9 ms·
Experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion thru social networks (2014)
- jonahbenton 6y agoNeeds a (2014)
- pseudolus 6y agoThe article appeared in a footnote to another post that offers something of a historical overview of the use of predictive data [0]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23836500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23836500
- hirundo 6y agoHere's a simple mechanism for emotional contagion: 1. Mirroring is the behavior in which one person unconsciously imitates the gesture, speech pattern, or attitude of another. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirroring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirroring 2. The facial feedback hypotheisis is that one's facial expression directly effects their emotional experience -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_feedback_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_feedback_hypothesis So you subconsciously imitate expressions and gestures from characters in media, even text, which activates corresponding emotional states. The states persist long enough to propagate to people you interact with, like ripples. It's just that the faster mirroring, feedback and propagation of bits over atoms are generating waves rather than ripples. Beware of tsunamis.
- 082349872349872 6y agosee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuleshov_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuleshov_effect
- zwirbl 6y agoThank you for this link! I haven't heard about this particular effect before, but it shows the importance of context very well I think
- fizixer 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness
- sitkack 6y agohttps://www.wikihow.com/Do-the-Floss-Dance https://www.wikihow.com/Do-the-Floss-Dance
- clairity 6y ago> "It's just that the faster mirroring, feedback and propagation of digits over atoms are generating waves rather than ripples. Beware of tsunamis." that's how the hysteria concerning corona has crashed all over our economy and social infrastructure. as in, lockdowns won't stop the virus and they're immaterially better than distancing (with masks for when you can't), but the economic and social costs (including the politically motivated backlash) are massive, and yet we keep imposing that enormous cost on ourselves to make us feel like we're doing something about it, no matter how trivial the effect or how great the costs, to assuage our irrational fears.
- gameswithgo 6y agoICU filled up fast in Houston after the lockdown ended. How does that fit with your idea here?
- clairity 6y agocorrelation not causation. the end of lockdown unleashed pent-up frustration and disregard for even simple yet effective distancing precautions--a case of throwing the baby out with the bathwater behavior as backlash.
- whatshisface 6y ago>correlation not causation. >the end of lockdown unleashed pent-up frustration and disregard* The debate totally set aside, realize that you proposed a causal relationship one sentence after saying "correlation not causation."
- clairity 6y agoyes, but "undistancing->more cases" is a simpler if subtler explanation than "unlockdown->more cases", and thereby invalidating the implied causation of the question via occam's razor.
- kerkeslager 6y ago
- aaron695 6y agoI wish we didn't have to rely on tweets that are possibly lies and certainly have bias, but I found this pretty interesting. It's a travesty the scientific comment can't and won't comment on it. So random tweets are what we have. "7 out of 9 teenage girls at this school have detransitioned since lockdown and one is considering it." <snip bias> https://twitter.com/transgendertrd/status/1277688415606247424 https://twitter.com/transgendertrd/status/127768841560624742...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonahss 6y agoAre studies of this sort still being done, perhaps privately at Fb or other social networks? This study was unethical, and revealed something very scary about the potential of social networking, but I haven't heard much since then. Did they stop all research into social behavior, find ethical ways to do it, or just stop publishing publicly?
- stx 6y ago>Are studies of this sort still being done, perhaps privately at Fb or other social networks? According to my facebook feed they said no, they don't do anything unethical. To be serious though this is pretty scary. The power these companies have to manipulate society is not understood by much of society.
- 908087 6y agoVery few understand it, but all are currently living with the consequences of it, particularly in the US.
- vmh1928 6y agoWhat's old is new again. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_Popular_Delusions_and_the_Madness_of_Crowds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_Popular_Delusion... Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds is an early study of crowd psychology by Scottish journalist Charles Mackay, first published in 1841 under the title Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions.[1] The book was published in three volumes: "National Delusions", "Peculiar Follies", and "Philosophical Delusions".[2
- acd 6y agoI think AI recommendations algorithms are too unregulated. Say a person is having or had for example a depression. Recommendation algorithms for advertising tech wants customer to stay on site and view content to sell advertising. So potentially recommendations algorithms could recommend videos or content that transfers depressed or other emotional states to viewers as long as it generates ad revenue. Depending on what the algorithms senses what others in the same emotional state are viewing. What is the legal liability For transfer these emotions for companies providing these platforms? On the other side the platform could transfer positive emotions. The issue I see is that we have unregulated emotional and potentially addiction transfers directly to consumers brains. What I mean for cigarettes there is warning here there is nothing but the product is probably as addictive minus health effects.
