7 ms·
Absolutely. I’ll note that nobody reposting Beto’s “we’re going to take your AR-15s!” line was blocked, even though I’m pretty sure Beto wasn’t planning on send
by rayiner 6y ago
Absolutely. I’ll note that nobody reposting Beto’s “we’re going to take your AR-15s!” line was blocked, even though I’m pretty sure Beto wasn’t planning on sending social workers to do the confiscation.
I’m not one of those “taxation is theft” people, but the state’s monopoly on violence is a real thing, and violence is implicit in every government law. When Warren proposed to create a wealth tax, implicit in that assertion is that the government would collect it from people by force if necessary.
Facebook’s policy on violence, applied to government speakers, is like people who eat meat being squeamish about hunting. Where do you think your food comes from? Likewise, what do you think is the basis for all these things you think the government should make people do?
- zozbot234 6y agoThe rationale for having a monopoly on violence is not "let's make people do stuff" because that would be, y'know, slavery. It's the obvious fact that the only alternative to a stable monopoly on violence is an all-out war, so a monopoly is very much the lesser evil. > When Warren proposed to create a wealth tax, implicit in that assertion is that the government would collect it from people by force if necessary. Strictly speaking, as a government, you won't need to collect a wealth tax by force. The government's monopoly on violence is inevitably bundled with provision of some privately-valuable services, such as managing and enforcing property rights. People selfishly want their rights to be enforced in a fair and predictable way, so they will find it in their interest to pay up.
- rayiner 6y agoI’m no anarchist, so I don’t disagree with that. But we shouldn’t forget that violent coercion is ultimately what makes the rule of law possible. I’m also no vegetarian, but for the same reason we shouldn’t forget that mass slaughter of animals makes steaks possible.
- smogcutter 6y agoThis is an argument that I think too often goes unexamined. Yes, the state obviously depends on a monopoly on violence to sustain itself, but that monopoly alone is not sufficient. After all, in order for the state to exercise violence, individual people need to agree to exert violence on the state’s behalf. The authority to deploy violence in a culturally sanctioned manner can’t come from violence itself. For people to agree that the state has the sole right to deploy violence, there must be a more fundamental source of legitimacy. For example, you could argue that the murder of the Gracchi was the beginning of the end for the Roman republic: once it became clear that the government was no longer playing by the rules and might really did make right, the republic’s legitimacy was fatally weakened. Before long you get a generation of civil war and the end of the republic.
- zozbot234 6y ago> For people to agree that the state has the sole right to deploy violence, there must be a more fundamental source of legitimacy. Having a stable monopoly on violence is generally in the involved parties' shared best interest, so a Schelling point (perhaps weighted by some expectation of shared future benefits) is as much of a source of "legitimacy" as anyone needs. When that process of agreeing on a single Schelling point fails due to excess ambiguity - well, then you might have some real trouble on your hands.
- smogcutter 6y agoAgreed, but an issue with a game theoretical explanation like that is it doesn’t account for the way that the kind of government people will agree on is highly culturally contingent. In other words it explains why people will get around to forming any government, but says little about how specific governments function (or fail to). To stick with Rome for example, it doesn’t explain why Augustus could rule as Princeps but would’ve lasted five minutes if he’d tried to rule as an eastern style despot. My real point, rather than trying to articulate a complete theory of statehood in some cockamamie HN post, is to push back against the common formulation that finds the source of state power in state violence. The real story is meaningfully more complex.
- danans 6y ago> Beto wasn’t planning on sending social workers to do the confiscation. No, but he needn't have sent people with guns at first. The first step in enforcing any law is just asking people to comply with it. The next step is putting fines on them. Only the last step involves the threat or at the very end, the use of force. Given the common attitudes of those who purchase and keep AR-15s, perhaps the chance of them complying with any future legal ban on assault weapons is small, but in that situation, by not complying they would be committing a criminal act. > if necessary. Yes, if necessary. A lot of issues we treat as law enforcement problems can be resolved without bringing violence into the picture, but that's only possible if the systems are set up that way that encourages non-violent intervention first. Unfortunately, our current law enforcement systems treat many situations as having a high probability of requiring violence.
