34 ms·
> First, you have to trust Apple that the indicator _really_ can't be disabled. You also have to trust that there isn't a vulnerability Apple is not aware about
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> First, you have to trust Apple that the indicator _really_ can't be disabled. You also have to trust that there isn't a vulnerability Apple is not aware about that could allow rolling the camera without the light coming on.
I have made this point several times throughout this thread, so I apologize for repeating myself:
Every laptop Apple has manufactured in the last ten years has an LED connected to the same circuit which powers up the camera. You cannot send power to the camera without also sending power to the LED, which will in turn cause the LED to light up. Unless the LED is broken, in which case you will know because it will never light up.
If you manage to find a vulnerability in this system, I don't think I even mind, because you've also broken physics and very possibly found a way to generate unlimited electricity forever.
- harry8 6y agoI trust you absolutely and toally on this. Why wouldn't I? But if you had your entire net worth riding on it, would you trust yourself to be infallibly correct or would you trust something along the lines of a post-it note to be completely sure? You know, if your life depended on it on every single possible model of apple laptop in all circumstances imaginable? (Do we include if your laptop was interecepted and altered by a hostile agent? Because we know that happens too...)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- taneq 6y agoDevil's advocate: If our threat model includes your laptop being tampered with by an evil maid competent enough to imperceptibly modify the camera LED circuit, couldn't they just install a separate camera elsewhere (maybe in one of the speakers)?
- harry8 6y agoOr they put you to sleep in a way where you have no memory and place the bug inside your body. You can go on like that forever. So leave your doors unlocked because you can't ever be 'safe' right? Obviously not. There's a scale from dead easy to more difficult to very dificult. Easier to get you is a bigger problem. Cheap & easy to prevent - well why wouldn't you? It's asymetric. Wouldn't you feel hilariously stupid if someone modified your camera circuit when interecepting your laptop and you actually didn't stick a post-it over it to thwart their dastardly plans. The point here is making the kind of claims made about LEDs and camera circuits is really, really easy when telling other people what is not a risk. When you carry that risk - ie "all possible models and other threat vectors" suddenly you should not be so sure anymore. A physical cover is better, easier, cheaper and basically infallible for what it is advertised to do. Asymetric payoffs are worth noting. A genunine plausible risk scenarios are all you need to take a /trivial/ mitigation step. Apple making trivial mitigation steps harder is really, really, really stupid. In fact, beyond merely stupid, it's unwittignly and incompetently user-hostile. (Unless you think they're design process has been infiltrated by the NSA or something, which I guess is at least possible, but I think it unlikely in the face of utterly incompetent idiocy - which Apple do display from time to time).
- Simon_says 6y agoCan one power up the camera for only a few milliseconds? Enough to take a still photo, without the LED getting bright enough for a human to notice?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoNo, because the LED doesn't need nearly as much power as the camera. And it takes the camera more than a few miliseconds to start working.
- xxs 6y ago> much power as the camera You mean current, right? And it'd have current limit circuit, at a resistor but likely a slow start circuit entirely? Unless you share the schematics, it's an empty argument.
- smsm42 6y agoIt doesn't have to be milliseconds. Most of people don't sit and stare on the camera all day. I have multiple displays and turning camera for a second when I am looking at another display - or even the laptop one but concentrating on something on the screen, especially the lower part - would slip my attention very easily. Or I might notice something off with peripheral sight, but it is very inexact and while I turn my head to bring it into the field of sight where I have a good resolution, it could be already gone. Of course, the cover has none of these problems. If it's covered, then it's covered.
- shakna 6y agoIn the past, this was exactly how it was done. Here's an article on the FBI doing it with an Apple webcam six years ago [0]. Should be noted that was after Apple went to the effort of making a hardware delay to try and force the LED to turn on first, but it was still worked around. [0] https://www.smh.com.au/technology/researchers-activate-apple-isight-webcams-without-warning-light-20131219-2zmy4.html https://www.smh.com.au/technology/researchers-activate-apple...
- saagarjha 6y agoThis used to be a thing, where you’d flash the LED briefly and hope the user didn’t notice. But new Macs prevent this by having a minimum duration the light will remain on.
