11 ms·
Cosmic Rays May Explain Life’s Bias for Right-Handed DNA
- jedimastert 6y agoMedlife Crisis, a cardiologist that makes educational YouTube videos[0], did a somewhat similar (and very very funny) talk about the chirality of of the human body, linking it to the chirality of DNA and beyond[1] [0]https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgRBRE1DUP2w7HTH9j_L4OQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgRBRE1DUP2w7HTH9j_L4OQ [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqv9HHNak0c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqv9HHNak0c
- monkeycantype 6y agooh this is genius!
- monkeycantype 6y agook someone didn't like this comment, lets see if I can make it better. The article linked doesn't have a lot of detail, but i'm impressed that someone has pushed through the standard reflexive though that either chiral form was equally likely and recognised that actually the universal has handedness that could have influenced the outcome. That's what I think is the stroke of genius here, not the conclusion, but the idea to consider other forms of handedness eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality_(electromagnetism)#Handedness_of_electromagnetic_waves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality_(electromagnetism)#H... as context in which the left or right forms might not actually be equivalent. The reason I think this is genius, is it is a question anyone could have asked. Lots of us have probably thought about it at some point and summarily concluded it was not a question we were capable of exploring.
- jjtheblunt 6y agodo modal verbs in titles seem correlated with clickbait?
- axegon_ 6y agoOn a semi-related note, I wonder why, even though I'm right-handed, my left hand is considerably stronger than my right one or how common this phenomenon is.
- ddrt 6y agoSon, have I ever told you about the move some call ‘the stranger?’
- TheGallopedHigh 6y agoHackney news is not the place for these kinds of jokes because they add nothing to the conversation.
- taneq 6y agoAny asymmetric activity involving a moderate amount of exertion and repeated regularly would create a difference in strength between the sides of the body, so this could actually be an explanation. ;)
- fiblye 6y agoI usually carry baggage and things in my left hand in order to leave my right hand free. My grip strength is tremendously better with my left hand and I'm pretty sure that's the reason.
- LarvaFX 6y agoAs I'm left handed, for me it's the other way round!
- AngryData 6y agoNot sure how accurate it was or how well I remember it but I once read an article that explained that your higher dexterity hand/limb(s) requires more conscious effort to reach the the same level of muscle utilization as a side effect of more sensitive nerve endings used for dexterity. And further speculated that the higher dexterity limb worked the muscles slightly more efficiently which can lead to slightly more muscle development in the non-dominate limb to balance out overutilization/less-efficient non-dominant limb. Suppose to be true for both arms and legs. However they did note that it only takes a small workout bias between limbs to surpass the small possibly natural differences in limb strengths.
- person_of_color 6y agoI was hoping this would explain handedness in humans, but it's semi clickbait.
- WhiteSage 6y agoPlenty of mutations are already produced by faulty copying. This is how viruses mutate. An early organism would have very error-prone RNA copying. How would the cosmic rays, producing a tiny effect on top of this, be relevant at all? The author fails to explain this. The secret to chirality might simply be chance: once the machinery is running it can only understand its own chirality.
- moonchild 6y agoThey do address this. Faulty copying is not biased (except towards mutations which help decrease it). DNA chirality is. Over the course of hundreds of millions of years, that tiny bias adds up to a significantly more successful organism.
- aresecson 6y agoI believe the original paper’s authors are suggesting that the effect of cosmic rays on mutations might be enantioselective (meaning they effect molecules differently based on their chirality). See original paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2002.12138.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2002.12138.pdf And previous HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23294294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23294294
- JoshTriplett 6y agoI would be interested to see more explanation for why cosmic rays turn out to have a specific chirality-preference, and the actual proportion to which they do. The article seems very light on information on that point.
- pantalaimon 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_interaction#Violation_of_symmetry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_interaction#Violation_of_...
- mkl 6y ago(Not OP) I read that earlier while trying to answer the same question, but it doesn't seem to explain the cosmic ray handedness. Am I missing something?
- JoshTriplett 6y agoLikewise; that's what I'd like to know as well.
- bronzeage 6y agoI bet that if they found out the opposite, that the current chirality is less prone to mutations from cosmic rays, we'll have an identical article which celebrates their finding, except that they would propose it's better to have less mutations. They need to prove that increasing number of mutations is even a desirable property.
- La1n 6y ago>They need to prove that increasing number of mutations is even a desirable property. Faster evolution is a desirable property, maybe not anymore, but in first life for sure.
- Symmetry 6y agoIt's always easy to mutate faster if you want to, though. Not mutating is the challenge.
- aparadja 6y agoI wonder why the parent comment is downvoted. To a layman like me, it sounds completely reasonable. Maintaining an exact copy of RNA/DNA through generations and generations is a real challenge, right? Loosening up the copying mechanisms to allow for more mistakes would probably be quite easy to achieve, if that was beneficial, right? I’d be interested to hear what makes the idea wrong.
