5 ms·
> I further predict that this will spark a creative gold rush among talented amateurs to train similar models and adapt them to a variety of purposes, including
by rvz 6y ago
> I further predict that this will spark a creative gold rush among talented amateurs to train similar models and adapt them to a variety of purposes, including: mock news, “researched journalism”, advertising, politics, and propaganda.
The first mention of 'Elon Musk' (who left the board) and this sentence alone gave me the tip-off that GPT-3 had generated that (and the whole blog) and it's following prediction makes no sense.
Sure, it may be used for nefarious purposes, but no-one can train GPT-3 in any acceptable time except for those with access to large GPU/ASIC compute power (OpenAI, Microsoft, Google, NVIDIA, etc.) Without the model, it is not possible to adapt it to any other purpose, unless OpenAI does it for them. Without a detection mechanism, it is very dangerous.
Nice try and a great GPT-3 hype experiment, (mostly by friends of OpenAI). I look forward to the day that GPT-3 gets proper scrutiny from the actual wider tech industry before we can safely use it with detection methods.
- monocasa 6y agoPropaganda, advertising, and politics (arguably all the same thing) absolutely have access to the funds for this. Facebook and Google, the biggest investors in state of the art ML are advertising companies. Their customers have the funds to do this independently.
- confeit 6y agoGiving certain people, highly visible on social media, pre-public access to the model, and letting them cherry pick their completions to post without the prompt or amount of tries, is a smart form of propaganda/hype building/PR management, that we have come to expect from "GPT-2 is too dangerous to release" openAI Sometimes I forget that, while this model was created by scientists, and released with a scientific paper, it is essentially a for-profit business product, and such cheap tricks deserve harsh criticism.
- derefr 6y ago> Sometimes I forget that, while this model was created by scientists, and released with a scientific paper, it is essentially a for-profit business product, and such cheap tricks deserve harsh criticism. Sure, but this is akin to seeing bad science journalism and tarring the science itself with the same brush. GPT-3 still factually has certain properties, independently of anyone making grandiose assertions about those properties. What those properties are, we can only say slightly—e.g. we know it’s capable of generating certain texts eventually, among an unbounded corpus of other texts it may have generated that were then human-discarded. But the fact that it can generate those texts at all—faster than brute-force, I mean—is an interesting fact on its own, worthy of scrutiny independent of whatever airier claims are being made.
- BickNowstrom 6y agoIt is certainly impressive, and I don't want to discard GPT-3. Just critiquing the (smart) release: make a select few feel special by giving them API access, and watch your product dominate the tech - and news cycle for weeks. You'll have VC money in the bank before showing actual worth or business value. Maybe a bit simplistic, but I view GPT as a Markov chain text generator, operating on word vectors instead of word tokens, and having a larger look-back. It's like a child copying a joke, because she heard adults laughing about it, but she does not understand the punchline. You wouldn't say that child understands or even displays humor, despite substituting "horse" with "donkey" when retelling the joke.
- Filligree 6y agoIf you want to play with GPT-3, you can do so right now. Go to https://play.aidungeon.com https://play.aidungeon.com Make an account, and select the "Dragon" model. That's GPT-3. I've spent ten hours playing with it over the last two days. It isn't perfect, and it feels short of the hype it's generating about itself, but it's an amazing leap nonetheless. It really seems to have an understanding of causality, biology, all sorts of fictional themes... It isn't perfect. You frequently have to back it up and try again. Unless you make good use of the site's long-term memory function, it'll forget anything that happened over a page ago, and a lot of the time its idea of what should happen next doesn't match the plot I had in mind. I'm getting better at that. However, as a writer myself, I can say that this is just as true for human writers as well. For every final draft you see there are ten discarded ones, and a hundred that never made it to paper. Viewed that way, GPT-3 is actually much better at the core part of writing than I am! It's more creative, it uses English better, it's better at matching the narration to the characters than I am... It's just that this isn't enough. It's missing a full model of the world, and it doesn't know how to look at what it's written and decide if it matches its intent, or whether it'll break consistency or get in the way later. It doesn't have an intent. It doesn't know about consistency. But that's also true for that part of me. GPT-3 isn't a human-level writer. What I've determined, however, is that it's a huge part of one, and it's more than good enough to fulfill the role of that part already. Now we just need the other nine tenths.
- graham_paul 6y ago> no-one can train GPT-3 in any acceptable time except for those with access to large GPU/ASIC compute power (OpenAI, Microsoft, Google, NVIDIA, etc.) Any state actor has access to large compute power
- briga 6y agoBut it might be hard to attract talented AI engineers to live in, say, North Korea
- acdha 6y agoWhat about North Koreans desperate to be part of the privileged elite? They can take courses and learn just like anyone else.
- nefitty 6y agoI’m genuinely curious how accessible that sort of material is to the average North Korean.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoHow much of a choice do they have? I can't imagine many of the top engineers in North Korea are allowed to leave
- ekianjo 6y agoWhen most of your population is borderline starving the number of top engineers can be counted on very few hands in NK.
- saagarjha 6y agoThat being said, North Korea has a fairly decent cyberespionage program from what I hear.
