7 ms·
The broader issue is that the US birth rate is 1.77 births per woman -- and falling, which is below the replacement rate. If you want to maintain the population
by arcticbull 6y ago
The broader issue is that the US birth rate is 1.77 births per woman -- and falling, which is below the replacement rate. If you want to maintain the population (and economic activity) at the same level as today, you're going to have to bring in 0.23 people per woman per generation via immigration. In the pathological case of closed borders, the economy will shrink in accordance with the birth rate.
This effect is on top of the non-zero-sum impact of qualified migrants.
Consider the 1.43 births per woman (and low net migration rate) of Japan and the fact that the GDP was lower last year than it was almost twenty years ago. In the same time period the US GDP has tripled. Canada's has almost quadrupled -- and Canada brings in 1% of the nations population each year via immigration, in part to offset its 1.5 births per woman.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThose who experience wealth inequality or are otherwise economically disadvantaged in their own country may view national economic activity in the same way they view the stock market: with apathy. Having a job at all is the priority for many.
- arcticbull 6y agoGDP is not a proxy for wealth inequality. For instance, Canada has much lower inequality than the US [1] (0.32 vs 0.47) and saw a much greater percentage of its country materialize through immigration, but still saw a greater increase in GDP over the same time period. Wealth inequality is a symptom of government policy, nothing more. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toochini 6y agoYou think a government can make inequality go away? Please give us one example
- arcticbull 6y agoSure, the Soviet Union. A government literally made inequality go away with the stroke of a pen. Ideal, of course not. Recommended? Definitely not. However, it's clear and self-evident that the US government allows wealthy people to keep their wealth. A wealth tax would solve that problem, for instance. Again, without advocating, I'm just saying that wealth and wealth inequality exist at the whim of the ruling class. I'm not sure I could come up with a counter-example that didn't involve a contrived crypto-ancap utopia. The fact that income and wealth inequality are different in different countries is proof in and of itself.
- jen20 6y ago> A government literally made inequality go away with the stroke of a pen. This is an _incredibly_ rose-tinted view of the Soviet Union. I would suggest researching Waldsiedlung as a starting point.
- arcticbull 6y agoWhy would that be rose-tinted? I believe in the value of inequality, to a point. Where I disagree with the status quo is I don't think the top end should be effectively unlimited, and I think the bottom end should be a lot higher. However to say that government policy can't substantially reduce inequality is patently absurd. The government has the power to take things from people, every year, in taxes.
- kofejnik 6y ago> Sure, the Soviet Union. A government literally made inequality go away with the stroke of a pen. You have no idea what you're talking about, just stop. Source: born in USSR
- cycomanic 6y ago
- toochini 6y agoNot even American but just consider the following. Rising wages (basic supply and demand) lead to an increase in the fertility rate as people feel more financially secure to have children. And before you say that it will go to remote work: big tech has been dying and trying to outsource everything as it is still cheaper than legal immigration. There might be bigger incentives if wages do rise, but they have pretty much been there all the time
- arcticbull 6y ago> Rising wages (basic supply and demand) lead to an increase in the fertility rate as people feel more financially secure to have children. That's actually the opposite of what happens. As a country develops, wages go up and fertility goes down. Check out this chart of GDP per capita vs fertility rates. [2] It's a well known and extremely strong effect. Fun and very poignant quote: In a 1974 UN population conference in Bucharest, Karan Singh, a former minister of population in India, illustrated this trend by stating "Development is the best contraceptive." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility#/media/File:TFR_vs_PPP_2015.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility#/media/Fi...
- toomuchtodo 6y agoControl-F “Economics matters for birth rates” for various citations backing a thesis that increasing wealth correlates with higher birth rates. https://www.brookings.edu/research/half-a-million-fewer-children-the-coming-covid-baby-bust/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/half-a-million-fewer-chil...
- arcticbull 6y agoThis is an extremely well studied and well documented effect. One-off extreme situations such as WWII and COVID aren't counter-examples of a global trend. Development leads to a reduction in fertility. The only dispute globally is what happens once incomes rise after the birth rate falls below replenishment (i.e. whether there's a J-curve effect). I read your article, and nothing there tracks the correlation between birth rates and income in a greater-than-replenishment situation. I conceded that in the tail end, rising wages may lead to more births, but I have not seen (including in your citations) an indication it would lead to an above-replenishment birth rate. Just some micro-level changes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dropit_sphere 6y ago>The broader issue is that the US birth rate is 1.77 births per woman -- and falling, which is below the replacement rate. Have you considered that the causation may be in the reverse? The article pokes fun at skeptics of women in the workforce in the 60's and 70's. Yet real wages have remained stagnant since then, and given that divorce rates are significantly higher when the woman is the higher earner, it's not insane to suggest that falling (who am I kidding, fallen) family formation rates are due to those couples now having trouble forming in the first place. Elizabeth Warren's Two-Income Trap is required reading here.
- beaner 6y agoWhy is continuous growth even a goal? There's a physical reality that at some point it must stop. We should plan for that. GDP growth is just a number. We should focus on quality of life. (Notwithstanding transitionary points like "but this other country is still growing and will displace things," and "but who will take care of those decaying cities," etc)
- logicchains 6y agoHuman wants are unlimited. GDP growth (in the ideal sense, when perfectly measured) means more wants are being satisifed. It doesn't imply growth in resource usage: if your CPU becomes twice as efficient, or your package delivery route is optimised, or your barber learns to cut hair faster, that all counts as GDP growth.
- peteradio 6y ago> It doesn't imply growth in resource usage: if your CPU becomes twice as efficient, or your package delivery route is optimised, or your barber learns to cut hair faster, that all counts as GDP growth. If demand is not saturating your efficiency improvement then you are maybe capturing a bigger piece of the pie but the pie may shrink or grow. Isn't the pie the proper measure? Why are we measuring scoops of pie passing back and forth?
