15 ms·
The largest city in each 10x10 degree latitude/longitude box
- mytailorisrich 6y agoGuangzhou is usually reported as larger than Shenzhen. A specific issue with the population of Chinese cities, though, is that the administrative 'city' division in China can be quite larger than what might be expected in the West.
- horsawlarway 6y agoa lot these are pretty bad representations of real population, even in the US. ex: Jacksonville is listed as the largest city in the southeast, and strictly speaking, this is true because it's a fairly dense population area. But it's a pretty misleading statement to say that it's the largest city. Jacksonville's metro population is only about 1.5 million. Atlanta is in the same box and Atlanta's metro population is nearly 4 times larger (5.9 million), Nashville also beats Jacksonville (1.9 million)
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoLies, Damned Lies, and Geographic Visualizations.
- markphip 6y agoI came to make the same comment. I was surprised to see that "technically" Jacksonville is nearly 2x larger than Atlanta but digging deeper it just seems about city borders. Jacksonville is pretty large and not that dense. Atlanta is pretty small and fairly dense. When you look at the metropolitan areas Atlanta is nearly 4x larger than Jacksonville metro area and that really just includes the area covered by MARTA so it is all pretty much "Atlanta".
- mc32 6y agoTo me that’s not misleading in that they count city proper rather than metro areas. Both have their places, but I wouldn’t say one is more misleading than the other. One is administrative and one is more demographic.
- ghaff 6y agoAnd they both go to show that statements/calculations about things like urban density are heavily influenced by historically and culturally determined political boundaries and definitions. Even look at the US Census Bureau 80% urban metric that a lot of people like to quote. Lots of small towns with farmlands and orchards (like where I live) are "urban" by this particular definition. And they are "urban" relative to truly rural Wyoming. But they're not urban in the sense of having any of the attributes of a dense city center.
- hpkuarg 6y agoThere must be a way to come up with an (almost) universally applicable metric of city-ness, regardless of the adminstrative boundaries, that can be applied to situations like this map. Something like, the area in which the population density is above a certain threshold, and the population that lives in that area.
- ghaff 6y agoFiveThirtyEight has done some work in that area for purposes of splitting urban/rural from a political perspective. The article also mentions a couple other examples of something similar. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-urban-or-rural-is-your-state-and-what-does-that-mean-for-the-2020-election/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-urban-or-rural-is-y...
- mc32 6y agoI agree with that. Lumping rural hamlets into urban definitions kind of muddies things. Urban, town, rural/agricultural, wilderness would add a bit more granularity and would give more conceptual fidelity.
- ghaff 6y agoAlthough it's often even messier than that. Look at the density of Manhattan vs. NYC as a whole. Or core Paris vs. Paris as a whole. Much less the many American cities with fairly dense but small downtowns but that sprawl far into the distance.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nathancahill 6y agoUsed to live on Baseline Rd. It originally split Nebraska Territory to the north and Kansas Territory to the south, originally surveyed in 1859. The Colorado territory wasn't formed until two years later in 1861. (Utah territory originally began somewhere in the Rockies beyond Boulder).
- pretendgeneer 6y agoI was surprised by Leonora, Western Australia being there with it's population of 556 [1], I tried to find a bigger town in the area but couldn't. I wonder if that is the smallest town on that map? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonora,_Western_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonora,_Western_Australia
- lb1lf 6y agoSounds plausible; I was just looking up a few of the eastern Siberian towns - Ust-Nera (143E, 64N or so) at 6,500 inhabitants, Bilibino (167E, 68N) - also home to the world's northernmost nuclear power plant, 6,000 inhabitants...) Closer to (my) home - Vardø (2,000) and Hammerfest (8,000) at the extreme north of Norway. Positively crowded!
- gbear605 6y agoThere’s Ittoqqortoormiit [1] on there too at a population of 452. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ittoqqortoormiit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ittoqqortoormiit
- caf 6y agoMejit in the Marshall Islands has a population of 348.
- cosminratiu 6y agoAlert in northern Canada has 62 permanent inhabitants, according to wikipedia [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alert,_Nunavut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alert,_Nunavut
- AMerrit 6y agoI had a friend who worked up in Alert while he was in the air force. It may be one of the most remote places on the map, it's essentially an out grown air force base/research station, there would be nothing there if not for the cold war.
- mikkom 6y agoTristan da Cunha - population: 246 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_da_Cunha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_da_Cunha
- Waterluvian 6y agoI love how this says something about the biases that exist in making legible maps. Toronto isn’t even shown. Any time to read a map, remember that at different scales, there’s an editorial opinion, whether direct or algorithmic, on what you see.
