5 ms·
Piracy is still piracy, regardless of your personal feelings about the value of your own use case. You’re taking something that is not yours for taking.
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Piracy is still piracy, regardless of your personal feelings about the value of your own use case. You’re taking something that is not yours for taking.
- kaibee 6y agoThis analogy really doesn't work, because taking something deprives someone of something they would've otherwise had. If you have the means to buy a piece of software and pirate instead to save money, then sure, I think you can make a case that it is 'taking'. When you're pirating something that you would've never been able to buy, who are you depriving of anything? I guess you're depriving those who have the means to buy that software of the exclusivity of their position, but is that something that they get to 'own'?
- nitrogen 6y agodepriving those who have the means to buy that software of the exclusivity of their position I'm gradually realizing that this probably plays a larger effect in society than we think. Like the ancient parable of the prodigal son, whose faithful brother was jealous that the rebel was celebrated in the end. Maybe it also plays out in lifelong CS devotees vs. CS-for- the-money people -- the nerds might feel that they have "earned" CS more, and the dayjob folks might not appreciate the depth of understanding that comes from the dedication of the lifelong devotees?
- Groxx 6y agoAt a moral absolutist standpoint: yea, absolutely. Whether it's harmful or not, the intent is still to avoid paying for what you got, which is pretty straightforward. For almost any other positions: it's murkier. If you take a berry off a bush on public property... what's the morality? Or growing from private property overhanging public that's just dropping fruit and the owners are either not present or clearly allowing fruit to drop? It's theirs, they absolutely could harvest it, but they're not and it's clearly implied that is not going to change. Now what? Yes that's still further towards harmless than you can likely argue software piracy is (... ignoring the network effects of everyone knowing how to use X because everyone pirated it, or I could probably come up with others), but my point is that strict black and white separations have dividing lines and breaking points. Whether there is black or white somewhere isn't really useful to anyone, it's where you draw the line.
- jacobolus 6y agoIf we are clear about terminology it’s less misleading. Unauthorized use of software downloaded from the internet is copyright infringement, not “piracy”. It is similar to making a xerox copy of a book obtained from the library, recording a rented video on a new videocassette tape, making an unauthorized recording at a music concert, or typing code you found in Numerical Recipes into your own open source project. It is not at all similar to boarding a ship and robbing the passengers.
- whakim 6y agoThat may be the case, but much of the "piracy is justified" crowd seems to rely on an "ends-justify-the-means" approach to suggest that piracy is great. If everyone pirated software (or if even a significant portion of people did), it'd be much harder to make money off of building software. I say this as someone who has pirated plenty of software in my life. I just didn't delude myself into thinking that I wasn't doing something wrong.
- imtringued 6y agoI'm having a dejavu but literally everyone who justifies piracy does it for the benefit of those who are dependent on it. People who have money don't care and just use the most convenient option.
- fortran77 6y agoYou are exactly right. And I'm surprised people are talking about it here cavalierly. I wouldn't hire someone who brags openly on forums about stealing software.
- zucker42 6y agoCopyright infringement isn't the same as stealing. I'm saying this as someone who can't recall ever using unlicensed software.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoAsk your colleagues. If you work around computers chances are that piracy is how a lot of them was able to start using them.
- fortran77 6y agoHere's the difference: People who stole software, but agree it's wrong have a moral compass. Those who try to rationalize it don't.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago>I wouldn't hire someone who brags openly on forums about stealing software. I'd just hire the best person for the job, which in some cases could be the person who has been using Photoshop since they were 12 because they pirated it. Think it's a pretty puritanical viewpoint to suggest someone was immoral and untrustworthy to the extent that it would compromise their job just because they pirated a few Adobe programs in their youth. I mean just what sort of other questions are you asking in your interviews for your purity test?