- sokoloff 6y agoI’m no expert in the field and the only remotely relevant experience I have is a tiny amount of genetic algorithm programming at a rank amateur level. I assume that making perfect replicas is the default way for a given type of life to dominate. Making “random copies” (an oxymoron) is not likely to result in domination of any individual type (of building block, single cell, or multi-cellular life). Making perfect copies allows a build-up of “winners”. If that implies a very strong selection process for perfect copies, then after that a selection process for increased (but still small in aggregate) mutation rate would seem globally helpful.
- madaxe_again 6y agoAsimov wrote about precisely this, and hypothesised, well, exactly this, in his essay “The asymmetry of life” in the collection “The Left Hand of the Electron” - in 1972 - right down to gamma ray chirality due to electron spin asymmetry affecting an initial randomly distributed population. See pages 65-67 of the below (pdf pages, not book pages). http://www.arvindguptatoys.com/arvindgupta/asimov-electron.pdf http://www.arvindguptatoys.com/arvindgupta/asimov-electron.p...
- mkl 6y agoAsimov refers to a 1968 paper, and a Nature article [1] refers to a 1967 paper by other researchers, so it seems like it may have been a common hypothesis at the time. However, Asimov doesn't refer to cosmic rays like the original article, but the Nature article does. [1] https://www.nature.com/news/force-of-nature-gave-life-its-asymmetry-1.15995 https://www.nature.com/news/force-of-nature-gave-life-its-as...
- jquery 6y agoThis is absolutely incredible. I’ve never read Asimov beyond one or two short stories, now I feel compelled to read his grander works. What an insanely keen mind.
- himinlomax 6y agoBe sure to read his paper on the properties of resublimated thiotimoline. It's a disgrace he never got a Nobel prize for this.
- baxtr 6y agoNice way to spread the story :)
- eindiran 6y agoIn case anyone was wondering what this referred to (like I did): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline > Thiotimoline is a fictitious chemical compound conceived by American biochemist and science fiction author Isaac Asimov. It was first described in a spoof scientific paper titled "The Endochronic Properties of Resublimated Thiotimoline" in 1948. The major peculiarity of the chemical is its "endochronicity": it starts dissolving before it makes contact with water. > Asimov went on to write three additional short stories, each describing different properties or uses of thiotimoline.
- Symmetry 6y agoA pretty small effect, given that Earth has on net lost atmosphere over time there was less cosmic ray radiation on the surface back then then there is now. Which is in stark contrast to UV radiation which came in easily before the Great Oxygenation produced an ozone layer. LUCA, the last universal common ancestor, probably already had some oxygen resistance before then because UV radiation was always breaking up water molecules to produce tiny amounts of oxygen that it had to deal with. (Currently reading Oxygen by Nick Lane)
- novaRom 6y agoUV radiation could not penetrate deep layers of oceans (where LUCA could potentially emerge)
- vanderZwan 6y agoHow much do the insights from this article overlap with this 12-minute stand-up comedy bit about (more or less) the same topic? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqv9HHNak0c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqv9HHNak0c
- necovek 6y agoSo, what they are saying is that if you climb a helix of a DNA molecule, you are always turning left? How weird to call that "right-handedness"!
- messe 6y agoMake a fist with your right hand. Which way do your fingers curl?
- necovek 6y agoThank you for explaining the convention (I've heard it before). How does that relate to "righthandedness" otherwise? I was just (jokingly) pointing out how introducing conventions for right or left requires memorization of some silly rule like this. I'd much prefer if they used made-for-purpose topological terms instead of pretending how this somehow relates to a widely known concept.
- mkl 6y agoPoint your right thumb along the purple DNA helix at the top of the article (either direction). Your right fingers curl in the direction the helix turns, so the purple helix is right-handed. Now do the same with your left hand and the orange DNA helices. When your left thumb points along the helix, your left fingers curl in the direction the helix turns, so the orange helices are left-handed.
- andy_ppp 6y agoThis is hugely interesting. Tangentially: I was told once the reason spiral staircases go the other way (in castles usually) is that when running upstairs with a sword you want to be able to use your right hand to kill anyone coming down the stairs. As a side note you do turn left in the UK roads, so this rule is not universal.
- sokoloff 6y agoWouldn’t castles be designed to favor the defender at the top of the stairs?
- jtanderson 6y agoRight, I think most staircases I've seen in castles have required you to go clockwise when ascending. This means the attacker's sword hand would be pretty constrained!
- andy_ppp 6y agoIf someone is coming into the castle how do they get inside? Over the castle walls usually.
- hbarka 6y agoI was told it had to do with practicality. Using the right arm to lean into the wall because ascending can get exhausting.
- SkyBelow 6y agoAre there any simplified explanations for the asymmetry of the weak force driving the cosmic ray polarity that doesn't require extensive knowledge in physics?
- 7thaccount 6y agoInteresting. SETI planned on identifying any left-handed chirality outside of Earth as a good indicator for life not formed on Earth as we haven't managed to find any on Earth yet.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoReally interesting. Tangentially related, this 2006 Astronomy Picture of the Day showing a render of cosmic rays coming down and the corresponding air showers is really illustrative [1]. These things happen millions of times per day. I'd love to see a more modern animation of it. [1] https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap060814.html https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap060814.html
- nullc 6y agoAren't the cosmic rays polarized due to earth's magnetic field? (if so-- wouldn't field reversals have swapped it?)