9 ms·
To me, that'd be a good outcome for the confederate flag. It is a hate symbol and exists almost exclusively to project hatred towards black people.
by UncleMeat 6y ago
To me, that'd be a good outcome for the confederate flag. It is a hate symbol and exists almost exclusively to project hatred towards black people.
- ta17711771 6y ago> To me, that'd be a good outcome for the confederate flag. Where does it end?
- mikepurvis 6y agoAt a point which is beyond the confederate flag. There may well be a slippery slope somewhere along this road, but it's not here. Gun advocates resist common sense reforms with the same logic, but lots of military weapons (minigun, flamethrower, rocket launcher, etc) are already either banned or highly regulated and have been for years without anyone's rights having been trampled.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWhat do you think of the counterargument about statues? A few years ago, the idea that removing Confederate statues might lead to removing statues of founding fathers was considered an absurd slippery slope argument; a few days ago, the New York Times published an opinion piece arguing that statues of George Washington should be torn down. How can we be confident that this isn't a step down that same slope?
- vimy 6y agoStatues of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and even Lincoln have already been attacked by the mob. Mount Rushmore is now a symbol of white supremacy. The Emancipation Memorial, paid for by former slaves, is also considered racist now. Boston is going to remove it. The slippery slope has turned into a slide with no end in sight. https://www.boston25news.com/news/local/boston-art-commission-votes-8-0-remove-emancipation-memorial-park-square/OZTMVYPMVJA6RJWRDUAM6P2DOU/ https://www.boston25news.com/news/local/boston-art-commissio...
- ceejayoz 6y agoFrom your own link: > But Blacks weren’t part of the design process, and the memorial’s central visual takeaway — a Black man kneeling before his white savior — has had people cringing for years. They paid for it, but didn't get to have input on how it'd look. Seems like the precise sort of thing folks are upset about. Rushmore was a treaty violation from the very beginning, and Native Americans occupied it as far back as 1971 in protest.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe NYT opinion page is hardly a barometer of broad public consensus— see the recent scandal of the Tom Cotton "send in the military" piece.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI'm not sure I follow. Opinion polls at the time showed that a significant majority of the public wanted the military sent in.
- rickbutton 6y agosource?
- mikepurvis 6y agoMost of the coverage I saw was people horrified at the constitutional implications of the military being turned on US citizens, on US soil, by order of the president.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI mean, there just aren't any constitutional implications - it happened in 1992 with no lasting repercussions.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThere are constitutional implications to the use of the Insurrection Act against largely peaceful demonstrations, like the ones in DC at the time it was invoked. The First Amendment does not protect riots, but it does protect protests outside the White House.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tc313 6y agoI agree with regards to private companies banning racist symbols, but the top comment was talking about anti hate-speech _laws_, which seem like a departure from my understanding of the first amendment. If a law against displaying the Confederate battle flag can be justified without a change to the constitution, then it really does become a slippery slope when determining what other unpopular expressions the first amendment fails to protect.
- beaner 6y agoReminds me of when Trump a while ago (before the recent George Floyd stuff) was commenting on statues being torn down, and commented something like, "next they'll go for George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, where does it end?" John Oliver did a bit on it answering "Somewhere. It ends somewhere," implying that he was an idiot, that it was a stupid comment, and everybody laughed. Now we're here and it has actually happened in reality. It's even gone further. Roosevelt. Lincoln?? We even have prominent BLM figures saying the western portrayal of Christ is systemic racism and must be erased. Since then I've come to see the answer "it ends somewhere" as completely void of any value or meaning, and mostly just a justification for mindless erasure. It's not a smart zinger, it's empty.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe Lincoln statue is kind of a special case, and it's obvious why from looking at it: https://www.wcvb.com/article/boston-art-commission-unanimously-votes-to-remove-controversial-abraham-lincoln-statue-in-park-square/33017211 https://www.wcvb.com/article/boston-art-commission-unanimous... As far as the others, clearly there is an Overton shift happening here, and that will embolden some advocates to make more extreme demands. Is that bad? Probably not, but I think most statues of Washington are likely safe for at least another generation or two, and if they get moved from the public square into museums at that later point, well, that's something the future will have decided on.
- ebg13 6y ago> figures saying the western portrayal of Christ is systemic racism You mean the ones where he's shown as west-european white? I suppose we could bother thinking about why he looks like that in those portrayals when he definitely wouldn't have in real life.
- beaner 6y agoOne reason is that people might feel closer to something that they think superficially resembles themselves. This is part of the reason why diversity is important, according to so many people right now. Not just because groups have more perspectives, but because the people in the minority feel more comfortable when the minority is not so small. I remember some years ago about a situation regarding a movie. I forget the exact details, but it was something like a Filipino movie about an American disaster, like 9/11. The movie was based on a historically inaccurate story of a Filipino man or family involved in the circumstances, when in reality there had been none. I don't know whether or not the Filipino person was a replacement for a white person's real story. But as someone much closer to the original circumstances, my perspective is not that I or my community's history has been replaced or been removed due to "racism." It is rather very touching that this foreign community felt close enough and impacted enough by the story to envision themselves inside it, taking part in it. To me, it was an expression of closeness and understanding, not appropriation or racism. Plus it seems strange to me that in a story where people walk on water and talk to burning bushes and kill gays, that the most offensive or historically inaccurate thing is that some people have envisioned the main character as being similar to them.
- ceejayoz 6y agoGermany doesn't seem to have significant difficulty banning Nazi symbols and propaganda without accidentally banning, say, depictions of unicorns. Slippery slopes have varying levels of steepness.
