18 ms·
> there is zero difference between what China does and what the FVEYs do, except that our Overlords tell us they are not spying on us, while every peasant in Ch
by echelon 6y ago
> there is zero difference between what China does and what the FVEYs do, except that our Overlords tell us they are not spying on us, while every peasant in China knows they are being spied on by their govt because the Chinese govt openly admits to it.
We can fight it by electing the correct people.
But more importantly, I won't be spirited away to a black site by speaking ill about the president. Nor can the government decide it doesn't want me as CEO of my company anymore. Or prevent me from funding the opposition party.
There's an enormous difference between the West and totalitarian dystopia China.
- wonnage 6y agoWhile in theory we could fight it via electing people, the fact is that these programs were built over the last three decades by elected administrations (both D and R), and this two-party setup doesn't seem to be changing any time soon.
- kortex 6y agoAnnoyed at both sides enabling surveilance? Time to advocate for STAR Voting and NPVIC, your cure to "lesser of two evils"! (not implying parent comment is both-siding, I am just trying to boost these ideas wherever it's relevant) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Inters...
- skissane 6y agoWhy STAR voting and not IRV? IRV has worldwide use – probably most heavily used in Australia, but also for some elections in Ireland, India, Papua New Guinea, and the United States (elections in Maine; also some local elections in a number of states). IRV also has a long history – Australia has been using it at the federal level for over a century now (and at the state level for even longer than that). By contrast, STAR doesn't appear to be used anywhere of any significance. There is a movement in Oregon to get it adopted, but thus far the movement hasn't had success. According to Wikipedia, the only people using it are Multnomah County Democratic Party for internal elections. And that's unsurprising given how new it is – it was invented in 2014. Why prefer a system which was only invented six years ago, to a system which has over a century of significant real world use?
- erklik 6y ago> IRV also has a long history – Australia has been using it at the federal level for over a century now (and at the state level for even longer than that). If the goal is to prevent the two-party system, Australia has basically turned into that with two major parties i.e. Labor and Liberal with smaller parties choosing sides, and being negligible. Although, IRV would generally be better than the current American system in a number of ways, but not necessarily something that would break the two-party hegemony.
- skissane 6y ago> If the goal is to prevent the two-party system, Australia has basically turned into that with two major parties i.e. Labor and Liberal with smaller parties choosing sides, and being negligible. I think minor parties and independents have played a far more important role in Australia's political history than your statements about "smaller parties choosing sides" and "being negligible" gives them credit. Consider for example, the 1999 decision of the Australian Democrats to support Howard's GST, or the role that the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) arguably played in helping to lock Labor out of the federal government between 1949 and 1972. (Although the Democrats role in supporting the GST was in the Senate, which uses STV not IRV.) In the results of the 2010 federal election, Labor and the Liberal-National Coalition had 74 seats each, both two short of a majority. Labor managed to form government with the support of four of the six unaligned (independent or minor party) MPs. Two of the independents who supported Labor (Rob Oakeshott and Tony Windsor) came from a conservative political background, and they could have easily chosen to support the Liberal-National Coalition instead. Even in strongly multi-party systems like Italy, Spain, Israel, etc, you still tend to end up with two broad coalitions anchored by the major parties of the Left and Right, plus a bunch of centrist parties that may switch between those two coalitions depending on what is on offer after each election. (And also sometimes a far-left / far-right fringe that gets locked out of government, but hopes for the day when the mainstream left/right are desperate enough to turn to them for support.)
- kyuudou 6y agoA big obstacle that was born out of the Ross Perot "surprise" was the formation of the Committee on Presidential Debates[1]. A form of manufacturing consent. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commission_on_Presidential_Debates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commission_on_Presidential_Deb...
- baddox 6y agoOkay, sure, but “we can fix it by fundamentally changing the entire way we attempt to have representation in government” is something China could do as well.
- Allower 6y agoYou are simply exploring the scope of the problem, I'm glad to see that. But the fact remains, in the west we have a cultural duty to eliminate this tyranny from our societies.
- r3trohack3r 6y agoHelp us end the DNC/RNC duopoly with a richer ballot system: https://represent.us https://represent.us You can be phone banking within 30 minutes.
