20 ms·
Playstation's secret weapon: a nearly all-automated factory
- chinathrow 6y agoMore graphics directly at https://vdata.nikkei.com/en/newsgraphics/sony-playstation/ https://vdata.nikkei.com/en/newsgraphics/sony-playstation/
- vmception 6y agoThat's a great sub-site. This is such a good year for exclusives! 2020 was always going to be epic for that, and I haven't been disappointed.
- throwaway888abc 6y agoImpressive
- blakesterz 6y ago"The 31.4-meter line, completed in 2018, has the ability to churn out a new console every 30 seconds." That seems.... slow? I mean, I have no idea what I expected, but 2 a minute, is that really fast for this type of manufacturing? How does that compare to Xbox or maybe iPhone output? I'm sure 2 a minute is really impressive, but I started reading that thinking something like hundreds or thousands an hour, I guess I was naive.
- kaesar14 6y agoI have to agree, if this ran all day it'd produce 2880 consoles. How do they keep up with launch demand that sees millions of units shipped in a span of a month or two?
- amznthrwaway 6y agoFactories have more than one line.
- tgb 6y agoIndeed, the lifetime sales of the PS2 were 155 million, which would take 147 years to produce at this rate. But the "graphical version" of the article that it links to says instead the following: > In this area of 31.4 meters by 6 meters, it takes just 30 seconds for a team of 32 robots to build a PS4. So presumably there is more than one PS4 going through the pipeline at once for more than 1 per 30 seconds.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tbrock 6y agoSurely there is a pipeline such that the 32 robots have 32 in flight at a time and don’t sit idle waiting for a single ps4 to complete.
- theandrewbailey 6y agoThat's kind of implied by the images. But if only two completed units come out the end every minute (regardless of how long it takes an individual unit to be assembled), that does seem a little underwhelming. There has to be more manufacturing lines than just this one to move millions of PS4s every year. 525,600 minutes per year * 2 units/minute = 1,051,200 units per year (assuming 100% uptime) There has to be at least a dozen manufacturing lines to meet yearly demand of over 10 million. https://www.statista.com/statistics/222403/unit-sales-of-sonys-gaming-hardware-by-category/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/222403/unit-sales-of-son...
- goda90 6y ago32 robots on the line. If each is always doing its job on a unit(because it's a pipeline), and a unit gets all 32 pieces done in 30 seconds, then each robot is spending about a second on its unit. That means a completed unit every second.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoI've programmed ABB, Epson, Denso, and Fanuc 6 axis robots (no Mitsubishis, but I've seen a few) and there's no way that those robots are running at 1-second cycle times. Maybe with a delta or SCARA, but just moving 200mm and back with the inertia of the robot alone will take you on the order of a second. It's almost certainly 30 seconds part-to-part, taking 16 minutes (minus 30 seconds for each of the stations that have two or more robots) from the start to the end of the line. It's not particularly important how long it takes from the start to the end of the line, and they'd be unlikely to share that trivia with a journalist - but part-to-part cycle time is important. If the TAKT time demanded a completed unit every second, they'd run multiple lines.
- TacoSteemers 6y agoI believe that number to be for just that length of factory line. The factory as a whole presumably has more production areas than just the one pictured. The other article, kindly linked in one of the replies, states the following: "In this area of 31.4 meters by 6 meters, it takes just 30 seconds for a team of 32 robots to build a PS4. "
- dcsilver 6y agoThe line can assemble a unit in 30 seconds and will presumably have more than one on it at a time.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhat you're talking about is the latency - start to end for construction for each is 30 seconds. But what the article is talking about is the throughput - one finished very 30 seconds - doesn't mention how long each takes to make start to finish. A throughput of one every 30 seconds is only a million per year. They have sold 100 million PS4s.
- eropple 6y agoFor that single factory line. Consumer electronics factories often have a lot of lines in parallel.
- neilpanchal 6y agoYep, also minimum 2 lines to address SPOF (single point of failure). Just because one little thing went wrong, you don’t stop the entire production line. My guess is that they have 12+ parallel lines.