- hummo56 6y agoThat is exactly what OP meant: you need to A) trust that in your actual laptop in front of you, this mechanism is correctly implemented. B) trust that you are not in the vulnerable phase where your LED broke and you did not notice yet. (Especially when you rarely use your camera).
- harha 6y agoRegarding B: I’m wondering if the camera or the led typically break Would first with a higher probability
- agsamek 6y agoIt is extremely unlikely (in the human terms - not possible) that LED would break in such a way that it transmits the power and not emit light at the same time. Of course the LED can be installed in a parallel connection on the circuit, but I read the op statement as it is not the case.
- edeion 6y ago"Let's devise a way to purposefully burn the LED in such a way that current can go through." We have to keep in mind that not everything has to be by accident :) I have no idea how likely it is to be possible, though, you've got a point.
- dgoldstein0 6y agoI would bet on the LED being parallel - otherwise sending more current through it will burn more power, generate more heat, and likely cause it to wear faster. I think the point though is that it's not software controlled in any way: powering on the camera lights up the LED, and there's no way to bypass that with only software. Or at least that's the claim.
- gugagore 6y agoWhy did you read that it's not the case? I read the opposite. That if the LED broke, you'd notice it because your camera would be on and the light would be off. Not that the camera never turns on.
- Natsu 6y agoThe problem is that the average user has no way to verify this and also the light doesn't prevent the camera from turning on, it merely notifies you that the camera is on. A manual, physical barrier, especially an aftermarket one, solves those issues. Personally, I use electrical tape.
- Reason077 6y ago> ”the light doesn't prevent the camera from turning on, it merely notifies you that the camera is on.” No, but the OS prevents the camera from turning on without permission from the user. (There have been bugs/compromises to this in the past, but at the browser level - you still had to give camera permission to the browser) Besides, if you’ve got some compromised or surreptitious software on your MacBook trying to secretly take photos, you probably have much bigger security problems to worry about than just what it can see through the camera.
- tim333 6y agoWithout worrying about malware, several times I've clicked on some Skype like program while trying to make a voice call only to find it trying to transmit ugly video of me.
- Natsu 6y agoYeah, I'm not even worried about malware, I'm more worried about joining a call with video on by mistake using a legit program. I mean, the thing is that I never want to use video on calls, basically. Waste of bandwidth and no worry about broadcasting the wrong thing by mistake.
- Reason077 6y agoValid point. I have to admit I'm a bit "video call vain" as well. I like to make sure my hair doesn't look too crazy and my room doesn't look too messy before getting on zoom/skype/etc. But one thing the last few months has taught me is that many of my friends/colleagues/family really don't care about these things!
- alexeichemenda 6y agoYou’re focused on the wrong part of the chain here. As the camera system is only as weak as it’s weakest link, if Apple indeed made a circuit connected to the LED (and I fully trust you on that), then the weakest link is elsewhere: company provided laptops are often altered prior to be given to an employee. I know of colonies who install software to track messages etc. What’s to say the same companies don’t alter the circuit board to modify the LED behavior? There is a risk/reward/effort to look at, putting a small piece of tape is low risk / low effort / high reward (if your company actually angers laptops).
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago> What’s to say the same companies don’t alter the circuit board The realities of modifying hardware. Is it possible? Sure. Is a company going to do it routinely at scale? Highly unlikely, because unlike software modifications, this would be pretty expensive. Are you aware of any companies that routinely do _hardware_ modifications on employee Macbooks?
- alexeichemenda 6y agoNot aware of any that do that for laptops but I know 2 personally that do that for phones. They have a collection of devices (phones) trash to go, so it’s not as unscalable as I initially thought because they re-use the devices. So I’m assuming if some do it for phones, must be some doing it in laptops. Again. It’s all about probabilities. 1/ What’s the likelihood of the company doing that? Close to none. 2/ what would be the severity of the issue if they were doing that for me? Very high. 3/ what’s the effort level to prevent that? Very little. This ratio ultimately tells us what to do.