- chrisoverzero 6y agoIt’s not particularly biased to say that New York is larger than Toronto, in my opinion.
- allengeorge 6y agoI think the OP got confused - as I did - on the position of Toronto on the lakes. We both didn’t realize that Toronto is in the same box as New York.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI’m not confused. That’s my point. That Toronto is a big city and the rules defining how this map gets symbolized makes it invisible.
- jobigoud 6y agoIt's like saying Pluto is a big planet. It may be true but there is a bigger one nearby that make it invisible if your map is about the biggest in the neighborhood.
- manojlds 6y agoIsn't that the point of the map (show the most populous city in each box?) Or you didn't get what the map is trying to do?
- II2II 6y agoI suspect the point is that decisions are made whenever a map is constructed, and those decisions can produce wildly different views of the world. While some of those decisions are in some sense objective (e.g. the equator being 0 degrees latitude), others are purely arbitrary or historical (e.g. the definition of 0 degrees longitude). If that meridian had a different definition, the results would be quite different. Then there are decisions made by a particular map maker. As others have noted, small town and research stations at far northern and southern latitudes have disproportionate representation simply because the parameters (10 degrees of arc in latitude and longitude) divide a smaller area of the globe into the same number of bins as the much larger area of the globe at equatorial latitudes. This map is far more interesting in terms of what it tells us about intrinsic biases in mapping than in terms of what it tells us about the world.
- ghj 6y agoWhy are some empty ocean squares colored dark blue and some light blue? Does light blue mean there is some land mass there but it's uninhabited?
- gbear605 6y agoYes. That’s the concept I believe. I’m not sure how big a landmass had to be to make the map though.
- theandrewbailey 6y agoIt would be good if empty pieces of land were shaded differently, too.
- wahlis 6y agoThis could serve as a good example of how politicians manipulate voting areas to ensure majorities. The results are probably correct, but the result is misleading.
- hliyan 6y agoGerrymandering was the very first thing that popped into my head when I noticed the most populace city in my country lose out to what's basically a town because it ended up on a grid with another country's city. I nearly started a "that's clearly a mistake" comment before realizing what had happened.
- cmroanirgo 6y agoLol. Some of the Australian towns are rather small, showing how sparse our population is: Leonara: 2,476 Geraldton: 37,000 Mackay: 80,000
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bbsimonbb 6y agoGoogle gives Leonora pop 556, which to me is much more believable. There's nothing for 2k folk to do in Leonora.
- margiani 6y agoWhere is Saint Petersburg, Russia? It seems to be on the border of the boxes and might be in the same box with Helsinki (metro 1,495,271) or Minsk (metro 2,645,500). Saint Petersburg's population is 5,351,935.
- perpetualpatzer 6y agoIt's at 59.9, 30.4, which edges it into the Moscow box.
- tobr 6y agoThe 60°00'00.0"N, 30°00'00.0"E intersection is actually slightly northwest of Saint Petersburg, so it ends up in the same square as Moscow.
- chrismorgan 6y agoIn the text of the article: > What the heck happened to St. Petersburg? (at 59.938N, 30.309E, it is just barely inside the same box as Moscow. The map is quite distorted in this region.)
- allengeorge 6y agoI’m fairly sure Toronto is larger than Chicago... EDIT: Yeah, back in 2013: https://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2013/03/05/torontos_population_overtakes_chicago.html https://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2013/03/05/torontos_p... - and I’m pretty sure it’s almost at or crossed the 3M mark (COVID may have tossed a wrench in the latter). Ah. It’s because Toronto is in the same box as _New York_ - my bad!
- griffinkelly 6y agoChicago is having significant population loss, so that gap will only grow. I believe Houston is about to pass Chicago.
- hellofunk 6y agoWhy is Chicago losing people?
- tristor 6y agoMany reasons, but probably the biggest one is social shifts causing an overall degradation of city life resulting in people leaving. When the Chicago Board of Trade ended floor trading a significant amount of large finance companies moved elsewhere, some relocated to Dallas, some reduced staffing/office space and had principle officers in NYC already. There's a lot of conversations about cities in the Midwest simply not happening, even though critical decay is occurring. St. Louis is another example of a city where they were doing very well for awhile and had a strong aerospace/telecom/manufacturing/tech sector and the city has now decayed dramatically to the point many businesses have pulled out and crime rates have skyrocketed. St Louis and Chicago are both more dangerous cities than Detroit, and all the available evidence points to violence being primarily a socioeconomic issue rather than an issue of any other factors.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIf you’re looking for somewhere to invest, anywhere in the bottom of these lists will make it much harder to earn a decent ROI due to a higher taxes to government services ratio compared to places higher on the lists. Chicago unfortunately is at the bottom of both lists. https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/financial-state-of-the-states-2019 https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/financial-stat... https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/2020-financial-state-of-the-cities https://www.truthinaccounting.org/news/detail/2020-financial...