- AtlasLion 6y agoIt only does if there are more packages that can be sent or hair that can be cut. With a shrinking population, both are untrue.
- cycomanic 6y agoI don't know where your "human wants are unlimited" comes from and is a pretty big statement to make to not back it up with evidence. However even if we except your premise that an increased GDP will help to fulfill this is highly doubtful. A increased GDP can (and does) very well decrease quality of life. Traffic accidents, environmental pollution, obesity, divorce all increase GDP, not sure if they fulfill human wants. In fact one of the reasons why the US has been so successful at increasing GDP is that the population has an increasingly unhealthy livestyle.
- shard972 6y agoHow about we encourage births again instead of encouring people to be gay and trans?
- 0xfaded 6y agoIf maintaining the population size is the goal, then an alternative is to make havimg kids more attractive. Free daycare, education, healthcare, etc would go some way, but income stability also needs to be addressed. Even in Europe, the decision to delay kids is primarily economic (after 20 years of net zero growth). Btw I still want open migration for all the other reasons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoI guess my question would be, why try and incentivize people who don't want to, to have children, when you can bring in willing fully-formed adults?
- pnako 6y agoTo maintain nations and cultures instead of creating the conditions for civil wars all over the world.
- mtgp1000 6y agoBecause it is a dangerous fallacy to presume that all peoples are simply replaceable. When you import people you import culture, and that potentially leads to friction.
- mrmonkeyman 6y agoWhy are downvoting this? This is obviously the only thing worth talking about. You see the cultural destabilisation happening all over the western world and it's not because of economic factors. Also, let's just name it: importing of Islamic 1. culture and 2. religion is problematic to say the least.
- newen 6y agoBecause it's not always the case that people don't want to have children but they are instead constrained by their situations, which can be alleviated by free daycare, education, healthcare, etc. I think what you are doing is assuming that the current state of the system is all it can be and that people's decisions they make resulting from the current system what they truly want.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The broader issue is that the US birth rate is 1.77 births per woman -- and falling, which is below the replacement rate That's the “Total” (e.g., projected hypothetical lifetime) fertility rate; completed fertility rate (measured by women age 40-44, so it's a tiny bit low since some, and an increasing number, of women actually have children past that age) is actually up above the replacement from a low of 1.86 in 2006. TFR is only useful as a tool to project the future CFR, but it has a pretty variable history in actually doing that, and there are reasons to suspect it currently may be underestimating what it will end up being for women currently in their childbearing years for the same (but inverted) reason it overestimated it during the baby boom.
- blockmarker 6y agoWhy instead of raising the birth rate, must we bring massive amounts of immigrants each year? For the short time Hungary's loan assistance to families with children has been put in place, it has already had great effects.
- notahacker 6y agoThe question applies equally the other way round: why, instead of an race-obsessed government determining that having children is a 'public matter, not a private one' and chastising women for having the temerity to prioritise other things, do we not simply permit people willing and able to do the work into the country? Irrespective of the merits or lack thereof of paying bonuses for having three or more children, fertility rate in Hungary is still well below replacement rate, and well below the US birth rate for that matter.
- kelnos 6y agoThat depends on the reasons behind why the birth rate is below the replacement rate. If it's because potential parents feel financial or other insecurity that causes them to not have children, or have fewer than they want, then sure, that's an actual problem that needs to be addressed. But if the reason is that people just don't feel like having 2 or more children, well, that should be up to them, no?
- pjc50 6y agoThis is a really terrible line of reasoning to pursue, because it's basically the continuation of colonialism - the need to have a caste of second-class noncitizens doing a large part of the work; while also telling the "race replacement" fascists that they are absolutely correct and they are being deliberately replaced for someone else's economic gain. > the GDP [of Japan] was lower last year than it was almost twenty years ago That is an extraordinary claim that's contradicted by brief searching: https://tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp-constant-prices https://tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp-constant-prices
- notahacker 6y ago> This is a really terrible line of reasoning to pursue, because it's basically the continuation of colonialism - the need to have a caste of second-class noncitizens doing a large part of the work Nobody said 'caste, second class or non-citizens' though. Yes, people who have the 'colonialist mentality' might assume that foreign-born people are only capable of replacing menial workers, but that's not implied by the basic logic that if people are born below the population replacement rate some countries and above it in others, some population transfer might be desirable and not consistent with much of the reality of immigration.
- pjc50 6y agoUnless and until deportation is eliminiated entirely, that's an inevitable part of being an immigrant. Regardless of the skill level and social status of your job. Even if you're a CEO you can still theoretically be deported for a driving offence in a lot of places, until you get your full permanent residence. And then you have to wonder whether a future government might remove that residence. The British government has gone backwards on this: a British-born child of non-British parents was stripped of her citizenship, barred from the country, and denied legal appeal. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c347vzp58nzt/shamima-begum-case https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c347vzp58nzt/shamima-begum...
- notahacker 6y agoAggressive stances towards deportation are the consequence of inaccurate arguments that immigrants are on average unwelcome freeloaders and destroyers of job value rather than making the future of the country more sustainable though. It's entirely possible for immigrants to have security of tenure and actually more desirable given declining birth rates: it's the assumption that our current society would be more sustainable in their absence which drives governments to make it as difficult as possible to obtain/retain. All the rhetoric which drove repatriation of the Windrush migrants [a much more representative case than Begum leaving the UK to join ISIS] was based around the popularisation of the idea that the UK was 'full' of 'unsustainable' numbers of migrants. So it certainly doesn't help immigrants to pointedly refuse to state reasons why this is incorrect.