- thdrdt 6y agoIf they take the efford to alter the circuit they might as well place a camera somewhere else, listen to all your network traffic, install a (hardware) keylogger and what not. I think you are taking this too far. People who fear to be tracked buy a laptop in a random store and don't use a provided one.
- bnegreve 6y ago> Every laptop Apple has manufactured in the last ten years has an LED connected to the same circuit which powers up the camera. At the very least, I need a citation or an official statement. Because clearly, this has not always been the case [1]: We describe how to disable the LED on a class of Apple internal iSight webcams used in some versions of MacBook laptops and iMac desktops. [..] our investigation of the iSight revealed that it is designed around a microprocessor and a separate image sensor with an indicator LED sitting between them such that whenever the image sensor is transmitting images to the microcontroller, a hardware interlock illuminates the LED. We show how to reprogram the microcontroller with arbitrary, new firmware. This in turn enables us to reconfigure the image sensor, allowing us to bypass the hardware interlock and disable the LED. [..] iSight webcam [was] found in previous generation Apple products including the iMac G5 and early Intel-based iMacs,MacBooks, and MacBook Pros until roughly 2008 Whatever reason Apple had to design the camera system this way back in 2008, is probably still a valid reason (cost, hardware simplicity, spacial constraints etc.). It means Apple and others have incentives to build camera systems that are easier to compromise. It's enough for me to worry. [1] https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2/36569/camera.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2...
- CiaranMcNulty 6y agoI find it odd that you argue with the 'in the last 10 years' statement with a thing from 2008
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway373438 6y ago"If you manage to find a vulnerability in this system, I don't think I even mind, " Taking a quick photo doesn't illuminate the LED for long enough for a human to reliably notice. "because you've also broken physics " Or merely recognized the role of the human element. A shame, Apple was once good at this.
- orion_mc2 6y agoYet this is only one of the points mansioned above...
- a9entroy 6y ago> You cannot send power to the camera without also sending power to the LED, which will in turn cause the LED to light up. Unless the LED is broken, in which case you will know because it will never light up. You make multiple assumptions here 1) You assume that the during the time that passes between the LED breaking and the user noticing, there was not a single attack or a single blunder that caused the camera to turn on and record/capture something that was unintended. 2) You assume that the LED breaks deterministically. The LED can break randomly. Maybe it lights up when nothing is being recorded resulting in a false positive. The user has no way of differentiating between a false positive and a true positive which can result in unintended captures. 3) Similarly the LED can break in a way where it sometimes doesn't light up when something is being recorded even though power is always sent to the LED when the camera is on resulting in a false negative. Again, the user has no idea of differentiating between a false negative and a true negative.
- minusSeven 6y agoWhy do I even have to trust Apple and physics here? Why can't Apple just provide a physical lid for the camera to disable it. Why even take that chance.
- partyboat1586 6y agoBecause a physical lid is ugly and inelegant.
- fbnlsr 6y agoMy Thinkpad comes with a physical lid that works perfectly and is in no way inelegant.
- murgindrag 6y agoMy ThinkPad comes with a butt-ugly lid which works perfectly, and I don't care about the ugliness.
- tjoff 6y agoTape it is then.
- lordlimecat 6y agoDell elite books have very elegant camera shutters with a barely visible slide. But obviously this is beyond Apple.
- neverminder 6y agoSo do their flagship Precision series laptops. Dell knows how to cater to their professional user base.
- yellowapple 6y agoI happen to have (collecting dust somewhere...) one of those old Firewire webcams Apple made. It has a physical shutter you can open and close by rotating the front. It's about as beautiful and elegant as it gets. If Apple still cared about beautiful and elegant products, it could surely find a way to incorporate a miniaturized version of that in a Macbook.
- peroporque 6y agoYou already found one yourself: if the LED is broken, you will notice at some point when it is too late.
- rustybolt 6y ago> If you manage to find a vulnerability in this system, I don't think I even mind, because you've also broken physics and very possibly found a way to generate unlimited electricity forever Or your LED might be broken.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xxs 6y agoPlease, share the circuit for the LED. To take a picture, it takes 4ms - a human eye would not even register that LED turning on. I don't think I even mind, because you've also broken physics and very possibly found a way to generate unlimited electricity forever. Unless there is an option to send higher voltage to the camera (control the VRM) and increase the current through the LED wear it off quickly for instance. The statement is incredible condescending, esp. given no link to actual schematics.
