5 ms·
The chicken first crossed the road in Southeast Asia, landmark gene study finds
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoEvery winter, looking at our chickens roosting in their unheated coop at -15C, I marvel at the ability of the descendant of a bird from the tropics to survive in a Canadian winter. But then I remember that my species comes from eastern Africa...
- markdown 6y agoI imagine that chickens had to adapt to the cold much much much faster than humans had to.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoYes, and I get the advantage of clothes :-) They don't even seem that bothered by it. If you put a heater in the coop they don't make a point of perching near it, for example. They hate the snow like it's lava though.
- churchillracist 6y ago> imagine that chickens had to adapt to the cold They already had that adaptation. Chickens are members of the fowl family which are all homeothermic animals, meaning that they maintain their own body temperature. Chickens thermoregulate their body temperatures through their respiratory system. Heat is lost by the bird as sensible heat directly to the atmosphere when the temperature gradient is sufficiently great and as insensible heat by the evaporation of water from the respiratory system and skin when the temperature gradient is less but relative humidity is low. The layer of fat usually found under the skin plus the coat of feathers provide very good protection from low temperature and it is unlikely that birds other than young chickens will die of hypothermia. For a constant deep body temperature to be maintained, heat production must equal heat loss.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoI live in the UK and I am amazed that date palms do well here, in a country with much higher rainfall and it does get colder than the middle east. Also agaves seem quite happy (what tequila is made out of. What's actually more surprising than cold tolerance is that water tolerance; desert-y plants tend to be adapted to be needing periods where their roots are dry for long periods. Let them stand with wet feet and many desert plants get very upset. I guess the middle east was wetter even in roman times, so perhaps that answers part of that. To flip the chicken question around a bit, it's perhaps odd that chickens can cope not with the cold but with their native heat so well, what with wearing a full-body, heavy down jacket all the time in their native tropical jungle.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoChickens molt! They rid themselves of the feathers and down periodically.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoAnd then they grow them back again I presume. In the middle of a jungle forest. It seems odd.
- smichel17 6y agoMy understanding is that they lose a lot of water through their skin. Not a deep enough understanding to know whether saying "chickens sweat a lot" is accurate, but I imagine in either case the evaporation helps them keep cool.
- pvaldes 6y agoBird feathers can trap air inside and can be raised all together in a second making it work like a sponge. A better analogy could be wearing a flask
- koheripbal 6y agoThat depends which humans. We are not one monolithic gene pool. Human diversity means that more recent migrations of humans had less time to adjust to their new climates. If you compare, say Inuit, Nordic, and native Siberian populations, to subsequent equatorial populations to higher latitudes, if you could find instances of low interbreeding, I wonder if we'd see certain genetic adaptations missing.
- sradman 6y ago> But then I remember that my species comes from eastern Africa... via Madagascar via South East Asia, assuming I'm remembering Jared Diamond correctly. I wonder if there are any Polynesian strains with interesting genetic diversity.
- samstave 6y agoSadly, haven't Humans worked diligently to eliminate genetic diversity in chickens - look at the history of how the Rocky Chicken, the most widely eaten chicken was bred.
- ghaff 6y agoGo to a fair in farm country and you'll see plenty of variety. But, yes, as with other animals raised for food and dairy (and plants for that matter), mainstream commercial production is mostly a near-monoculture.
- samatman 6y agoWhich is a trend that must stop. After we've all seen what SARS2 can do to the industrial world, the risk monoculture poses for breeding a bird flu which can jump to poultry handlers is simply unacceptable. Monoculture, and the conditions of chicken husbandry, simply must improve. This is an existential risk.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThere's lots of variety out there still, just not in factory farms. Lucky for the chicken it has a personality which humans seem to get immense enjoyment out of. My wife has gone a little chicken crazy since I brought home 4 pullets a couple years ago...
- sradman 6y agoI was being fuzzy with my language. Between 5kya and 3kya [1], the domesticated chickens that began their journey in mainland Asia ended up as part of the standard toolkit of the Melanesian and Polynesian people that spread widely throughout the Pacific. If any of those chicken strains remain, they might be genetically unique compared to what we find in mainland Asia today. I'm interested in the origins of domestication not returning to some form of pastoral idealism. I need to strike "diversity" from my vocabulary. I should have said "interesting genetic variations". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polynesia#Origins_and_expansion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polynesia#Origins_and_expansio...
- tibbydudeza 6y agoI wonder how far the Chickenosaurus project is coming along.
- scorecard 6y agoThere is progress toward Jurassic Park. 1. Gene edits turn a bill into something like a dinosaur snout: https://www.livescience.com/50886-scientific-progress-dino-chicken.html https://www.livescience.com/50886-scientific-progress-dino-c... 2. early birds may have been baby dinosaurs that stopped developing, yet could produce off spring, according to another recent DNA study I can't locate at the moment. Now if that development process could be turned back on in a bird ...
- mirimir 6y ago> 2. early birds may have been baby dinosaurs that stopped developing, yet could produce off spring, according to another recent DNA study I can't locate at the moment. And early humans may have been baby ~chimpanzees that stopped developing, yet could produce offspring :)
- jshprentz 6y agoUnanswered is the question of where and when a chicken would first have an opportunity to cross a road. The article reports that researchers traced chickens genetically back to southeast Asian pheasants domesticated around 7500 BCE. Beyond the title, the article mentions nothing about roads. At what point in history did some trails and paths become roads?
- masklinn 6y agoThere were stone-paved streets in Harappa and Ur, circa 4000BCE. There's also evidence of log roads in England appearing between 4000 BCE and 3800BCE. Brick paving appeared in India around 3000BCE. By 2000 BCE, the "leading edge" roads had become quite advanced: Minos had tens of kilometers worth of roads which were not just paved but mortared, on thick subgrade, with side-drains and distinct shoulders, and anatolian roads had sidewalks.
