8 ms·
The A12 is clearly at parity now vs. Intel's existing mobile offerings, probably somewhat ahead given the long delays with 10nm. The question upthread is wheth
by ajross 6y ago
The A12 is clearly at parity now vs. Intel's existing mobile offerings, probably somewhat ahead given the long delays with 10nm.
The question upthread is whether or not switching architectures makes financial sense, not whether it's a (mild) technical win.
Switching to their own chips cuts Intel out of the loop, but as far as business risk that simply replaces one single source manufacturer with another (TSMC).
It probably saves money per-part, which is good. But then Apple is still drowning in cash and immediate term savings really aren't much of a motivator.
> By 2021 Intel can probably deliver a 1.1-1.2x speed up tops for Macbook airs, while Apple can probably deliver a 2x speed up for 2021 with the A15 and another one for 2023 with the A16.
That's going to need some citation. Moore's law is ending for everyone, not just Intel. TSMC has pulled ahead of Intel (and Samsung has caught up) for sure, but progress is slowing. That kind of scaling just isn't going to happen for anyone.
- fluffything 6y ago> That's going to need some citation. So this is Geekbench 5 showing the difference between a 2012 macbook air i5 and a 2020 macbook air i5 - both base models and similar price: https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2613713?baseline=2613509 https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2613713?baselin... And this is a thread in the rust subreddit about compilation speed on macbooks where some users report the performance increase for different generations of macbook pros and macbook airs, if you want a more "realistic benchmark" to calibrate geekbench results: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/gypajc/macbook_pro_2020_compile_performance/ https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/gypajc/macbook_pro_20... This is the ipad pro 2020 crushing the macbook air 2020: https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2612714?baseline=2613509 https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2612714?baselin... And this is the improvement from the previous generation ipad A10 to the ipad pro's A12Z - 2x speed up in single a generation: https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2613991?baseline=2613301 https://browser.geekbench.com/v5/cpu/compare/2613991?baselin... You are definetely right that Moore's law is hitting Intel hard. But AMD is still doing quite well, nvidia and "ati" are doing incredibly well, and Apple chips have been doing extremely well over the last couple generations. Maybe you are right, and Apple won't be able to deliver 2x speed ups in the next 2 generations. I'd expect that, just like for Intel, things won't abruptly change from one gen to another, but for this to happen over a longer period of time. Right now, only apple knows what perf their next 2 gens of chips are expected to deliver. The only thing we know is that Apple ARM chips are crushing their previous generation both for ipads and iphones year after year, and now they are betting on them for macbooks, and potentially mac pros, probably for at least the next 10-15 years.
- asjw 6y agoIt could well be that MacOS is a slower OS It's been the case for years in comparison to every other competitor Let's put Linux on both those chips and see what happens
- ComputerGuru 6y agoThere is no point in benchmarking anything: Macs have long shipped with CPUs one to two generations behind. If performance or efficiency (they’re interchangeable In this regard) on the desktop/notebook fronts mattered to Apple as a company, that would never have happened. Clearly there are other factors beyond the performance/efficiency curve at play and so it’s not a matter of benchmarking anything.
- runjake 6y agoThe benchmarked Mac in his post is running the latest 10th gen Intel that everyone else is using.
- asjw 6y agoYes, the 10th generation of the Facebook/email CPU Nobody would use that for real work, Apple won the laptop market when developers started using it, now they are killing them for tablets, which are gadgets, not work machines.
- messe 6y ago> Nobody would use that for real work It always amuses me how warped many commentators on HN's perspectives are on what is and isn't "real work". At time's it's bordering on "no true scotsman" fallacy. I assure you that plenty of people are using those computers and getting paid for the work they do on them.
- oarsinsync 6y agoMost of these people do their work without writing any JS too, enabling them to cope without 32TB of RAM to manage their 16 tabs of JavaScript each running in its own chromium instance. Some day, we’ll re-learn some old lessons about the need for efficient utilisation of resources. In the mean time, check out the latest old game re-implemented at a fraction of the frame rate in your browser.