- monkpit 6y agoWe are also assuming that the article is worded correctly. It could very well mean that the assembly time for 1 unit is 30 seconds total from start to finish, and the wording is just inaccurate. It happens a lot with articles like this, so who knows. EDIT: another commenter points out that another version of the article does indeed say 30 seconds to complete one unit, as opposed to “one unit per 30 seconds”
- ginko 6y ago>another commenter points out that another version of the article does indeed say 30 seconds to complete one unit, as opposed to “one unit per 30 seconds How would that even be possible? Also what's are the start and end state here? Just pure assembly? Surely printing the PCBs can't possibly take a fraction of 30s. Neither can placing and SMD soldering the components.
- lm2s 6y agoYes it does seem slow, and being an assembly line I wonder if it's just poor communication in the news article. I'd think that 30 seconds would be how long 1 PlayStation takes to be assembled, but that there would be a new one every few seconds coming out of the line.
- barrkel 6y agoJournalist innumeracy. It's a pipeline. 30 seconds per build, but not 30 seconds between each console.
- colinmhayes 6y agoThere's no way they can build an entire one in just 30 seconds. It probably takes longer than that just to package them.
- Hamuko 6y agoWell, the packaging is done by humans.
- CobrastanJorji 6y agoNo, it isn't. The article specifically describes the robots packaging the final product.
- niea_11 6y agofrom the article : Just a few humans were present to deal with a handful of tasks -- two to feed bare motherboards to the line, and two to package the finished consoles.
- JosephRedfern 6y agoIt’s ambiguously worded (up to vs up to and including), but the article actually specifically describes humans packaging the final product: “Just a few humans were present to deal with a handful of tasks -- two to feed bare motherboards to the line, and two to package the finished consoles.“
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoIt's not clear if the journalist understood throughput vs latency. But more fundamentally: factories often have more than one line.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoControls engineer here - no, that's pretty normal. I'm accustomed to automotive work, but I believe the electronics assembly lines are similar. The flexible materials handling stuff (connecting flat flex cables? Applying Kapton tape?) is indeed super impressive, but the timing is ordinary. A sizeable 6-axis robot like those used here has a minimum cycle time of a second or two for the simplest possible "move in, place the thing, move out" operation. They're not ultralight delta or SCARA bots, they're about as fast as a human can control their arm. Also, there's a second or two lost while the pallets moves along and are parked at the multiple stations along the line, you want to design the system to maximize the ratio of useful on-station time to transition time. The line is bottlenecked by the slowest process. You can make a slow station run in parallel - as in the photo at [1] with the 16 stations arrayed around the robot - but that adds a lot of complexity. I'd assume that their requirements were to accommodate up to ~8 minutes for burn-in testing at that station, and that by the empty stations, the software guys ended up only using 4 minutes. You can't make the whole line wait that long, so you spend the extra effort and introduce extra complexity by buffering parts there, but now your process has forked and needs to be merged again - really a pain for tracking suspect parts or tools. All that matters is that you unload each pallet before it needs to move on and replace it with a completed part. Some stations may be doing nothing but running a 5 second electrical test. If there's some station that has to pick up a cable, photograph it, analyze it, contort it by rotating robot joints through large angles, plug it in, and get out of the way, that could easily take 10 seconds. Others may have a human who needs to keep up. Others might be heat-staking a plastic component and need time to blow on the stake until it cools enough to be unclamped. Others might have multi-headed tooling and can connect several different parts all at once. 30 seconds is a nice middling part-to-part value if you've got a few complex operations, a few human operations, and don't want heavy robots slinging your expensive parts around at high speed. I wouldn't have been surprised at a 10-second cycle time, but 30 seconds is still reasonable. A final consideration is that you don't want an entire factory dependent on a single line. If you want to produce thousands of parts an hour, it's much, much better to have 10 identical lines that work at a 30-second cycle time than a single line frenetically thrashing to put out out parts in 3 seconds. If one line goes down, you still have 90% capacity, and can probably catch back up. If your single line goes down, you're in big trouble. [1]: https://s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/psh-ex-ftnikkei-3937bb4/images/2/1/7/9/28039712-10-eng-GB/Cropped-1593718166%E9%9B%BB%E5%AD%90%E7%89%88%E8%BF%BD%E5%8A%A0%EF%BC%89%E3%83%97%E3%83%AC%E3%82%B9%E3%83%86%E3%81%AE%E8%A3%8F%E5%81%B4%E3%80%81%E9%9B%BB%E5%AD%90%E7%89%88%E7%94%A8%E3%81%AE%E8%BF%BD%E5%8A%A0%E5%86%99%E7%9C%9F%E2%91%A320200703034521471_Data.jpg https://s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/psh-ex-ftnikkei-3937...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- latch 6y agoIn case anyone misses the link in the article, they have a graphic-rich version: https://vdata.nikkei.com/en/newsgraphics/sony-playstation/ https://vdata.nikkei.com/en/newsgraphics/sony-playstation/ (The content is different, though both articles cover the same topic. A bit weird)
- nullc 6y agoThanks, the link on that page wouldn't do anything for me.
