10 ms·
I'm surprised they didn't look at Walt Disney for how to run a successful creative company. His ideas apply equally well to software as they do to the arts. I
by jedberg 6y ago
I'm surprised they didn't look at Walt Disney for how to run a successful creative company. His ideas apply equally well to software as they do to the arts.
I've been watching the documentaries on Disney+, particularly The Imagineering Story (great doc BTW). They talk about the history of the creative side of Disneyland.
What you learn is that when they are simply given a budget and told "build" they thrive. When a CFO type gets involved with Disney, suddenly their output drops, because that CEO is asking what the ROI is for everything they do. A lot of what they do fails and has no ROI, and the people that work there start to worry about what their ROI will be before they start working.
When the CEO just says "We're going to spend X% on research, here is the budget" then they thrive again.
I think this is applicable to software. When an engineer isn't asked to think about the ROI ahead of time, they are left free to come up with novel innovations. But if they know they will be judged on ROI, they will take fewer risks.
This of course is all predicated on being a profitable company. You have to already have a good cashflow to have the freedom to say "just go create".
- deepakhj 6y agoMy friend at Pixar says they've slowly dismantled all the good things and benefits at Pixar after Disney bought them. Disney+ was built by the acquisition of BAMTech I believe. Maybe they have more autonomy like AWS does inside of Amazon.
- jedberg 6y agoD+ was literally built by BAMTech using the same tech that powers HBOGo and MLB streaming. I think the Pixar thing has more to do with their management, namely John Lassater, moving south to head up Disney Animation, which did extremely well when he took over. Apparently they're doing even better under Jennifer Lee, who took over for him when he left/was ousted.
- hitsurume 6y agoWhat's the documentary called?
- jedberg 6y agoThe Imagineering Story https://www.disneyplus.com/series/the-imagineering-story/6ryoXv1e1rWW https://www.disneyplus.com/series/the-imagineering-story/6ry...
- acidbaseextract 6y agoI would vouch for Imagineering Story as well. Great mix of technical stuff that's awesome from a nerd perspective, while entertaining for the non-techies too.
- andi999 6y agoIf I remember correct suppesedly Walt said:"I dont get (stomach) ulcers, I give them". But I fully agree on the CFOs spoiling the show: remember Tom & Jerry? There are (I think) 114 (great) episodes. Then at their creative peak the whole animation team was dismanteled, since they calculated they can make more money with reruns than with new content. Later there was a low quality reboot, though.
- skmurphy 6y agoQuote investigator https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/11/04/ulcer/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/11/04/ulcer/ sourced this to David O. Selznick or Samuel Goldwyn. There are not attributions to Walt Disney uncovered. In an article about Disney https://jewishjournal.com/uncategorized/17567/ https://jewishjournal.com/uncategorized/17567/ Stanley Gold, a former director at Disney, is quoted saying, "I don’t get ulcers – I give ulcers." I don't believe that you remembered this correctly.
- andi999 6y agoThanks. This made me look up where I got it from. It seems from the orbituary in the LA Times: https://www.latimes.com/local/obituaries/archives/la-me-walt-disney-19661216-story.html?_amp=true https://www.latimes.com/local/obituaries/archives/la-me-walt...
- skmurphy 6y agoThanks for the cite, I learned something new.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat's true of anything! Engineers optimize for a living. $ + labor ($$) = Output. It works when you grow, but gets expensive when growth slows. When the accountants come in, that's when the business is settling for (by choice or by market pressure) whatever they have, a little cheaper. You see this with big capital assets in your personal life like houses and cars. Check out a cookie cutter subdivision new house with "builder spec" trimmings. The house is $600k, so they'll put in a granite countertop and shiny metal appliances to check the boxes and get the mortgage approved. But the light fixtures, toilets, etc are "builder grade" crap that are $14.99 at Home Depot! In lower price developments, the developers will skimp even more -- one near my house actually stripped and sold the topsoil! Imagine the corners cut inside if they were harvesting dirt for $.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoWhen the CEO just says "We're going to spend X% on research, here is the budget" then they thrive again. Incidentally, this is how OpenAI wound up in a situation where they might die in a few years. (Aka be acquired by Microsoft.) The logic works at Google, Facebook, and Disney. Not so much for startups without a revenue model.
- jedberg 6y agoThat's why I said in my last sentence, that this is all predicated on already having positive cashflow.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoSorry, you’re right. I’ll read more carefully from now on.
- scarface74 6y agoHas it really worked at Google? After all of these years they are still an ad company after years of trying to diversify.
