7 ms·
Onyx is violating the Linux kernel's license, refuses to release source code
- applecrazy 6y agoSeeing how this is a company in China, how would the legalities work?
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoI believe the wronged party in such cases can ask to have imports banned.
- floatingatoll 6y agohttps://heathermeeker.com/2018/04/30/first-gpl-case-in-china-or-is-it/ https://heathermeeker.com/2018/04/30/first-gpl-case-in-china... As the link warns, this is a secondhand translation, and my summary is thirdhand. Do your own reading, especially in the original language, if able. The general point here is that the Chinese legal system declared that the GPL legalese is OK, but that judges have the power to evaluate it in context of the case and retain the authority to override the legalese when it results in inappropriate outcomes. In this specific ruling, the judges ruled that bundling ('aggregation') of GPLv3 and unlicensed code did not infect the unlicensed code with the GPLv3, resulting in a loss for the defendant. If Onyx is bundling GPLv3 code with non-GPLv3 code, based on this single case, they are not required to disclose the source of the non-GPLv3 code that is aggregated with the GPLv3 code. If they have also/instead modified GPLv3 code, then they would probably be required to publish the source for the works derived from GPLv3 code. The usual arguments here are that modifying a bundle of GPLv3 code to include non-GPLv3 code is itself a 'derivative work' of GPLv3 code, or that the GPLv3 specifies that such bundling shall result in the bundled code being forcibly licensed under GPLv3. The Chinese court apparently did not accept this line of reasoning. YMMV, IANYL
- anticensor 6y agoThe lesson here is if you want non-severability provision to work, you need to make the licence restrictions also binding for the original author (full reciprocity). Similar cases will also arise in Europe.
- Kiro 6y agoWhat do you mean?
- anticensor 6y agoRestrictions like share alike and termination provision should also apply to the original copyright holder.
- Kiro 6y agoWhy is that the lesson? Maybe I'm dumb but I don't understand how that would help anything.
- anticensor 6y agoThere are principles of arm's length and equal treatment among equals for contracts to be enforceable. Copyright licences are treated like contracts of adhesion in many jurisdictions (though not in USA). By-attribution share-alike , non-severability and non-revocation clauses in a share-alike licence attempt to make the parties equal, but it does not arrive quite in there, still leaving the copyright owner privileged a bit. IANAL, YMMV
- Kiro 6y agoI realize I don't know much about licensing because I didn't understand a word of that.
- mpol 6y agoThat is currently not the case, and I don't think it should be. If I write a piece of software and release it under the GPL, I can sell it as proprietary code as well, dual-licensed. I am in no way obligated to provide updates and changes under the GPL too.
- CuriousSkeptic 6y agoI think you have a few details wrong. Firstly (a minor detail) I don’t think GPL requires you to “publish” source code per se. Just make sure that every recipient of a binary copy can also receive the source code. But more importantly, the license doesn’t “infect” things. In no way can you be forced to license your code according GPL. Failure to comply with the GPL simply means the license isn’t applicable and the situation reverts back to normal copyright rules.
- floatingatoll 6y agoThat makes more sense than I was able to make of it, thank you.
- marcoperaza 6y ago>But more importantly, the license doesn’t “infect” things. [I’m not your lawyer and this is not legal advice.] It can have that effect. My understanding is that if you include GPL code in your software[1] and distribute it without sharing your source code, you are committing an ongoing contract/copyright violation that can be remedied either by recalling and destroying the offending products, complying with license terms by releasing your source code, or settling with the original copyright owner (effectively, paying a license). As for a court forcing you to release the code, that is in fact what the GPL contract requires so the court is within its rights to require specific performance instead of monetary damages. Even though common law courts strongly prefer monetary damages, they will turn to specific performance if they think it's appropriate. All of this is going to turn on some questions about when you can bring copyright infringement vs. contract actions. It's not an area I'm super familiar with, but see my response below about at least one case that suggests you could sustain a contract action for a GPL violation in some circumstances. [1] In the way that requires you to release your own software under the GPL. Of course, there are ways to use GPL software that don't implicate that. I'm not talking about those.