- HenryKissinger 6y ago"The PS looks impressive."
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoThis article is crying out for GIFs, great pictures but you can't hype me up about how these robots move and not show me.
- rusk 6y agoGod I love my PS4 - it has to be the peak of this class of machine. I can't imagine how it could be improved upon without going beyond the "box under the telly format". Incredible piece of machinery. I can't imagine the PS5 will be much more than an upgrade. In my opinion the second best console is the PS2. I love Nintendo but they're more like toys than hard core gaming and entertainment machines. PS2 up until PS4 was pretty much the pinnacle, but I think the way PS4 improved upon it is the development platform, and the online experience (which even so does require some improvement). I still play games on the PS2 from time to time and they still feel viable as offline single-player experiences and I could imagine development for the PS4 could continue for 20 years or so and still be producing great and relevant games. Where to from here? VR is one obvious route but may I suggest a HN-friendly alternative? Hows about selling a more open system that allows end-users to tinker and contribute themselves? I think in order for this to be viable in terms of protecting the profitability and stability of the ecosystem there are some business and technical challenges but I would love to see them take this direction. They've dabbled before with the Yaroze system and Playstation Linux … both had their business operational issues but hardly insurmountable? EDIT - can't respond below any more so I just have "one more thing" to say: > PS4 is famous for being the cheapest sony home console relatively speaking and what exactly is the problem with that? This is a feature not a bug. The PS3 was a novel system with exotic hardware but it suffered from some very serious flaws. It's reliance on proprietary technologies meant it was harder for developers to work with. It never took off as a result and is little more than a footnote in the lineage's history. A learning experience if you will. Surely an extension of making something easier for professional developers to get to grips with is making something that hobby developers (and other classes of creative) can get to grips with?
- ThomW 6y agoI can't imagine how it could be improved upon... When my PS4 Pro is playing stuff like TLOU2, it sounds like it's going to start hovering off my TV cabinet.
- azuriten 6y ago> When my PS4 Pro is playing stuff like TLOU2, it sounds like it's going to start hovering off my TV cabinet. I have the CUH-7200 PS4 Pro model which is apparently the quietest model and it's insane how loud that thing gets when I played TLOU2. The copying times for updates/patches is equally bad with downloading taking a few minutes and copying times taking more than 20mins. There's clearly alot of room for improvement - At least Sony have realised this as the PS5 will have a SSD instead of a HDD.
- KaoruAoiShiho 6y agoThis is so cool, but how long till they automate the packaging too?
- ashtonkem 6y agoAt only 2 workers per line to package them, would it be worth it to automate that role? Seems like they might've min/maxed the automation already.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoThere is also some (if limited) utility in having someone on the line doing stuff, watching stuff, and serving as a form of QC. You can hang in the control room watching the latest, greatest SCADA software run things, but it's useful to have some eyes-on as the line runs.
- partingshots 6y agoA good baseline to measure how fast these are would be to look at comparative Xbox production times.