- mrlonglong 6y agoAnd the Romans perfected the art of building long and straight roads, some of which still are in use today.
- TomMarius 6y agoMostly just the same place, though. Even the terrain around it is probably very different.
- samatman 6y agoAh yes, the Road of Theseus problem.
- mrlonglong 6y agoIs it the same road if it is renumbered ?
- soperj 6y ago
- kinghtown 6y agoI guess this is why Korean and Taiwanese fried chicken is the best.
- quicklime 6y agoI don't follow, Korea and Taiwan are not part of South-East Asia?
- kinghtown 6y agoI really need to read links before posting any comments. My bad. (Taiwan’s fried chicken is still really amazing.)
- ksaj 6y agoYes people should read the links before commenting, lest they end up sounding like capricious idiots. But this was in the title.
- kinghtown 6y agoDo you feel better after venting, little one?
- dang 6y agoPosting like this will get you banned here, so please don't. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the spirit of the site to heart, we'd be grateful.
- dang 6y agoPlease don't be a jerk on HN, regardless of what somebody else did or didn't read. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- lazylizard 6y ago
- sysrpl 6y agoWhy did the chicken cross the road? The next time someone asks you this question, you can give them the following answer. The question "Why did the chicken cross the road" is invalid. It is invalid because "why" assumes that the chicken had some reason for taking the action "cross the road". This, in turn, assumes that the chicken has the concept of "road"; after all, if the chicken doesn't know that the road is there, then the chicken did not - from the chickens point of view - cross the road, and consequently it is meaningless to ask for its motivations for doing so. Since chicken is an animal, it is unlikely that it has the concept of road in the same sense than humans do; since it is a bird, whose ancestors were propably capable of flight in the near past, it is unlikely to have the concept of road in any sense - why would a flying bird need roads? Therefore, the chicken can never have any motivation for crossing the road, since from the chickens point of view, it never does any such thing. It simply moves from one point to another, and these points happen to be on the opposite side of a flat area of ground. No road-crossing has happened. Think of it this way: if you walk over a scent trail left by some animal, and you don't know that the trail is there, it is foolish to ask your motives of crossing that trail. One can ask your motives for walking in the first place, but the crossing was pure coincidence and not something you chose.
- jameshart 6y agoTl;dr: to get to the other side
- 082349872349872 6y agoThe blood sport connection makes me wonder "when the chicken crossed the road[1], what was his entrance music?" "He's constantly confusing, confounding, won't throw the towel / Everyone give it up for America's favourite fighting fowl" [1] a "road" might also be a sea route, but it looks like land-based roads predate seaborne trade by several thousand years.
- baddox 6y ago> "why" assumes that the chicken had some reason for taking the action "cross the road". I don’t think so. It’s pretty normal to ask “why” questions about non-conscious entities. “Why does my stomach hurt?” “Why is the sky blue?” And so on.
- partyboat1586 6y agoThought this was an Onion headline at first.
- econcon 6y agoDoesn't it make sense that flying dragons fossils are often found in South East Asia so chickens appeared there?
- SeanLuke 6y agoI am confused. I thought it was long established that the chicken came from SE Asia. Why is this article a "landmark study"?
- ksaj 6y agoI just mentioned this article to my Vietnamese partner, and got a lengthy story about how the modern chicken came from SE Asian pheasants, which are often referred to as "jungle chickens," as taught 30+ years ago in primary school. So it's pretty clear that there are generations of children who were well aware of the connection, too. There must be something hidden in the details that would raise this study to the lofty level of "landmark."
- aspaceman 6y agoMaybe it provided genetic evidence for this human oral history? I would consider that landmark personally. Although writing an article about it is harder.
- pvaldes 6y agoThere are four species of Gallus. Only one, the red jungle fowl hens, became the mother of modern chicken, in several places at the same time, but the history is more complicated than that. Indonesian for example have an endemic species, the green one, and are fond of producing red+green hybrids for navigation at open sea [1]. Green is the oldest species and does not live in China. Then we have the chicken skin. Plucked chicken are typically yellow. Only a few chicken breeds have black skin, they are all black in fact, black beak, legs, caruncles, crest, inner organs and even black bones But when we think in a plucked modern chicken is yellow. This is because the grey species, from India, provided the yellow gene. Therefore all (or almost) chicken that you can buy in the market have indian blood. Grey (and Ceylon's wildfowl) are endemic from Indian continent. And any study that is not sampling this areas would be incomplete. The red was adapted to rainforest but is a species from bamboo cloud forests also in the mountains, so provided the cold resistance gene, and won in the battle being the easiest to breed. [1] Each rooster has a different song that is really loud and unique from this animal. People go fishing with their pet rooster and thus can locate the position of all other people easily even in dense fog or open sea.
- coderintherye 6y agoWow, rooster identification as sort of a "Marco-Polo" is rather ingenious.
- pvaldes 6y agoYes but this couldn't be done with the red. The green junglefowl is a mangrove species, so was particularly well suited for the fishermen lifestyle. It feeds on fishes, starfishes and marine animal's carcasses stranded in beaches and can survive without drinking freshwater for a longer time. Is perfect for long distance open sea travel and to colonize small isolate islands without permanent sources of freshwater Araucanas, ameraucanas and olive eggers have its blood. It provided the genes for blue and green eggs.
- pmcp 6y ago> and are fond of producing red+green hybrids for navigation at open sea TIL Indonesians breed roosters like Chocobos.
- fortran77 6y agoThe question isn't when. It's _why_.
- monadic2 6y agoI’m fairly sure this hypothesis predates Darwin.