19 ms·
Microsoft duplicates data from Firefox without asking
- numlock86 6y agoIs there actually any data being sent or shared from your device remotely or is it just copying/taking local data from one application to another application?
- dazhbog 6y agoWhy are we so powerless? So annoying that we cannot sue them out of existence.. ;(
- chrisseaton 6y agoSue them for... what?
- aloisdg 6y agosomething something linux. The more we are to jump, better the collaborative effort will be.
- spicymaki 6y agoIt would not surprise me that if by clicking on the EULA, you sign away the right to sue them.
- squarefoot 6y agoAFAICT That kind of agreement should be void for being one sided; not sure if it has ever been tested in court however.
- nitrogen 6y agoIIRC binding arbitration has been upheld by courts in the US.
- colejohnson66 6y agoThe supposed reasoning being: it’s in the contract that you willingly agreed to. You could’ve not paid for and installed Windows, but you did, then agreed to the EULA. So you’re out of luck. It’s a perversion if what a contract is supposed to be: negotiable, but it’s what it is right now.
- dependenttypes 6y agoIs this not what chrom(ium?) has been doing since the very start (at least on windows)?
- mox1 6y agothis happened to me last night. I never asked to install Edge, it was part of some automatic windows update. Immediately after reboot, Edge goes fullscreen and pops up a unclosable modal window. It also puts an icon on the desktop and pinned itself to the start menu. Attempting to remove Edge via powershell results in errors and warnings about it being a required system component. So...a bit more than chrome.
- rantwasp 6y agoinsert meme i live here now
- de_watcher 6y agoCan we start requiring legally tracing of the origin of these decisions? Someone has decided that. Why can't we have a name?
- rasz 6y agoOrigin was somewhere around this 1989 email: "You never sent me a response on the question of what things an app [application] would do that would make it run with MSDOS and not run with DR-DOS," ... "Is there [sic] feature they have that might get in our way?" and 1992 one: "What the [user] is supposed to do is feel uncomfortable, and when he has bugs, suspect that the problem is DR-DOS and then go out to buy MS-DOS,"
- dependenttypes 6y agoMicrosoft did, petition to them to change their policy. Or... use a system that does not treat you like the product.
- catalogia 6y ago> [Edge] being a required system component. This sounds.. familiar.
- Santosh83 6y agoCompanies seem to follow a standard rulebook for these things. Do something flagrantly invasive and outrageous, wait for the inevitable backlash and then back down on a few of the minor points which is also great opportunity for PR to say how much they care about your privacy, and when the dust settles, they've gained a little more ground against user control of their device.
- switch007 6y agoIt's the exact same rulebook of politicians. It's so obvious I don't know how they get away with it, but they have done for a very, very long time!
- inetknght 6y agoPoliticians cloak it in the idea of "compromise". Ask for more than what you want and then negotiate to some middle ground. Playing that game isn't a good faith negotiation.
- squarefoot 6y ago"Ask for more than what you want and then negotiate to some middle ground." Very common practice in politics which serves both sides (assuming the most common 2 main parties context) as both of them can tell voters they accomplished part of their goal after hard fighting.
- Silhouette 6y agoPlaying that game isn't a good faith negotiation. What you described is how almost all negotiation is done, in good faith or otherwise. But it's only a negotiation if both parties can propose changes and, if they don't like the deal, walk away.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoHistorically I've minimized the use of Windows 10 on my home network, because of Microsoft's history regarding privacy and spyware. Lately, however, I've considered letting Windows 10 run in a fairly locked down VM, so my family can use some apps and games that don't function well in Wine/Proton. I reckoned that the combination of VM isolation, and limiting Windows 10's internet access to a handful of whitelisted domains, is a reasonable compromise. I.e., I had a technical solution to a technical problem. But this news story reminds me of another reason to keep Microsoft out of my network: they piss me off. Regardless of whether or not I'm currently ahead of them in the arms race. I don't want to reward Microsoft with even one more installation, and I don't want to be perpetually pissed off about something on my network. I crave Schadenfreude for everyone who conspired on this. (Yes, I realize this sounds like the backstory for the least-compelling super-villain character ever.)
