6 ms·
i have a mini-theory in which any group that allocates resources to existential risks will operate at a disadvantage (in the short term) to groups that do not,
by dekhn 6y ago
i have a mini-theory in which any group that allocates resources to existential risks will operate at a disadvantage (in the short term) to groups that do not, thus it's likely that anybody who does this will lose to competitors (businesses, countries) that do not.
FOr example, cloud providers who do not plan for meteor-based regional outages (which occur rarely) believe they can home all their data in a single region. This is much cheaper and will allow the provider a better profit margin, and realistically, not a lot of customers care about their data surviving a meteor taking out US-EAST1.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- digitallogic 6y agoYou don't need to worry about a meteor taking out us-east-1 because us-east-1 will take itself out several times over before a meteor ever shows up.
- DavidSJ 6y agoBesides, if the meteor’s big enough, it’ll also take out your customers.
- simonh 6y agoThis is a significant issue, any company that set aside resources to protect against a pandemic after the Spanish Flu would have been operating with increased costs for a full 100 years. Yet when the virus hit and companies struggled, I saw plenty of comments saying these companies deserved to fail. I’m all for capitalism and the benefits of market forces, but that’s ludicrous. I’m not saying they should all be bailed out either, companies come and go to be honest, but what we do need to do is ensure our vital interests and the infrastructure we depend on is secure and that’s going to take a pragmatic approach. The global cost of the virus is astronomical, but protecting ourselves effectively against a new virus doesn’t have to be crippling. The same is true of many other credible risks the article covers. Such preparations could even offer additional useful benefits. It’s just going to take vision and pragmatism I’m not sure our political leaders have in them these days.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y ago>...vital interests and the infrastructure we depend on is secure and that’s going to take a pragmatic approach. I argue for letting these businesses fail, even if vital, because, it seems, the powers that be have forgotten to take care of them, regulate them, and not get captured by private interests, for decades now. Infrastructure across the the country is literally crumbling. Major dams have failed this year. I fully expect to suffer much more before those with the power to delegate resources where needed will find the will too.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoMoral hazard. Why would anyone waste money planning for something that could make the business fail, when they know there will be trillions in bailouts? We'll solve the problem eventually, I guess, when it becomes clear that there's no money left for bailouts.
- overtomanu 6y agoMoney will never run out. Government will just print more money resulting in inflation and other problems. Most of the currencies are free floating and are not backed up by something tangible like gold.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoOh, sure, money itself may conjured such that it never runs out, but the ability of the government to tap the economy's output is definitely finite. If you start just conjuring money to bridge the gap, you're basically robbing whoever holds money (or other financial instruments denominated in your currency). These parties then work very hard to stop holding money. When that process is done, you're back where you started, only with less trust, higher transaction costs, and elevated risk burdens depressing output across the economy.
- renewiltord 6y agoDoesn’t appear to be a problem. Print money to accelerate out of the quagmire seems sensible.
- Forge36 6y agoBut they do care about power outages, hurricanes, tornadoes (maybe not in US-EAST1), cut fiber lines The probability any one very rare event is low. Preparing for it helps mitigate risks for many other issues however.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI believe GPS premise is largely correct, although the metaphor used could use a bit of work.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 6y agoElon musk is a counter example to your theory.
- qqqwerty 6y agoNot quite. Elon's strategies involve finding product/market fit in the short term for technologies that will be critical in the long term. But the companies themselves are on a knifes edge of survival. For example, if a meteor struck tomorrow, neither Tesla or SpaceX would have any advantage over their competitors. And if anything, because he runs his companies so close to the edge, his companies are uniquely susceptible to external catastrophic events.
- amelius 6y agoProbably one of the reasons why security is at the bottom of everybody's priority list.
- skillpass 6y agoThere's a great SlateStarCodex essay on this called "Studies on Slack", where this tradeoff of investing resources in preparation for low-likelihood catastrophic events is examined. Here is a link to the full article on LessWrong - https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GZSzMqr8hAB2dR8pk/studies-on-slack#:~:text=%20Studies%20On%20Slack%20%201%20I..%20Imagine,that%20gave%20itself%20slack%20in%20its...%20More%20 https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/GZSzMqr8hAB2dR8pk/studies-on...
- wizzwizz4 6y agoShame you can't link to the original Slate Star Codex copy.