- nkurz 6y ago> they will turn to specific performance if they think it's appropriate Do you know of any cases with the GPL where a court has in fact done so? I'm not aware of any outcomes where code has been forcefully licensed as a penalty. Absent strange outside circumstances (like a signed contract) I'd instinctively (but without legal training) think that that a court would treat the violator as "acting without a license" rather than "had specifically agreed to the terms of a contract and then broken it".
- beojan 6y agoThat's interesting. The GPL actually includes language specifically permitting aggregation like this: > A compilation of a covered work with other separate and independent works, which are not by their nature extensions of the covered work, and which are not combined with it such as to form a larger program, in or on a volume of a storage or distribution medium, is called an “aggregate” if the compilation and its resulting copyright are not used to limit the access or legal rights of the compilation's users beyond what the individual works permit. Inclusion of a covered work in an aggregate does not cause this License to apply to the other parts of the aggregate.
- redtexture 6y agoPossibly via: Import halt via complaint in appropriate US Customs regulatory regime and / or court, about infringement of intellectual property. This can embargo a company's product nationally in the US, and gets the attention of the producer. Not quite on topic: Stopping Infringing Products From China: Section 337 Cases. By Bill Perry - China Law Blog -- August 22, 2016 https://www.chinalawblog.com/2016/08/stopping-infringing-products-from-china-section-337-cases.html https://www.chinalawblog.com/2016/08/stopping-infringing-pro...
- pabs3 6y agoUS Customs halt has had the desired effect in GPL compliance cases before: https://mjg59.livejournal.com/126865.html https://mjg59.livejournal.com/126865.html https://lwn.net/Articles/404450/ https://lwn.net/Articles/404450/ http://mjg59.livejournal.com/132810.html http://mjg59.livejournal.com/132810.html
- colejohnson66 6y agoThis was a problem with Creality in the 3d printing world two years back. They used Marlin - a program for the embedded micros used in them - which is licensed under the GNU GPLv3+. Creality refused to release their contributions until they were convinced by Naomi Wu (Sexy Cyborg) that the community would actually refuse to purchase from them unless they did, which they probably would’ve. https://hackaday.com/2018/08/27/gpl-violations-cost-creality-a-us-distributor/ https://hackaday.com/2018/08/27/gpl-violations-cost-creality...
- artsyca 6y agoI seriously can't believe how short sighted people can be. That's bad business. I worked at a big bank too, you'd think they would understand about investment? No. They simply leeched off open source in the same way.
- uyrdjdurfurhdh 6y agoIt's this actually short sighted though? I feel like the 'companies are exploiting open source' dialogue always ignores how wildly miniscule the risks often are for the company. Creality might have lost a US distributor but is the US their primary market and were they unable to find another distributor? Don't get me won't, I'm not happy about the state of affairs, but banks are usually pretty risk averse (or more accurately, their risk portfolio is catastrophe averse). If an org like a bank doesn't care it seems like a sign that open source either needs some better teeth or it needs to accept that its role in the ecosystem is changing. We might see some short term success calling out bad actors but if there's enough of them to put on a whole play then it seems more useful to focus on why they're all able to book a theatre so easily.
- artsyca 6y agoThat's definitely one way of looking at it but when you're a bank with projects in the tens of millions hinging on EmberJS, you'd think you'd be more sensitive to the plight of EmberJS development? I mean the open source project suddenly being abandoned due to lack of a corporate sponsor would be pretty catastrophic, no? What struck me the most is that at its heart the bank has these sorts of provisions in its constitution, ie giving back to the community and being in harmony with the environment and being relationship oriented. It's like the lion not rewarding the mouse in that old fable, due to brand having been subverted by petty bureaucracy and middling management.
- Teknoman117 6y agoThis kind of behavior is one of the things that kills me about grsecurity. They're completely abusing the spirit of the GPLv2 license but are probably following the letter of it. If you choose to exercise your GPLv2 rights, your contract with them is terminated and you will receive no further security updates (considering this is a security product, it makes it pretty useless to you). You are then blacklisted from doing business with them ever again.