- Jonnax 6y agoI'm so curious. Why do you care so much about Microsoft telemetry? What data do you think they will exfiltrate that's so important that you go through the effort of setting of VMs and whitelisting? Do you ban your family from using social media as well due to data collection?
- cycloptic 6y agoIf it's really not that important then perhaps they could afford to stop doing it?
- speeder 6y agoI am not OP. But an example that I once used to explain to my wife why I don't trust TikTok and whatnot: Some time ago (I obviously won't say when) we interacted with a person, that had a bounty on his head, setup by Boko Haram, and people DID tried to kill him before. What if for example we had filmed him and that information leaked or got intercepted? Me, and my wife, have no enemies, done nothing illegal, and so on, nothing to hide personally, but about other people we interact with? What if some day a friend on internet, maybe a gaming buddy, tells me a important secret out of the blue because he needs urgent help, and that secret gets intercepted?
- dx87 6y agoInteresting info from that thread. Apparently if you follow through the entire setup, it asks what you'd like to import, but if you go through the task manager and force close it, then it automatically imports everything without your consent.
- jimbob45 6y ago>It unsets your default browser, so next time you click a URL from a shortcut, you'll have to re-choose your default browser. Isn’t this exactly the kind of thing that would bring their hallmark antitrust case back to life?
- jjoonathan 6y agoOne can hope. I personally suspect Microsoft will argue that reverting certain system settings to defaults every update is SOP because they've been doing it elsewhere. For example: sound settings. My physical Bose headphones show up as 2 different logical bluetooth headphones, one with sound that sucks, and one with sound that doesn't suck. Whenever Windows chooses the one with sound that sucks, I go into sound settings and disable it. This prevents sucky audio for a few months until an update lands, the sound settings get reverted, and the sucky audio returns. Ugh.
- nitrogen 6y agoDoes your microphone work in the stereo hq audio case? On my headphones the mic only works in the crappy audio mode. Maybe they are trying to "fix" Cortana by un-disabling the bt interface that has a mic? Idk
- jjoonathan 6y agoYes, that's why it happens, but it doesn't make it less obnoxious. It's obnoxious that Microsoft periodically breaks my audio and it's doubly obnoxious that some designer at Bose thought that trading away a physical button for this two-bluetooth-endpoint nonsense was a UX win (or, cynically, a portfolio win). The fact that I've been able to figure out what's going on and am therefore able to work around the problem with only minor inconvenience is neither here nor there. Most users with the same setup will not be in a position to understand or do anything about the problem. Microsoft will degrade their audio, and they will live with it. Same with Edge.
- boardwaalk 6y agoMy speakers connected via HDMI and monitors w/ HDMI audio did something similar. It seemed like I got duplicate audio devices, depending on which port I used (DisplayPort or HDMI, via an adapter cable or not). The audio driver seemed to get so confused with this it just stopped working. I had to unprotect a deep registry entry and clear out my audio devices, at which time the relevant entries came back after a reboot. Any normal user would have been stuck with reinstalling. It’s quite amazing how many “edges” Windows still has. I’m very close to figuring out how I can have a Windows VM w/ graphics card passthrough just for games on top of Linux. It might have warts too, but at least I can fix it.
- typingmonkey 6y agoWhen Bing was released they did a similar thing with copying search results from the users browser to their servers.
- dane-pgp 6y agoThe people downvoting you perhaps didn't know about this: https://www.wired.com/2011/02/bing-copies-google/ https://www.wired.com/2011/02/bing-copies-google/
- speeder 6y agoThis is another reason I avoid Win10 on my personal machine like the plague. People just don't get it. For example Cyberpunk 2077 has no official mininum requeriments listed for PC yet, and I noticed in their official forums a couple people are asking if it will support Win7, a lot of people replied to these questions along the lines: "Of course not you loser, Win7 support from MS ended, noone is going to be retarded and support a game that uses Win7" and this just makes me sad. I really hope Linux will "take off" before I am actually forced to ditch Win7.
- Zhyl 6y agoIf you can put as much weight on Linux as possible, that will help it happen. We've made massive strides in the last 2 years, but we need everyone who is Win7 Main to at least run Linux for some games to get used to the differences and to get the numbers up. This will help bolster the efforts of all those who are switching from 'some usage -> dual booting', 'dual booting -> Linux main' and 'Linux main -> leading edge'. If all take one step forwards then overall the scales start to tip!