- foota 6y agoI think something more interesting might be like a voronoi diagram of all cities such that the city is in like the top 5 within a 1000 miles radius or something (or just that but without the voronoi part). This should preserve the fact that only the largest cities in some area are present, but eliminate the arbitrariness of the boundaries. I think you would want to compute this with a sweep line algorithm.
- incompatible 6y agoA map projection that preserves area would be better, otherwise there's an excessive number of cities in the far northern hemisphere, and a lack of detail in the tropics.
- toxik 6y agoMeanwhile, neither Sweden’s nor Norway’s capital is in the map. But two smaller Norwegian cities are. I think this just teaches you the issue with discretization.
- ewendel 6y agoThere are in fact five small Norwegian towns on this map. Vadsø, Hammerfest, Trondheim, Bergen and Longyearbyen.
- jononor 6y agoTrondheim and Bergen rank 3 and 2 in Norway (after the capital, Oslo). Some 200k people live in each. Not so small by scandinavian standards. But Vadsø, Hammerfest and Longyearbyen are tiny - population 2-12 thousand.
- runarberg 6y agoDenmark has a funnier case. There are 6 cities/town within the Kingdom of Denmark with 0 of them in Denmark. (5 in Greenland and 1 in The Faeroe Islands; Iceland belonging to the Kingdom until 1944 has 2)
- caf 6y agoI quibble with the description of the shapes bounded by 10 degrees of longitude and latitude as "rectangles" - they're not even planar shapes, and their adjacent sides certainly aren't at right angles. Some of them don't even have four sides. This bears considering when looking at the map, because some of those regions are much, much smaller than others.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NopeNotToday 6y agoHe's not making a mathematical definition of the areas. 'area' or 'box' is a simple description that everyone can understand. And the map projection used does form squares.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> And the map projection used does form squares. Some of those squares have zero-length edges.
- jtbayly 6y agoWhich is really cool. Also very confusing!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mjd 6y agoSince you want to quibble, I'll just point out that the word “rectangles” does not appear in the article.
- areyousure 6y agohttps://i.imgur.com/El0JhG0.png https://i.imgur.com/El0JhG0.png
- blueblisters 6y agoTIL Atlanta, GA has fewer people than Jacksonville, FL. The Atlanta metropolitan area has a lot more people.
- l72 6y agoThis is the problem with how we define cities. Jacksonville is technically the largest city in all of Florida too, but that is because it annexed almost all of its suburbs, so the whole "metro" area is just on city, which is quite different then most other American cities.
- js2 6y agoRight. Havana is more populous than Miami because it includes 15 municipalities, covering 728 km2. Miami is just Miami proper, which is 145 km2. But the Miami urban area is 2900 km2, and has 5.5M people which would be larger than Havana (2.1M people). Miami is much denser than Havana (4,299.7/km2 vs 2,892.0/km2). But that's besides the point I guess. Every map maker makes arbitrary choices. And it made me curious why some cities and not others.
- schnable 6y agoThis is also why Phoenix appears as one of the US's largest cities, while its metro area is significantly smaller than other cities that have a smaller population.
- AshleyGrant 6y agoJacksonville is the largest city by land area in the continental United States, not just Florida. https://web.archive.org/web/20021017211112/http://www.census.gov/statab/ccdb/cit1010r.txt https://web.archive.org/web/20021017211112/http://www.census...
- codeOnMaster 6y agoInteresting that a small country like Cuba has two cities in a square.
- jl6 6y agoI wonder if London could be the largest city in two boxes. The zero meridian line goes through Greenwich, which leaves most of London in the western box, but a still sizeable chunk of East London in the eastern box. Is East London bigger than Hamburg? Are there any other large cities that straddle the bounding boxes?
- sdflhasjd 6y agoAnd Hamburg at 10°E is also split, so really the question is: Is East London bigger than West Hamburg
- colourgarden 6y agoBrussels (c.1.2m) and Cologne (c.1.1m) are both in that box, I believe. It seems the population of the parts of Greater London east of the Meridian is something around one million[1] so it would be close. 1. https://www.citypopulation.de/en/uk/greaterlondon/ https://www.citypopulation.de/en/uk/greaterlondon/
- baud147258 6y agoThere's a typo in Port-aux-Français, the name on the map is missing an x.