- mikepurvis 6y agoI believe the parent poster is referring to the extremely recent reforms going on in Germany, which are above and beyond their historic control of Nazi symbols: https://techcrunch.com/2020/06/19/germany-tightens-online-hate-speech-rules-to-make-platforms-send-reports-straight-to-the-feds/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/06/19/germany-tightens-online-ha... I don't have an opinion on this as it's way too fresh to have observed the effects of it and render a judgment; just here to provide context.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThat sounds like they're just setting up a mandatory reporter scenario, akin to how certain private entities are obligated to report child abuse in the USA.
- namdnay 6y agoLike most European countries today? This slope doesn’t seem particularly slippy
- jaywalk 6y agoYou mean countries where you can be arrested for a tweet that offends someone? Yeah, no thanks.
- namdnay 6y agoBecause that’s not already the case in the US? Ask a Muslim friend to post a joke about blowing up JFK and see how long it is until their door is broken down
- jaywalk 6y agoCome on. Threatening to blow up an airport is not in the same ballpark as hurting someone's feelings.
- ceejayoz 6y agoWhich European nations have rules against mere "hurting someone's feelings"?
- kube-system 6y agoThere are a number of examples of speech laws in the western world that have banned insults. From 1994-2014 the UK had a ban on speech that was "insulting" The UK's Communications Act 2003 section 127 also says: > (1) A person is guilty of an offence if he- > (a) sends by means of a public electronic communications network a message or other matter that is grossly offensive or of an indecent, obscene or menacing character; or > (b) causes any such message or matter to be so sent. > (2) A person is guilty of an offence if, for the purpose of causing annoyance, inconvenience or needless anxiety to another, he- > (a) sends by means of a public electronic communications network, a message that he knows to be false, > (b) causes such a message to be sent; or > (c) persistently makes use of a public electronic communications network.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 0l2wn9Bmxw 6y agoIs that a good enough reason to not start at all? (Even in general, not necessarily in this context)
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoWhy do you assume it continues?
- happytoexplain 6y agoThis question is applicable to all laws and impossible to objectively answer. It has no real value.
- UncleMeat 6y agoThe confederate flag maybe? We get to pick each time. "Well, we banned the confederate flag, better prevent white people from listening to rap" isn't the sort of thing that happens. Each adjustment to social norms is an independent choice that our society gets to make.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thepangolino 6y agoThe problem with that is that it's a pretty slippery slope. Is this a hate symbol? If it is and it gets banned, will you also consider whatever other symbol gets co-opted?
- happytoexplain 6y ago>it's a pretty slippery slope. I disagree. >Is this a hate symbol? I believe so. >will you also consider whatever other symbol gets co-opted? Yes, if it does get co-opted to the extent of replacing its original meaning. Luckily that only happens rarely. That's just how symbols and communication work - it's an unfortunate and unavoidable reality. The swastika is the most obvious example.
- cm2187 6y agoI think a photo of the Che is a hate symbol. It is glorifying a psychopath who killed without a second thought for a genocidal ideology. That's my opinion. So do I get to get it removed everywhere because it offends me?
- pfraze 6y ago1. Spend time educating people on why Che doesn't deserve to be idolized 2. Garner support for his removal 3. Go to any company using or selling his image and use your support to have it removed You asked how it works, that's how it works
- spaceisballer 6y agoIt’s so odd for people to mention it being a slippery slope. The confederate flag is a symbol of when traitors in our own country tried to rise up so that they could keep people as slaves. People say it was about state’s rights, yes the rights to keep people as slaves was a huge factor of it. There is nothing to celebrate here, the South wanted to unify and overrun the North. A lot of people died over this, it’s not worth celebrating there’s no heritage there worth putting on display. Full disclosure I grew up in the north, so it wasn’t until I moved out East that I ever encountered people that really tried to pass off flying the Confederate flag as a symbol of heritage. My belief is the Nazi flag is to Germany as the Confederate flag is to the US. They are symbols of hate and symbols of a dark past. The case seems clear cut, there’s nothing slippery.
- haram_masala 6y agoI don't think this is accurate. There are, or perhaps until recently were, a large number of people in the South who flew that flag out of a sense of regional pride and cohesion, and who had absolutely no problem with black people. Of course, that's not enough to forgive flying it - as a Jew I wouldn't be happy about a German person flying a Swastika, even if the only meaning it had for them was a benign pride in German accomplishments. Still, though, it's important to recognize the wholesome impulse to celebrate the South, as it is a distinct region with its own valuable culture. A few years back there was an attempt to replace the Stars and Bars with a new "Southern Pride" flag [1]. Predictably, it's bland garbage. [1] http://thesouth.us/ http://thesouth.us/
- UncleMeat 6y agoThere are definitely people who have been bamboozled into recognizing it as a symbol of abstract southern pride - but the connection remains. Regional pride can be a valuable thing. But "Southern Pride" should not just exist among white southerners. It should include the whole south, and using a symbol of the enslavement of black people doesn't exactly bring black southerners along for the ride of southern pride.
- acdha 6y agoThe problem is that this history is rooted in racism: the Confederacy was founded to preserve the institution of slavery (people who claim otherwise need to read the states’ own declarations) and the Army of Northern Virginia battle flag most commonly displayed has a long history from the Jim Crow era of being used to intimidate free Black people. Just as someone proud of being German has a wide variety of symbols they can use other than a swastika, someone proud of their Southern ancestry could pick almost anything else to express that. Choosing a symbol which racists have proudly used to intimidate others for a century in a half immediately calls motives into question and even if someone somehow managed to avoid learning the history until now the only polite response is “I had no idea. I’ll use something else!”
- pathseeker 6y agoSo the problem is you are conflating southern pride (pride in the culture) with the confederacy. Many people in the south used to view the confederate flag as representative of southern pride (iced tea on a porch while complaining about the heat).