- ip26 6y agoThat's just evolutionary theory applied to groups. Bacteria that allocate resources to existential risks (e.g. antibiotics) operate at a disadvantage to bacteria that do not, except in environments with frequent encounters with antibiotics.
- repsilat 6y agoDefinitely. Another place the mathematics translates pretty cleanly to is financial leverage. If you take a loan to expand your business and pull forward profits, or even rent property instead of buying it, you take tail risk but in normal times tend to outcompete. I think it's an ironclad argument for regulation (and maybe government intervention) in insurance markets, and a good argument in many others -- Even though I'm generally in favour of some leverage.
- ip26 6y agoThe right answer may not always be the risk compensated answer. The social gains to be had from ignoring the risk could be worthwhile in the broader picture, even if some groups fail.
- dekhn 6y agoYes, precisely (my background is biophysics). Selection pressure leads to rapid population shifts when one has a favorable mutation. However, you can look at eukaryotes and see that absolute efficiency isn't the metric by which they are being evaluated.
- cortesoft 6y agoMatt Levine has a great take on this in regards to the airline industry in this pandemic. He talks about all the people upset about all the stock buybacks they did during the boom years and how they should have saved cash for a pandemic. He runs the basic math, and even if the airlines completely cease to exist, it was still the financially sound decision to return the money to investors. Even if they knew the pandemic was going to happen this year, they made the right decision... and given that this was such a rare event, it would have been extremely foolish to try to maintain a cash cushion for this.
- dehrmann 6y agoThings this catastrophic are better left to governments for bailouts (which really is just insurance at a societal level) than for companies to save for. Having to save for events this unlikely is incredibly inefficient.
- antepodius 6y agoOr just let the airlines go bust. New ones will crop up once the situation improves.
- jfoster 6y agoPretty much. When an airline goes out of business, most of the physical aircraft will still be sold to someone unless they fall victim to lack of proper maintenance.
- willtim 6y agoI'm not convinced the premiums paid (taxes paid by corporations) match the risk and payouts given, it's only been 12 years since the last hundreds of billion dollar bailout. But yes, capitalism alone does not work.
- pete762 6y agoDo you have a link?
- fullshark 6y agoThis is basically the case for many government regulations, e.g. bank reserve requirements, building codes, food and safety laws, etc.
- gamell 6y agoToby Ord talks about this very problem in his book "The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity" [1] -- I totally recommend it if you are into this subject, although I have to admit I am pretty pessimistic after reading it, as it seems that the only way to avoid existential risk is by preparing through international collaboration at a global level. Precisely what I do not think will happen any time soon in the current climate. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Precipice-Existential-Risk-Future-Humanity/dp/0316484911 https://www.amazon.com/Precipice-Existential-Risk-Future-Hum...
- ascorbic 6y agoThey cite that book in the article. It seems to be their primary source.
- pbourke 6y agoThe US government could find the money to be fully prepared for pandemic diseases in its couch cushions. The problem is not a lack of resources but rather a lack of operational capability to observe, orient, decide and act.
- pasquinelli 6y agothat works for a profot seeking institution, but preparing for existential risks doesn't have a disadvantage in national security. it's the profit motive that is short sighted, and you've accidentally mistaken "any group" for "any group organized for the purpose of making profit."
- 082349872349872 6y agoSo it's a coordination problem. If only there were some sort of Organisation (in this specific example, for Health), whose remit was the whole World instead of particular groups, maybe we'd be able to coordinate to avoid a tragedy of the commons?
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's a pretty good theory. It even shows up in the start-up world: those companies that invest in good security and proper IT infra have a short term disadvantage compared to the ones that don't, which actually may have the effect that those that don't eventually win out at which point they will either end up with a massive security issue or they get wise and fix things in time. It's not a level playing field and tricks like this can easily make a big difference in outcome.
- jfoster 6y agoAnd even if you do prepare, the preparation might be for nil (or very little) advantage if a government will just bail out your competitors anyway.
- Tepix 6y agoThis is a good example where good marketing can make up for the disadvantage. If you explain to your customers what you did to prepare for eventualities, those among them who are risk averse may decide to become customers and pay you a little extra.
- Magnets 6y agoIt's compounded because of the interdependance of companies and countires.