22 ms·
Apple rejects appeal from email app Hey
- aurizon 6y agoApple needs to be pissed on from a height - I wonder if they have bribed the monopoly inquisition they face in the USA/Europe
- rhapsodic 6y ago> "pissed on from a height" I've never heard that expression before. Was it translated to English from some other language?
- chrisseaton 6y agoThey don't have a monopoly - you can buy an Android.
- Avamander 6y agoThat's bullshit, softly put. Google and Microsoft have gotten more heat for doing less monopolistic stuff.
- throw0101a 6y agoGoogle and Microsoft control(ed) more of the markets that they operated in: in the 1990s to 2000s what percentage of PCs ran Windows? What percentage of search does Google have? Apple/iOS currently has less that 20%: * https://www.strategyanalytics.com/strategy-analytics/blogs/devices/smartphones/smart-phones/2020/04/30/global-smartphone-shipments-fall-17-percent-in-q1-2020 https://www.strategyanalytics.com/strategy-analytics/blogs/d... * https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-smartphone-share/ https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-smartphone-share... * https://www.idc.com/promo/smartphone-market-share/vendor https://www.idc.com/promo/smartphone-market-share/vendor Android, split across multiple manufacturers, has >80%.
- Avamander 6y agoApple/iOS has 100% on their platform. Noone stopped you back then from buying an Apple PC, installing Linux or BSD etc. either. Noone stopped you from installing an alternative browser on either Windows or Android, yet they got slapped for it.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThis is like saying McDonald's have a monopoly because you can only buy McDonalds in a McDonalds restaurant... go somewhere else if you don't want the McDonalds menu.
- Avamander 6y agoYour analogy is just blatantly incorrect from the developer's perspective, very user-centric. You can't choose not to sell "patties" "McDonalds" if you want to actually sell your "patties". And as I said, people were just as free to install other browsers than IE on Windows and Chrome on Android, but it was still considered bad monopolistic behaviour and they got punished for it.
- throw0101a 6y ago> And as I said, people were just as free to install other browsers than IE on Windows Check the ruling against Microsoft: they were slapped down for this because they had a monopoly in the field of PCs / computers, and they (tried to) leveraged that monopoly into a monopoly for browsers. Android is the dominant smartphone platform (per units shipped), so Google is closer being considered a monopoly. Apple does not have a monopoly in smartphones or computers, so I'm failing to see how any parallels here. The best argument you can hope to make is that a duopoly exists between Android and iOS, and the duopoly together should be treated as monopoly for practical purposes. But claiming monopolistic behaviours and associated restrictions on a company that has 20% of the market is silly.
- Avamander 6y ago
- chrisseaton 6y ago> That's bullshit Can you buy an alternative product and have nothing to do with Apple's store? Yes. They aren't a monopoly. Are they a big player? Yes. But they aren't a monopoly. If you don't like it go somewhere else. Vote with your dollars and impressions.
- e_y_ 6y agoI'd call it a duopoly, which is not as bad as a monopoly but it's definitely enough to set market prices and arguably should subject them to antitrust scrutiny for anti-competitive behavior. They have more than 50% of global app sales revenue; Apple's App Store revenue is about 80% higher than Google Play. They also have about 57% of the "premium" ($400+) smartphone market. That has a strong impact on the ability for developers to create and sell apps. Not to say that Google is innocent either; they've started adopting some of Apple's practices as well. Unless you're a masochist, going outside the Apple/Google ecosystem is not really a viable option. https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/03/app-revenue-tops-39-billion-in-first-half-of-2019-up-15-from-first-half-of-last-year/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/03/app-revenue-tops-39-billio... https://www.gsmarena.com/counterpoint_flagship_smartphone_shipments_dipped_by_13_in_q1_apple_had_4_of_the_5_best_sellers-news-43799.php https://www.gsmarena.com/counterpoint_flagship_smartphone_sh...
- gizmo 6y agoAs an app developer you can't NOT be in the Apple app store. As a consumer you can simply say no to Apple products. As a business Apple is too big a percentage of your customer base and you're forced to play by their arbitrary and capricious rules.
- google234123 6y agoYou have 1000s of other phones for sale from 50$+ that you can buy,.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ipsum2 6y agoWhat's infuriating is Apple's inconsistency. Some apps offer subscriptions outside of the app store and are still there (including Basecamp!)