- speeder 6y agoAt home currently I run my machine by default on Win7 and my wife machine by default on Ubuntu (I prefer Fedora but... it is her machine, not mine). Often we play games with each other and whatnot. But it is still obvious Linux is behind in some senses. 1. Some interfaces are just awful, Ubuntu default one took me ages to figure how to type addresses on the file explorer thingy it has (seemly you have to type Control+G or something). 2. If you use nVidia, you are screwed, nVidia drivers just suck. 3. Often even native linux games do weird unexpected things, like refusing to close, and the kill interface on Linux is generally awfull, it is hard to track why the hell the game just doesn't close, my wife reboots her computer much more often than me because of something going wrong with a game and make the system go into a weird state of some kind. 4. Installing wine and whatnot is a pain, for example when I tried to install Magic Arena I ended somehow, with many, many copies of wine on the system, and NONE worked. There are multiple game launchers and wine wrappers too, all of them trying to fix this issue, and none of them succeed completely.
- 1656450391 6y agoWhat a depressing time to be alive. The end of privacy, police brutality, dysfunctional dystopian governments, fascism on the rise, and tech companies brainwashing everyone so they can get away with dehumanizing everyone in the name of profits. Also massive inequality, rising productivity, declining real wages, increased debt, global warming, and a complete lack of opportunity for most people.
- salmon30salmon 6y agoDon't be so glum. We can travel across the world in a day. We have medical treatments for diseases that would have killed millions a year 75 years ago. We can communicate openly and freely with people all over the world. We can go to motherfucking space! The world is more at peace right now than any other time in recorded history. The power of religion to control people has slowly degraded away. What a time to be alive!
- na85 6y ago>We can travel across the world in a day. Damaging the fragile environment in so doing. >We have medical treatments for diseases that would have killed millions a year 75 years ago. Thus exacerbating global overpopulation and all the problems this causes >We can communicate openly and freely with people all over the world. Not for much longer. There's a push everywhere to centralize communications into silos owned by tech giants with zero accountability. How many times have I seen on HN that "email is deprecated" and the way of the future is to just buy into $proprietary_messenger that the user happens to work for? >We can go to motherfucking space! If you're a CEO, sure. The privileged overclass enjoys many perks as a consequence of its dominance. >The world is more at peace right now than any other time in recorded history. The power of religion to control people has slowly degraded away. Replaced by massive media and tech corporations controlling public discourse via social media, the new opiate of the masses, and fomenting identity politics to stave off the realization of class consciousness. We live in a corporate dystopia.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago
- rkagerer 6y agoAs if I needed more reasons to avoid Windows 10. The level of user hostility emergent from this OS is absurd. The shame is I want to love it. The engineers made some great improvements under the hood. But the product decisions are a disaster. It's like an out of control dog with an owner that just doesn't care, who shits in the middle of your meticulously maintained PC and pisses your privacy all over the neighborhood.
- stinos 6y agoThe engineers made some great improvements under the hood. But the product decisions are a disaster. This would be a good reply anytime someone goes the generalist 'Microsoft does this and that and that and that and it's all bad' way. I've always found it somewhat strange how many people don't seem to realize there's x different divisions within Microsoft, and that's it's somewhat unfair to call all of it crap just because some lame in-your-face management-crap. Not that the latter is acceptable, but as you say: other divisions have been doing some neat things for the past decades..
- uoaei 6y agoYou sound like a lower-level Microsoft employee who took a generalization personally.
- stinos 6y agoMight be because I can vividly imagine there are many of those. I.e. suppose you're doing nice work on improving VScode (just to name a well known thing) and then another unrelated part of your company does stupid things like this and then you get associated with it. That just sucks. Like when you use a linux shell for your day-to-day work and others are all like 'linux is completely not ready for the desktop, linux sucks'. I guess I just don't like generalizations.
- dang 6y agoPersonal attacks are not ok. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful.
