant anti-fascist organisation, emphasis mine. People who self-identify as anti-fascist nowadays have little to do with communism. Why not link this page? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-fascism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-fascism Second of all, is "communist" a slur on HN? Is that supposed to sound scary or something?
- revnode 6y ago> Second of all, is "communist" a slur on HN? Is that supposed to sound scary or something? No, it's supposed to sound accurate. > People who self-identify as anti-fascist nowadays have little to do with communism. From your own link: "This article has multiple issues." Mine doesn't and accurately describes the group's origins.
- vmception 6y agoThey should just use the admin panel to start posting different stuff, a distributed re-education campaign with shadowban for user-generated content I'm sure they granted themselves this power in the Terms of Service, if not then I'm sure they've granted themselves the power to update the Terms of Service
- vecinu 6y agoCan anyone explain what is happening with the downvotes on this post? Almost every single top level comment has been downvoted to almost disappearing.
- zrail 6y agoThere are a few different contingents that frequent HN and bother to look at the comments on posts like this, which results in equal numbers of downvotes on wildly opposing top level comments.
- dang 6y ago1. The community is divided because society is divided. Each side downvotes the other. 2. HN users tend to downvote tedious, repetitive flamewar.
- arkitaip 6y agoHN has had a problem with bigotry and white supremacy for a long time. That's why.
- alienhuman 6y agoDisagreement over the role of social media companies in our society = white supremacy. Got it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 6y agoThere is a large contingent on HM that doesn’t seem to want to discuss anything that’s related to politics in the smallest way, no matter how directly on topic it is for technology. So you’ll find stories like this one that should be pretty high up which have been flagged to death and no longer appear on the main page.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jakeogh 6y agoCurious people can read the posts themselves at qmap dot pub.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- berryjerry 6y agoDon't know what QAnon was, apparently it's not just one person but 7K accounts so a group? I took one visit to the website not long ago and wrote it off as garbage. Obviously there is true stuff mixed in but I'd say the fake news level at least slightly higher then CNN so I can see why twitter would flag it as such. Should they be banned though? Honestly, I'm more for leaving the nonsense like flat earth stuff up so you know who is crazy, but twitter will do twitter things.
- rukittenme 6y agoif i hosted a forum i would very likely ban people who posted extreme messages. but, of course, im small. the relative harm to the extremist is small. they can find another place to spread their awful message. but what if i'm bigger? what if i have monopolized a large portion of political speech within a country? what if my platform is the primary communication channel for the president of the united states? do i then have an obligation to provide a platform to that speech? what if myself and a few friends own such a significant share of the internet that we can effectively remove extremists from all online participation. they cant host a server. they cant register a domain. they cant use private messenger apps. they cant send or receive money. to what degree can a person be ostracized from society for having an unpopular opinion. i certainly don't agree with the views of the taliban. i certainly wouldn't want to be complicit in the hosting of those views. but i have to wonder, if "illegitimate" speech can be removed by a small minority of corporate leaders how long is it before "legitimate" speech is removed? can a democratic society really exist where all opinions are filtered through a corporate elite? can "problematic" speech be allowed to exist so long as it doesn't call for violence? are calls to violence always evil? the BLM protests have certainly made calls to violence. should the cause for racial equality be stopped because it offends or threatens a minority (or even a majority) of people? couldnt' the BLM protest be construed as "problematic" or "illegitimate" and removed from the civil discourse overnight? im asking because i don't know what to do. there doesn't seem to be a clear path forward. there is no "public square" on the internet. its all private. but there's no one left in the "real" public square. the one in meat space. the "public square" has moved onto private property and there's no way to get it back.
- some1else 6y agoFacebook hate groups don't need Twitter accounts to operate. Regardless of the presumably positive outcome for the mainstream timeline, this is likely a futile whack-a-mole move that only benefits Twitter. Hate groups organize in private and output the vitriol with whichever fake accounts they have in possession. The way to definitively solve this societal problem is to help the people caught in the self-radicalisation filter bubble to overcome their real-life problems that fuel the hate. Banning them from the services that played a part in turning them seems a bit hypocritical.
- AndrewBissell 6y agoThe comparison to hate groups is a little off the mark. QAnon doesn't organize in secret, and so far you're not likely to get fired if someone shows a picture of you wearing a Q shirt to your employer. That said I agree with the broader point that this may not do that much to inhibit QAnon, especially because it exhibits a lot of cultlike belief that might just be reinforced by this ban.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoIn fact, "Q" predicted this behavior by the social media platforms over a year ago, so the QAnon movement is not, in general, surprised by Twitter. According to their conspiracy, Twitter just checked off a box in the list of items they believe will happen coming up in the future.
- shadowgovt 6y agoAs prognostications go, "The mainstream media will find my nonsense so aggressively hateful that they'll kick it off the site" is right up there with "It'll be cold in winter." Especially when Q controls the level of the aggressive hate in the nonsense.
