8 ms·
The great depression in live performances is truly a global tragedy. If you think restaurants and barbershops have it bad, imagine theaters. For most of them it
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
The great depression in live performances is truly a global tragedy. If you think restaurants and barbershops have it bad, imagine theaters. For most of them it's basically impossible to do social distancing and remain financially solvent. People may be itching to go out to eat and get a haircut, but it will be a long time before people are going to pack in to an opera house. Couple that with the fact that audiences for ballet, opera, and orchestras skews much older I'm any case, and I fear many of these art forms will face a catastrophic blow in some cities.
- runawaybottle 6y agoThis holiday season is going to be a real test since we won’t have a vaccine by Novemberish. No ones going to fly out to holiday hotspots, or travel for Thanksgiving. Vaccine or bust basically.
- xwdv 6y agoWe will not have a vaccine this year, period.
- MuffinFlavored 6y agoI might be like... extra retarded for saying this but... with 153k cases in Florida and 3.5k deaths (2.3%), is it really that bad? I can only imagine how many hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of Florida citizens have it/have had it and had no symptoms and aren't getting tested (which would drive the death percentage down something fierce). I feel like I have a higher chance of dying driving down the street. Am I being ignorant?
- MrGilbert 6y ago> Am I being ignorant? Not, it's called 'optimism bias' [1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimism_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optimism_bias
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- m0zg 6y ago> with 153k cases in Florida and 3.5k deaths (2.3%), is it really that bad? You don't even know if it's 3.5K deaths _due to_ COVID in the first place. The way US counts the deaths from this is "unique" in that if someone had COVID when they died, but they did not die _from_ COVID, they're still counted as a COVID death. That's why countries like Russia with much less formidable healthcare systems have "lower" fatality ratios. They're counting those who died _because of_ COVID, not _with_ it. Why are we counting our deaths like this? I genuinely do not have a rational explanation, assuming there is one. And soon you won't even know if the number of cases is accurate either, since CDC has put out guidance that there is a chance of false positives in newer tests if you had common cold. Which most people have _several times a year_. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/lab/resources/antibody-tests-guidelines.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/lab/resources/anti... Quote: "Some tests may exhibit cross-reactivity with other coronaviruses, such as those that cause the common cold."
- atmosx 6y agoBecause for many cases it is not clear. The resources needed to understand are not there, they need to allocate them to save the living. This situation is extremely complex and we simply don’t have the tools and resources to deal with it effectively.
- l0ner 6y agoIn most countries, if you die having COVID, and you cant exclude COVID as being the cause, you are included in the COVID death count. In russia, if you die having COVID, but yoy also have any other sickness that could be the cause of death, you are not included in the COVID death count. While the former overestimates, the latter underestimates. I dont have any reference to prove it, but my gut feeling tells me that the latter is probably even further away from the true number than the former. In any case, they are absolutely not comparable.
- barrkel 6y agoThe best statistical tool we have to figure out the real death rate due to COVID is excess mortality, and these numbers have been higher even than the seemingly overattributed numbers. There are still a bunch of people who die and don't get attributed, and there are people who die because there's a pandemic on and they don't get healthcare as a result, either because there isn't capacity or to avoid infection.
- elorant 6y agoIt is bad once hospitals become overflown with cases. We saw it in NY, in Italy, in Spain etc. It's not the fatality rate per se the problem, it's how fast all these people will get infected.
- 1123581321 6y agoYour odds of dying from covid are higher. Auto deaths per passenger mile are 1-2 per 100 million miles, or about 1/20th (rough ballpark) the chance of dying from covid in the next couple years if you drive regularly and if you don’t already have health issues. I think it’s reasonable to wonder that, though.