- dontbenebby 6y agoThis is admittedly a bit of a movie plot threat, but could an evil maid attack rewire this, then later malware takes advantage of the rewiring? IMHO layers of security are good. On my end I worry about the risks of constantly just leaving my Mac, which has filevault enabled, simply protected by a screensaver. Is that less secure than if I put it to sleep? And presumably turning it off completely is safest? How do I make informed choices about how much "locking" to do when I step away? These are all things I think about reading an article like this, and I'd love to hear other's thoughts.
- donmcronald 6y agoRegardless of how foolproof the design is, I don’t have the ability to assess it to ensure it’s doing what I’ve been told it’s doing. I can definitely assess a shutter.
- tyk0 6y agoI wouldn't be so sure about this without looking at some images of the camera PCB in these devices. From what I have extracted from other manufacturers, what you suggest has never been the case with these and similar devices. There are several possible circuit configurations I can imagine being in use in theory... however, most have some rather glaring flaws. I'll do my best to describe a few that come to mind. 1) LED in series with supply: This would, at first blush, enforce the behavior that if the interface IC has power, the LED will be illuminated. The issues come from the side effects of having an LED in the current path of a supply line. Illumination is a function of current through the LED, so brightness would be determined by the power requirements of the remaining circuitry. Also, depending on the chemistry of the LED, there is a (relatively) significant voltage drop across it, reducing your supply voltage Vss by ~1V. In short, this just would not be viable. 2) LED in parallel with supply and interface IC: With an appropriate current limiting resistor, this has the expected behavior: When power is applied to the device, the LED is illuminated. This is unlikely to be the configuration, however. The reason why this is unlikely to be the case has to do with the fact that most low bandwidth peripherals are attached via USB. This means power is always applied. If power was switched by the USB controller, there would be side effects. Most notably would be device enumeration every time it was turned on. The other is that, how would a program know that your PC has a camera if it is unpowered and undiscoverable? That leaves (not exclusively, as there are a few other cleaver ways)- 3) LED is controlled by interface IC: The exact behavior here is dictated by the IC's design, likely involving a gpio or status line turned on via firmware. I suppose the LED could be in parallel with the supply line going to the CMOS/driver IC located on the camera module itself if the module and interface board are separate, however, I believe this configuration is highly unlikely. There are plenty of hypothetical exploits given any of these (and other) configurations, involving under-volting, over-volting, high speed switching, software, etc. Heck, somewhere in this thread there is discussion of physical alterations with arguments that it would be too difficult or expensive to modify. Although not 'easy', it is by no means difficult either. All it would require is a screwdriver or two, depending on fasteners. Gain access to the module, locate LED, remove/destroy. TL;DR: Cover it if you have any concerns.
- m-p-3 6y agoYet Dell and some other laptop manufacturers started to include a physical privacy slider right in the hardware. Considering Apple stance on privacy, I hope they consider this at some point.
- somjeed 6y agoWhy not then put it on the iPhone too. Considering Apple's stance on aesthetics and non-moving parts, seems unlikely
- MadWombat 6y ago> Every laptop Apple has manufactured in the last ten years has an LED connected to the same circuit which powers up the camera It would be very helpful if you could provide some evidence of that
- bloody-crow 6y ago> Every laptop Apple has manufactured in the last ten years has an LED connected to the same circuit which powers up the camera. You cannot send power to the camera without also sending power to the LED, which will in turn cause the LED to light up. Unless the LED is broken, in which case you will know because it will never light up. In order to accept this argument I need to trust that you, an internet rando I know nothing about, are telling the truth AND that it'll remain so for any future Apple models. I think no matter how confident you're in your assessment of the current Apple hardware, you can't in good faith argue that they will not change course in the future for whatever reason. Also, again, they already messed it up once in the past. It won't be hard to imagine that they will do it again some time in the future or already doing so.