- outworlder 6y agoEDIT: Having deployed a few apps in the past which required login and not being harassed, I thought something else was going on. This seems to be an unspoken policy change. I'm joining the outrage bandwagon now. > What's infuriating is Apple's inconsistency. Some apps offer subscriptions outside of the app store and are still there (including Basecamp!) That doesn't violate guidelines. Unless your app takes users outside of the app store to purchase stuff(including the subscription itself) without in app purchases. Having an app requiring login is ok. It doesn't matter that the login is protecting a paid service.
- Hamuko 6y ago>Unless your app takes users outside of the app store to purchase stuff(including the subscription itself) without in app purchases. Where did Hey take users outside of the app?
- outworlder 6y ago'Hey' itself may not be doing this right now, I don't know. I was referring to: > 3.1.1 In-App Purchase: If you want to unlock features or functionality within your app, (by way of example: subscriptions, in-game currencies, game levels, access to premium content, or unlocking a full version), you must use in-app purchase. Apps may not use their own mechanisms to unlock content or functionality, such as license keys, augmented reality markers, QR codes, etc. Apps and their metadata may not include buttons, external links, or other calls to action that direct customers to purchasing mechanisms other than in-app purchase.
- scarface74 6y agoThis isn’t true for most of the OTT streaming cable TV apps. They all require subscriptions.
- Traster 6y agoI don't think picking a fight with Apple as a PR strategy is a good move. The rules on the app store are very clear, if you're charging a subscription for functionality you're providing through an iOS app, that subscription must be available through Apple's payment system. I know people don't like that, but it's not unexpected. So given that Hey knew the rules, it seems a bit manipulative for them to submit their app and then go on a massive PR campaign about how outraged they are. I understand that they may feel that the app store rules are unfair, but this whole fanfare seems ridiculous to me. Instead they seem to think that they're going to benefit from picking a fight with Apple - it reminds of small youtubers who make expose videos about big youtubers to try and get people''s attention.
- scarface74 6y agoIt is very unclear. The rule has been that you cannot advertise that it requires a subscription or provide a link. There are literally a dozen apps that I am personally aware of that require subscriptions and don’t allow in app subscriptions. - Netflix - Sling TV - ATT Now (DirecTVNow) - ACloudGuru - Kindle - Youtube TV - Spotify - Microsoft Office - Hulu Live TV (not regular Hulu)
- grecy 6y agoWell yeah, people & companies with a lot of money get a different set of rules. That's the same in the app store as it is in real life. I'd be much more interested in seeing in change in real life before some silly app store.
- pmontra 6y agoMaybe it's the number of users. If the iPhone was the phone you can't watch Netflix with (or any similar service), maybe a lot of people would buy an Android device.
- Despegar 6y agoThey have a specific section in the rules for "Reader" apps like Netflix and Spotify. It's not unclear, it's been there since 2018.
- Hamuko 6y ago>"The Hey Email app is marketed as an email app on the App Store, but when users download your app, it does not work," Apple said in a letter to Basecamp CEO Jason Fried on Thursday. "Users cannot use the app to access email or perform any useful function until after they go to the Basecamp website for Hey Email and purchase a license to use the Hey Email app." Imagine if all applications on the App Store had to work straight out of the box without any kind of interaction with any kind of an external service. Even my bank would be barred from the App Store since I actually need to get in my car and drive to the bank in order to have an account for the damn thing. Rival bank's application doesn't even allow you to login even if you have an account if you have not logged into that account at the bank's website at least once. So much for working out of the box. Banking apps do not have an exception in the App Store Review Guidelines, so I don't really understand why they're getting off so easily.
- dilly_li 6y agoThe news I read yesterday [0] (from Hey's founder?) painted Apple as the obvious villain. Today's news (the above link) shows a slightly differnet picture. > "The Hey Email app is marketed as an email app on the App Store, but when users download your app, it does not work," Apple said in a letter to Basecamp CEO Jason Fried on Thursday. "Users cannot use the app to access email or perform any useful function until after they go to the Basecamp website for Hey Email and purchase a license to use the Hey Email app." Basically Hey doesn't work as a standalone free app. The user has to download it AND subscribe somehow. Apple basically dictates, the developers either 1) offer some Reader-like free features, or 2) pay the Apple tax and build the subscription feature with IAP. I am not saying the 30% tax is justifiable. The logic behind Apple's rejection doesn't seem completely unreasonable to me. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23542937 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23542937
- htunnicliff 6y agoThis is how the Netflix app works.