- marta_morena_25 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. Can we? Please explain how that would work... Your faith in democracy is admirable, although misplaced.
- LegitShady 6y agoMany forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time…
- marta_morena_25 6y agoI am not suggesting to replace democracy... The thing is that we don't have a democracy in most countries. It's more like the government is throwing a bone to people. Real power comes through lobbying. So in a way, lobbyists have the actual power to elect, and therefore they are the actual electorate in our democracy. The "normal" person is simply just getting his bone as well to keep quiet. And looking at the fact that 40% of USA still support Trump, that may actually be a good thing.
- LegitShady 6y agoThe best way to ethically secure your rights are to secure everyone else's as well.
- chrischen 6y agoDemocracy can both be not perfect and also conducive to a surveillance state. That being said, the experiment is on-going so we can’t definitively say Democracy is the best system (unless of course you are a nationalist, in which case any system which is adopted by us is by definition the best system because we are in it).
- LegitShady 6y ago
- chooseaname 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. Can we? I don't see anyone on either side [0] of the isle doing much of anything about this. > But more importantly, I won't be spirited away to a black site by speaking ill about the president. No, but you can be if you're in Portland any time soon. [0] Why TF are we stuck with TWO?
- Forbo 6y agoBecause game theory and first past the post electoral system. Nearly any other voting system would be better than what we have.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- r3trohack3r 6y agoHelp us make that a reality: https://represent.us https://represent.us
- iso1210 6y ago> [0] Why TF are we stuck with TWO? No STV for congress/senate No AV for president Imagine you could rank you votes 1) Cruz 2) Bush (J) 3) McCain 4) Johnson 5) Sanders 6) Trump 7) Clinton (H)
- ahahahha 6y ago> Can we? I don't see anyone on either side [0] of the isle doing much of anything about this. I dont see the point of this argument. If a person has lost faith in US democracy, the person is free to leave. The US does not stop its citizens from leaving like China does with HK. The other option is to stay and work towards a more representative democracy. Doomer questions like "can we" are a waste of everyone's time. On whats happening in Portland: https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/507922-aclu-files-lawsuit-over-federal-agents-in-portland https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/507922-aclu-fil... https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53460495 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-53460495 I dont see China or Chinese cities doing either of the above. So stop with the false equivalence.
- dcposch 6y ago> Nor can the government decide it doesn't want me as CEO of my company anymore. You sure about that? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/09/30/a-ceo-who-resisted-nsa-spying-is-out-of-prison-and-he-feels-vindicated-by-snowden-leaks/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/09/30...
- dylan604 6y agoI was going to comment on just the recent use of unmarked federal agents in Portland. I never thought that within the single term of US president things could swing so far. I used to question how it happened in WWI/II, but now I see it first hand.
- zo1 6y agoI'm on the other side of that. Something needs to be done about the violent protests as it's gone way passed "free speech". At some point we have to agree that people are not really trying to enact change, but are just angry and acting out violently (or not peacefully). If it means having to send in "unmarked federal agents" to detain them because the local politicians are abdicating their duty to keeping civility within their territory, then so be it. It really is a far cry from what is happening in China.
- Cyph0n 6y agoFirst they came for the communists...
- djohnston 6y agoOn the preceding I think it would be: "First they came for the rioters.", although I disagree with OPs sentiment.
- Cyph0n 6y agoHow exactly do you know that only violent rioters are being forcibly taken? And my comment was not about who they're targeting first, but about how that kind of logic is a slippery slope. The reality is that most people lack empathy for those they do not know, and only become engaged when it affects them personally. It’s good to keep that in mind when taking dangerous stances like the above.
- deadbunny 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. Can you point to any candidate let alone party (that stands a snowballs chance in hell of being elected) that has "reduce surveillance" anywhere in their manifestos? The last 70 years of Democrat and Republican rule would suggest not.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Can you point to any candidate let alone party (that stands a snowballs chance in hell of being elected) that has "reduce surveillance" anywhere in their manifestos? Every year for a long time there has been a senator named Paul who has complained about this stuff nonstop. Nobody has listened because it is not a partisan issue. If this were a partisan issue we'd have billions of dollars behind it on both sides and the pendulum would eventually swing one way or the other.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chillwaves 6y agoRon Paul was not a Senator and his son just postures about such issues to get spotlight. I never see any action when it counts from Rand Paul. He seems to be just another enabler.