- tracker1 6y agoI think it helped with their mind-share and broader lockin as a side effect.
- scarface74 6y agoLock-in how? There is absolutely nothing Google offers outside of search where there are not better, more polished alternatives. I’ll admit that ChromeBooks+GSuite is excellent for elementary and middle school though.
- greiskul 6y agoWhat is more polished than YouTube? For live content there is Twitch, but for edited amateur content YouTube is king.
- csours 6y agoInteresting that you bring up Disney. My company had an organization go through Disney's training (I don't remember the name of it), and then later the rest of the company had similar training. Some things have changed for the better since thing, but IT is still a cost center, which drives how projects are allocated. Until you get upper level management away from treating IT as a cost center, you can't really unlock the creative potential. Of course you have to have financial discipline, and one of the classic methods for that is cost based accounting.
- ci5er 6y agoIf you aren't a software products or services company (engine of revenue), won't IT always be a cost center? If you are in IT at a bank, in retail, logistics, telecom, O&G, even trading, if what you produce isn't what you sell, then is IT not a cost center? If you were the CEO at a retail giant, like Target, how would you account for IT's in/out budget and expectations? I'm frankly amazed that Xerox PARC got away with being unaccountable rogues (with great unmonetized results!) for so long given that they didn't support the revenue side of the house one little bit. (Amazing place and time, though! And the director of the lab appears to have been a hell of a manager of unruly computer scientists!)
- csours 6y agoThe very short answer is "value based accounting" - but that opens up so many questions that I don't have the answer to. I can tell that cost based accounting is definitely part of the problem, but I can't really tell you how to get to somewhere better.
- save_ferris 6y agoWithin the last 5-10 years, Disney outsourced entire technology divisions using the H1-B visa program and forced employees to train their replacements for their last 90 days or forgo severance. A former Disney IT employee testified before Congress, at times crying while he recounted the experience of being let go and having to personally train his replacement.[0] Whatever Walt Disney was doing back in the day doesn't seem to apply anymore, at least based on your description of what a successful creative company looks like. To me, this looks ruthless and manipulative. 0: https://www.computerworld.com/article/3038292/former-disney-it-worker-to-congress-how-can-you-allow-this.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/3038292/former-disney-...
- dijit 6y agoOne could argue that both you and the parent are not in disagreement. The extreme success of Walt Disney as CEO has created a huge company that is an unfeeling monster predisposed to owning everything and chewing up human capital when needed.
- Spivak 6y agoAnd the management practices that allowed the creative culture to thrive weren't applied to tech and IT because the creatives were the "rockstars" at Disney and everyone else was the boring business side that supported them. I think the takeaway for the tech side of things is what parts of our businesses are we not letting thrive because the engineers are the focus.
- jimbokun 6y agoOr maybe it makes sense for the creatives to be the "rockstars" at Disney, and for the engineers to be the "rockstars" at software companies. Companies should invest most heavily in the areas that are directly creating and discovering value, and outsource everything else to the greatest extent possible.
- petra 6y ago
- ptmcc 6y agoI know a bunch of software engineers that used to work for Disney, specifically in their online content divisions, and they universally reviled that place. The usual bad software engineering practices with overbearing management, unrealistic deadlines, etc. but also below market pay and benefits, constant pressure to lower costs and outsource, and just generally a very cutthroat business environment. Like other "cool" companies, they cash in on their brand cachet to treat employees badly, because they should be honored to work for such a company! Whatever "magic" there is at Disney is all marketing.
- nostromo95 6y agoLike any company, it’s much better working in the function that drives their competitive advantage—supply chain at walmart, marketing at coke, etc. They get the management attention and the budget. Working in software at Disney is going to be closer to working in software at your average company, which isn’t fantastic.
- jimmaswell 6y agoI just watched a series of videos by Technology Connections of the opposite playing out at RCA leading to the failure of the CED video system. They hired a bunch of smart people with various science/engineering degrees from prestigious universities, gave them essentially free reign to research things, and all they ended up doing was floundering around for decades, not wanting to develop anything to practicality because that's less interesting than new theoretical research and is less likely to get them more published papers. Seems like you certainly need at some degree of direction and limitations on research teams.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe problem there is more that they chose researchers to do engineering tasks. There are plenty of people inclined to build, just not those people.
- dialamac 6y agoHave seen those videos (quite good) and very familiar with the downfall of RCA, but not sure I agree with this take. RCA basically set up an unworkable scenario and management did not heed the sunk cost fallacy to realize they were down the garden path. A stylus based cheaply made consumer electronic device with the technology at the time was pretty much impossible (and then of course by the time tech had advanced a stylus based system was totally moot). You could have hired manhattan project people and it wouldn’t have changed the physical/economic realities of what they were trying to do.