- jedieaston 6y agoAs usual, there is a way to disable this if you can apply GPO or registry tweaks. GPO: After installing[0] the Edge Group Policies (because of course they aren't included with the installer!), set the "Automatically import another browser's data and settings at first run" policy to "4: Disables automatic import, and the import section of the first-run experience is skipped". This works on any version of Windows 7 or later. Note that if you already enabled the "Hide first-run" policy, Edge will take it upon itself to import from the user's default browser anyway without asking, so you'll still have to set the other policy as well. Registry: Go to Computer\HKEY_CURRENT_USER\SOFTWARE\Policies\Microsoft\Edge, create a new DWORD called "AutoImportAtFirstRun", and set it to 4. Auto import will not happen when Edge (Chromium) is launched for the first time, and you won't be asked about it during setup.[1] If you want to disable the first-run wizard entirely, create another DWORD called "HideFirstRunExperience", and set it to 1. If you've already opened Edge (as described in the article), these policies being applied will not clear your browser of already imported data. You'll have to delete your Edge profile (edge://settings, -> profiles, delete) to get rid of it. If you haven't installed Edge, note that new Edge becomes mandatory in version 20H2, so you'll want to set the policy now before you get overtaken after a system update. Guess this is another thing to add to the "new-install checklist"... 0: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/configure-microsoft-edge https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/configure-micros... 1: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/microsoft-edge-policies#autoimportatfirstrun https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/microsoft-edge-p...
- unnouinceput 6y agoI don't get it. What happened and when? I am running Win10 on all my computers in my house and none of these happened to me. On the other hand I don't run an online but local account and I've disabled Win10 all crap by using WPD.
- orev 6y agoFor all the people who keep fawning of how Microsoft is now such a wonderful friend of open source, how this is not the Microsoft of 10 years ago, blah blah blah, THIS is why the old timers don’t trust them. THIS kind of behavior is what we expect from Microsoft, and is exactly why we have long memories and distrust of them, including all their new seemingly open initiatives.
- notriddle 6y agoSo who would you trust more? Red Hat? Apple? Mozilla? Independent developers? DuckDuckGo? Your government? Yourself? All of them will betray your trust, either through maliciousness or incompetence. All major Linux distributions ship Firefox as the preferred default browser, which would be considered spyware if it were held to the same standards that Microsoft is held to. And even if they didn't, odds are you'll screw something up and get hacked (nobody, not even DJB, is perfect). If you really want privacy, don't use a computer.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhy is Firefox spyware?
- Tsarbomb 6y agoBecause it too collects telemetry data.
- notriddle 6y agohttps://spyware.neocities.org/articles/firefox.html https://spyware.neocities.org/articles/firefox.html
- franga2000 6y agoSorry, but I couldn't help but laugh the whole time reading this. The vast majority of these things are bullshit. - portal detection is a plain GET request - no actual data is sent - Google Analytics is used on Mozilla Web pages, not Firefox itself - default search engines are meaningless, as you can pick which one to use and not even suggestions are requested without opt-in - FHR I believe is still opt-in and also contains no PII - Pocket does absolutely nothing unless you manually register and log in - Auto updates are only on Mac and Windows, but if you're using either of those, you really can't complain here That site is a good resource, but it is extremely exaggerating the situation - and that's not ok. Once you label Firefox as "spyware level HIGH", what do you call something like Windows 10? Firefox has a few opt-out points of telemetry that share no PII and aren't correlatable by design, whereas Windows 10 has no opt-out and automatically sends everything from local search queries to full binaries back to the mothership. Saying everything is bad isn't helping anyone. We need to work on getting people off the things that actually violate their privacy (Windows, most Google products, FB, Web trackers...) and only then start working on improving the lesser offenders.
- k0stas 6y agoThe title should be updated to "Microsoft Edge copies user data from Firefox without asking". The current title is ambiguous: "Windows duplicates data from Firefox without asking". The fact that this is user data is an important distinction. Also, the word duplicates has a sense of having a purpose of redundancy, which is not the case here.
- ketzu 6y agoIf I get it right, the title could as well be "new edge automatically imports user data from Firefox"
- pierrebai 6y agoThe correct title should actually be "Edge imports Firefox data if you say yes when it asks you". Because that is what is happening. The article on Reddit is just wrong.
- keithnz 6y agoI think its more complicated because it happens if you try to avoid the getting started screen (by terminating it) where it does ask you, if you just answer the questions, then it seems it doesn't import.
- maest 6y agoI found it particularly jarring the this pushy behaviour is present on Windows10 Pro as well, which is supposed to be a "for business" edition of Windows.
