5 ms·
That is one legal route, but it takes time, and immigration being the reason for a hasty greencard marriage that the couple wasn't already naturally for, is nev
by dheera 6y ago
That is one legal route, but it takes time, and immigration being the reason for a hasty greencard marriage that the couple wasn't already naturally for, is never a good thing for the relationship and mental health of the couple.
It does make me wonder though why there isn't a "long-term relationship visa" for people who haven't reached marriage yet but want to be together and be eligible to work, and require some evidence that the two have been together stably for some period of time. In many cases one party is a US citizen and it would be in the best interest of the mental health of that US citizen to allow his/her partner to be together with them, and from the government perspective would thus be indirectly in the best interest of the country.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> It does make me wonder though why there isn't a "long-term relationship visa" for people who haven't reached marriage yet but want to be together and be eligible to work What purpose would this status serve that marriage wouldn't? What is the idea behind planning to be in a permanent relationship, but not marrying?
- dheera 6y ago> What is the idea behind planning to be in a permanent relationship, but not marrying? What? This seems perfectly normal to me. At least for me any serious relationship is always with at least the vision of permanence, starting from the very beginning of when you call yourselves official -- unless it fails at some point. Considering most such failures occur in the first couple years, as you're still getting to understand each other, it's probably a bad idea to jump the gun into marriage that early while you still don't have a full understanding of each other. But that doesn't make it any less "planning to be permanent". I'd also say that people who meet "the one" earlier on should arguably stay unmarried for longer. If you meet at 20, I'd say wait till 25+ till you marry. A lot can change in a person between 20 and 25. If you meet at 30, you can cut that shorter a bit and that's fine because most people know what they want in life at 30. But a 22 year old US citizen who has been in a 2 year stable relationship with an F1 student, possibly living together, with permanent intent? I'd say don't rush them into marriage, but for goodness sake, let them be happily together.
- copperx 6y ago>> because most people know what they want in life at 30 I'm not sure if this statement makes me want to laugh or cry.
- rumanator 6y ago> If you meet at 30, you can cut that shorter a bit and that's fine because most people know what they want in life at 30. I'd like to meet that "most people" you mentioned. So far, everyone I ever knew at best was conformed with the constraints placed on their life.
- t0ughcritic 6y agoThere’s really no reason to get married unless you want to have kids or save on taxes. Every other reason will be more emotional then logical.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoI'll have that status here in the Canadian province of Quebec later this year when my partner and I pass 1 year of living together. We'll be called common-law partners. That counts the same as marriage for many purposes, including tax and immigration rights within the Canadian system, but not for everything (e.g. no automatic inheritance and no need for divorce if we split). Many of the other legal differences can be reduced or eliminated by preparing contracts or documents like wills, but not all. It's a great step before marriage, to provide recognition and protections for people who want a different bundle of legal consequences than marriage provides, for people who object to marriage on any number of reasons of principle, for people who want to defer the legally binding wedding until after the pandemic when their family can attend, to have less of a relationship hierarchy in polyamorous or open relationships, while waiting for just the right romantic moment to propose or to be able to obtain the right engagement ring, etc. A lot of people either don't like marriage or don't view it as a valuable priority, even if they have a relationship. Federal government statistics from here in Quebec in 2016 show that only 34.3% of the province's population age 15 or over was married, and fully 22% of that population had a common-law partner. https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2016/as-sa/fogs-spg/Facts-PR-Eng.cfm?TOPIC=4&LANG=Eng&GK=PR&GC=24 https://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2016/as-sa/fo... (I'm not sure why they started that stat at 15, since the earliest you can get married in Canada is 16 and even that requires permission from e.g. a court or parent. Maybe it's for uniform reporting versus pre-2015 data where earlier ages were sometimes legal.)
- philistine 6y agoBe careful. The only automatic common-law things that the Québec government kick in are the “bad” ones (paying taxes). If you want to benefit from the full protection of a common law relationship, you have to actively register.
- jkaplowitz 6y agoThere's no such thing as registering a common-law relationship in Quebec, unless you mean a civil union which is legally entirely different. By common-law partner I mean (as do the federal government statistics I cited) what the Quebec government and legislation often call de facto spouse, de facto partner, or sometimes shoehorn into the definition of spouse despite not being married. And the taxes aren't always a bad thing. In my case, my partner makes much less income than me, so starting this year we can shift medical expenses to her tax return to save with the medical expenses tax credit. We'll also qualify to share health insurance plans despite not being married.
- ramraj07 6y agoI and almost everyone I know studied in the US and most of my friends stay there now. In the end, being allowed in a country to study and then potentially to continue living there is a privilige. For the most part all of us were already from the priviliged parts of our country (almost no one I knew from India who went to the US was from anything less than middle class in India). This is all the more important when you consider the draconian rules India puts even on folks who used to be it's citizens, leave alone other nationals. Until the Trump administration, the US still had one of the most liberal immigration policies of any country. We don't need a girlfriend visa on top of that. The only beef I have is the constant moving of goal posts - just make the rules up and stick to them, whatever they are.
- dheera 6y ago> one of the most liberal immigration policies of any country Uh, no. In a lot of countries, obtaining a work visa to live there and work there is as simple as a local company handing you an offer letter for a highly-skilled job. It's the US that loves to intrude on employer-employee relationships. That kind of BS doesn't happen in e.g. China. If a company wants your talent, they'll find a way to get you a visa. For STEM jobs it's not even a question. Singapore might even hand you a landed permanent residence (LPR) card if you have a PhD out of a well-known academic institution. You need to meet certain criteria within your first year there but goddamn the immigration policy is much more sensible for the future of the country.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoIn China, you only qualify for one year (and I think now 3 year for special cases) working visas and you have a really hard chance of obtaining permanent residency. Almost all foreigners are temporary residents. So while you can come and work...you aren’t supposed to immigrate. Plus you are subject to political whimsy if your country of origin does something the CPC doesn’t like (even if you are Canadian).
- dheera 6y agoSure, but renewing your work visa is easy enough as long as you are of value to the industry you work in. It's not nearly as bad as the H1B system. If e.g. Alibaba really wants you on their deep learning research team the government isn't going to say no.