- xwdv 6y agoWhat would be awesome is if you can take a grid like this and then drag it to create an offset and change in subtle ways what cities appear in the boxes. This could be the beginning of something like a gerrymandering tool.
- alexhutcheson 6y agoPretty interesting, but it suffers from a common flaw for this type of analysis - it counts the population that lives within the municipal boundaries of the city itself, not the population that lives within the "urban area" or commuting zone of that city. Different regions have different norms and laws for how they define municipal boundaries, so in some places the main municipality (e.g. Boston) is just a fraction of the urban core, while in other places the municipal boundaries include huge amounts of suburban and even rural land. Unless you're specifically interested in analyzing something related to municipal government, this isn't normally what you want to use to compare across regions. Jacksonville, FL is an extreme example of this. Jacksonville's municipal boundaries are huge - it covers 875 sq. miles[1]. This is ~1.85x the area of New York City[2], and 3.77x the area of San Francisco[3]. Within the US, it's preferable to use core-based statistical areas (CBSAs)[4] for this type of analysis. They're defined by commuting zones, and they're not sensitive to political boundaries except to the extent that political boundaries actually affect commuting patterns. If you want to limit yourself to the "dense" part of the metro area then you can use the Census-defined Urbanized Areas[5], but the definitions of those might not match your intuitions about what should be included. Assuming we use CBSA population, then the box that contains Jacksonville should instead have Atlanta, which has an CBSA population of ~5.8 million vs. only ~1.5 million in Jacksonville[5]. The statistical agencies for other countries have similar concepts. For Europe, Eurostat defines metropolitan regions[6], which have a similar definition. The OECD also maintains a data set of population by metropolitan area for OECD countries, although the methodology isn't consistent across all countries in that data set[7]. TL;DR - political and municipal boundaries aren't comparable across regions, use commuting zones or density-based region definitions instead. If you see Jacksonville, FL in a list of "biggest cities", it's always a red flag that they're using municipal boundaries. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacksonville,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacksonville,_Florida [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_york_city https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_york_city [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Core-based_statistical_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Core-based_statistical_area [5] https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/guidance/geo-areas/urban-rural/2010-urban-rural.html https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/guidance/g... [5] https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=United%20States&tid=ACSDT5Y2018.B01003&g=0100000US.310000&vintage=2018&hidePreview=true&tp=true&moe=false https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=United%20States&tid=A... [6] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/metropolitan-regions/data/database https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/metropolitan-regions/data/... [7] https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=CITIES https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=CITIES
- ppod 6y agoI think Dingle is bigger than and west of Clifden.
- mjd 6y agoDingle is bigger, and is in the same box. The article mentions this, but thanks for pointing it out. The author of the map is preparing a corrected version.
- bmmayer1 6y agoSeems like Malé, Maldives is missing in favor of Hithadhoo, a city 1/14th the size. Edit: Actually Kochi, India is in Malé's box. So that makes sense. Interesting mental gymnastics at play here!
- milkytron 6y agoInteresting map! What I found particularly interesting is that Fort Collins (in Colorado) was the largest city in it's block with a population of only 167k people. Just goes to show how sparsely populated that region is around Wyoming/Northern CO/Montana.
- curiousgal 6y agoIt's rapidly growing too!
- perrygeo 6y agoAnd a good example of why the 10 degree grid is arbitrary and meaningless - Denver is an hour south with a metro population in the millions. But it didn't make the arbitrary cutoff at 40N.
- oefrha 6y agoSpotted a factual mistake immediately: > There is a Chinese version of this. The Chinese cities on the map include the big Chinese cities: Shanghai, Beijing, Chongqing, Shenzhen, Chengdu. Shenyang. A couple of cities in Mongolia, analogous to the appearance of Winnipeg on the U.S. map. Baotou and Hohhot are both Inner Mongolian cities, i.e. Chinese cities.
- mjd 6y agoThank you for pointing this out. I will correct it. (edit: Fixed. Thanks again.)
- angleofrepose 6y agoUnless I'm missing something, this map might be pretty or impressive that it can be made, but it is entirely meaningless. Meaningless in that I don't know of significant meaning of breaking down the globe into 10° chunks whatsoever. This doesn't tell you anything about the cities shown, nor the area in which those cities exist. There is zero meaning in this map because no meaning can be derived from the filter process. The constraints have no relation to the data. The article is cool that it takes a dive into the "odder" boxes and finds a flaw or two. The author also recognizes the arbitrary nature of the map. I imagine that almost any other filtering would be more interesting to geek out over though. I am somewhat surprised by the popularity of this post here and on reddit, but then again that is sometimes how popularity works. The piece is presented well, just meaningless.