- albertsondev 6y agoPro is still primarily targeted towards individual users, albeit as a "productivity-focused" version. Businesses are mostly targeted by Enterprise, and they (along with educators) are the only customers for whom MS generally avoids mucking with established configs.
- slezyr 6y agoGood old Microsoft in the brand new PR wrap.
- walrus01 6y agoQuoting the top comment there, this is egregiously blunt: "I was immediately annoyed at how invasive this. I'm a software developer so I'm sensitive to these sort of UI tricks. What MS has done this time: Hit the user with a maximized Edge, with a modal roadblock window that only has one button that says "Get Started" No option to get rid of the window, you cannot close Edge with the mouse and you cannot escape the modal window. The only option if you don't want to "Get started" is to use task manager to kill it Even when you do, it pins itself to your task bar It puts an Edge icon on your desktop It unsets your default browser, so next time you click a URL from a shortcut, you'll have to re-choose your default browser. Apparently it ingests data from other browsers without your permission Your parents and grand parents are probably using Edge now. They didn't mean to, they just couldn't seem to get it out of the way unless they agreed to "Get Started"."
- mkl 6y agoI don't see anything egregious about the bluntness. It seems entirely appropriate.
- FBISurveillance 6y agoI'm not saying it's OK, but if you open Safari for the first time after using Chrome, it will import Bookmarks and History without asking for permission.
- rasz 6y agoGuess $700 million (1) is simply too cheap a price for directly marketing your product to 1 billion (2) users 1 https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-fined-731m-by-eu-in-browser-choice-screw-up/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-fined-731m-by-eu-in-... 2 https://venturebeat.com/2020/03/16/windows-10-now-runs-on-1-billion-devices/ https://venturebeat.com/2020/03/16/windows-10-now-runs-on-1-...
- avery42 6y agoUnfortunately people's solution to this will be "edit this registry value" or "use this tool that disables it", just like with telemetry, instead of dropping this user-hostile data collection system off the face of the planet. But it's OK - Microsoft <3 open-source :)
- techntoke 6y agoSo much that they use their proprietary OS to collect information about users in order to exploit them.
- zzo38computer 6y agoReading that, it does seem like it is bad, but at least Microsoft has documented a registry setting to disable this feature. Still, that doesn't excuse most of the bad stuff they have done with this, and otherwise with Windows 10, even if they have made a few good improvements too.
- techntoke 6y agoThis behavior is predatory. Microsoft is inherently a racist organization because they choose profit over doing the right thing. If they were serious about caring about racism they would have open sourced Windows, but they are too afraid of losing money to care that much. You don't get a lot of quality education content and software when you install Windows, but you do get Candy Crush with microtransactions.
- orra 6y agoThis sounds dodgy as hell. Surely incompatible with GDPR: processing personal information despite an explicit rejection by the user.
- mirimir 6y agoI just went through this with a Win10 box, and had no problems with declining migration from Firefox to Edge. And when I open Edge, I see no personalization.
- tilolebo 6y agoSame for me. I fired up Edge, it asked about migrating from Firefox, I declined and that was it...
- hyperman1 6y agoAt this point, every ms customer should stop complaining. MS knows what you think about it, and ignores you. Look at your options rationally: You can chose to live with it and bitch. Sorry, dont expect anyone to care, you preferred it over the alternatives. You can mess with the registry/ group policy/ whatever. It will take you a few hours, and in a few weeks you'll have to do it again. You'll never be in the lead. If that's your choice, so be it, but be honest: you wanted this more than any alternative. You can go to linux. Things will be better, but not perfect, and there will be an uncomfortable learning curve of a few weeks. Bonus points if you reclaim the money for the license. More bonus points if you give some money to the linux ecosystem. You can go to OSX, and deal with the walled garden. Life will be good, as long as you can live with whatever apple thinks is best. You can contact local politicians, consumer groups, etc... You can sue microsoft. Really. Especially in the EU, if you thoroughly do your homework, you have a reasonable chance of winning. Somebody complained about seeing the license only after having paid for windows, sued and won. After that ms printed the url to the license on all their EU windows boxes. You can contact ms support and complain. They will notice if their decisions make their support costs raise. Each non ms option causes some short term discomfort, but each small drop eventually wears down a mountain. Make your choice and live with it.
