7 ms·
The Sidney Harbor Tunnel had a similar problem. They came up with an elaborate but successful solution.[1] There are detectors and huge flashing warning signs t
by Animats 6y ago
The Sidney Harbor Tunnel had a similar problem. They came up with an elaborate but successful solution.[1] There are detectors and huge flashing warning signs that light up. Then, there's the last-chance sign. At the entrance to the tunnel, pumps force a curtain of water straight down across the entire roadway. Then a powerful laser system projects a giant octagonal red STOP sign onto the water curtain, filling the entire height of the tunnel opening. That's in addition to the six red traffic lights, flashing red Xs above each lane, and a big STOP with a flashing frame above the tunnel mouth.
That was expensive, but after someone wedged an oversized truck into the tunnel, blocking it for three weeks, it was worth it. Gets tripped about 18 times a year.
[1] https://youtu.be/pRKA7m-tbqM https://youtu.be/pRKA7m-tbqM
- gobins 6y agoThis is the first time I am hearing about this. Very elaborate but I guess it’s worth it.
- Invictus0 6y agoWhy cant they put a swinging bar at the tunnel height some distance before the tunnel? The bar knocks the top of the truck and wakes up whoever is driving to the fact that the truck is too tall.
- fouc 6y agoThis sounds like the perfect solution, a few swinging bars, thin enough not to knock something over but enough to make a loud banging noise.
- mc32 6y agoJust like the ones at parking garage entrances...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- loeg 6y agoOr a wedge barrier: https://eci-illinois.com/wedge-barrier-versus-medium-size-truck-wedge-barrier-wins/ https://eci-illinois.com/wedge-barrier-versus-medium-size-tr...
- notatoad 6y agoi think the point is to prevent damage to trucks, not to completely destroy them
- loeg 6y agoFor a major tunnel like this, you'd rather prevent damage / long-term obstruction of the tunnel.
- closeparen 6y agoA technology meant to kill suicide bombers might be a little much for that.
- lifeformed 6y agoWell, you'll kill the occupants instead of just get them stuck.
- dTal 6y agoThen why not just build a throwaway structure the same shape as the tunnel, some ways from the entrance, for people to crash into instead?
- numpad0 6y agono the point is to prevent damage to road thus preventing a mini catastrophe like an underwater tunnel collapsing Destroying the truck is indeed overkill though
- deathgrips 6y agoIn my professional engineering opinion, this is very badass.
- Animats 6y agoAt higher speeds, and with semitrailer-type vehicles, drivers don't notice the banging far behind them.[1] Much of the trouble at the Sydney Harbor Tunnel involves overloaded trucks with tarps on top. The truck may have taken the same route before, but become overheight due to the load. Thus, driver overconfidence. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352146516304884 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S235214651...
- tobtoh 6y agoThey don't work - well at least they aren't idiot-proof. See the comment above regarding the Montague Bridge in Melbourne, Australia. They have those height bars installed and we still routinely have trucks being peeled open. I have no idea how you can be so distracted when driving that you fail to register when your truck is whacked by those height bars, but ... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- tetris11 6y agoThey're not stupid, they're tired. They've been driving day in day out on autopilot. Signs begin to blur after a while.
- rusk 6y agoProbably shouldn’t be driving so ...
- throwaway2048 6y agoThere is a long list of unhelpful "Probably" statement's that don't solve the problem.
- rusk 6y agoNo. Really. Driving while tired is considered to be as bad as driving under the influence. HGV drivers should really be seeing rigorous testing for this but - hurdur - freedom
- rkagerer 6y agoThey tried an electronic warning sign that lights up when a truck is too tall, but drivers still can't resist the lure of the hungry bridge: https://youtu.be/YQssl0sM9As?t=6 https://youtu.be/YQssl0sM9As?t=6, https://youtu.be/cZrOcCXNq5c?t=5 https://youtu.be/cZrOcCXNq5c?t=5, https://youtu.be/iQfSvIgIs_M?t=32 https://youtu.be/iQfSvIgIs_M?t=32 Might have been better off erecting a giant, no-tech billboard picturing a previous crash. But your projected water screen is awesome - they could buy one and play footage from these youtube videos while they wait on the red light.
- loosescrews 6y agoI think the difference is that the Sydney one is very clearing telling you, the driver, to stop right now. The 11 foot 8 bridge one just looks like a generic message to all truck drivers that they should turn if they happen to be too tall. It isn't clear that it only turns on when it detects a too tall truck. If the driver of the truck thought that the bridge was too low, they wouldn't try to go under it in the first place.
- rightbyte 6y agoYe it should say "Your truck is too tall" instead of a general "overheight must turn around" (it is quite obvoius what you need to do so it just wastes space).
- tinus_hn 6y agoThe difference is the Sydney tunnel is at the end of an access road where the only way to go is the tunnel, while this bridge is around a corner and driving straight ahead with a vehicle that is too tall is allowed.
- walrus01 6y agoThat water curtain and projector looks like something adapted from the casino, convention center and special event industry.
- kayfox 6y ago
- quickthrower2 6y agoIf traffic to that tunnel were to get blocked at say 6am, expect mayhem across many routes in Sydney as that backs up, people take alternative routes along the harbour bridge and lower traffic bridges. The topography and indeed topology doesn't really like this tunnel to be out of use!