- hobofan 6y agoIf you enjoy that you will probably also enjoy the fully-automated Valve Steam Controller assembly line (including video)[0]. [0]: https://www.theverge.com/2015/12/11/9890914/valves-steam-controller-assembly-line-video https://www.theverge.com/2015/12/11/9890914/valves-steam-con...
- huseyinkeles 6y agoWatched the video before reading the title and was thinking myself how it reminded me of Portal (a puzzle-platform game by Valve). Thanks for posting this! Very entertaining to watch indeed :)
- bluejellybean 6y agoThis is a fantastic video, extremely well done in my opinion. I remember fanatically watching "How It's Made", in that show they focused on more run of the mill assembly lines for generic plastic things and usually there was a ton of labor involved. The video linked here was really the first time I saw this level of automation and my jaw nearly hit the floor, the technology industry has created some incredible feats of engineering.
- cosmodisk 6y agoVery few high end factories would allow some random journalists to poke around. Some candle factory is a different story I suppose. But you are right,I'd love them to visit some more modern shops.
- phjesusthatguy3 6y agoI watched How It's Made with my kids for a good number of years, and I was just amazed that the parts that were automated worked as well as they did. It made manufacturing look really complicated and that human hands were the most important part of the assembly line.
- ekianjo 6y agoIt's not operating anymore though.
- duxup 6y agoI've always wondered if you could automate a sort of standard assembly system with a certain amount of adjustments within some parameters (device dimensions, how things are connected)... and pump out any number of different electronics all on the same assembly line / factory using the same robots? Granted that probably already is a thing, or isn't for good reason.
- bowmessage 6y agoYou should look into pick-and-place machines and other awesome fab robots.
- duxup 6y agoI will do that thank you!
- mkroman 6y agoAs you might imagine, this is already the case in places like Shenzhen - there's off the shelf “building blocks” for machines - not necessarily to any written standard, though. In this[1] Strange Parts video he mentions it. If you watch some of his other videos you'll start to notice that many of the machines actually look similar - I highly recommend watching them, they're great. [1]: https://youtu.be/PZBQzLfCKpw?t=1019 https://youtu.be/PZBQzLfCKpw?t=1019
- blackrock 6y agoThat video was incredible. The machines that makes the product, the lithium ion battery for your iPhone, is this super intricate process, that outputs the final product. And everything is made from the raw materials. Now, this is what I call a true fabrication process.
- 6nf 6y ago'Industrial lego' as some call it. Get all right bits and pieces, put them together and you have a production line. Every piece comes with detailed specifications, performance curves, maintenance instructions etc - which means an industrial part is more expensive than consumer grade stuff doing the same task. But when you're building a big machine you don't want unplanned downtime.
- zbrozek 6y agoLots of folks here are talking about the latency and throughput, but nobody is amazed at what the robots are doing. Plugging in cables and putting down tape is fiddly and hard. I'm super impressed that they elected to automate those things based on cost merit. Massive kudos to the manufacturing engineers who managed to pull that off.
- jccooper 6y agoI'm surprised they didn't design out stuff like tape. Although perhaps they did and the article actually means handling things like ribbon cables, which is super impressive, as humans can barely handle those.
- imglorp 6y agoReally. A dot of hot glue to hold a cable down must be easier.
- zbrozek 6y agoAll the manufacturing engineers I've talked to hate doing fluid dispense. Glue is in a class all its own because if you take the line down it tends to cure in the dispenser or nozzle.
- Qworg 6y agoFluids/moltens are a nightmare.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _bxg1 6y agoThe PS4 officially supports replacing the internal hard drive, and that's not even getting into the question of repairs
- 6y ago
- actuator 6y agoThis looks so amazing and I wasn't aware that Playstations are still manufactured in Sony's home country itself. I guess automation helps in keeping the manufacturing cost low. Now I am intrigued about what high selling electronic devices are manufactured in their home country itself and not by the ODMs/CMs in countries with cheap labour like China.
- hobofan 6y agoTo me it's almost more surprising that with that high degree of automation they are not splitting the factory up into smaller ones and building them per-continent.
