3 ms·
If you’re trying to start another venue with a stated specific bias, there is every reason to believe that it will (eventually, if not immediately) become exact
by teddyh 6y ago
If you’re trying to start another venue with a stated specific bias, there is every reason to believe that it will (eventually, if not immediately) become exactly as limiting and echo-chambery like the rest of them.
However, if you’re trying to not do that, and create a truly open environment, you run into the problem which was perhaps best described like this:
“If you’re against witch-hunts, and you promise to found your own little utopian community where witch-hunts will never happen, your new society will end up consisting of approximately three principled civil libertarians and seven zillion witches. It will be a terrible place to live even if witch-hunts are genuinely wrong.” (Emphasis in original.)
— https://web.archive.org/web/20200618093842/https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/01/neutral-vs-conservative-the-eternal-struggle/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200618093842/https://slatestar...
- afarrell 6y ago> echo-chambery What is the distinction you draw between an echo chamber and a community which mostly shares certain baseline assumptions and values?
- bananamerica 6y agoAn echo chamber is violently hostile to different opinions and the individuals that defend them. A community with shared values tends to voice their disagreement (sometimes vehemently) without ejecting or deplatforming alien elements This usually excludes acts of moderation that enacts policies, guidelines, etc.
- teddyh 6y agoSince you ask: A community which just happens to mostly share common values is merely that and nothing more. An “echo chamber”, on the other hand, is when such a community does not get any significant input from any outside sources, and as a result keep reinforcing their own internal beliefs, even though those beliefs may be erroneous. This extreme homogeneity, thus created, in turn gives rise to a culture in which any persistent dissenters are viewed as anomalous and therefore dangerous. And this is limiting for those who sometimes wishes they could express dissent. It is also restricting the community itself from ever developing any further. To contrast, a normal community with mostly shared values would occasionally be affected by outside influences. This would create a constant level of turbulence in the system; there would always be some base level of variation between individuals, and over time, the median belief would slowly change this way and that, somewhat like fashions, and this would be normal.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe article says the goal of Persuasion is to serve as a platform for the group the author terms "philosophical liberals" to argue their case. A "fighting magazine", he calls it. It doesn't seem to be meant as an unlimited space or a pure response to witch-hunts.
- joe_the_user 6y agoThe magazines the OP cites, Reason, The National Review and Jacobin, are all good, principled magazines from their respective points of view (National Review has written scathingly of Trump notably not as a concession to liberalism as well as I know). As someone well the left, I'd still take articles from either Reason or National Review seriously, for example. And Jacobin doesn't take a single, fixed leftist position either. Aspiring to produce a magazine of that quality seems reasonable and quite possible in the abstract.