- justrudd 6y agoHow so? I'm looking at the Netflix app in the App store right now and it offers in app purchases. I don't have to sign up before using it. I can sign up in the app (I'm assuming based on this screenshot from the App Store - https://imgur.com/a/t6AqwEx https://imgur.com/a/t6AqwEx). I already have an account. Not going to jump through hoops to try it out. Edited: added screenshot
- Hamuko 6y ago>I can sign up in the app You absolutely can't. The first thing you see when you download the app is a info string telling you how you can't sign up inside the app. https://miro.medium.com/1*-mAqC-14gV7zNvWdn_SNxA.jpeg https://miro.medium.com/1*-mAqC-14gV7zNvWdn_SNxA.jpeg
- bjtitus 6y agoYou need to logout to see the first time user experience. Those in-app purchases are grandfathered in from older versions of the app so they don't lose those subscribers. They no longer allow new subscriptions through IAP.
- outworlder 6y agoEDIT: I'm retracting my statement. This is how things used to work. I don't see any changes to the policy. Yet, the app is still not getting approved. And it is not taking users to its own payment portal. So I got no clue WTF is going on. > In rejecting Hey's appeal, Apple notes that the developers could work within Apple's rules by allowing the app to function as a reader for standard e-mail, while also offering Hey subscriptions from its Web site. Alternatively, it says Hey can add an in-app subscription option, sharing revenue on those purchased within the app while keeping all subscription revenue earned outside of Apple's ecosystem. 1) Don't handle payments inside the app at all, do everything payment-related on the website. 2) Implement in app purchases These are the options. "Hey" should pick one.
- ChrisLTD 6y agoThey already did #1. Apple is saying they have to do #2.
- vasachi 6y agoWell, they did implement option 1.
- cmelbye 6y ago“1” isn’t an option on its own, that’s what they’re already doing today and part of why they were rejected.
- davesmylie 6y ago> 1) Don't handle payments inside the app at all, do everything payment-related on the website. It's not quite so simple as that. If you're charging a subscription for functionality you're providing through an iOS app, that subscription must be available through Apple's payment system.
- xxpor 6y ago#1 USED to be the option. Apple decided to start enforcing the letter of the agreement, which meant 1 is only available for "reader" apps. That's what's so egregious.
- 6y ago
- AYBABTME 6y agoProbably naive question, but couldn't they markup the In-App-Subscription by whatever % of cut Apple is taking? The same is done by restaurants for things like Uber Eat/Postmate: they have their prices on their menu, and a marked-up price on these platforms. downvotes: mind explaining why my naive question is not a worthy contribution/question? or if you just disagree, I'm genuinely interested in understanding what I'm not grasping.
- evan_ 6y agoWhy should they have to spend a month building a whole new iPhone-first onboarding flow and updating their entire app to accept a different subscription provider? Who's to say that if they spend that hundreds of thousands of dollars of developer time Apple won't just knock them down for some other imagined infraction?
- scarface74 6y agoHundreds of thousands of dollars to create in app subscriptions? There are many indy developers that have done that as a one man operation.
- evan_ 6y agoI said dollars, not hours. I stand by that estimate. Right now there's no mobile-first onboarding flow. That's a completely new thing they'll have to build. They'll also need to update all of their code that checks subscriptions, handles dunning, etc., to now work with multiple billing providers. So yeah, it's going to take a lot of time, which is a lot of dollars.
- scarface74 6y agoHundreds of thousands of dollars to do in app purchases. As an example, do you really think Marco Arment - sole creator of Instapaper before he sold it, The Magazine, and now Overcast spent “hundreds of thousands of dollars” just to create in app purchases?