- actuator 6y agoThey will still need to ship the parts which depending on the part might be coming from SK/Taiwan/China but I guess they can still reap the benefit of probably reduced taxes because of local assembly.
- cbmuser 6y agoNot necessarily. All components can be made by Japanese companies. Whether Sony uses a Japanese supplier or a company from the other countries you mentioned is a matter of the production volume and which supplier makes the best offer.
- jbob2000 6y agoElectronics are fairly light, you probably don’t save much by shipping raw/incomplete products to the consuming country for final assembly. It’s not like soft drinks, where you want to bottle them close to the point of consumption so you aren’t shipping the dead weight of water around.
- dfox 6y agoAlso shipping the manufacturing/automation technology is not particularly cheap, not to mention the amount of on-site setup/calibration that would be required.
- jariel 6y agoPowerful example of operational innovation, and that there is so much untapped opportunity we are not leveraging in so many areas. A company like Apple may not have the wherewithal or impetus to do something like this. When they need manufacturing, they are resigned to the traditional approach: China. Since labour is cheap there, and they just may not be thinking in these terms and may not have the wherewithal either ... the cost-effective solution invariable involves high labour intensity. It may very well take factories like this to inspire other organisations to have the necessary 'Eureka!' moment to grasp that they too, might be better off 'fully automated' as well. Note the eye-watering scale of the business however, quoted at nearly $100 Billion in sales, which is rather a lot of money indicating that it may take a product with a very long life cycle wherein there are considerable profits for this to be feasible. Looking at this, one has to wonder why Western nations are not more keen to duplicate.
- owenmarshall 6y ago> Note the eye-watering scale of the business however, quoted at nearly $100 Billion in sales, which is rather a lot of money indicating that it may take a product with a very long life cycle wherein there are considerable profits for this to be feasible. You mention Apple. The iPhone SE 2 is basically "iPhone 11 guts in an iPhone 8 shell" – and as I understand it Apple went to software to handle things like the camera so they could keep the older generation optics and not change the body. That type of tick/tock cadence would support this nicely.
- taytus 6y agoNah. They are killing it because of amazing exclusives. That's all.
- KorfmannArno 6y agoAha, color me confused. Which would be those?
- taytus 6y agoThe Last of Us, Uncharted, God of War, Horizon: Zero Dawn
- KorfmannArno 6y agoIt's all senseless shooting or close combat...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 6y agoAlso the origin story for the Portal games.
- baybal2 6y agoFully automated assembly lines rarely make sense economically even in Europe, and Japan. A "lights out" factory needs a really expensive, complex widget to make, but one which doesn't vary, or change over time much. Game consoles are exactly like: long product life times, and can be engineered specifically with automated lines in mind, without compromises. Robotic factories are by no means a final solution for manufacturing.
- arcticfox 6y ago> Robotic factories are by no means a final solution for manufacturing. Robotic factories are by no means a final solution for manufacturing...Yet
- zanny 6y agoDefinitionally they kind of are inevitably the final solution. We will either totally automate all production, go extinct, or get trapped in a loop of destroying civilization putting the survivors back to pre-industry and having to rebuild in perpetuity. Its only a question of time scales.
- walrus01 6y agoA game console is also a fairly simple thing since everything is on one fully-integrated motherboard. Boiling it down to the essence it's a robotic process of inserting an already-fabricated ready to go board into a plastic case. Or two boards if you count the 110-240VAC input power supply to DC module which is in an xbox one or PS4.
- nabilhat 6y agoIt really helps make sense when automation is a sibling product line or you're able to partner with an automation business. Given the detailed pictures of the assembly line for a critical product at launch, I'm suspecting that automation R&D and presentation is a factor here.
- mywittyname 6y agoSony is also a huge company who can leverage experience from this across several markets. It certainly makes more financial sense to use the playstation budget to make this happen rather than start with one of their bluray players.
- shmerl 6y agoWhen will Sony start supporting Vulkan on PS?
- bigcheesegs 6y agoI seriously doubt it. The PS4 has a custom graphics API which directly creates command buffers in the GPUs native format. There's not really much of a graphics driver at all other than what's necessary to isolate the game from the OS.