- agent3bood 6y ago> You can go to linux. Things will be better, but not perfect A lot of people say Linux is not perfect or it is not as good as windows or mac. I have used all three operating systems and all of them are not perfect, Linux may be the best among them for a software engineer.
- whateveracct 6y agoWith Linux, at least it's easy to fix things myself. Doubly so for NixOS which is especially hackable. The UX is atrocious and you don't get the network effects of the mainstream though.
- YetAnotherNick 6y ago
- pseudosavant 6y agoAm I the only one who actually clicked through the link and is confused? It looks like a rant thread, with no specific information or links to blog posts, against Windows 10. I was expecting to get a link to a blog post, tweet, etc that showed specifically what MS is doing, with I don't know, some proof or facts? It doesn't seem like any of the HN commenters have clicked through; I know shocking... All it is is some text that says: Are we going to get treated to spam popups advertising Edge and having it duplicate our data from Firefox without asking every time Microsoft decides to update it from now on? Love rebooting my computer to get treated to a forced tour of a browser I'm not going to use that I have to force close through the task manager to escape, and then finding out it's been copying over my data from Firefox without permission.
- ShamelessC 6y agoSame here. Surprised so many people have commented on this without questioning the veracity of the claim. Specifically, the claim that it is importing your firefox data without you giving it permission. It's not that I have trouble believing this. It's definitely something they might do. But when did some random redditor become a reliable source? Christ, people.
- 0-_-0 6y agoFor what it's worth, I just updated my Windows 10 install and all that changed was a new Edge icon appearing on the desktop, that's it. When I clicked it I had the option to load settings from Firefox which I declined. It didn't set itself as the default browser (maybe there was a prompt about it but I don't remember), but it did get pinned to the taskbar, which I now removed.
- LockAndLol 6y agoI mean, honestly... you're using Windows. This kind of behavior shouldn't even come as a surprise, but should be expected. The longer you stay on it, the longer you're tacitly supporting those kind of decisions. If I went to a restaurant and they kept bringing me something I didn't order, I wouldn't go there anymore.
- ragnese 6y agoDon't know why you're being down voted. There is absolutely nothing that Windows 10 can do to its users' privacy or nonconsent that will surprise me.
- _bxg1 6y agoYour user files for one program are never "private" from any other program running on your computer. This is the security model of the desktop OS. It's not specific to Windows. It may be presumptuous - offensive, even - for Microsoft to do this from a UX standpoint, but there's nothing new here. There was no breach of protocol, Microsoft wasn't abusing its privileged position. Any program on your PC could do this at any time. We shouldn't act surprised.
- MrDresden 6y agoAs someone who only runs a win10 instance for gaming, while using Linux for all other aspects of my computing, I am honestly now thinking about giving PC gaming up just so I can stop having to deal with M$ and their practices. And before it is mentioned; I do realize I can play on Linux, but frankly I dont feel like sysadmining every time I want some escapism.
- fartcannon 6y agoSteam handles all that now. You literally dont have to do anything special for an ever increasing number of new games. The method of installation is the same as on windows: Click install and wait.
- MrDresden 6y agoIt has admittedly been some time since I last gave it a go. In my memory I had wasted hours tweaking graphical drivers and game configs to get a game working, before finally giving up.
- fartcannon 6y agoyes, neither of those things have been issues in ages.
- MrDresden 6y agoSo I just had some free time today to look into the state of Steam gaming on Linux. And my mind is blown! Between Proton and Vulcan it couldn't be easier and more stable. I might just toss my Windows partition overboard in due time.
- deadbunny 6y agoAs has already been said this isn't an issue these days. Pretty much the only games which don't work these days are games that require anti cheat software (though some progress is being made on this) or games with really bad DRM which are few and far between the days. This week alone I've managed to play Titanfall 2, Doom Eternal, Elite Dangerous (with full HOTAS and VR support), and Some sniper game I picked up for a couple of quid. All Windows titles with no Linux support. I only needed to "fix" one (TF2) to get working but that was a weird tiling window manager and Origin bug which was fixed with 2 minutes of Gooling and a single line of config for my WM. Valve have knocked it out if the park with Proton (as well as the community of course) and 99% of things "just work". If you're unsure if your favourite games will work check protondb.com and have a search.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoMicrosoft was, is and will always be a company doing shady shit to catch up with their competitors. https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2011/02/microsofts-bing-uses-google-search.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2011/02/microsofts-bing-uses...