- graham_paul 6y ago
- smallnamespace 6y ago> no-one can train GPT-3 in any acceptable time except Gwern, who has spent probably as much time with GPT-3 and GPT-2 as any 'amateur' out there, is publicly out there saying that for most use cases, GPT-3 + creative use of prompts gets you better results than GPT-2 with finetuning. That's an amazing capability that Gwern elaborates on more here: > A new programming paradigm? The GPT-3 neural network is so large a model in terms of power and dataset that it exhibits qualitatively different behavior: you do not apply it to a fixed set of tasks which were in the training dataset, requiring retraining on additional data if one wants to handle a new task (as one would have to retrain GPT-2); instead, you interact with it, expressing any task in terms of natural language descriptions, requests, and examples, tweaking the prompt until it “understands” & it meta-learns the new task based on the high-level abstractions it learned from the pretraining. This is a rather different way of using a DL model, and it’s better to think of it as a new kind of programming, where the prompt is now a “program” which programs GPT-3 to do new things. https://www.gwern.net/GPT-3#prompts-as-programming https://www.gwern.net/GPT-3#prompts-as-programming Almost all the GPT-3 results you see on Twitter are via the OpenAI API - no finetuning, only prompting. That implies... > Without the model, it is not possible to adapt it to any other purpose, unless OpenAI does it for them ... that we're actually very far from plumbing the possible ranges of behavior of GPT-3 with different sorts of prompting. This is a new ballgame folks. The old rules don't quite apply here.
- yomly 6y agoI don't really understand your post (and don't know much about GPT3) are you suggesting that the model is stateful in that it can continue learning from successive prompts? Maybe you can elaborate on this: >instead, you interact with it, expressing any task in terms of natural language descriptions, requests, and examples, tweaking the prompt until it “understands” & it meta-learns the new task based on the high-level abstractions it learned from the pretraining. Or are you suggesting that it has such a deep network of abstractions that once a user starts to map that out, the mileage they can extract back out of the model via prompts is very exciting.
- walleeee 6y ago
- threeseed 6y ago> no-one can train GPT-3 in any acceptable time except for those with access to large GPU/ASIC compute power That's not true. a) Premium AWS customers, for example, can request to have instance limits removed which then gives you access to all of the AWS GPU-enabled instances available worldwide. b) People ramble on about GPUs but Intel DLBoost/AVX-512 enabled CPUs can get you comparable performance to a medium end GPU in many situations. That then opens the door to training across all of the cloud and VPS providers. Money is the limiting factor here not available compute resources.
- thu2111 6y agoDo you have any links I can read in the latter claim? Using avx512 for ai with comparable power to a GPU?
- sinity 6y agoUh-huh. Except anyone can verify the results themselves, sans specific ones like code generation - through (paid version) of AI Dungeon. Amount of people confidently posting bullshit on Hacker News is astounding. Reacting like everything we know about GPT is just a bunch of tech demos. Supposedly everyone who has access to the API is just a shill. Eh.
- Tarrosion 6y agoI just spent an hour or so playing around with the paid version of AI Dungeon, and was super unimpressed. It's pretty fun for a moment, sure, and I assume some really heroic work went into building it. I'm not saying the creators did a poor job so much as the task is really hard and the final result is...lacking. The "Dragon" (GPT-3) engine responds reasonably to any particular input, but clearly lacks a coherent state of the world. Objects appear and disappear; plot cues are given and then can never be summoned again if not immediately grabbed, environments change dramatically without explanation, etc. Do you feel otherwise?
- ilaksh 6y agoRight. It has some type of language ability, but no world modeling. So overall it really doesn't make sense. But since that is so obvious, I assume many people are trying to figure out how to improve it. So I am excited to see if they can make progress in the next few years. It is going to be quite difficult though. I think it might require integrating a totally different type of subsystem, if it is possible at all. But the ability to make realistic sounding language is a step forward it seems to me.
- killerstorm 6y agoWhy do you believe they won't release the model? It's Open AI after all. Google, NVIDIA and Microsoft also make their models freely available. Google already trained a model which is bigger than GPT-3. There might be some delay, but no fundamental problem with it. Fine-tuning the entire GPT-3 is impossible on a single GPU. But it's still possible to fine-tune specific layers. Plus, I'm sure somebody will release a distilled version of it which is more manageable.
- polyanos 6y ago>Why do you believe they won't release the model? It's Open AI after all. Because they want to commercialize the model "to cover the costs of research", it's stated in their blog post FAQ[0]. >Google already trained a model which is bigger than GPT-3. Source?, a fast Google search yielded no results and I'm curious. [0]https://openai.com/blog/openai-api/ https://openai.com/blog/openai-api/
- killerstorm 6y agoThey commercialize the API. The model is so large you can't run it on a single GPU, AFAIK. OpenAI developed an infrastructure to run the model efficiently. So many companies would rather use API than deploy the model on their own hardware. They will probably release the baseline model, not model optimized for deployment. There are many optimizations possible such as precision reduction, pruning, distillation, and they don't have to share these optimizations. > a fast Google search yielded no results and I'm curious. List of pre-trained models on huggingface: https://huggingface.co/models https://huggingface.co/models You can see some of them are prefixed with "google". Also ALBERT is from Google Research. That's just natural language processing, I dunno what they have in other fields.
- nschucher 6y agoThey trained a >600B parameter translation model (GPT-3 is 175B parameters). GShard: Scaling Giant Models with Conditional Computation and Automatic Sharding (https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.16668 https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.16668)