18 ms·
Also, under Helmut Kohl, despite advice from experts to use fiber, the German government wired the whole country with copper instead because the ministry of inf
by ChuckNorris89 6y ago
Also, under Helmut Kohl, despite advice from experts to use fiber, the German government wired the whole country with copper instead because the ministry of infrastructure at the time had stocks in the copper business leaving the country's internet behind Ukraine or Belarus.[1]
If you're on the DAX or a politician, you're untouchable in Germany and lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are.
Sure, it's not like Russia or the CCP and you're not in danger of being suicided if you uncover some high level dirt but nobody really ever gets punished when obvious corruption gets proven so I have no idea how they always manage to looks so good in the corruption statistics.
[1] https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/web/deutschland-warum-unsere-handynetze-so-schlecht-sind-kolumne-a-1297362.html https://www.spiegel.de/netzwelt/web/deutschland-warum-unsere...
- lordnacho 6y agoThe big corruption study that comes out each year is actually a corruption perceptions list. So basically how good is your PR.
- poushkar 6y agoMay I ask why you have picked Ukraine and Belarus as the basis for comparison?
- new2628 6y agoFaster internet than Germany, while being far behind Germany by most standard socio-economic metrics.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoThe fact that no one has resigned or been fired from the Regulator. The head of the regulator should have resigned weeks ago.
- chki 6y ago>If you're on the DAX or a politician, you're untouchable in Germany and lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are. This is obviously not true. There have been numerous uncovered political scandals in Germany that have led to politicians and managers loosing their job. Christian Wulff (Former German President), Guttenberg (former Defence Minister), etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoYes, but did they got to jail or have their earnings confiscated? Losing your job is not much of a deterrent when you've filled your pockets with bribes you get to keep and have a nice pension waiting for you while being put on the payroll as an external consultant to the $BIG_CORP you helped during your rule.
- qayxc 6y agoIn order for any of that to happen you'd have to be convicted of a crime first. This would involve stripping immunity first, which doesn't happen all that often and involves approval from the parliament. Naturally, this is a partisan issue and members of the ruling parties would obviously vote against it, making it very difficult to achieve in practise. This is common practise in most democratic countries, though and isn't unique to Germany at all.
- tsimionescu 6y agoBut that still means that the OP was mostly right: these people are untouchable, so they can steal with impunity.
- qayxc 6y agoIt doesn't mean that these politicians are untouchable. If a politician is being caught stealing (e.g. embezzlement), criminal charges W I L L be put forward and immunity will be stripped from them. The problem here is that unethical behaviour and gross incompetence simply aren't criminal offences. Are they to be tolerated? No! But that's a question of changing laws and legislation accordingly, not one of being "untouchable" - because even politicians aren't and that's the point. There's a difference between conflict of interests/unethical behaviour/incompetence and criminal actions. The consequence of scandals like this should be a call for tighter laws, increased responsibility of all involved parties and better financial supervision in both politics and private enterprise. Simply getting out the pitchforks, shouting that all politicians are corrupt criminals and demanding heads to roll doesn't change anything and isn't constructive.
- DangerousPie 6y agoI don't disagree that the investment in copper was the wrong decision, but according to that article the minister actually sold his shares to Nixdorf (now Siemens?) immediately before becoming a minister. So I'm not quite sure if this is actually a case of corruption or just a case of being too conservative and incompetent (which is also quite widespread in politics).
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoHe sold his shares hours(!) before being signed on as minister and he sold them to the company that benefited the most from the copper cabling that he pushed for. How you can mistake this obvious corruption for incompetence is beyond me.
- slightwinder 6y ago> He sold his shares hours(!) before being signed on as minister This is normal procedure. There is a rather short timeframe between appointment and becoming a minister. Of course did he sold it only after he know it would be a problem. > How you can mistake this obvious corruption for incompetence is beyond me. He had no benefits personally, so it's not corruption. This is just a nice story you tell the kids to give them a scapegoat, ignoring the historical context. This happend 1982, when Internet did not even exist yet. And fiber at the time wasn't really great as today. Copper probably was indeed the better solution, consicdering that survived the decades, where fiber from that time has already become useless long ago.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoExcept you're ignoring the part where the copper cable policy he pushed against the advice of his experts made the company he sold his share to obscenely rich. Is that also not corruption but incompetence?
- DangerousPie 6y agoI don’t see how you could call this corruption, he didn’t benefit from someone else getting rich. Unless there is any evidence that he sold his shares at an inflated price with the understanding that he would pay back the favour while in office or something like that, which I don’t think there is.
- hetspookjee 6y agoJust to add to your list: Read into the history of the Deutsche Bank and their current business proceedings. It's literally obscene the list of controversies that has spun out of their practices, and steadily keeps on going.