- luckylion 6y ago> Only the last step involves the threat or at the very end, the use of force. The use of force is certainly the last step, but the threat of force is present at any step. If the government sends you a letter asking you to do something, they're not "asking" you like your neighbor or your friend might ask you. They are telling you to do something, and it's clear to everyone that, if you don't convince them or a court otherwise, they absolutely will use force if you don't comply. I don't mind the monopoly on violence (though I do believe that the state must enforce it much more: it can absolutely not tolerate challenges to that monopoly, and it must absolutely crush any violence against citizens), but it's not helpful to pretend that, there isn't a gun at the end of the line that gives the nicely worded letter its weight.
- danans 6y ago> but it's not helpful to pretend that, there isn't a gun at the end of the line that gives the nicely worded letter its weight. I also believe that the monopoly on violence is the least worst option we have for not having a society at war with itself. But it's also blindingly obvious that it is the backstop for everything, not just enforcing weapons bans, but even things as mundane as speed limits. When the sign says max speed 55mph, that's asking. When the highway patrol pulls you over to give you a ticket - that's fining you. If you don't stop and they need to run you off the road and arrest you - that's the violence stage. It's also sitting there behind every right we enjoy in free societies. Everything from property rights to civil rights are backstopped by the monopoly on violence. However, that doesn't mean we bring the visceral threat of violence into every property or civil rights dispute. Just as important as the underlying threat of the use of the monopoly on violence is the judicious and restrained use of it only in the cases where it truly is proportional to the situation it is facing. Otherwise we get situations like the murder of George Floyd for merely using a counterfeit bill for payment at a convenience store.
- _jal 6y ago> Facebook’s policy on violence, applied to government speakers, is like people who eat meat being squeamish about hunting Do you feel a cop's post threatening to beat the shit out of someone in a plausibly legal fashion stays up, but not that same post from a non-cop?
- obiye 6y agoThis is exactly how I felt when I was 16. Then I grew up.
- clusterfish 6y agoTake your content free one liners back to reddit please. If you have an actual argument, present it.
- obiye 6y agoNo, I think I will continue to point and laugh at idiots on this site. It’s fun and easy because everyone here thinks VERY highly of themselves. For proof see your own comment.
- tonyhb 6y agoAt no point was there ever a threat of force from Beto, especially not with armed police. Maybe you should read up on how the Australian government handled gun control: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_law_of_Australia#2017_National_Firearms_Amnesty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_law_of_Australia#2017_Nati... Hint: their campaign poster said "Now's the time to hand it in without penalty". You're comparing two very different things here - disingenuously. One in which the president _literally threatens force_, the other which says the government will take ownership of guns.
- rayiner 6y agoBeto said the government would “take” peoples’ guns. That word “take” (as opposed to all the other words he could have used, such as “buy back”) clearly was meant to emphasize the threat of government force. (Watch the video and substitute “buy back” for “take” and see if the tone still works.) The assertion relies, for its rhetoric effect, on the threat of government violence against lawbreakers.
- tonyhb 6y agoI disagree that the average person can genuinely believe that "take" is a strong word of force and should be banned from twitter. It's definitely not equal to "they'll be met with serious force" in terms of threat. This is the original point: "We'll take your guns" isn't inciting violence anywhere near the level that trump does. The comparison doesn't stand. If you can make that argument with a straight face, I take my hat off to you.
- rayiner 6y agoWatch the video: https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2019/09/13/beto-orourke-abc-news-democratic-debate-guns-ar15-orig-js.cnn/video/playlists/2020-democratic-debate-abc https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2019/09/13/beto-orourke-.... Listen to Beto’s tone and the crowd’s reaction. “Hell yes, we’ll [accept your AR-15 in a buy-back]” would not have had the same rhetorical impact because that’s not what he meant. The crowd cheered because they knew what he meant.