- warent 6y agoI'm not sure what retardation has anything to do with this. If you mean you might be extra ignorant, that's something else. Consider speaking more clearly and abandoning the awkward slang. There's a common trend of mixing up the fatality percentage and the odds of dying to this. You seem to be falling into that confusion. A mortality rate of 2.3% doesnt mean you have a 2.3% chance of dying to it. If you're elderly and/or have a preexisting respiratory condition, then you have a much higher likelihood of something going very wrong. The younger and healthier you are, the lower the likelihood is that your health will be severely impacted. That's why young healthy people such as myself (25, regular exercise, no preexisting conditions) need to be more worried about other people. It isn't about my health, it's about theirs.
- bsder 6y ago> That's why young healthy people such as myself (25, regular exercise, no preexisting conditions) need to be more worried about other people. It isn't about my health, it's about theirs. This is not a factual statement. America is skewing younger with more complications than Europe. While it is always a good idea to think about others, the young aren't as immune to this as they think they are. Or, as I crudely put it to one youngster: You use condoms, right? Well, Covid statistically is more dangerous and more contagious than anything a condom protects against. Wear a mask, wash your hands, and keep your distance.
- pjc50 6y ago9/11 killed about 3k Americans, was it really that bad?
- tasuki 6y agoFor the people killed and their relatives and friends? Yes, for sure. Considering all the suffering going on in the world? No, not at all. There was a huge overreaction to 9/11 in the US which caused much more suffering than the event itself.
- junipertea 6y agoIt was definitely terrible for many other countries.
- jacquesm 6y agoIf you were an Iraqi, yes, it was really that bad.
- duaoebg 6y agoThe media tells us who to care about and by how much. I find the whole thing very irrational and very isolating. I’m quasi American and I have always hated the people who worked in those towers. The primary business of financialization is to rob the masses of their wealth / pensions. They are a well dressed and well behaved parasitical class. Osama Bin Laden’s stated intention was to drag the US in to a quagmire and the US obliged. Despite what MMT people may believe, the US will now have to get used to being a much poorer country. That adjustment will not be easy.
- viraptor 6y agoIt's not just the question of dying, although the numbers seems to be concentrating on that. Some people who don't die are sick for months. Some don't really fully recover, or have lasting effects. It's a bit like the stats for dying driving. It doesn't include people who survive but lose their legs or can't function independently anymore. In both cases think of the affected percentage which is so much higher.
- ascotan 6y agoNot your not wrong. The statistics show that the mortality rate is low unless your 65+. It's much higher than the flu, but less than say SARS was back in 2005. However, this isn't the real problem. Unlike most illnesses this one has a very long incubation time (like 1-2 weeks) unlike the flu where you get sick in a day or so. This means you can be walking around making people ill and spreading the disease even though you're totally fine. (Which is why walking around with out a mask isn't healthy for other people) So the real issue isn't you getting sick and dying but the fact that you're spreading the illness to 20+ other people and making the problem so much worse. All these sick people will eventually effect you (as they already have) overwhelming health and social services.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoNYC Broadway theater district just said they were going to remain closed through 2020. It's really devastating.
- atmosx 6y agoA digital platform with some sort of interaction (clap, reactions, emojis, live chat with some sort of censorship) might adjust public spectacles to the new age.
- saagarjha 6y agoIt’s one thing to watch a video of a performance, and quite another to watch it live.
- jaspax 6y agoThis. Watching a live performance can be way better than watching a video... but watching a live performance over Zoom is usually worse.
- JohnBooty 6y agoIt kind of has already -- Twitch, etc -- but whatever it evolves into online seems unlikely to support expensive and lavishly budgeted spectacles like Cirque. I feel certain live performances and sports with physically-present audiences will return, as that experience seems to fill some kind of deep-seated human need. (One I certainly share) But I increasingly fear that COVID-19 represents something like an asteroid-versus-dinosaurs event where, even though life continued, it looked drastically different. Perhaps it will be a good thing in the long run, but much will be lost.