- terracatta 6y agoThis letter is actually astonishing. In this letter Apple: * Chastises them for making free apps in the past * Reminds them they've had to distribute their apps for free (almost as if they should be grateful and now give them some money) * States they would accept their app if it provided unrelated functionality or access to competitor products (who are oddly not subject to the same rules). * Implies that everyone is following the rules but them (which is demonstrably false even if you accept the "Reader" and "Business" definitions they provide) Also, according to DHH, they leaked this letter to the press before sending it to the Basecamp CEO. Nice. The argument is so strange, it's almost as if "email" is a special term of art that causes Apple to categorize this app in a way that is not is not consistent with other SaaS products. Even with that said, there are no other similar email apps like Superhuman that are subject to these rules. If I was a Chat or Email based SaaS company CEO and I relied on the iPhone to complete my multi-platform value prop, I would be very worried about this happening to my already approved app.
- Hamuko 6y ago>Reminds they've had to distribute their apps for free Apple has never had to distribute any application for free since you need to pay $99 per year to have anything listed on the App Store.
- NotSammyHagar 6y agobut that $99 charge is really a way to reduce trolls and scams. For regular us devs it almost meaningless, it blocks poor people in the west and third world devs.
- Hamuko 6y agoIf there were 10,000 developers on the App Store, their yearly membership fees come to a total of $990,000. That's pretty good revenue for troll/scam reduction. Now do the same math for the actual number of active App Store devs.
- 6y ago
- embrassingstuff 6y agoFrom the article > could work within Apple's rules by allowing the app to function as a reader for standard e-mail, while also offering Hey subscriptions This is apple's new stance or is it conventional wisdom for store policy? If only Hey also worked with regular mail all would have been well?
- evan_ 6y agothat's what the email that Apple sent them said. > If you would prefer not to offer users the option of in-app purchases, you could consider having the app function as marketed — an email client that works with standard IMAP and POP email accounts, where customers can optionally configure the Hey Email service as their preferred email service provider.
- paxys 6y agoIt was a suggestion on how to update their app to comply with the policy - basically offer a free version that's just like any other email app.
- nrmitchi 6y agoI would personally love to see Hey come back with a free Apple version of their service which gives the user a hilariously long @hey.com email address and lets them use it.
- donmcronald 6y agoYeah, like the digital equivalent of work to rule. 1MB storage, no attachments, forced signature, etc.. It would be hilarious to see Apple respond to that because it's still more ethical than all the trial subscription scams they allow on the app store.
- nrmitchi 6y agoI wouldn't even put any limits on the account (outside of the fact that your address would be an exceptionally unfriendly string. Since this sign up is through Apple, I assume Hey would have the device ID, and could limit repeat/duplicate/spam sign ups in some way. I am also assuming that the marginal cost of hosting an account is trivial. In this situation, _worst case_, someone creates a free account, likes how it works, and then has to pay $99 elsewhere in order to get a reasonable address. This would kind of be the definition of malicious compliance. And honestly, ya, I would love it.
- whycombagator 6y agoMaybe it’s time for Hey to go full PWA. Sunk costs with the native app though
- Hamuko 6y agoApple's attitude towards PWA isn't much to build on.
- whycombagator 6y agoEverything is a trade off ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- andrei_says_ 6y agoYes, especially a monopoly intentionally crippling their browser to make PWAs unusable.
- danieljacksonno 6y agoApple doesn't allow push notifications for PWAs, a fairly essential feature for an email app
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 6y agoIt continues to amaze me that Apple is picking this fight the week before WWDC. We know that the EU is already looking at Apple, and now the US seems to be making noise about it. And they decide to have this fight. I usually understand Apple but this one… eludes me.
- Hamuko 6y agoEven more bizarre considering Hey is not even publicly available yet. They could have easily deferred this fight without it having any effect on the absolutely miniscule number of new clients that are getting in before the general availability.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago> The company notes that the store has been operating for more than a decade and has never raised fees "We've never asked for more than a third of your income, what's the problem?"
- donmcronald 6y agoThat's absolutely hilarious and tone deaf at the same time. Lol.
- corkmask 6y agothey didn't ask for 50% or 80%, so instead of being thankful like some fanbois you are being sarcastic /s
- ggregoire 6y agoWhy does Basecamp refuse (?) to add the in-app subscription? Is it only to avoid sharing their revenues with Apple or are there other reasons? (sorry I'm not that familiar with this topic and didn't follow the whole story)
- jetpackjoe 6y agoThey see it as ransom.
