10 ms·
Honestly I think the proclaimed death of intel is vastly exaggerated. AMD came back from worse places and they do still have the manufacturing edge. Intel CPU f
by raxxorrax 6y ago
Honestly I think the proclaimed death of intel is vastly exaggerated. AMD came back from worse places and they do still have the manufacturing edge. Intel CPU for desktop still use less power, which is a big plus. How many people do you know that bought the fastest CPU available recently? Glad AMD is back on track, they were in a rough place, far worse than intels current situation.
- pedrocr 6y agoAll I've read says Intel has a manufacturing disadvantage to TSMC (where AMD, Apple and many others get their chips) and their CPUs are less power efficient, not more, compared to AMD and particularly these kinds of upcoming ARM parts. Is that not the case?
- ksec 6y ago> Is that not the case? If simply having a better, and cheaper product will equal to immediate success then Mid-High End Fashion, as well as gazillion of other products in many other industry would not have existed as there are always competitors that offers something better at cheaper price. Marketing / Discovery and Channels / Distributions. And that also excluding the software advantage Intel has. AWS only just had their GA on Zen 2, nearly a year since they first made the announcement. Compared to Intel. I dont have any insider information. But I guess AMD has a lot to learn with regards to dealing with HyperScalers. And you may have notice, Intel has way more leaks than usual in the past 12-18 months. That is part of the PR play to keep people from buying AMD while they try to Catch up. Intel as of today is still operating at 100% capacity with back-log orders to fulfil, and a new record revenue in the last quarter. So yes, technically Intel is inferior, but until all of those disadvantage materialise into financial numbers it is far too early to call the death of Intel. I dont hold any Intel Stocks but speaking as an AMD shareholder.
- klelatti 6y agoAMD had to take radical action to survive and it was never in Intel's interests for it to vanish. Intel had the twin defensive 'moats' of x86 and the leading process technology. But now Intel has stalled relative to TSMC on the process lead (and possibly lost it) and the last few days have shown that the x86 moat is crumbling. The world will not move to TSMC manufactured ARM overnight but a significant shift could happen quite quickly I think. Intel will / has defended with lower prices but that will ultimately mean a big shift in business model. but .... Intel is the last firm with leading edge technology manufacturing in the US. If it starts to falter I can see a concerted effort to maintain that from the US government.
- api 6y agoWe still have somewhat of a lead in areas like composites, exotic materials, jet engines, turbines, and aerospace, but they are eroding. We can make good cars, though the majority of the good cars made in the US are made under the management of Japanese car companies. Tesla has some great technology and product design but on the manufacturing front they are behind the majors.
- klelatti 6y agoMy mistake - I meant just in chip manufacturing. Definitely leading in lots and lots of other areas.
- deelowe 6y agoYeah. Silicon manufacturing has huge implications for national defense. Not sure how relevant Intel is in that particular discussion. Did the US Govt express concerns when IBM stopped making chips in-house?
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThey're relevant to the need for computers free from (foreign) backdoors. Otherwise, defense doesn't rely on cutting edge ICs any more. Modern processes can't deliver the reliability most military systems need, particularly if radiation hardening is a requirement.
- smolder 6y agoIntel desktop cpus do not use less power. The only metric where intel desktop cpus win right now is maximum per-core performance, and not by much. They're worse at performance per dollar, performance per watt, maximum multithreaded performance, and overall power efficiency. (edit: perhaps not idle power efficiency...)
- blattimwind 6y agoAs a desktop user, my CPU tends to be mostly idle. So overall power efficiency is impacted a lot by idle power consumption; my AMD Ryzen CPU alone draws significantly more power in idle than my previous several-years-old Intel system. In fact, just the IO die alone draws almost as much power as some office PCs.
- smolder 6y agoAh sorry, I thought I had seen zen2 measuring lower for idle consumption than comparable intel as well, but some searching says to me you're right.
- zrm 6y agoComparing idle power consumption for desktop parts is kind of a desperation. For laptops it matters, but the Zen2 laptops aren't using an IO die manufactured on the older process. For desktops the difference at idle is something like 10 watts, i.e. ~$10/year in electricity, and even that much only if the machine is both turned on and idle 24 hours a day the whole year, whereas anybody worried about power consumption would put it to sleep. Between Windows Update and crappy javascript, the theory that modern desktops are usually idle is also increasingly untrue, and under load the power consumption for the Intel parts is worse.
- bcrosby95 6y agoYes, AMD as a power hog or a space heater is just a weird assumption people make based upon some old chips. It hasn't really been true for any of the Zen architecture chips.
- blattimwind 6y agoFor what it's worth, Intel is still faster in most applications, simply by virtue of having a clock speed advantage that by far exceeds any IPC difference, and also by having much lower memory latencies. AMD has basically a 20-30 ns extra latency over Intel; so with good memory you can do ~45 ns on current Intels, but that will give you ~65 ns on a Ryzen. That's significant for a lot of code (e.g. pointer chasing, complex logic etc.). On the other hand, few applications scale efficiently to more than just four cores. Yes, of course, AMD delivers more Cinebenchpoints-per-Dollar and usually more Cinebenchpoints overall, but that's not necessarily an interesting metric. Personally I find that if I'm waiting on something to complete that the application in question tends to use only a tiny number of cores for the task at hand. Usually one. Another significant weakness of AMD's current platform is idle power consumption. These factors leave me with a much more nuanced impression than "Intel is ded" or "HOW IS INTEL GOING TO CATCH UP TO THIS????"; CPU reviews these days are just pure clickbait.
- highfrequency 6y agoHi, this is very informative. To clarify a couple points: - By memory latency, do you mean the time to access an uncached portion of RAM? - RE clock speed advantage, are you referring to the fact that AMD turbo boost doesn't hit 5GHz?
- blattimwind 6y agoIIRC L3 is slightly slower on Zen 2, main memory as mentioned much slower. Clock speed advantage -- Most Zen 2 CPUs don't overclock to 4.5 GHz on any core, let alone all-core. The boost numbers are reached with current firmware, but only for tiniest fractions of a second and never under any real load. Sustained single-core boost frequencies are 200-400 MHz lower than the specified boost frequency. On the other hand, Intel CPUs consistently reach their boost frequencies under load, and most CPUs can do their single-core boost as an all-core overclock under load (with much greater power consumption of course). In practice this means that for equivalently priced parts (e.g. 3900X vs 10900K) the AMD part will have about a GHz lower clock for lightly threaded workloads, which are most workloads. With Intel settings, the Intel and AMD parts have about the same sustained clocks (3.8-4 GHz) under all-core load, but with the defaults of many motherboards the Intel part will run at 4.8-5 GHz, depending on the cooling.