- Fjolsvith 6y ago> Especially when Q controls the level of the aggressive hate in the nonsense. I'm not so sure that the level of aggressive hate from the populace is attributable to Q. I believe he's just tapping into it.
- auganov 6y ago> We will permanently suspend accounts Tweeting about these topics that we know are engaged in violations of our multi-account policy, coordinating abuse around individual victims, or are attempting to evade a previous suspension — something we’ve seen more of in recent weeks. So is Twitter essentially admitting this rule is only enforced against groups they don't like? If they're spreading hatred against some groups or harassing individuals why not use these rules instead? Twitter prohibits that already. Also the timing is interesting given America is having and election in a few months and these Q people are some of President Trump's most devoted supporters. Didn't seem to bother them for over 2 years.
- thephyber 6y agoYou could have read another 2 paragraphs lower and had your questions answered: > The spokesperson said while the targeted enforcement against QAnon fell under Twitter’s existing platform manipulation rules, its classification of QAnon as coordinated harmful activity was a new designation. The spokesperson said Twitter was taking action now because of an escalating degree of harm associated with the conspiracy theory. Q / QAnon only exists because of the Trump election. It's a way for "President Trump's most devoted supporters" to be engaged in the campaign. I wouldn't be surprised if the entire LARP was created by or steered by the campaign team.
- codeddesign 6y agoIn regards to your last point: Is it though? That’s a very large generalization for half the country. That’s like saying Obama supporters are pro killing innocent people with drones. Obviously this is ridiculous. Both far right and left have extremists that shouldn’t be tolerated by anyone.
- thephyber 6y agoI didn't mean to insinuate that all Trump supporters participate in the QAnon thing. I have yet to see a QAnon follower who didn't also support Trump, so from my perspective being a Trump Supporter is a necessary but not sufficient condition for being a QAnon follower. > Both far right and left have extremists that shouldn’t be tolerated by anyone. I'm not sure what you mean by "tolerated" here. I'm fine with calling them out for their silly ideas and actions. Perhaps even "canceling" them if they get too extreme. I'm not interested in actually adopting their techniques.
- Apocryphon 6y agoBack in the '90s, when you entered AOL Instant Messenger chatrooms there was always disclaimers saying that certain content (swearing, hate speech, sexual material, etc.) were subject to be filtered out, or would cause you to be kicked. Message boards and forums have always had moderators and admins who could censor at will. You're posting on one right now. Can anyone explain how Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, etc. is qualitatively different from any of these other websites?
- manigandham 6y agoThe scale. These major platforms are becoming increasingly dominant forms of communication and mediums of expression. There's a real question about when they cease being just another website or chatroom and become a public utility.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThen regulate them, break them up, nationalize them, etc. But don't pretend that internet communities don't have the power to moderate their content. It's inherent to the format and has always been with us. One would imagine in the '90s, AOL was probably as dominant as Facebook or Twitter is today- large enough to push its own alternative to URLs ("AOL Keywords"). The difference was there were far fewer people on the internet and the internet and computers in general were not as significant to our day-to-day lives. I doubt that Twitter today acts any differently from AOL Time Warner in Y2K. Finally, scale is a measure of quantity, not quality.
- ellyagg 6y agoRight, that's what the debate that is coming to. Are the platforms the townsquare for speech and should we hold them to a standard of free speech that doesn't just mean "no interference from government"? Also, a difference of degree can be such that it becomes a difference in kind.
- Apocryphon 6y ago
- AndrewBissell 6y agoFor those interested in a deep dive into QAnon and its origins I highly recommend this podcast by Robbie Martin. He goes into possible links to Roger Stone and Erik Prince (and therefore ultimately Trump). https://soundcloud.com/media-roots/the-origins-of-qanon-follow-the-white-rabbit-into-a-deeper-layer-of-the-maga-cult-pt-1-of-2 https://soundcloud.com/media-roots/the-origins-of-qanon-foll...
- torresjrjr 6y agoFor those looking for a viable, already-blooming alternative, with resistance to such problems, look into the Fediverse. https://torresjrjr.com/archive/2020-07-19-guide-to-the-fediverse https://torresjrjr.com/archive/2020-07-19-guide-to-the-fediv...
- shadowgovt 6y agoUnpopular opinion: while I don't oppose the existence of non-moderated social networks in the sense that I'd want them extinguished overtly, I'm not deeply convinced they're good, especially in this decade. gab.ai gave breathing room for a man to be so radicalized by surrounding himself with anti-Jewish conspiracy that he murdered people at a synagogue. 4chan is a notorious breeding ground of terrible memetic hazards (including, notably, QAnon). I don't guarantee Fediverse will end up the same, but the alternative services seem to collect mostly fringers who got kicked off of mainstream services with cause, and that's not a group I intend to support with my time and engineering labor. When I see a new social media site pop up, the first question I have is "What stops it from being the next gab.ai?"