- donmcronald 6y ago30% (then 15% forever) of revenue is a huge amount of money. If Hey thinks they're following the rules and the app got approved the first time, Hey might already be committed to pricing that's going to be hard to change. It could break their business model. It's also really obvious it's nothing more than rent seeking because Apple adds almost no value. The infrastructure for payments, updates, etc. on other platforms is still needed, so I'm sure the only reason they're even using the Apple app store is because it's the only way to distribute their app. 15% of lifetime revenue for Apple to host some update files is a really bad deal. IMHO if Apple approved it "by mistake" the first time they should have just owned the mistake and granted Hey a one-off exemption from the rules.
- drewg123 6y agoI suggested this on the other article about this yesterday: They should just offer an in-app subscription for some absurd price ($1000/year, for example).
- ballenf 6y agoIf apple would just insist on taking it's cut from ads and indirect revenue from surveillance and spyware, so many of these problems would go away. Apple currently effectively subsidizes the surveillance of its users with adware and spyware apps getting free ride. The only problem with this approach is that it's basically completely unworkable. But other than that minor issue, it's a great idea. Maybe the ad revenue side of things could be done, but the spyware side is hard to even come up with a theoretical valuation. While it's theory only, one could even theorize gmail having to put a valuation on the user profile data gathered and give Apple a cut. Either that or stop surveilling its users.
- scarface74 6y agoAre people actually asking Apple to get in the ad business? It’s already a step too far that they sell ads on the App Store.
- bjtitus 6y agoThey were in the ad business years ago with iAd. https://developer.apple.com/support/iad/ https://developer.apple.com/support/iad/
- scarface74 6y agoAnd it was a complete disaster.
- samwillis 6y agoIf Apple are taking issue with this being a “consumer” email service, Fastmail[0] have exactly the same setup, download the app but have to go to website (no direct links) to signup and pay. How is it not also blocked? My only thoughts are that fastmail is also accessible through imap and has corporate accounts with centralised billing. If Basecamp add company accounts to Hay, which they have always said is coming later in the year, does that not fix the problem? [0] https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/fastmail-email-calendar/id931370077 https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/fastmail-email-calendar/id9313...
- paxys 6y agoHeck if we're talking about inconsistency we don't even have to look at other apps. Apple itself already approved Hey (and it is in the App Store right now), but is now rejecting updates, simply because it got assigned to a different agent this time around.
- sam_lowry_ 6y agoThis time, the agent is Tim Cook.
- gnicholas 6y ago> "All the rules they're citing should apply to Gmail and Outlook as well," Hansson told Axios. " I agree Apple is being inconsistent here, but not vis a vis gmail and outlook. Those are free services, so they’re not the right comparison. Apple doesn’t require IAP for these because there is no payment involved. Netflix, on the other hand, proves that Apple does allow apps that are useless unless the user has a separate subscription.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Hamuko 6y agoGoogle does charge for additional Gmail storage in the form of Google One.
- tssva 6y agoThe Gmail app is not tied to the Gmail email service. It can be used to access non-Gmail accounts. Google Photos and Google Drive both allow in-app purchasing of additional storage space billed through Apple. Edit: Added statement about Gmail app working with non-Gmail email accounts.
- bjtitus 6y agoYes, but streaming video apps are explicitly given a pass on that rule, along with several other categories: "magazines, newspapers, books, audio, music, video, access to professional databases, VoIP, cloud storage, and approved services such as classroom management apps" How the hell they came up with this list is anyone's guess. Seems like they kind of tacked things on that they were concerned about completely removing.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThe problem is, Apple taking a cut from service where they don't own the device (you bought it from them; you own it) don't provide the network (you contract for that yourself) don't provide the content Its just some kind of strong-arm tactic - they do it because they can. Like some bouncer outside a club who demands money, but is not employed by the club nor the act. Just standing in the door and demanding money, and you have to pay because you want to get in. All this splitting hairs over exactly who they strong-arm and who they don't is beside the point.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd the console makers? Google Play? The movie theaters? Amazon? Spotify?
- vertis 6y agoGoogle Play is a bad example here because you can absolutely use app stores like F-Droid or Amazon to get content onto your device. Arguably, they have problems as well, but it's not an apples to apples (no pun intended) comparison. One has a completely locked down ecosystem that people are worried to speak against lest they lose access to it. The other has alternatives, albeit ones without huge traction. It does allow you to make decisions about whether Google Play gives value (discovery, etc).