- luckylion 6y agoI share your belief that it will change a lot, but I'm less fearful about it. I believe that quite a bit of traditions and "how we do things" are mostly there because that's how it was done, not because they are still what people want. A major disruption makes that more obvious and asks the question whether we still want it the way it was before. Maybe we don't want e.g. theaters any more. They've had declining audiences for quite a while and are, at least over here, heavily subsidized by the government. That money could also be used on other things that more people care for. Starting anew isn't necessarily a bad thing.
- 6y ago
- econcon 6y agoEscorts and strippers (sex workers) also can't perfect with social distancing in mind.
- ipnon 6y agoSerious question: will unregulated industries bother with public health orders if they are already ignoring the law to begin with?
- ashtonkem 6y agoStrippers are usually regulated.
- thelittleone 6y agoProstition is legal in many countries.
- purerandomness 6y agoIsn't it only the US (in the developed world) criminalizing sex work?
- luckylion 6y agoIt's mixed. Some countries have it regulated, but legal, others, like Sweden, make it legal to sell sex, but illegal to buy.
- yread 6y agoIn Netherlands they already work https://www.insidehook.com/daily_brief/news-opinion/amsterdam-red-light-district-reopens-after-coronavirus https://www.insidehook.com/daily_brief/news-opinion/amsterda...
- ashtonkem 6y agoThat and a lot of these venues had razor thin margins during the best of times; at half capacity they can’t survive. And that’s not even including the fact that discretionary spending will remain low until people feel financially secure, which might happen long after the pandemic is solved. Those who lost out on work will have credit holes to dig back out of once this is over. Here in LA this is killing off some standup clubs. I’ve speculated that it’ll decimate a whole generation of up and coming comics; if you’re a club that’s struggling and needs to sell half the seats at a higher price per, you’re going to reach for tried and true artists and not anyone slightly risky.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoBreaking out in standup comedy is already moving to YouTube. There are a few comics who record themselves performing to a very small crowd (probably of their friends) to get that live-audience energy, but their main audience is internet viewers.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgreed. I'm friends with many ballet dancers, and my heart breaks for them. I feel like ballet had a bit of a resurgence recently with the popularity of shows like "You think you can dance" and stars like Misty Copeland. But now I think a generation of dancers will be lost. Dancers can't just "pause". Staying in shape without access to studios and performances is incredibly difficult. The career of a dancer is incredibly short in the best of times. I think many will start to realize the gravity of the situation and move on.
- chrischen 6y agoWhy can't they just pause and resume (and the employees get unemployment benefits)?
- himinlomax 6y agoFinancial and commercial commitments: mortgages and contracts.
- jacquesm 6y agoBecause fixed costs such as building rent, maintenance and such will continue. Those are substantial amounts for any venue of note.
- the_other 6y agoThe value of a building (or the land it sits on) in a commercial district is entirely linked to the potential for that building to make money. During lockdown there's MUCH less opportunity for that building to make money. Accordingly, rents should drop; banks should make equity release more readily available etc etc.
- jacquesm 6y agoRental contracts are typically five or ten year fixed. You don't get to renegotiate in the middle because circumstances change.
- stagethrowaway 6y ago
- badrabbit 6y agoLive streaming a perfomance isn't an option? Wouldn't mind paying to live stream my favorite orchestra while stuck at home. There was a thing about spanish orchestra performing to an audience of plants and streaming it.
- fwn 6y agoI think that theaters and orchestras are often more event than content business. While there might be a aspects of a performance that can be conveyed through a video feed a large part of the experience is probably lost by attendants not being able to participate in person.
- brailsafe 6y agoIt might be a way to supplement their income for people who wouldn't have shown up anyway, but I personally wouldn't pay for it unless I was truly stuck at home. There's nothing like being there.
- ballenf 6y agoLoss of concessions could easily make it financially infeasible. Parking fees also lost. I end up out of pocket easily double the ticket price when all is done. But the real killer is everyone will want the equivalent ticket of the cheap seats. How do you stratify your prices while streaming?