- amINeolib 6y agoRand is particularly bad. I can't compare him to Ron. Ron Paul was right and ahead of his time.
- monadic2 6y agoShahid Buttar, running against Nancy Pelosi, has a strong record of anti-surveillance activism and seems willing to run on it. Anti-surveillance politicians are out there, if rare.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoRon Wyden, Senator from OR
- fossuser 6y agoI'm pretty skeptical of the comments on issues like this when new accounts show up and immediately have a pro-china, false equivalence, or argumentative whataboutism posture (like the one you replied to): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party I agree there are clear and important differences between the west and China. Chinese Police Are Making Threatening Video Calls to Dissidents Abroad: https://www.vice.com/en_in/article/jgxdv7/chinese-police-are-video-calling-citizens-abroad-with-threats-not-to-criticize-beijing https://www.vice.com/en_in/article/jgxdv7/chinese-police-are... The World’s Most Technologically Sophisticated Genocide Is Happening in Xinjiang: https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/07/15/uighur-genocide-xinjiang-china-surveillance-sterilization/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/07/15/uighur-genocide-xinjian... Leaked drone footage of CCP authorities loading Uyghurs onto trains, presumably to transport them to reeducation camps: https://twitter.com/ne0liberal/status/1283422710555607045?s=21 https://twitter.com/ne0liberal/status/1283422710555607045?s=... Also, Hong Kong security law, tight speech controls, government restriction of the internet, political prisoners (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liu_Xiaobo#Death_and_funeral https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liu_Xiaobo#Death_and_funeral) Suggesting the US and Chinese approach to their citizens and spying are equivalent is wrong and plays into the hands of authoritarian countries that push that exact message. The irony is it's because of strong speech protections in the US people can loudly and publicly state stupid positions. You'd have less ability to do so in China (unless of course those stupid positions benefit the CCP). This doesn't mean there aren't problems in the US or that we don't need tighter controls and more public accountability/oversight in the US, but they are not equivalent.
- Cyph0n 6y agoYep. The people who think that what’s happening here is equivalent to what has been going on in China are, at best, arguing from a position of ignorance. The US, with all its flaws, is miles ahead of the human rights and privacy violations that China is committing on a daily basis.
- duncan_bayne 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. No, you can't. Because the people you're allowed to elect are all complicit in the creation and maintenance of these systems.
- hedora 6y ago> I won't be spirited away to a black site by speaking ill about the president. Trump started doing that in Portland last week. Earlier today, he said he plans to expand the program to New York, Chicago, Oakland, Detroit, and a bunch of cities with in blue states. Apparently, the Chicago PD’s leadership is welcoming it because the mayor “makes them fight with kid gloves” and this will let them ignore state and local regulations. They also say they’re planning to bypass the state courts because federal courts have harsher sentencing guidelines.
- modoc 6y agoI'm outraged about Trump's use of Federal troops in Portland as well. But to date they are either letting people go after grabbing them(in gross violations of their constitutional rights), or they are being charged with crimes in a US court, with due process and lawyers and a normal level of transparency. Portland protestors aren't being whisked away to black sites...
- chrischen 6y agoAlright, next election cycle please tell me which of the two candidates is the correct one, and then tell me how I can be a part of the electoral college so that my vote actually counts. My point isn’t that we are powerless, but that our secretly surveillance state is baked into the system, probably far beyond repair since we’ve long already chosen security over freedom.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fakeslimshady 6y ago> There's an enormous difference between the West and totalitarian dystopia China. Yes there is. Most surveys e.g. Harvard have shown the Chinese approve of their government at 80% approval. You want to guess at approval rating of Trump’s paradise. Everything you “know” is a lie regarding China. [edit] [GOP anti-china propaganda scripts](https://static.politico.com/80/54/2f3219384e01833b0a0ddf95181c/corona-virus-big-book-4.17.20.pdf https://static.politico.com/80/54/2f3219384e01833b0a0ddf9518...)
- djohnston 6y agoi mean, not everything. i think everyone sees the two systems of gov't transparently enough at least.