- mjd 6y agoNot everything needs to have utility. Some things are just for fun. Utility is important, but fun is important too.
- angleofrepose 6y agoThat's a fair point I respect. It does seem that it would be easy to have this fun in a way which is also useful, with literally any filtering system which had a relationship to the data. Equal work, equal fun, more than zero use.
- autokad 6y agoits an interesting problem. for the longest time, openstreetmap hid Philadelphia pretty much until you got down to the rooftop level and it annoyed the crap out of me. Its still not very good at what cities to show; Its a hard problem and I appreciate the article shining light on this issue.
- m3kw9 6y agoSo what’s the big deal of cities coincidentally aligning with one of his drawn lines?
- At1C 6y agoThe largest city in Canada as I remember is Edmonton the Capital of Alberta this is based on per Sq.M. just find that interesting trivia.
- adiM 6y agoInterestingly the most populous cities in Canada--Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal, are not there.
- vikramkr 6y agoA lot of comments about metros areas and the like, such as how Jacksonville shows up because of city limits being larger than atlanta, but if you start getting I to trying to define what a city's metro area is, you run into a lot of issues with giant powerful cities like NY. Can you really count the population of Newark, New Jersey as part of NYC, NY? Even though newark is firmly within the NYC metro area, it's a separate city in a different state with it's own government etc. And what do you do about the bay? Is San Francisco part of san Jose? What about twin cities, like dallas and fort worth? This probably makes the most sense as a way of doing this map since at least it's clear cut.
- frogpelt 6y agoJacksonville is the largest U.S. city by area, in the contiguous 48 states. Alaska has several cities with enormous boundaries. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...
- vikramkr 6y agoyes that's exactly what I'm referring to as the problem - the city limits are arbitrary administrative lines. What would not be counted in atlanta as simply part of the suburb would be counted towards the population of jacksonville because the boundaries just happen to be huge, which means jacksonville ends up larger than atlanta, even though more people are in the atlanta metro area and would call themselves as people from atlanta as there are people in the jacksonville metro area
- Gaelan 6y agoAs you get near the outskirts of a city, where you live starts to depend on who you're talking to. I live in Gig Harbor, Washington, which is about 20 minutes from Tacoma, which is itself about half an hour from Seattle. If I was talking to someone else from the area, I'd never claim to live in Seattle. But if I'm talking to someone from out of state, then yeah, sure, I'm from Seattle.
- 6y ago
- ronyfadel 6y agoI'm currently working on a project that involves dataviz & mapping, and one of the things I've discovered along the way was WikiData's SPARQL query engine. Mind = blown. You can basically ask Wiki(pedia) almost anything you can think of (including the largest city in a bounding box) using the same query language. Examples: - Largest cities per country (https://w.wiki/UC4 https://w.wiki/UC4) - Cities connected by the European route E40 (https://w.wiki/74E https://w.wiki/74E) - Streets in France named after a woman (https://w.wiki/34K https://w.wiki/34K)
- philshem 6y agoYou can even request a query from the community: https://wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Request_a_query https://wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Request_a_query
- ronyfadel 6y agoThat's handy! To be honest, SPARQL is definitely not easy to use.
- leipert 6y agoI have worked with SPARQL professionally. The biggest problem: Quality if the data. Yes it is amazing, but if stuff is missing annotations, it is hard to get meaningful results.
- Delk 6y agoLots of things in the semantic web and RDF realm suffer from that. The technologies and ideas have been largely built under the (probably implicit) assumption that the data can be made perfect, but it never is.
- chaps 6y agoThis was my experience also. It's bad enough that it's effectively useless and requires extensive validation.
- enjoyyourlife 6y agoNauru is not a city, it's a country. Its largest city is Denigomodu Tristan da Cunha also isn't a city. Though there is only one city there: Edinburgh of the Seven Seas
- allard 6y agoNiue isn't a city (nor village). It's a country.
- ivanche 6y agoAh, the famous country which has Pokemon, Disney, Star Wars etc. characters embossed at their national currency coins [1]. [1] https://www.procaffenation.com/niue-currency-cartoon-coins/ https://www.procaffenation.com/niue-currency-cartoon-coins/
- Aperocky 6y agoHow is Jacksonville larger than Atlanta?
- strictnein 6y agopop(Jacksonville) > pop(Atlanta) 903,889 > 498,044
- techbio 6y agoA geographically curious conceptualization of the random error in sampling artifacts.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoThis is not a good use case for the Mercator projection. Mercator sacrifices area accuracy to facilitate navigation.