- bluedispatcher 6y agoI don't think those are good examples. The communities you described formed because they were unwelcome in the mainstream, so it's only logical that they would devolve into radicalization as that's the very essence of their existence. I don't think social platforms should be non-moderated. Calling for harmful action should lead to a ban. Believing unrealistic things shouldn't. In such a context, most non mainstream communities would have no need to exist in a bubble. In the same vein downvotes and upvotes are fundamentally antithetic to free speech as they only serve to amplify the dominant echo and push minorities to their own bubbles. Instead people should be able to downvote locally, informing their own future interactions without affecting the community as a whole.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- s9w 6y agoelection coming up boys, gotta get that annoying free speech under control. Also the 'article' is complete bs. The connection to wayfair is made up entirely.
- onyva 6y agoGood “first” step. Thing is in a time of public health crisis misinformation is not something we need to put up with. It’s should be blocked, not just not propagate. Social media has indeed become a public health problem.
- timavr 6y agoI don't know what is the right answer. It is like we are stuck between two evils. One is censorship, that is used by dominant group to silence everyone else. Another is bunch of minority groups that might have outlandish aims and use free speech platforms to harrass everyone else. What I don't like that it is left to private company to sort it out and enact their own policies. This questions should be clearly handled on legislative level. In the end of the day a company provides a service, they shouldn't be the judge of how much free speech is allowed/not allowed. So I would say it is not failure of twitter here, it is just massive failure of our political process, but we all kind of know that already.
- gremlinsinc 6y agothe right to post on twitter, or even have a platform isn't a human right, it's not even a constitutional right, it's a 'privilege' the company gives you as long as you don't act like an idiot. Just like every web forum on the internet since aol and newsgroups in the 90s. W/out twitter you lose a voice you'd never have had if Twitter didn't exist, so by them banning hate speech maybe if your voice matters you'll exercise some caution and prudence when making a statement.
- timavr 6y agoThe problem is that the same argument is used in dictatorships to ban people and activist from traditional media(print/TV). Right now, what prevents Russian government/companies going to twitter and telling them look guys, you just banned your American extremists, can you please do the same for ours. They also practice hate speech, disinformation etc. The only problem is that Russian extremists look like average centrist US democrat. In terms what is the right and what is not the right is not really for twitter to determine in this case. My point was it should be determine on legislative level what should be on twitter and what shouldn't. In the end of the day twitter is a massive part of the political process. People exercising their rights, complaining to their representatives, supporting them, spreading their message. So if you ban entitties from twitter, you ban them from political process. And I do think some entities should be banned, but it shouldn't be up to twitter, it should be up to us citizens to decide that. If we think that holocost-deniers, nazy sympaphizers or whatever should be banned from social media bring it to the vote, pass the law, hopefully it will stand supreme court challenge and move on.
- yobi-ponti 6y agoTime to get off of twitter
- shadowgovt 6y agoA lot of people did that years ago, when Twitter's response to a notorious Twitter troll being elected as President of the United States was to modify their TOS so that there's a "newsworthiness" carve-out that keeps trolls on Twitter.
- motohagiography 6y agoThis comment was on a dupe thread and I'm adding it here in case this gets un-flagged. There is a good reason to discuss this: I sympathize with the argument that social platforms are private and can do business (or not) with whomever they please, the counter argument is that these platforms are "Radical Monopolies" (https://wikitia.com/wiki/Radical_Monopoly https://wikitia.com/wiki/Radical_Monopoly) apropos of a recent HN thread on Ivan Illich, where the analogy for the effect of being kicked off a platform is not like Ford declining to sell you a car where you can just go get another one, but rather, cancelling your license in Los Angeles. It's not 1:1, but if you lose your drivers license in a city like LA or non-coastal state, your ability to participate in society (find work, etc) and your social franchise in society is diminished because the automobile has a radical monopoly in American cities. Twitter and social platforms like Facebook have definitely become radical monopolies for reputation, where if you have no social media presence, you are excluded socially. (Regarding Facebook, try find a date without an instagram page.) Facebook execs even commented publicly early on that people without Facebook accounts should be treated as suspicious. That QAnon types are so ridiculous and indefensible is what makes them a great example for discussing how and whether to protect minority views. Twitter does have the right to do what they want, and I'm optimistic that these purges will create demand for the divergent platforms that will replace this first generation of them, but to say this right is simple and natural ignores precedents of radical monopolies that were enabled and sustained by political protection, which seems naive. The non-libertarian case for limiting social platforms ability to purge can be summed up in president Obama's thoughts,when he said, "you didn't build that." Arguably, social platforms that rely on network effects to become radical monopolies didn't "build that," either.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "enabled and sustained by political protection" in this context. Facebook and Twitter didn't have to build the web infrastructure, but there were other social networks in existence before those two became dominant. I'm not sure how we perceive their network effects as non-self-built. Facebook beat out competitors with two advantages: access to primary sources (they primed the network with college students) and requirement to use real names, which set them apart from other persona-based social networks at the time and encouraged people to be their "normal selves" on FB. Turns out, that's what a lot of people wanted; relative to the cyberpunk-esque other options, it felt "normal and safe." They made a market choice and it paid off for them.