- SilasX 6y agoYes, there is an implicit asterisk in all of this about "state violence under the law is okay".
- three_seagrass 6y ago>I’m not one of those “taxation is theft" but I think a wealth tax is theft This comes across as wealth apologism. If a wealth tax is theft through a monopoly on violence, then all tax is theft through a monopoly on violence. Singularly applying this concept as a the negative of a wealth tax, while ignoring the rest of taxes, is biased towards the wealthy.
- rayiner 6y agoYour mistake is assuming that taking property through the threat of violence is theft. That’s incorrect. Theft is an illegal taking of property. Taxes are a legal taking of property. But collection of the wealth tax, like all taxes, is premised on the threat of violence. It’s legal violence towards a legal end, and therefore justified, but it’s still violence.
- majormajor 6y agoI think you are being disingenuous to equate something talking about a "we're going to change the law" with "will be met with serious force." Yes, the use of force is implicit in all law, but the other is a direct explicit threat of force. Is proposing any law a threat of force? They're all backed the same way.
- dx87 6y agoIsn't it a bit hypocritical for you to call them disingeneous when you had to use a fake quote to argue that it isn't as bad as what Trump said?
- georgeecollins 6y agoI think what is implied is the inciting of people to commit unlawful acts of violence.
- philistine 6y agoAn elected legislator is not the government in my mind. This whole personification of the government done by Americans puzzles me. Government holds the monopoly on violence, not Beto. He shouldn’t imply such a terrible thing.
- vageli 6y ago> An elected legislator is not the government in my mind. This whole personification of the government done by Americans puzzles me. Government holds the monopoly on violence, not Beto. He shouldn’t imply such a terrible thing. The government is comprised of people. Pointing to individual actors in that group seems sensible since "government" is not some autonomously system but a system composed of individuals who direct the actions of the group.
- newacct583 6y ago> I’ll note that nobody reposting Beto’s “we’re going to take your AR-15s!” line How about you quote that line instead of paraphrasing it (like the grandparent did for the Trump tweet), and you'll find that there are some significant differences between literally threatening violence and announcing a regulation policy entirely in line with existing policy and a ton of proposed legislation.
- baddox 6y agoIf the mayor of a small town threatens on Facebook to murder people, should that be left alone, since, after all, violence is what government does?
- philwelch 6y agoYes, because the public has a right to know that their mayor is threatening to murder them.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoTaking the threat itself down from Facebook in no way violates the public’s “right to know”.
- vageli 6y ago> Taking the threat itself down from Facebook in no way violates the public’s “right to know”. How can we even do journalism if we are deleting the sources quoted?
- philwelch 6y agoThat’s the insidious side of censorship. If you censor the original source, you can claim that the original source said literally anything.
- baddox 6y agoHow can we do journalism about things people say to journalists that aren’t even recorded?
- philwelch 6y agoYou can, but if you actually start from those recordings and then delete them and claim that it's too dangerous to publish actual evidence that somebody said X when journalists keep claiming that they said X, that's a little suspicious.
- wonnage 6y agoHow did a private company deciding to regulate speech, become a strawman about how all government is violence?
- barunio 6y agoBy your logic, a government official saying "you can not kill your neighbor" is inciting violence because there is an implicit threat of the use of force if you do not comply. A government official ever referencing the enforcement of any law would be inciting violence. Your interpretation of the phrase "inciting violence" is not remotely useful or common. Humans are not machines and language is not the same as computer code. There is social context implicit in the interpretation of the words we use.
- concordDance 6y agoIndeed there is such a social context. However it's very subculture specific. Something a person from culture A says might be interpretted as an incitement by someone from culture B even though people from culture A wouldn't read it that way. And if the deciders are chosen by culture B are using rules written by culture B and are from culture B themselves...