- goodcjw2 6y agoDisclaimer: I moved to US from China about 10 years ago. "China knows they are being spied" -> Not sure govt public admitting spying and censorship is a good thing at all. It sets a vert bad example for the rest of the country to follow. If it's OK for the central govt to do those shitty business (arguably backed by those so called national security rationals, whole another topic). Then how about local govt to use the same toolkits? How about powerful corporations, how about celebrities? Since the central govt sets a bad example, everyone else who's holding power are tend to think this is just OK. IMHO, that is what's causing much bigger damages.
- tintor 6y ago"I won't be spirited away to a black site by speaking ill about the president." It is happening in Oregon. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/07/18/call-kidnapping-federal-officers-accused-using-unmarked-cars/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/07/18/call-kidnapping-...
- unchocked 6y agoWhich is aberrant, and is being denounced by political opposition and non-state-controlled media.
- jhardy54 6y agoThat's great, but as a Portlander I'd prefer that it stopped happing. It seems that the feds are instead escalating further.
- plato_rx 6y agoOnce the violent rioters end their rioting the Feds will leave. Perhaps the rioters should just stop rioting?
- Pokepokalypse 6y agoEventually, they'll be going house-to-house.
- ergothus 6y agoHow many things have been aberrant and denounced, only to become the regrettable norm in the last few years? When I was a child, the US wouldn't open admit to torture. It didn't have publicly known programs to ship prisoners to other jurisdictions so the U.S. rules of conduct could be bypassed. It didn't have a (publicly known) prison filled with non-U.S. people that were denied a civil trial. It didn't have a president that actively preached for or against public companies outside of criminal matters. When I was a child, a president openly violating ethics concerns WAS a matter of that president getting removed - with such certainty they'd step down to avoid the inevitable result. I'm totally willing to believe that an aberrant behavior doesn't have to become the norm, but I won't believe that should be expected. I've been told all my life to expect that dramatic reactions and concerns are overstated and not the case, that we should all be calm and expect things to work out well, but if I look at the actual events of my life, I see the opposite lessons being taught: Unless we react strongly, clearly, and persistently, progress will not happen and things will slide for the worse. It's not the lesson I want to learn, it's not a lesson I am comfortable with, but it does appear to be what I've seen in the last few decades.
- u801e 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. The spying is supported by both major parties.
- justanotheranon 6y agofun fact: back in 2003, after Bush's President's Surveillance Program (NSA STELLARWIND) had been up and running for 2 years, hoovering up all domestic phone calls, emails and web traffic, the whole program was so secret that you could count on your hands who outside of NSA knew it was happening. guess who was the 9th person outside of NSA and the WH who was "read into the program" and told about NSA STELLARWIND? House Minority leader Nancy Pelosi, that's who. guess who was the 14th person read in? Deputy AG James Comey. guess who was the 17th person read in? DOJ Criminal Division chief Chris Wray, who is now FBI Director. every single Democrat leader who has been in DC for their entire career LOVES mass domestic surveillance. they have known about it all along and they never once blew the whistle or tried to stop it or simply resign their jobs in silent protest. they all went along with it, "just doing my job." voting new people into office isnt going to work.
- retromario 6y agoThey are few and far between, but there have been a couple efforts by some of the "leaders" above to stop some of the illegal domestic surveillance programs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Comey#NSA_domestic_wiretapping https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Comey#NSA_domestic_wiret...
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYes! our surveillance woes are on us. In China you have no choice.
- yibg 6y agoMaybe this is the key point here. We feel our system is less evil because we think we control it. While the evil CPP has no accountability to the population. I think the reality is both systems are really not under the control of the citizens (not really anyways. Call it 0% control in China and 10% in the US), but the illusion of control in the west gives a sense of comfort.
- jojobas 6y ago>echelon You could at least log in with a different account before posting this.
- chiefalchemist 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. How exactly does that happen when the two key entities have direct ties the the rest of the (surveillance) system? Those two enties control who gets to run, who is on the ballot. For example, look at Biden. He didn't win. The DNC put their thumb on the scale for him. Any perception of being able to fight is an illusion, it's a ruse. As for the difference between East and West, that's true. That doesn't mean we're not in danger. Just because you can't see doesn't mean it's not there.
