4 ms·
Are there any honest, reputable operators in the financial industry? Between Enron, S&L, Lehman, WorldCom, AIG, Wirecard, Madoff, VW, gold price fixing, 1MDB,
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Are there any honest, reputable operators in the financial industry?
Between Enron, S&L, Lehman, WorldCom, AIG, Wirecard, Madoff, VW, gold price fixing, 1MDB, and all the "lost" BTC stories - among so many others - it seems like a question that needs to be asked.
- enriquto 6y ago> Are there any honest, reputable operators in the financial industry? The fact that they choose to label their unproductive activities as an "industry" and their scams as "products" means that the answer is no.
- qppo 6y agoI mean not all of those companies you listed are in the financial industry. VW didn't even commit financial crimes, it was regulatory fraud. I don't know if the 1MDB is in the same league either, that's plain government corruption. I feel like if you're going to ask that question then focus on dishonest financiers and not every business that has broken the law.
- the-dude 6y agoYou forgot HSBC
- _curious_ 6y ago+Countrywide, Indymac, and Bear Stearns
- pjc50 6y agoThere are degrees of this issue; any business handling money is going to attract fraud, the question is how well the internal controls deal with it and whether management are in on it. At one end is Lehman, which was incredibly over-leveraged and only slightly fraudulent ( https://www.accountancyage.com/2010/12/21/ey-sued-over-lehmans-audit/ https://www.accountancyage.com/2010/12/21/ey-sued-over-lehma... ), but set out to be a legit investment bank. AIG is in a roughly similar category. There was some fraud: https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-gen-re-aig-trial-012709-2009jan27-story.html https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-gen-re-aig-trial-0... - but the collapse was due to leverage. At the other end are Madoff and 1MDB, which were intentionally fraudulent from the beginning. The "lost" BTC stories are just off in outer space; the bitcoin ecosystem doesn't acknowledge fraud or accounting control as a concept, because that goes against "code is law" and transaction irreversability.
- the-dude 6y ago> the bitcoin ecosystem doesn't acknowledge fraud or accounting control as a concept, Neither do banks. Transferred means transferred. They had to be regulated into KYC. I don't recall the reason, wether it was fraud or terrorism.
- bildung 6y ago> I don't recall the reason, wether it was fraud or terrorism. Interesting question to procrastinate with :) Apparently it was both, it started with measures to prevent money laundering by the mafia, with the Federal Deposit Insurance Act of 1950[0]. The current regulations are a result of 9/11 and came as part of the Patriot Act[1]. [0] = https://authenteq.com/the-evolution-of-kyc-part-2/ https://authenteq.com/the-evolution-of-kyc-part-2/ [1] = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer#Laws_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer#Laws_by_cou...
- pjc50 6y agoYou can get it back with a court order (or less) most of the time for domestic transfers. IBAN transfers are more of a problem. (In the UK a lot of bill payment stuff is done by direct debit, which has a better "guarantee" agreement on getting your money back)
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoReal people lost a lot of BTC on Mt Gox, so I'm not sure how the BTC stories are in outer space. Apart from that, the second half of your first sentence is exactly the question - is fraud endemic to this industry, and actually central to its operation? The popular perception is that the industry is somehow fundamentally honest with a few bad-actor exceptions. Considering how regularly fraud happens, how damaging it is, and how rarely it's flagged by auditors and regulators, I think it would be useful to question that view. Or to invert the polarity - how many significant potential frauds have been prevented by auditors and regulators, or by paperwork theatre like KYC? Are there any? If so, how do the numbers compare with the number of frauds that blow up into real financial and reputational damage?
- jansan 6y agoYes, but they are usually considered lame and boring.
- Arnt 6y agoAnd aren't in the news for that reason. So most of the news is about the exciting people doing exciting things, often with other people's money. I searched for the name of (IIRC) the third biggest Swiss bank on HN now. No stories ever, one comment, and that comment was basically a list of banks. That bank exists, though, it just isn't named when people talk about scandals.
- imglorp 6y agoThen there's systematic fraud between those players. Two that come to mind are the Libor manipulation (in the $ trillions) around 2006 and the subprime lending fiasco in 08. The rats will cooperate if it lets them steal more.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoGiven that there's tens of thousands of such companies, and you can list a handful of bad ones, I suspect the vast majority do reputable and honest business.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoSeems more likely that those who run financial services are motivated primarily by money, and that all such institutions are corrupt to the core because they're always prepared to break regulations/laws/ethics of there is sufficient monetary gain. All the big name financial companies have recent irregularities AFAICT.
- tomp 6y agoWell, there's two kinds of people - those that are happy with what they earn (saving under a mattress or (maybe) in a bank), and those that want to have more unearned profits and invest their savings / pensions in the stock markets (or other businesses). You mainly hear about the latter kind, and finance is in particular an industry that's targeting them. When people want something (profit) out of nothing (little to no work carefully picking investments, instead just give your money to someone else), there's a lot of people willing to sell them "something" that's really "nothing".
- nradov 6y agoThe gold market is too large for anyone to fix the price. Not even central banks are capable of doing that. It's a paranoid fantasy concocted by incompetent traders looking to blame someone else for their losses.
- bboreham 6y agoErr https://www.reuters.com/article/us-barclays-regulations-gold/barclays-slapped-with-44-million-fine-over-gold-price-fix-idUSBREA4M06620140523 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-barclays-regulations-gold...