- raxxorrax 6y agoAI recommendations is something for bored people in my opinion. Sure, you may stumble upon content you would not have considered, but the examples people tend to bring up aren't too convincing. Some might think that showing depressed people some cute dog pics would lighten them up, but that isn't how it works. On the contrary, the expectations towards themselves to be happy can be counterproductive. I believe this is the crux of the matter, since social media tends to load people with expectations, depression or not and advertisers try to use this handle to promoted their products. If a site would try to "transfer positive emotions" I would be seriously concerned. Humans don't even know what content would be best for an individual. How would you train an AI? From resonance of other users? No, that leaves out a lot of context. But I still don't think AI curators should be regulated, because the quality of regulation would certainly be horrible.
- satokema_work 6y agoIn some places though (see: algorithmic views of the primary content e.e. facebook or twitter, youtube recs), the recommendations can't be disabled. You cannot avoid the machine entirely, and all it might take is showing a thumbnail or a preview of something to you. This sort of thing has led me to getting off those services.
- py_samos 6y agoRecommendation algorithms have dramatic effects on a user's emotions, beliefs, vocabulary, and choices. This applies not only to social networks but also to search engines, content recommendation, and other applications built on metrics like "relevance" and "engagement".
- kingkawn 6y agoI think calling it contagion misrepresents that this quality of emotional transfer is the original internet
- LatteLazy 6y agoThere's a much wider discussion (educational process?) we need to have as a society. The idea that your or my opinions are our own, that we came to them independently or that they're based on facts and logic is basically disproven at this point. But people insist on pretending they are and mistakenly believe that facts change minds. This is leading to disastrous public policy and significant damage to people's mental health. These are the issues (directly or indirectly) of our time. Solving them is the big challenge on the 2000s...
- MrMan 6y agoThis blindness afflicts people who self-identify as "rational" the most, in my opinion. They see themselves as strong, independent thinkers who are immune from efforts to manipulate. No one is immune, the same way no human is independent in the way that individualists would hope they are.
- goblin89 6y ago> When positive expressions were reduced, people produced fewer positive posts and more negative posts; when negative expressions were reduced, the opposite pattern occurred. More precisely, this research appears to show how emotions expressed in Facebook posts get mimicked by connections. Should this be taken as literally reflecting people’s underlying emotional states[0]? I’d accept that they correlate to a degree, but not completely, especially not on a platform that mandates real names. [0] Anecdotally, I could be on balance in a happy state but express annoyance at minor aspects of life in my posts. In fact, the existence of things to complain about is a sign things are going relatively well (when things are looking down on a fundamental level, going on record with that under a real name is risking to alienate IRL connections, and minor nuisances of life seem too insignificant to be worth mentioning). Conversely, seeing more negative posts would make me feel compelled to post more of the same, but on balance feel better about my own situation after seeing what emotions others have to deal with.
- mennis16 6y agoYes if I'm remembering correctly this study was published by Facebook data science after some psych lab published a study that went semi-viral suggesting people were more unhappy when their network made mostly happy posts (which was explained by jealousy/comparing self to others). I remember thinking both studies had limitations, the main one here being that the interpretation is a stretch and to me was obviously trying to push back on the original popular narrative. Point being, I agree it is definitely plausible that seeing positive posts encourages more showing off rather than actual happiness. I would be interested if anyone is aware of any more recent follow-up studies?
- tathougies 6y agoThis is insanity. How did this study pass an ethics council? They admit to exposing people to negative emotional cues at random? Their N is 689K. At this point, they are certainly responsible for some number of suicides. The authors should be ashamed of themselves. Their salary is being paid by manipulating people's emotions on purpose. Something is wrong with that.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoThe issue is that they published it in a journal? Otherwise an ethics board isnt required for running an A/B test
- thaw13579 6y agoSeems like there are several concerns: the journal, a question of whether the FB usage agreement permitted such a report from being published, and generally whether it is ethical (separate from the review board question). Some more discussion: http://ulan.mede.uic.edu/alansz/2014/07/an-open-letter-to-pnas-about-their-publication-of-the-facebook-study/ http://ulan.mede.uic.edu/alansz/2014/07/an-open-letter-to-pn...
- dr_dshiv 6y agoThe ethical question is whether to do A/B tests privately vs to do A/B tests and publish scientific papers about them. I would be interested to understand the ethical basis for removing the ability of companies to run A/B tests.
- thaw13579 6y agoAnd further, whether to do A/B tests or not, and whether the subject consents, since the test might have negative effect
- dr_dshiv 6y agoHow should a user consent to a Google A/B test other than agreeing to use the software that has A/B tests in it? They run 10s of thousands of tests every day