- kome 6y ago> If you're on the DAX or a politician, you're untouchable in Germany and lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are. Trust me, we know. I speak for central/eastern Europe: where Deutsche Telekom has a big market share you can bet they formed a cartel and the prices for phones are higher than in western Europe. (edit) Also: basically nothing of relevance happened in Europe after Volkswagen diesel scandal... I wonder why.
- juskrey 6y agoInternet in Ukraine and Belarus was not built in centralized manner, but quite naturally, and in competitive environment. Reasonably most places ended up with fiber where it was possible. Monopolist telecoms were not prepared and were overpowered by enthusiasts overcoming communication obstacles in any imaginable way, including legal quirks and vacuum at that time. Nothing good can be expected when central gotv starts to "innovate".
- andrepd 6y agoIt's funny, because we all know the German stereotype of efficiency etc.
- cosmodisk 6y agoAll western countries are corrupt. The difference from the usual suspects is the way it's done. If in Russia, it may be as simple as cash in hand, in Germany or Britain it will be kids placement into a nice job, maybe a donation to a family run charity org, or a contract to friend's friend's construction company. Or even the good old one,where you do a favour and 5-7 years later, once not in government position anymore,get a board seat in some large conglomerate.The opportunities are endless.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoYou're being downvoted because network effects aren't the same as corruption. Although it is certainly unpleasant to consider that government officials might be making decisions more favorable to one company than another in the hope or expectation that that they will get a board seat five years hence, it is worth noting that if they upset one company now, they may get the board seat on the other company. And since anything can happen in five years, it may in many cases make better sense to make the right decision, rather than the self-interested decision. Moreover, quite independent of any decisions they make, they remain valuable since they have contacts and know government processes. So cash in hand is a bazillion times worse than a board seat.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoYou might have a point if one of the reliable features of privatisations in the UK over the last few decades hadn't been a steady stream of ministers pushing through privatisation - often at significant public cost - and then parachuting straight into the board of the privatised company. This is a bazillion times worse than cash in an envelope, because it's straightforward larceny of public resources, papered over with some thin PR nonsense about "efficiency". This current government isn't even pretending to do anything else. There have been so many no-bid contracts for "PPE supply" handed out to cronies with no PPE experience - and no PPE delivered, while lethal shortages continue - that there are are now formal legal challenges working their way through the courts.
- jen20 6y ago
- trabant00 6y ago> lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are Compared to what? The ideal 100% angles? Because compared to reality and the rest of the world Germany sits very well in that regard.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoMost corruption stats that I have seen are based on perception of corruption. If people perceive it as dodgy but legal, or if people view it as the odd bad egg, then it won't affect perceptions, no matter how rife it is. If it doesn't affect perceptions, it doesn't affect measures.
- elliekelly 6y agoThere’s a really great documentary about how criminals used the disconnect between perception of corruption and actual corruption in Vatican City to launder money for decades. (And still do, really.) The name of the movie escapes me but I’m commenting in hopes that someone here will know.
- lioeters 6y agoA few keyword searches found: - Vatican Inc. - https://topdocumentaryfilms.com/vatican-inc/ https://topdocumentaryfilms.com/vatican-inc/ - Holy Money - Vatican City Corruption
- op03 6y agoMindlessly ambitious networks of people who care about themselves more than anything else exist in all countries. Google distribution of personality types within a population. They are weirdly similar across cultures. Where resources are low and there is not enough to go around for the most ambitious and driven, there "punishment" for wasting each others time and resources is more extreme. If Facebook or Google or Twitter, one day in the future is sophisticated enough to label the most "corrupt"/"corruptible" individuals in a population based on all their data how would you "punish" all of them if it is 30% the population?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe same way you punish other crimes. Corruption is crime, not vaguely acceptable opportunism. It has very direct negative social, political, and economic consequences. The fact that someone is robbing people using a company and/or a political organisation instead of guns and knives isn't an excuse - especially not when the sums involved can be so large.
- usrusr 6y agoMy impression is that during the formative decades of West German power structures (let's say late Adenauer to early Kohl), the entire surrounding culture of media, regulators and of course politicians and business people themselves, failed to develop an awareness for corruption because everything was so nicely self-regulated by what basically boils down to modesty. In terms of anti-corruption measures it was like that nice village where nobody locks their front door. Now decades of neoliberal ideology have swept away that modesty, greed has slowly shifted from vice to virtue, but the trust is still there. Now working as a deceptive national brand that is quickly crumbling away, without a replacement (reliable countermeasures) in sight.
- hef19898 6y agoOh, the Kohl days have been corrupt enough. A lot as related scandals happened and started then. With the political changes after Kohl it just became harder to keep them covered up. Schreiber is name that came up often enough, and of course Franz-Josef Strauss, the Bavarian political king pin and capo of all Bavarian amigos. And a staunch right leaning conservative.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y ago> Now decades of neoliberal ideology have swept away that modesty, greed has slowly shifted from vice to virtue, but the trust is still there. Please explain your definition of “neoliberal” to us.