- shmerl 6y agoWhy not though? It makes it easier for developers, instead of the need to address yet another proprietary API. Simplifying things has value. That API was created by Sony when something like Vulkan didn't exist yet, but today there is no good reason not to support Vulkan.
- 6510 6y agonice video
- dschuetz 6y agoThat indeed is impressive.
- mips_avatar 6y agoI'm so fascinated by lights out "autofac" manufacturing. Instead of amazon warehouses along I-90 let's just have "autofac" clusters that can make most anything.
- velox_io 6y agoElectronics manufacturing has been moving to more and more automation for years. Humans don't place components on PCBs anymore (well, most components). it's done by machines that look more like a gatling gun than human arm. It's quite stunning how small the components are these days. Gamers Nexus: How Motherboards Are Made (2019) | Taiwan Automated Factory Tour, ft. Gigabyte https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cnAFTMaS5R0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cnAFTMaS5R0
- everseason 6y agoSo why do most of the PS4s I find on ebay all say "Made in China"? Are the parts made in China and then assembled in Japan at the Kisarazu plant? Or are they only making PS4 units in Japan for the domestic Japanese market...and making the rest of the world's units in China?
- tanilama 6y agoI guess only a certain fraction of it is made in this factory and possibly just to Japan's domestic market.
- cbmuser 6y agoSony uses multiple OEMs, including Sony EMCS in Japan and Foxconn in China. Usually, the first batches of a Sony product are made in Japan or the ones sold domestically. If you buy an early PlayStation 1, 2, 3 or 4 in Japan, they're usually all Made in Japan.
- impalallama 6y agoI wonder if this speaker to its nature of being a Japanese article but the tone is largely awe and pride of the accomplishment lacking the usual fear of automation and jobs lost I see in other such articles. >“If you keep watching them long enough, they will start to look like humans,” said one engineer. The look in his eye is gentle like a father watching over his children. Unlike large robots that lift heavy items, the delicate movements of compact robots resemble those of human arms and have surprising warmth.
- smoe 6y agoI don't know if it is just cliche, but I have heard that Japanese people have a very different relationship to robots/automatization than western countries. Were we immediatly think Skynet, they see something that helps them.
- fomine3 6y agoI'm doraemon
- zanny 6y agoLoyalty to the group - family, workplace, country - is huge in Japan. The expectation is that those who are no longer productive for society will still be taken care of, by family, prior workplace, or society. And then the US is on the opposite end where you are largely treated as on your own where you find the most hostility to automation.
- smoe 6y ago> Just a few humans were present to deal with a handful of tasks -- two to feed bare motherboards to the line, and two to package the finished consoles. Maybe I'm just ignorant, but, especially the first task, seems rather trivial compared to what they achieved with their robots? Even the second one, If I remember correctly Amazon does/did this manually because every single package is different and no robot flexible enough, but I assume in Sonys case packages are all exactly the same. Doesn't sound a whole lot harder than plugging in the cables. So why wouldn't they automatize those steps as well?
- 946789987649 6y agoPossibly cost factor? Hiring 4 non-skilled people may have been cheaper than adding the extra machinery.
- aidenn0 6y agoLoading into the sort of packaging used for electronics is definitely hard to automate. For low margin products it used to be universal that boxed items were manufactured where labor was cheap, and that's for very simple to load items. Automation is improving at a rapid rate though. I've definitely seen automated boxers for some simple to load items start to show up.
- enginoor 6y agoIf anyone is interested in factory automation I'm working on a site to catalog different processes. A good design can often be recycled into a similar machine. https://automate.engineer/ https://automate.engineer/ I'm mostly building it for myself but I thought other people may enjoy.
- strider12 6y agowonderful website, thanks for sharing!
- LockAndLol 6y agoTaking out the human element. China knows it's coming and it's a big reason they're "investing" in poor countries. They won't have the upper hand on cheap labor soon.
- Iv 6y agoI am happy that China reached the point where their average wage is high enough that we can finally resume the manufacturing automation effort that kinda stalled since the 90.