- scarface74 6y agoSo how has that worked out for developers who chose to use alternate stores?
- corkmask 6y agoYou are confusing market access and distribution. If I wanted alot of eyes on my app and I saw a benefit from the appstore then I would pay the 30%. All I want is being able to give to MY customers, who I paid MY money to acquire, a native app. Apple is refusing to allow this, unless I pay protection money. Textbook rent seeking
- chaostheory 6y agoThe big problem with Apple and Nintendo is that compared to other companies, they don't have enough rules for app submission written out, and that many of the rules are vague enough to be subject to individual interpretation. The end result is chaos.
- realtalk_sp 6y agoSome people here seem to be responding to all of this inappropriately. The simple fact is that Apple is injecting itself as an intermediary in the payment process and extracting a preposterously oversized commission for no meaningful added value. And it's easy to see that Apple knows what they're doing is wrong. They strictly prohibit developers from signaling that there's an extra cost for purchases made through Apple's system or that there are alternative payment options available. A well-informed consumer would be a clear threat to Apple's gravy train. This system should have never emerged to begin with. It's highly unethical and, given the direction things are taking [1], will likely be found in violation of antitrust laws. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/13/supreme-court-rules-against-apple-allowing-an-app-store-antitrust-case-to-proceed/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/13/supreme-court-rules-agains...
- Despegar 6y ago>The simple fact is that Apple is injecting itself as an intermediary in the payment process and extracting a comically oversized commission for no meaningful added value. Frankly anyone who says this with a straight face is being absurd. Apple's commission isn't for "payment processing", promotion, any particular API, or service they provide on their platform. That they do all of those things makes it an attractive place to develop for and sell your product, but it isn't the reason why they get to charge 30%. They charge 30% because they've amassed 1 billion extremely valuable users who are willing to spend money on apps in their marketplace.
- realtalk_sp 6y ago> They charge 30% because they've amassed 1 billion extremely valuable users who are willing to spend money on apps in their marketplace. Apps that are made up to 42% more expensive (NOTE: the 30% fee applies to all in-app purchases and the first year of subscriptions) in a way that's entirely opaque to those users. The fact that you think this is okay is the only thing I find absurd. You also seem like someone who is for some reason predisposed to be an apologist for Apple's monopolistic business practices. You certainly don't represent what would likely be the average/majority sentiment of Apple's customers, were they sufficiently informed.
- subdane 6y agoApple has an abusive relationship with developers. I bet this harkens back to Jobs being pissed about jailbreaking and having to open up the platform. I think the culture still reflects that basic misunderstanding at the company. It's ironic, because it's the apps and developers that made the iPhone what it is - case in point, "There's an app for that," which they actually went and trademarked. https://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/mobile/10/12/app.for.that/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2010/TECH/mobile/10/12/app.for.that/inde...
- scarface74 6y agoYou have no idea about how Nintendo and all of the console makers treat developers. Roku won’t let commercial streaming apps on their platform without making a deal with them.
- arvinsim 6y agoSeems to be a case of whataboutism. Just because someone is doing it doesn't make it any less wrong.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s how the industry has worked from day one. “Wrong” is an opinion. In a legal sense it’s “precedent”. This is how the entire industry works. Before Apple, software developers only got a 30% to 40% cut to be in carriers app stores. Yes they had app stores where you could buy J2ME apps. Most retailers have a far greater wholesale to retail margin than 30%.
- kelnos 6y ago> “Wrong” is an opinion. So people aren't allowed to have opinions anymore?
- mustardo 6y agoAgree it seems short sighted of Apple to me Windows Phone largely failed because developers had abandoned the platform and "There is no app developed for that" ended up being common
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hypewatch 6y ago> Apple typically gets 30% of in-app subscriptions for the first year and 15% of renewals. I think that 30% then 15% commission are both way too high. Apple should be able to charge a modest commission fee to be on their App Store but that price is way too high. Maybe 5% then 3% would be more reasonable. But the worst part about this is that Apple is so inconsistent with its enforcement. There is an anti-competitive element to Apple’s enforcement behavior that is very concerning. I’m surprised that Tim Cook has allowed this behavior. Long term this will hurt app developers and Tim should understand that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonbeebe 6y agoWhy don’t these rules apply to banking apps then? I wouldn’t consider them business-only as most individuals interacting with the App Store have bank accounts, so that argument breaks down. I wouldn’t consider them stictly “reader” apps as you can perform many non-passive things in many banking apps (make deposits, iniatiate transfers to and from accounts, pay bills, etc), so that argument doesn’t stick either. You can’t use the app unless you have a (most of the time) paid account.