- jimmaswell 6y agoI got the impression everyone on the research team was more interested in publishing papers and going down obscure research than more immediately useful results. That kind of research has its value but I think you need more direction and a mix of more people that are more interested in making working stuff.
- smabie 6y agoThe ultimate example of this is Symbolics, the company behind the General Lisp machine. PhDs controlled the place and they ended up wasting gargantuan sums of money on building the "perfect" Lisp machine. It's still probably the most advanced OS ever designed and yet it failed miserably. Like all things, balance is required. Engineers and finance people need to be on equal footing, to serve as a system of checks and balances. The when either group becomes to strong, it spells doom. It's usually the finance types that win these struggles of power though (I'm not exactly sure why), so don't have as many examples of engineers destroying companies. Though, I think Google might be a good example of flaky engineers taking over and the bad that results from it.
- aprdm 6y agoBob Iger's book - the ride of a lifetime - is also really good if you're interested in that!
- larrik 6y agoCounterpoint: 3D Realms. They made so much money off of Duke Nukem 3D that they never learned how to manage their business and burned all their money trying to make "the perfect sequel".
- paulryanrogers 6y agoValve software may be another example. Though with their shadow hierarchy I'm not sure the why is as clear cut.
- leonroy 6y agoHere’s a look at how and why Valve lost their way and hopefully an indication that they might be on the path back to making great games again (although I personally think their new focus has more to do with competition to Steam from Epic and GOG sharpening minds). https://youtu.be/mHdrosltGJA https://youtu.be/mHdrosltGJA
- scarface74 6y agoWhat you learn is that when they are simply given a budget and told "build" they thrive. Or they end up with dozens of failed initiatives including three or four messenger apps being developed in parallel.... There are a lot of “smart people” (tm) when left to their own devices can’t create a product that anyone wants to save their lives. When the CEO just says "We're going to spend X% on research, here is the budget" then they thrive again. Or you end up with the Apple Technology Group that brought the world great products like OpenDoc, QuickDraw GX, Squeak, etc
- ci5er 6y ago"Pink" also brought us Dylan, Kaleida and Taligent. The old Mac team was pretty core to General Magic w/ IBM, Motorola and AT&T as partners. A lot of it was pretty good! But it suffered from a top-down "from on high" market introduction, and somehow never got traction. Which is too bad. (General Magic's mobile agent model also had some unfortunate dynamic security effects when an agent "traveled to a 'bad neighborhood' to compute on the results of a query, it wasn't allowed back into the gated-community good neighborhoods to deliver results. Large distributed systems got pretty unusable pretty fast. Unfortunate - because I liked the vision - and some super-smart people worked on it - and I was surprised they didn't catch that early on)
- scarface74 6y agoIsn’t that the point? “Smart People” had free reign and couldn’t ship.
- ci5er 6y agoThey could ship ... but to whom? Marketing and market timing and product-market fit. (Ref: why didn't Smalltalk take over the world)
- scarface74 6y agoThat still kind of making my point. The right product at the wrong time is the wrong product. Post 1997 Apple, there was Jobs, Cook, Schiller, Ive and Forstall among others that actually focused on shipping products instead of letting the “smart people” run wild. All indications is that they balanced each other out as leaders.
- wnevets 6y agoIs a documentary about Disney created by Disney being streamed on Disney+ really a great source?
- jedberg 6y agoAdmittedly the docs on Disney+ about Disney are somewhat propaganda, some more obvious than not. But you can still extract kernels of truth.
- burntoutfire 6y ago> When an engineer isn't asked to think about the ROI ahead of time, they are left free to come up with novel innovations. In the cases I've seen, given free reign the engineers were happy to focus their effort on their personal interests, such as writing everything in a functional language or developing byzantine microservices + CI/CD.
- jiofih 6y agoSeems quite presumptuous to assume those choices were not adding value. Would you be able to tell if they were? Most importantly, as mentioned in the article, engineering teams need (and want) clear business goals. There is a huge chasm between having an expected ROI vs having no targets at all.
- burntoutfire 6y agoThe very complex and ambitious solutions they engineered, are currently a nightmare to maintain, as it's hard to hire people who can understand them (thanks to the technologies being very new and/or niche). Meanwhile, the requirements were bog standard and there's no demand to be scalable, to have high reliability etc. The system could probably be coded by a bunch of interns and grads in whatever language they fancy.