- hnuser123456 6y agoSomeone who complains about everything that is good instead of everything that is bad.
- msla 6y ago> Please explain your definition of “neoliberal” to us. "Everything I hate", same as everyone else.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoYeah, heard the same about Britain being “so much more liberal back in the days”. My bet is that isn’t true.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>If you're on the DAX or a politician, you're untouchable in Germany and lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are. This generalizes to damn near every government (or any big powerful organization to some extent as well) ever. The only difference is that more money enables some governments to abstract it away and reduce the visibility of it better than others.
- peroporque 6y agoAt the past 38C3 congress there was also an interesting talk about how the main political parties influence the German public broadcasters. No surprise there is so little critical reporting, despite the 9 billion euros yearly budget.
- gumby 6y agoGermany is notable for its lack of “retail” or low level corruption (cops don’t take bribes, you can get a building permit by following the rules, etc). One of the best in the world. But at the highest levels the opposite prevails, up there with France or even the US. Not Kleptocracy by any means, but bad by OECD standards. Because it’s so institutionalized it doesn’t really appear in those “corruption index” reports that NGOs like to produce.
- formerly_proven 6y agoI agree, it's quite weird. Low level corruption exists but I'd say 99 % of the time it isn't and can't be bought but is awarded through social connections instead.
- oblio 6y agoI'm from Romania. You don't know how good you have it. The low level corruption is the thing that eats away at your soul and poisons your day to day life. High level corruption? Awful, but we have that too. But having to bribe the nurse so that your grandma gets painkillers (or toilet paper!) in the hospital? Having to bribe the police officer to get your driver's license? Having to bribe the lady at the counter working for the City Hall, so that you can actually get papers you need this year, not 2 years from now? That really messes with your head!
- manquer 6y agoTo any individual lower corruption is what that matters most. However as a country it is higher level corruption that costs you the most , all the money governments are spending without oversight on Coronavirus response for example . This is lot costlier to the country than a beat cop taking a bribe . Most ngos and corruption indices focus too much on lower level corruption instead of both.
- maest 6y agoI believe you are underestimating the negative drag low level corruption has on the economy. It means setting up businesses or conducting any commercial activity is slow and fraught with hidden costs and risks. Information isn't usually freely available and solving problems usually involes "knowing someone" and going through backchannels.
- keymone 6y ago> Sure, it's not like Russia or the CCP You really lost me there. The gap is civilizational. Russia and CCP are systemically corrupt, those countries must collapse for there to be a chance to uproot that disease. Pretending like it’s even meaningful comparing them to Germany on linear scale just creates suspicion in my mind that you’re part of somebody’s propaganda machine.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoThe first paragraph is exactly what happened in Australia too. I will never forgive anyone in the Liberal party (the conservative one) for the treasonous act of deliberately destroying the NBN. It set every industry in the country back decades. Medicine, education, everything. It makes my blood boil. I have to avoid thinking or reading about it at this point.
- Jdam 6y agoBS. My area had fibre since the 80s or 90s and that's why we had to have dial-up until early 2000s. Early DSL only worked through copper.
- zelphirkalt 6y agoHa! "being suicided" I like what you did there. > Sure, it's not like Russia or the CCP and you're not in danger of being suicided if you uncover some high level dirt but nobody really ever gets punished when obvious corruption gets proven so I have no idea how they always manage to looks so good in the corruption statistics. That's the thing. The statistics are not untouched either. It's a rather pervasive thing, this corruption. I also agree with the sentiment, that they do not really get punished. When have I read the last time, that some politician with hundreds of thousands of € of unregistered side-income is put in jail, like any merely normal citizen would for such a hefty sum? Oh wait, never.
- bboygravity 6y ago> so I have no idea how they always manage to looks so good in the corruption statistics. It's all about definition of corruption isn't it? In European politics and press we describe "outright deliberate corruption" with innocent deceiving descriptions such as "lobbying" and "failed government IT projects". Is Northern Europe less corrupt than the South? Or is the Northern corruption just more institutionalized (aka: more competent at corruption)? I wouldn't know where to start to get an answer to that. Is it corruption if the public never finds out?
- kensai 6y agoI am an expat living in Germany. I laugh out loud at such amazing statements such as yours. Whatever Germany's shortcomings, its heavy history, its complicated laws and customs... I would still take this over any other Western country.
- freeflight 6y agoNobody is saying Germany is a horrible place, but pointing out problems is the only way one can fix them. That's why "complaining on a high level" is a rather German thing.
- holoduke 6y agothe concept of strong inner connections between top politicians and top businesses applies for almost every country regardless of the political system. so corruption in that sense is everywhere in every layer of society.