- cam_l 6y agoI never understood the high-tech approach to this problem. Where i am from they have large metal tubes dangling down a ways in front of the bridge. Makes it sound like you have already hit it. Another more insistent approach I have seen elsewhere is to mount a large steel bar across the road, which takes the top of the truck off before they hit the bridge. (edit:not very simple problem, obviously..)
- georgebarnett 6y agoThere are metal bars. Why do you think the team at the tunnel would go to such lengths and expense if there was a simple solution?
- marcinzm 6y agoFriendly bit of advice, you may want to work on your hubris. In general, when a group of experts implements a complex solution there is a reason for it. Rather than reveling in your ignorance and feeling of superiority you may want to instead research those reasons. Fyi, others in this thread have listed them.
- cam_l 6y agoWasn't meant to read as hubris, I genuinely was curious (if a little unclear). FWIW I have read about this at length generally at a local level, living and working next to a couple of bridges with this issue. A high tech approach has been tried and abandoned with these bridges as they were (fatally) not effective (though not this high-tech). I naturally assumed there was some particular reason for the tunnel. I read the rest of the thread before I commented, the ones you point out were written after, and they do indeed go some way toward explaining that particular issue at that particular tunnel. The original post did not explain anything but the bad road design. While we are giving friendly advice, your comments may be better received if you gave them in a spirit of generosity, as I have taken yours, rather than jumping straight to judgements and epithets.
- twic 6y ago> Friendly bit of advice, you may want to work on your hubris. In general, when a group of experts implements a complex solution there is a reason for it. As an aside, i work in the software industry, and here, that is absolutely not the case at all.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joshschreuder 6y agoMelbourne, not to be outdone by our rivals, have the Montague St bridge which is frequently doing in trucks. Even has its own Twitter account, because of course it does: https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/1219751538660233216 https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/12197515386602332... https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/1206816848278253568 https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/12068168482782535... https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/1191944456905330688 https://twitter.com/MontagueStBridg/status/11919444569053306...
- lysp 6y agoYep! And Montegue Bridge is even smaller - 3.0m (9 foot 10) It also website counting when it last was hit: https://howmanydayssincemontaguestreetbridgehasbeenhit.com/ https://howmanydayssincemontaguestreetbridgehasbeenhit.com/ With full history: https://howmanydayssincemontaguestreetbridgehasbeenhit.com/history/ https://howmanydayssincemontaguestreetbridgehasbeenhit.com/h... It's also a bit hard to miss: #1 - multiple big coloured signs #2 - bright rubber things that will hit your truck and make a noise #3 - sign, flashing lights and stripe across bridge. https://i.imgur.com/kYwsgEZ.png https://i.imgur.com/kYwsgEZ.png
- tetris11 6y ago6 days, with the last streak being 102. Not bad
- taneq 6y agoSimilarly, Perth has the Baysie Bridge: https://www.howmanydayssincebayswaterbridgehasbeenhit.com/ https://www.howmanydayssincebayswaterbridgehasbeenhit.com/ It's apparently slated to be replaced, though.
- john-tells-all 6y agoI thought you were joking... until I saw the video. It looks like a huge bright curtain with a 15-foot tall STOP sign unfurls in front of the driver! Whatever the cost, I'm sure it's paid for itself already.
- londons_explore 6y agoIt should be possible to design a sign like that pretty cheaply... Just a toilet flush mechanism to a pipe with thousands of holes spraying downwards, and a bulb, lens, and plastic film for the logo. The bulb would be a few of those football stadium arc lamps. One kilowatt per square meter is sunlight brightness, so you're going to be needing ~10kw of lighting. The whole system, complete with installation labor, probably $30k. Most of that is in mechanical supports for the water system. Except, government being government, I bet this was a $10M contract awarded to someone's mate...
- ddingus 6y agoThat water display is excellent! Great engineering on what appears to be a tough problem.
- jansan 6y agoAnd what makes it even better is that it's a truly geeky solution. You would expect something like this in the homes of geek super villains like Vector (from Despicable Me) or Bill Gates (yes, I am joking here)
- ddingus 6y agoTotally. It just stands out. OF COURSE! Someone found just the right use case and went for an unconventional display tech. Love it.
- lmilcin 6y agoThat will just cause people to pay less attention when they know they will get warned before driving in too small a tunnel. I personally think things like red light with height detector or metal bars that bump into your truck and make massive amount of noise should be enough. Water curtains with lasers projecting stop sign? That's just crazy. And we all pay for the infrastructure to save people who can't be bothered to stop before red light. In my opinion if things like that start getting implemented this is just going to cause people to pay even less attention. Everybody should know to stop before red light.
- Kwantuum 6y agoFrom the video, it looked like the truck braked faster than I would expect a human driver. I wonder if that water-curtain stop sign tripped up the truck's anti-collision braking system, that sounds like it would be a good target for such systems!
- slim 6y agoI thought this problem is solved. 50m before the tunnel, we have a big arc with a long wooden red and white sign hanging by chains at the maximum height (like the ones in railroad crossings). if you try, you get hit hard by it. it's the most unambiguous message you can get.