- shultays 6y agoI dont remember it resetting default browser back to edge. I remember the update, edge popup, it putting edge shortcut to taskbar but firefox was still my default browser.
- simonblack 6y agoMicrosoft is that proverbial leopard. It never changes its spots.
- factchecker01 6y agoPeople are nuts, they are making another browser accessible if Firefox/Chrome stop working.
- k__ 6y agoMy Windows 10 even tried to sell me the new Edge as Chrome. Somehow it displayed the Chrome logo when it started automatically and it had all my Firefox bookmarks. Right after an update. Was really scary.
- grawprog 6y agoWow, it's almost as though Microsoft has been spending the last couple years trying to gain what they thought was enough good pr to allow them to just brazenly start openly pulling all their old bullshit again and expect it to be ok because, they gave people a powershell, the linux subsystem, 'open sourced' some of their software and bought github...who woulda ever guessed.
- saltedonion 6y agoSo Microsoft no longer has a strong foothold in the browser market and shit like this is no longer considered anti-competitive?
- bsznjyewgd 6y agoThe title is misleading. The Edge popup asks you if you want to import data from other browsers and set the default browser (like what happens when any browser is installed). If you just press cancel a bunch of times nothing gets imported or defaults changed and only some icons get added. That dude just killed it in the task manager so it used the popup's default settings. Complain about getting the chromified Edge popup as part of a regular update, not about it copying data.
- Dylan16807 6y agoIf you do nothing, it copies your data. That is unacceptable, and the title is not misleading.
- bsznjyewgd 6y agoNo, that guy didn't "do nothing". He killed it in task explorer instead of just pressing no.
- Dylan16807 6y agoYou shouldn't have to do that. And it disables the normal close button. What if you reboot without engaging with this weird unclosable window? What if you lose power? That's not agreement to the terms! When you have a dialog to choose between yes and no, it is not acceptable to copy data without 'yes' being clicked. Justification about "they didn't 'just press no'" is not okay. He did nothing in terms of giving the program any kind of input.
- masswerk 6y ago"Do nothing" doesn't imply consent by any means. Exiting (killing) a forced onboarding process must be an option and doesn't imply any consent, as well. Like "do nothing", the clear intent is to not to alter the status quo. Default settings can't imply consent. There's no contract, no grant, no entitlement for any subsequent actions. (The EU GDPR made this quite clear on a legal level.)
- fomine3 6y agoIIRC Chromium-based Edge imports not only bookmarks but also Cookies from Google Chrome that's surprising (and convenient) for me. Anyone know details?
- anonymousiam 6y agoMaybe this is a little off-topic, but has anyone else noticed that the Microsoft Teams browser interface works a lot better with Chrome than it does with Edge? Aside from the curious behavior where Teams meetings open in a browser, then either the native Teams app or another browser depending on which "Teams" ecosystem your meeting originated, if you open the Teams browser interface in Edge, you cannot share your desktop or present files. If you open in Chrome, you can do these things. Go figure...
- l0b0 6y agoIs there an idiot-proof way to set up a Windows 10 VM with good performance these days? I play computer games. Because maybe 30% or so of the games I play work badly or terribly in Linux (anything from screen tear to crashing on startup) I have a licensed copy of Windows 10. I tried setting up a KVM / QEMU-based VM with GPU passthrough, but apparently Windows detected it because it locked up (somehow, I don't remember the details) after I entered the license key, and I ended up having to dual-boot.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoDo you by any chance have an Nvidia gpu? Nvidia doesn't like people passing through their consumer grade gpus to VMs and blocks those. You can however enable a "hiding" mode so it works regardless. Maybe have a look at the Archwiki about OVMF Passthrough That's how I got it to work.
- l0b0 6y agoYes, it's cursed Nvidia. Thanks for the tip, I'll try that out! Edit: Yeah, not exactly idiot-proof. Without a simple list of commands it'll probably take a couple hours just to establish beyond a doubt that my hardware even fits the prerequisites.