- an_opabinia 6y agoBrian Chesky says, verbatim, if he could be anyone, it would be "Walt Disney." Okay, here's a CEO who read a bio on Walt Disney, he's been aspiring to be Walt Disney for a while, verbatim, at least since being some guy at 3DID. Is AirBnb profitable? Then? Now? Is it just really about saying the right stuff? Are they creative and innovative? Do engineers like working there? So what if they say yes versus no? Is it really about ROI versus not ROI? If Brian Chesky says, as he frequently does, that he learned a lot about management from Walt Disney, okay, he did. No dispute there. But you're talking about Walt Disney, you are speculating about CEOs who should be copying him, I found one for you. Go ahead and analyze that, Brian Chesky and his company. Management performance is, and always will be, mostly but not exclusively explained by "I was around in the right place at the right time to concentrate returns on capital in my hands." For every S&P 500 exec there are 6 Russell 3000 execs, most of them receiving roughly the same elite educations, learn of the same trends, representing a great diversity of businesses. S&P 500 median CEO pay 2019Q1 was $12.2m and Russell 3000 was $2.7m. Russell 3000 CEOs might be at worst 10 percentage points "less creative" than S&P 500 CEOs, but no way they are 4.5x less creative. It matters little what you do, if the pie is big and you eat most of it you will be the fattest. This is also incidentally VC view of management and corporate strategy.
- jimbokun 6y ago> Russell 3000 CEOs might be at worst 10 percentage points "less creative" than S&P 500 CEOs, but no way they are 4.5x less creative. How do you know that? How would you measure it?
- an_opabinia 6y agoExactly. Creativity is incommensurable with developing best practices in an MBA program, going both ways - there are strong priors about the weights of factors in a model of performance, and creativity is basically impossible to measure.
- ativzzz 6y ago> Management performance is, and always will be, mostly but not exclusively explained by "I was around in the right place at the right time to concentrate returns on capital in my hands." I agree with this statement. [1] seems to agree with it as well, finding no correlation between CEO performance and quality of MBA program or past successes as CEO. Obviously those aren't the only two factors to consider what makes a successful CEO, but it's what a lot of people in society think. [1] https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1db3jy3201d38/The-MBA-Myth-and-the-Cult-of-the-CEO https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1db3jy3201d38...
- scarface74 6y agoThat’s an idealized version of how Disney has worked for decades that doesn’t match reality. Disney is all about the “wheelhouse” where the various parts of the company work together to monetize IP - movie distribution, merchandising, home video, parks, licensing, spin off cartoons, etc. Apple doesn’t let “1000 flowers bloom” either. Everything is coordinated from software, hardware, design, marketing, operations, etc.
- jedberg 6y agoApple is actually a perfect example. Most of their employees are directed in what they do, but they also have small groups of people who are just handed money and told to make something amazing. Usually it starts with an executive who has an idea, and is then given budget to spin up a team to execute that vision.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lend000 6y agoI can only speak to engineering, but in my experience it isn't that simple. An example: SpaceX vs Blue Origin. SpaceX was actually founded 2 years after Blue Origin, but it has a significant technology and business lead. Elon Musk set ambitious deadlines and micromanaged some of the technology goals from the start, requiring deliverable products to be able to stay in business. Whereas Bezos still just infuses up to a billion dollars of his own money a year, and as a result has a more relaxed atmosphere and slower progress. The result is that everyone knows what SpaceX is doing, but only people on HN have heard of Blue Origin. Caveats: Elon Musk's far more active leadership may have also played a role, while Bezos left leadership to people who probably did not fully match Musk's creativity and drive.
- ativzzz 6y agoIs Blue Origin as cutthroat and aggressive as Amazon about squeezing out performance out of its employees? SpaceX definitely is.
- api 6y ago> and the people that work there start to worry about what their ROI will be before they start working. This is it I think. People start basically self-censoring. The problem is that it's notoriously hard to predict ROI ahead of time. Many of the highest ROI projects look like long shots while many "sure thing" projects bomb. You can see the result of this with Hollywood and its endless remakes, reboots, and comic book flicks. These are "sure things" and most do in fact make money, but the whole sector is sinking. I have zero excitement about movies anymore. All the interesting stuff is in serialized series and indie projects. I don't even pay attention to what movies are being released, and I'm not alone.
- m463 6y agoYeah a friend wanted to work at Disney maybe 20-25 years ago and they don't treat their engineers very well.
- rojobuffalo 6y agoi think for most software engineering, pursuing novel innovations is not the best thing to optimize. novelty can mean complexity and duplication. but i would totally agree with taking risk around giving people freedom to decide what to work on.