- ksec 6y agoI agree with every single point you said and has been stating something similar. >It probably saves money per-part, which is good. But then Apple is still drowning in cash and immediate term savings really aren't much of a motivator. The only possible reason I could think of is to lower cost and lower selling price ( While retaining same margin ). A Macbook 12" ( Or will it be Macbook SE? ) that cost $799, the same price as iPad Pro. It is basically Apple admitting tablet with Touch computing will never take over PC with Keyboard and Mouse. Both will continually coexist for a long time if not indefinitely. And this isn't a far fetch statement. Most enterprise have absolutely no plan to replace their office Desktop Workflow with Tablet. The PC market is actually growing. There are still 1.5B PC in the world, of which only 100M belongs to Apple. I still dont understand how they will give up x86 compatibility on the Pro market though. They could make the distinction where every Mac product with Pro uses x86. And non-Pro uses ARM. At least that is my hypothesis.
- _ph_ 6y agoThe iPad pro not taking over a PC is a self-fulfilling prophecy as long as Apple does not allow it. With the mandatory App Store and its restricting rules, there are many things you just cannot do on an iPad. I wouldn't consider a MB Air, if the iPad had the same capabilities. That it doesn't have, is purely a software limitation.
- ksec 6y agoFor consumers and business users, you have Excel and Email. iPad already does 95% of what most Mac user do on their Desktop If not more and yet it hasn't taken over. It has not taken over by numbers, there isn't even a trend, projection or glimpse of hope anything has started. The tablet and PC is simply a different paradigm best suited for their own purpose. It is the same narrative that Smartphone will take over most of your computing needs. At first it seems obvious, Nations not been through PC era will go straight to Smartphone. And yet 5 years later the biggest growth area for PC are these Smartphone nations.
- koenneker 6y ago>Moores law is ending for everyone, not just Intel. I am by no means an "in the know" on Chip design and this whole bit is probably a fair bit of speculation, but I remember Jim Keller talking about the ending of Moores law on a podcast in February[1]. If I remember correctly his argument boiled down to the theory, that Moores law is in some sense a self fulfilling prophecy. You need to have every part of your company believing in it, or else the parts stop meshing into one another well. I.e. if a team doesn't believe that they will get reach a density/size improvement, that would allow them to use more transistors in their design they will need to cut down and adjust their plans to that new reality. If this distrust in improvement spreads inside of a company, it would in turn lead to a steeper slowdown in overall improvement. And while there may be an industry-wide slowdown at the current point in time, perhaps this dynamic is exacerbated at intel, causing them to loose their competitive edge over the past years. [1]https://youtu.be/Nb2tebYAaOA?t=1805 https://youtu.be/Nb2tebYAaOA?t=1805 (Timestamped to the beginning of Topic of Moores law slowing down)
- Klinky 6y ago~ignore bad info~
- wmf 6y agoIntel 10 nm does not use EUV.
- Klinky 6y agoThanks for the correction.
- wtallis 6y agoIntel's 10nm strategy was basically to do everything they could to advance their fabrication process without having to use EUV. Some of those changes turned out to be bigger risks than EUV. TSMC was a bit less aggressive with their last non-EUV nodes, but it actually worked and now they have EUV in mass production (though few if any end-user products have switched over to the EUV process at this point).
- AnonC 6y ago> But then Apple is still drowning in cash and immediate term savings really aren't much of a motivator. Why would you think so? Apple is a for profit company. Apple consistently makes more than 35% or so in margins. Why wouldn’t it make sense to increase that wherever possible (to increase profits or offset some discounted pricing it’s offering elsewhere, like a free one year subscription to Apple TV+ on purchasing a new device)? Also consider the impact of COVID-19 for the next one year or so.
- nojito 6y agoBecause the price of iPads have been falling over time.
- AnonC 6y agoThat could be because of cheaper production costs or because Apple has seen iPad sales dropping and traded some of its margins to sell them at lower prices. As a for profit company with very good margins, it only makes sense that Apple would continue to maximize that and not let it slip a lot, even if the gains may seem minimal to an outsider. It’s also the same reason why Apple continues to sell Macs at the same price a at launch time even years later without any hardware updates, even though Macs are a small percentage of its total revenues.
- IshKebab 6y ago> replaces one single source manufacturer with another (TSMC) Sure except it's Apple that design the chip then. A pretty huge advantage. Apple loves vertical integration.