- diogenescynic 6y ago>If you're on the DAX or a politician, you're untouchable in Germany and lots of people inside and outside of Germany have no idea of how insanely corrupt the German government and their corporate buddies are. Replace the DAX with Nasdaq and America is basically the same. We just have different names for it like lobbying.
- freeflight 6y ago> Sure, it's not like Russia or the CCP and you're not in danger of being suicided if you uncover some high level dirt Gustl Mollath [0] would probably disagree with that notion, just like the death of Jürgen Möllemann [1] left more questions unanswered than a proper investigation of him would very likely have answered. Similar situation with Wolfgang Hüllen during the CDU donations scandal. Similarly the NSU process saw a lot of witnesses die under rather weird circumstances [2]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustl_Mollath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustl_Mollath [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%C3%BCrgen_M%C3%B6llemann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%C3%BCrgen_M%C3%B6llemann [2]https://www1.wdr.de/fernsehen/aktuelle-stunde/startseite/nsu-prozess-zeugen-sterben-100.html https://www1.wdr.de/fernsehen/aktuelle-stunde/startseite/nsu...
- FabHK 6y agoMollath wasn’t killed: he was falsely imprisoned and received EUR 670k compensation for that. Mölleman‘s death was suicide (the accomplished parachuter jumped out of a plane less than half an hour after his parliamentary immunity was revoked, opened the main chute, cut it, and didn’t open the reserve, (and the automatic reserve deployment was disabled)). Seriously, it’s not Russia.
- freeflight 6y ago> Mollath wasn’t killed: he was falsely imprisoned He wasn't imprisoned, they sent him to the asylum for 8 years because claiming German banks could do criminal things is just such crazy of a thing to do. Which has quite some similarities to what happened to Hessian tax investigators [0] that were too successful for their own good: Using psychiatric assessments to discredit people who blow the whistle on corruption. In that context it's quite cynical how nearly every high-profile suicide in Russia is framed as some kind of political hit-job ordered straight by the government, while in other countries people are looking for any reason to deny the existence of foul play. [0] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steuerfahnder-Aff%C3%A4re https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steuerfahnder-Aff%C3%A4re
- deleted 6y ago
- papito 6y agoWhat about Deutsche Bank? The absolute gold standard in international money laundering.
- FabHK 6y agoSwiss, US and UK Banks (HSBC) are not far behind though. But agreed, Deutsche aims to be participant in any possible scandal.
- bostik 6y ago> looks so good in the corruption statistics The main corruption measurement I know of is the CPI: Corruption Perception Index. It doesn't measure how much corruption there is in any given country, it only measures how much visible corruption there is. I'm sure there are other gauges but that's the one that gets reported and made comparisons on. For a long time Finland tended to be either the top dog on that list, or at least hold firmly its hold in the top-3. As a Finn, I always found that rather depressing, for a simple reason. The top spot on the CPI list tells nothing about how well things are in a country. It merely tells how shitty they are even for the runner-up.
- imtringued 6y agoThis is just conventional lobbying. It's pretty bad when the lobbyists come from a company with a monopoly like an ISP but every other company is still at risk of being boycotted.
- blablabla123 6y agoThe article referenced in your article about that is from 1983. [1] I don't think fibre optics technology was that established at the time. Helmut Kohl's chancellorship was from 1982-1998. During that time, after the German reunion there were large scale investments into an upgrade of the Eastern German infrastructure including fibre glass deployment in the new German Länder. Therefore for a long time this area had some of the most modern telecommunication infrastructure world-wide - and for that matter probably also highway infrastructure. [1] https://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-14018341.html https://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-14018341.html
- atVelocet 6y agoThis doesn’t matter as what you are stating is false assumption. Deutsche Bundespost built a first fibre optics link in 1978[0]. In 1981 they „ruled“ to invest in fibre tech over the next 30 years. Guess who canceled that. You can also find more in-depth Info and should definitely read [1]. Also the Russians got to Kohl in 1986/1987 and offered him the reunification. But he refused in fear to loose the Bundestagswahl of 1987. This guy was one the ridiculous politicians we ever saw. Heck.. the bribe money the CDU owned that was stored in Switzerland even has ties to gold the Nazis stole from the Jews. Never trust anything the CDU does. Never trust anyone of the high ranking politicians. Always ask yourself: Qui Bono? [0] https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lichtwellenleiter https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lichtwellenleiter [1] https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Missing-Link-Der-Kampf-um-die-Glasfaser-oder-Der-verpasste-Breitbandausbau-in-Deutschland-3952581.html https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/Missing-Link-Der-Kam...
- msla 6y ago> Sure, it's not like Russia or the CCP and you're not in danger of being suicided if you uncover some high level dirt Don't they lock people up in mental hospitals for that, though? That's classic USSR tactics.