5 ms·
'Chemical imbalance' as a causal explanation seems to me almost useless because every severe change in behaviour pretty much by definition corresponds to change
by Barrin92 6y ago
'Chemical imbalance' as a causal explanation seems to me almost useless because every severe change in behaviour pretty much by definition corresponds to change in the brain. How else is it supposed to be manifest? Is there supposed to be drastic change in psychology without change in the brain?
There can be a company pouring lead into a river, psychological hazard during a civil war, and it will always manifest in the brain, what kind of explanation is this? Of course these things can be found in the brain, it would be crazy if they didn't.
That's not to say there's no diseases that are actual individual pathologies of the brain of course, but to use 'chemical imbalance' as a sort of first order response to what may have actual social or environmental reasons say, is entirely circular reasoning.
- numpad0 6y ago“It’s not a bug, it’s electronic misplacement”
- koheripbal 6y ago"People in distress" is even more useless. "in distress" could mean anything from having fallen down the stairs, to running out of gas on the highway. I don't mind changing language, as long as we're become more precise, not less. If "chemical imbalance" is bad, suggest something better. I think a bigger problem is that people are fixated on word definitions and offending others instead of solving problems.
- horsawlarway 6y ago>I think a bigger problem is that people are fixated on word definitions and offending others instead of solving problems. I agree, and this is pretty much unavoidable when the current clinical term is vague enough to be used as a generic insult. The general pattern I see 1. A vague term is used to describe symptoms of an issue we have a poor understanding of. 2. That term becomes associated with the symptoms, but is vague enough to be used as a generic insult (ex: playground school children yelling it at each other) 3. That term develops a stigma as an insult, and becomes more and more controversial 4. That term is replaced with a new term, rinse and repeat. We've seen this before ex: Moron, Imbecile, and Retard all once had vague clinical meanings. Then we went to mentally challenged, special needs, etc. Now even those are fairly loaded terms. In all of these cases, the word/phrase describes something that people would rather not have or be, but it does it without clarity. It will develop a stigma. I find the folks who constantly advocate for changing these names well-intentioned, but basically a waste of time.
- koheripbal 6y agoI would say this cycle happens regardless of how vague the term is. Terms like Black, Dwarf, Gay, etc... were all, at some point, considered insults despite being specific. (note: I'm not saying these are illnesses - just that the same phenomena exists - there are probably much better examples of what I'm trying to say).
- pravus 6y agoHow is "distress" not the correct term? It is defined as extreme anxiety, sorrow, or pain which can be caused by any of the factors you described as well as many more you are not even aware of. It is an emotional state that is perceived on the part of the person suffering rather than observers outside of them regardless of the actual physical realities involved. The term "chemical imbalance" can describe anything from acid reflux to genetic neurological pathologies or even snake bites and can certainly put people "in distress". The problem is people aren't interested in using correct definitions for anything anymore.
- koheripbal 6y ago> The problem is people aren't interested in using correct definitions for anything anymore. Really? That's the problem? Not the mental disorder itself? These semantic debates are less than worthless.
- derangedHorse 6y agoProblems can only be addressed once precisely defined.
- Supermancho 6y ago> How else is it supposed to be manifest? Is there supposed to be drastic change in psychology without change in the brain? There is an implication inherent to "chemical imbalance" that assumes a normative range. Modern medicine is universally based on normative ranges. If you are outside this range, it is considered a problem. Chemical imbalance is a generic and apt descriptor.
- nicky0 6y agoIt might be a descriptor of a state but it does not explain the cause. The argument here is against the notion that depression is caused by chemical imbalance.
- fzeroracer 6y agoI don't think it is though. For example, one of the things we know is that IBS can cause depression/anxiety (or perhaps more accurately, people with IBS are more likely to have depression/anxiety). In this case chemical imbalance would be objectively wrong. Their brain is being affected by another part of the body entirely, but you would have doctors selectively treating the symptoms (the 'chemical imbalance') rather than the cause.
- Supermancho 6y ago> In this case chemical imbalance would be objectively wrong. I disagree. Chemical imbalance is not necessarily a solitary cause, it's describing a condition regardless. shrug > you would have doctors selectively treating the symptoms (the 'chemical imbalance') rather than the cause Typically they treat both or in most cases, the easier problem with less severe treatment consequences (classic House MD - live in constant pain from muscle death vs lose a limb).
- DubiousPusher 6y agoThere are normative ranges but being outside of such a range alone is usually not enough for a diagnosis. Especially in the arena of mental illness, "abnormal" behavior must also present as interfering with life to earn someone a diagnosis as nearly everyone has some "abnormal" behavior and it would be counter productive to literally diagnose everyone.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoYes, but you have to see it in the historical context. Not that long ago, mental sickness was caused by various demons, curses and so on. Things change a lot faster now, but it is still taking a while. Hell, being gay was a mental sickness was only 30 years ago. In other words, it is not useless. It may seem obvious now, but it is not useless.