- andreareina 6y agoBruce Perens argues[1] that this is a penalty for exercising your rights under the GPL and therefore violates section 6[2]: "You may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein" [1] https://perens.com/2017/06/28/warning-grsecurity-potential-contributory-infringement-risk-for-customers/ https://perens.com/2017/06/28/warning-grsecurity-potential-c... [2] https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0.html
- st1ck 6y agoOpen Source Security (company behind grsecurity) sued him for that post, but the case got dismissed and looks like OSS has to pay his legal fees: https://www.digitalmunition.me/maker-of-linux-patch-batch-grsecurity-cant-duck-260000-legal-bills-says-cali-appeals-court-in-anti-slapp-case/ https://www.digitalmunition.me/maker-of-linux-patch-batch-gr...
- tzs 6y agoHe argues contributory infringement and breach of contract, but he really only goes into the breach of contract theory. I'm more curious about the contributory infringement theory. You cannot have contributory infringement without there being a direct infringement by someone else for the contributory infringer to have contributed to. I don't see offhand who would be the direct infringer whose infringement Grsecurity is contributing to.
- chaosite 6y ago
- c-c-c-c-c 6y agoThey release their firmware updates on their page, packaged with upx. Someone could enjoy decompressing it https://onyxboox.com/firmware https://onyxboox.com/firmware
- adielsa 6y agoTheir is no source code there. Decompress wont bring it back to soirce code state
- c-c-c-c-c 6y agoDownload it, unpack it, patch it to enable ssh, ssh into the machine, monitor internet traffic and see if its doing anything fishy.
- Shared404 6y agoWhile this is certainly a method that could be used to tell if it's doing anything it shouldn't, it still skips over the fact that this is a violation of the GPL. That being said, this is apparently a Chinese company, and I have no idea if the GPL even has teeth in this scenario.
- rjzzleep 6y agoI've said this elsewhere. But I genuinely don't think that they know what the gpl means. Maybe someone could approach them in Chinese preferably directly to the company instead of the forum minion. The forum minion always responds with the same answer to any question that is asked. That person gives the same answer to a quick switch option between the notes and library app. Usually what happens in the onyx customer forum is that a person asks for something. The forum minion says it's been forwarded and being worked on and then the cycle repeats until one of the customers gets pissed and starts threats.
- ralph84 6y agoThey know what it means. It means a copyright holder of the Linux kernel would have to sue them in China. Good luck with that.
- davidgerard 6y agoIf the software is embedded, they can be sued elsewhere. Like that time BusyBox sued over the GPL and won ... a pile of TVs! http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20100803132055210 http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20100803132055210
- ballenf 6y agoCould users of the product also be sued by a Linux contributor? If you can’t go after them, going after their customers would kill their business. But this approach seems too cute to be feasible even on the long shot that the GPL would allow it.
- _sbrk 6y agoI'm not surprised. The Chinese mentality is to steal software, which they don't consider to be a "good", whenever they can.
- LifeLiverTransp 6y agoThat mentality is depressingly common. In some german companys, software is considered part of the electrician job. There are companys with tech debt hiring electricians at alarming rates. It would be funny, but its actually a display of a cultural deficit, a inability to percieve value.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rimutaka 6y agoI have just updated their Wikipedia page with a mention of the incident. Let's see how long it will take for someone to take it down https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Onyx_Boox&action=history https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Onyx_Boox&action=...
- leijurv 6y agoI've obliged.
- djeiasbsbo 6y agoIt was removed because you apparently didn't quote/provide a reliable source... Looks like you quoted a reddit comment?
- maitredusoi 6y agoThat is where MIT license is largely superior to GPL, you know what you are buying for... ;) GPL put enforcement without the cops to maintain it ;) With MIT, everyone is free to do whatever they want. In a way GPL recreate (unnecessary) bureaucraty, where MIT generate pure liberty.
- zelphirkalt 6y agoSo, in which way is the result any better?
- toyg 6y agoAh, the freedom of business to exploit free labor! How do we long for that!
- nikita2206 6y agoSo, wtf is Onyx and how does it violate GPLv2?
- sirn 6y agoOnyx is a manufacturer of Android-based e-Ink tablet/e-Reader.
