7 ms·
Or, and this is a really crazy theory, they were studying it in China because it was a local virus that they were worried might one day infect humans. Maybe th
by sandworm101 6y ago
Or, and this is a really crazy theory, they were studying it in China because it was a local virus that they were worried might one day infect humans. Maybe they were studying which changes would make it most dangerous because they wanted to be ready if those changes happened naturally. Honest hard work can sometimes look like evil plans, and not every coincidence is the result of conspiracy.
- markdown 6y ago> they were studying it in China because it was a local virus that they were worried might one day infect humans. Maybe they were studying which changes would make it most dangerous because they wanted to be ready if those changes happened naturally. The person you're responding to didn't say anything different to what you've said. > Honest hard work can sometimes look like evil plans, and not every coincidence is the result of conspiracy. Why did you say that? It certainly isn't stated or even implied by the person you're replying to.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoThe person he/she/they is responding to may not have originated the thought, but the quote this poster is responding to is very clear from context. It reads as follows: “The authors feel that, in light of this preponderance of circumstantial evidence, the hypothesis that the biogenesis of SARS-CoV-2 involved human intervention should be seen as the leading (i.e. most likely) explanation.”
- bitcurious 6y agoWhich is not an accusation of research done in bad faith. The linked paper referenced 4 others as evidence. It doesn't say that those 4 were somehow done for evil - just that they were done.
- stx 6y agoI actually believe this to be the case. From what I have read researchers often do something called gain of function research. In this research they add genetic features to viruses that could make it more infective. This is done, at least in part, to help learn how to protect society from such a virus if it were to evolve naturally. I thought I heard somewhere that one of the functions coronavirus has that its closest known relatives do not have just happens to be something that virologists frequently add. All this leads me to believe it was created in a lab. Likely for altruistic purposes but still. When this escaped whoever knew that it was from a lab should have disclosed it ASAP to help the world prepare. I have no experience in virology so don't trust me.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe thing I just don't understand is why gain research would take the effort of making the virus much less deadly. This virus is around ten times less deadly that SARS, wouldn't gain research at least maintain virulence?
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoDepends, what if you had a virus that caused the same antiviral response as SARS on the immune system but had no deaths (couldn't cause death)?
- nickfromseattle 6y agoYou switch from death rate or R0, so it's not clear which variable you are referring to. COVID-19 may be less deadly, but it has killed more people than SARS. So it does appear to be a 'better' virus.
- Confusion 6y agoOne way of discovering what increases property X is testing that some change decreases property X. Another way of discovering what increases property X is testing that some change indeed increases property X, while also discovering it decreases property Y. While attempting to increase both X and Y, they made an intermediate with increased X and decreased Y. Perhaps it seemed a promising starting point to also increase Y. I don't get the surprise. This is all par for the course in research.
- esalman 6y agoI do not have experience in virology either but what you heard is correct. Researchers do work on creating new strains of viruses, with the goal being development of vaccines before epidemics start.
- waspleg 6y agoWhy give a government with modern day concentration camps, forced organ harvesting, and military occupation of free countries like Hong Kong the benefit of the doubt on biological weapons research gone awry?
- ss7pro 6y agoC'mon Hong Kong belongs to China and always was. It was just leased to UK and this lease had ended in last century. China just wanted to reap benefits of Being Kong economy this is why they given them such a huge autonomy . They can change it anytime as this is their property. If someone would follow your logic Hawai is also US occupied country ...
- vmlinuz 6y agoSo I'm not going to get into an argument, just make three basic points to reply here: Hong Kong did not always belong to China, and was not leased to the UK - part of Hong Kong's area (the New Territories) was leased, but Kowloon and Hong Kong island were ceded in perpetuity. China signed an international treaty with the UK regarding the handover of Hong Kong, a treaty which comes with certain rights and responsibilities. Sure, there's no real way to actually enforce such a treaty, but you can't really complain if other countries react to the breaking of a treaty with punitive measures, and don't trust the treaty-breaker not to break other treaties in future. How about asking the people of Hong Kong what they want? There's about 7.5 million of us here, with a fairly unique history and culture, so maybe just being subsumed into another country wouldn't be the choice of the population?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anonAndOn 6y agoHawaii was taken from its native peoples and there is a very slow process underway to remediate that. [0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_recognition_of_Native_Hawaiians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_recognit...
- 6y ago
- tasogare 6y agoYeah sure the racist hypothesis of Chinese people eating bats is far more likely than a virus escape from a Wuhan lab with known protocol defects that worked on coronaviruses. /s
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoAre you saying bats weren't sold/used as food in Wuhan? What's racist about suggesting someone eats bats? Mammalian flesh is a common food source across human cultures. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_as_food https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_as_food
- mytailorisrich 6y agoBats are not really eaten as food in China. Maybe eaten as part of traditional medicines or rarely in specific rural areas but that's about it. The videos of people eating bats that surfaced following the beginning of Covid-19 were from Indonesia. The way this misinformation has spread is indeed based on racism (Chinese are 'barbarians' who have 'barbarian' eating habits and they should change them and eat like 'normal' people). Now, (fruit) bats eaten as food in West Africa is a major vector of the spread of Ebola.
- jryle70 6y ago> Now, (fruit) bats eaten as food in West Africa is a major vector of the spread of Ebola. And maybe one day we can conclusively say bats play no roles whatsoever in the spread of Covid-19, like we are able to say confidently about bats and Ebola. We aren't at that point yet, dismissing bats as a factor is a disservice to science.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoDiscussing whether bats play a role as vector or reservoir of the virus is not the same as making thinly-veiled racist comments on a culture or as spreading misinformation on a culture.
- biolurker1 6y agoThis is not the scientific method you are applying but a hopeful emotional reaction.