- xiphias2 6y agoYou need to go though KYC and other custom checks to get a bank account and it's a heavily regulated process.
- AnonC 6y agoNot defending Apple here, but I see commenters making different sorts of comparisons and saying that Apple is taking an unfairly large cut. Can someone do an objective comparison with publishers of print and ebooks and what commissions they take before the author gets paid (please consider all kinds of publishers and publishing platforms)? AFAIK, that industry is far worse (look at pragprog.com to see what’s considered a fantastic rate), and hardly any reader/consumer seems to be complaining.
- realtalk_sp 6y agoI find it odd that so many people are relying on the "well they do it too argument", as if Apple has a monopoly on monopolistic business practices. If you want an example of a horrible middleman in publishing that's slowly being extinguished by rebelling counterparties, take a look at Elsevier.
- AnonC 6y agoIf at all my earlier comment was misunderstood, my intent was not to point or justify Apple's policies by implying that "someone else is doing worse, so it's ok for Apple to do this" on the cuts it takes. It's just that the comparisons seem highly selective and dismissive of counter-arguments (there was one such point about video game consoles that was dismissed too).
- skc 6y agoIt's a pity that so many companies have effectively locked themselves inside the walled garden. They did it willingly too and it's fantastic until it's not. Every time the topic of Apples app store rules comes up on HN the general consensus always seems to be that the rules are fair. Now that a highly visible company is kicking up a fuss it'll be interesting to see if Apple even responds
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoApples idea of the future is one I no longer want any part in.
- ijpsud 6y agoDoes iOS support PWAs yet? I'd have thought that PWAs would have all the features required for an email application at this point. Apparently 20% of Apple's revenue comes from their marketplaces (music, apps, etc), but in terms of profit it's probably significantly higher since the costs ought to be much lower than their hardware. So it seems like there's a decent chance that at least third of their profit could get wiped out by PWAs in the long run. You'd think they'd be treating developers a little better.
- ledauphin 6y agomy understanding is that their on-device browser monopoly (Safari) cripples many capabilities of PWAs, like for instance push notifications.
- beardedman 6y ago- An app does not need to be part of the appstore to function - It's Apple's store - not a community project, fascinated how people seem to think they are accountable to some higher authority - it's also totally optional - Apple is the one being consistent - HEY is also built by one of the most attention seeking developers in the world, who's sole purpose seems to be criticising large corporations on Twitter - I like ownership of my data - not a manifesto by a closed door company based on "promises" and feel good messages
- lolsal 6y agoI just can't enraged by a platform enforcing their rules. Don't use their platform, or play by their rules?
- zadkey 6y agoOne of the issues that is brought up in the article is that they enforce their rules selectively. "All the rules they're citing should apply to Gmail and Outlook as well," Hansson told Axios. "So it's laughable that they state that we must follow the rules that everyone follows when it's plain as day that not everyone follows the same rules."
- lolsal 6y agoI know it's frustrating, but similarly I enforce my diet selectively. It's their prerogative, right?
- projektfu 6y agoHere's another possible solution. Make the "Hey" app a general e-mail client for all e-mail clients that support the "Hey" protocol, whatever that is. Publish a rough draft of the protocol and call it a day.
- musicale 6y agoApple is certainly an illegal monopoly for not allowing other game/app stores on its handheld devices and dictating the terms and conditions for developers. And hiding behind the DMCA to ban circumvention tools for its intrusive DRM. And competing against its own third-party developers. Bring on the anti-trust lawsuits! Fortunately we don't have to patronize Apple's evil monopoly on handheld gaming and game/app stores anymore. As for me, I'll go back to playing Animal Crossing, which I bought on Nintendo's eShop on my Nintendo Switch! (Then I'll maybe I'll lay down some tracks with Korg Gadget and write some code in SmileBASIC. Maybe I'll buy some DLC for my favorite games also - all from the Nintendo eShop, naturally.) /s