- input_sh 6y agoTo answer the second part of your question, if you modify code released under GPL, you need a way to provide a machine-readable copy of your modifications to your users. So, it doesn't need to be publicly available (as in, you and me are not Onyx users, therefore we don't need to have access to it), just to its users. Screenshot shows their user requesting it and being denied the request, hence, GPL violation. https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#GPLRequireSourcePostedPublic https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.en.html#GPLRequireSourc...
- EE84M3i 6y ago>if you modify code released under GPL _and distribute it_ Running it server-side is fine. That's what the AGPL addresses. If you modify GPL code and only use it yourself without distributing it, you never have to give anyone else access to the modifications.
- iso947 6y agoIndeed - I amended the show waves filter in ffmpeg to create square wave forms for, but my C is terrible and I’m far too embarrassed to commit to a public code forum. As the binary goes no further than my own machines there’s no issue.
- mindB 6y agoUnfortunately this has been going at least as long as I've been aware of Onyx Boox products. E.g. https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=277431 https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=277431. It's by no means an isolated incident.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI tend to license my stuff MIT. That’s mostly because I don’t want to deal with legal agita. It helps to avoid people suing me because the hammer they stole from me bends their screws. We basically live in a digital kleptocracy. Everyone steals from everyone. I tend not to, but that’s because I’m a complete control freak, and have a hard time letting go. I think that decompilers are so good, these days, and the use of intermediate steps like LLVM, mean that people won’t have much difficulty figuring out what’s going on, under the hood. With the financial incentives, it is quite possible to hire top-notch folks to implement, and even improve the work. Also, I don’t think anything I do is so great that I want to hide how I do it. In fact, I see people do stuff in more clever fashion all the time. My own advantage is in how I do stuff, and it would be great if folks copied it. I don’t think many would. It’s a pain, and is only efficient once it becomes habit. Go ahead and steal my stuff. Get rich. I doubt my stuff will be the “secret” to your success. My only hope is that, if you do use it, there might be a tiny piece of high-quality software in there. I do feel as if we should all strive to do the best quality work possible, and take some personal pride in our craft. I don’t mind that going viral, and I don’t think a license will affect that.
- stefan_ 6y agoIt's not about you, it's about the user.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoYup. That's what I said. The user can benefit from my work. Seriously. Why was what I wrote bad? I just put enough legal fig leaf on to make sure I don't get sued for anything, do the very best work I can, and put it out there, for all to use. I literally wrote a post, encouraging people to open-source their software, and I led by example; not decree, which is usually the best way to proceed. Is the MIT license a bad license? If so, why? I have found that if I make it GPL, then a lot of folks won't use it. I want people to use my stuff. I think it's good stuff, and can benefit users, by being a high-quality component. I think I do have one GPL project; an ffmpeg wrapper that uses the GPL H.264 codec. I could probably get away with not licensing it GPL, but why bother? It's not gonna save the world. I suspect no one will have much of a use for it, anyway.
- weinzierl 6y agoThis is not unusual, there are many cases of GPL violations out there and if someone puts energy into them they are solved. Harald Welte and gpl-violations.org [1] have been doing good work for many, many years in this regard. From their about page: "By June 2006, the project has hit the magic "100 cases finished" mark, at an exciting equal "100% legal success" mark. Every GPL infringement that we started to enforce was resolved in a legal success, either in-court or out of court." gpl-violations.org is in an extraordinary good position to help when it comes to GPL violations in the Linux kernel, because they work closely with some kernel developers that "[..] have transferred their rights in a fiduciary license agreement to enable the successful gpl-violations.org project [..]" Their website looks a little bit outdated but from what I understood from a talk that Harald Welte gave last year[2], they are still active. If someone wants to report the Onyx case you can do it at license-violation@gpl-violations.org but be prepared to provide solid information[2]. [1] https://gpl-violations.org https://gpl-violations.org [2] https://www.luga.de/static/LIT-2019/events/84.html https://www.luga.de/static/LIT-2019/events/84.html [3] https://gpl-violations.org/helping/ https://gpl-violations.org/helping/.
- fierarul 6y agoNot sure what Onyx is but my first though was about the System76 system https://system76.com/laptops/oryx https://system76.com/laptops/oryx Turns out that one is called Oryx
- thekyle 6y agoOnyx makes eInk tablets. I was actually thinking of buying one earlier this year, but not after this.