- bmitc 6y ago----
- ratsmack 6y ago>He can do and has done whatever he wants Do you have some examples of what he's done?
- normalnorm 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people. Can you? There are a few problems: firstly, the primaries are controlled by the parties, so you have a very limited menu to choose from when it comes to the actual elections. Secondly, the media is no longer independent. If you are not aligned with the status quo, you will get no exposure, or only very negative exposure. Finally, politicians consistently do the opposite of what they promise on such matters. Take Obama: a lot of people believed that he was the way to fight, that he was the "correct person". He promised to encourage whistle-blowing, and then he did the opposite. This is not a partisan observation, I pick this example because it is the most recent disappointment on such matters. > But more importantly, I won't be spirited away to a black site by speaking ill about the president. It is happening right now in Oregon. > Nor can the government decide it doesn't want me as CEO of my company anymore. Are you sure? > Or prevent me from funding the opposition party. Try funding a radical party and see what happens. > There's an enormous difference between the West and totalitarian dystopia China. I agree that there is, but it is scary to see that the difference is becoming smaller and most people seem ok with that. I worry that the future will not be a place worth living in.
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoCan you ? Cause the patriot act has been reconducted for 3 generations of presidents since 9/11, including obama, along with legalized mass surveillance, torture and deny of habeas corpus.
- grey-area 6y agoWell to cite some examples from the recent past by the US: You may be drummed out as CEO of a major corp on trumped up charges (almost any high level exec could be found guilty of this): https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2007/10/qwest-ceo-nsa-punished-qwest-refusing-participate-illegal-surveillance-pre-9-11 https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2007/10/qwest-ceo-nsa-punished... You may be assassinated without trial or explanation anywhere in the world: https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/18/opinion/the-drone-that-killed-my-grandson.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/18/opinion/the-drone-that-ki... You may be kidnapped in any country and tortured at a black site in Syria: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maher_Arar You may be arbitrarily pulled off the streets and detained by unidentified paramilitary forces: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jul/20/trump-shock-troops-portland-doomed https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jul/20/trump-... It's extremely unlikely if you are white, non-muslim and do exactly as they ask, which may give you some comfort, but the US or other Western states do engage in the things you listed too. I agree China is a much worse state at present than the US say, but I wouldn't be too comfortable about defying the US government on something they care about - they have murdered, coerced and ruined lives too in the recent past.
- thablackbull 6y ago"worse" perhaps based on whatever scale you're using. Starting illegal wars and overthrowing governments to put in puppets tends to be quite atrocious, but I guess if you benefit from it, no problems then.
- grey-area 6y agoChina has done this too and will continue to do so. They've also recently perpetrated genocide, ethnic cleansing and massive oppression of their population. It's very hard to compare countries, and there are certainly major problems with civil rights in the US, but I'd rather live in the US than in China right now.
- Cthulhu_ 6y ago> It's extremely unlikely if you are white, non-muslim and do exactly as they ask True now, but that one poem will come up; First They Came (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_...). If this keeps up, anyone who is more left / liberal leaning will be next, then the intellectuals, etc. It's happened before, pretty much exactly like this, it's just that the uniforms are different. Why isn't the international community pulling on the emergency brakes? The UN was founded to prevent this exact shit. But the problem with the UN is that the perpetrators in this case all have a lot of influence there + veto powers, so it's basically powerless and useless.
- raxxorrax 6y agoHillary Clinton? Joe Biden? Who are these magic people you speak of? It is true what you say, but officially it isn't permitted to spy on citizens through the western world. If that is scrapped, I would prefer honesty.
- OwlsParlay 6y agoWhich correct people? The Democrats and Republicans are hand-in-glove on supporting the surveillance state.
- GordonS 6y ago> We can fight it by electing the correct people In theory - the reality is very different. In both the US and UK you effectively have only 2 political parties, and have done since forever. In both the US and UK, the foreign policies, stance on mass surveillance, and support for the defence and security services, are the same. Ask yourself when the last time was that the US/UK weren't cosied up Saudi Arabia, or the last time when the US wasn't bombing other countries to hell in the name of freedom or stoppi g the boogeyman de-jour (with allies like the UK in tow, of course). It's been the same since forever, and I don't see how our political system will ever offer a way out, a way to become better nations.