5 ms·
Unfortunately, I have to post this comment again, from just 3 days ago [1]. Also remember that Eric Yuan is an American citizen, not a Chinese citizen. He switc
by crazygringo 6y ago
Unfortunately, I have to post this comment again, from just 3 days ago [1]. Also remember that Eric Yuan is an American citizen, not a Chinese citizen. He switched. Original comment:
When will this meme die?
Zoom is NOT a Chinese company. It is incorporated in and headquartered in the US. Like any American company ever, it follows US laws in the US, and local laws in other companies where it operates. End of story.
Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? At the end of the day, they're a public, profit-driven corporation trying to make lots of money across the entire world.
It's not like they're secretly and nefariously doing the CCP's bidding, which seems to be the veiled suggestion people keep making.
Seriously, every time someone brings up that Zoom is "really" a Chinese company, it comes across as borderline racism or conspiracy-mongering or both. And while I'd usually never comment on someone using a throwaway account, in this case when you're pushing these kinds of shady "stronger than the more-commonly-discussed" insituations, I think using a throwaway here is representative of exactly the kind of astroturfing that spreads malicious rumors without evidence.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23510886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23510886
- throwaway9482 6y ago> Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? A lot.
- xwowsersx 6y agoHow is it racist to suggest that Zoom has Chinese influences (seemingly not farfetched based on the equity ownership mentioned above and not at all disputed based on the technicality of Zoom being a US company)?
- maxmcd 6y agoIt is not racist to suggest that the Chinese government influences companies. It is racist to suggest that Chinese people are automatically predispositioned to certain actions.
- xwowsersx 6y agoFair enough and I don't think anyone here will find that statement controversial. I think what bothers me in some of the dialogue here is what I perceive as an attempt to play "hide the ball" by pretending that CCP interests don't run counter to the interests of liberal democracies by labeling raised concerns as racist. No one framed anything in racial terms to begin with so I don't see why it needs to be placed in that context.
- laughinghan 6y agoDid you read the comment he's replying to? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23553503 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23553503 It's entire contents is an argument that Zoom is evil because Eric Yuan is Chinese-American. It doesn't say a single one of the things you're saying.
- g-b-r 6y agoIt's racist to suggest that Chinese people (NOT the similarly-colored Taiwanese) feel some weight from the dictatorship were they live/grew up/have parents in?
- 0xy 6y agoThat was never suggested. Zoom is developed almost entirely in China, which means it is effectively a Chinese company under full influence of the CCP.
- tw04 6y agoReally? And which part of "local law" required Zoom to close accounts of US citizens in the US who weren't breaking any US Laws? https://news.sky.com/story/zoom-disables-accounts-of-chinese-dissidents-for-commemorating-tiananmen-square-12004693 https://news.sky.com/story/zoom-disables-accounts-of-chinese... >The suspension targeted Humanitarian China, an organisation based in the US, after it held a call with roughly 250 people, including a number who dialled in from China.
- brenschluss 6y agoSame reason why Google censored itself for China in 2006. Did people think Google was a 'Chinese company'? Note that this was before Google set up a presence in China. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/4645596.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/4645596.stm
- mapcars 6y agoI don't see how it's the same. In Zoom's case organization was in US and call organization was in US and company works by US laws. Why would they censor these accounts? Google on the other hand had to do it to operate in China, had to submit to Chinese regulations. The same would be if they blocked Gmail of US citizens because of discussions related to China.
- SahAssar 6y agoI think you're missing the point. Google censored itself in china based on Chinese requests. Zoom censored itself in the US based on Chinese requests. There's a pretty big difference IMO.
- tw04 6y agoI guess I don't consider that the same thing at all. They're censoring searches coming from china to google.cn (hosted in China). They didn't really have a choice, the servers are in China, the users are in China. What they aren't doing is actively blocking users from China getting to www.google.com, and they aren't censoring searches Chinese users do on www.google.com because those resources aren't hosted in China and aren't subject to Chinese law. Zoom on the other hand IS blocking users from China accessing resources in the US and while they may have "undone" the ban, they banned US users from their platform for breaking a Chinese law that they aren't subject to. Namely talking about the Tienanmen Square massacre.
- thoraway1010 6y agoLet's be 100% clear. Based on a complaint from china regarding non-Chinese citizens with non-china accounts, zoom cancelled the non-china accounts. Full stop. Let that sink in. If you are wondering who zoom will accommodate you have your answer. This is a fact. This is what we are calling "racism"?
- maxmcd 6y agoDefending something as "NOT a Chinese company" or not a Chinese citizen (as if those would allow certain assumptions about the actions of individuals) is still xenophobic framing. People are people and are capable of independent thought and actions. We can be upset at power structures and at their effects. Taking that further to make assumptions about groups of people is racist.
- g-b-r 6y ago"Chinese" are not a race, and assuming that groups of people are somewhat more likely to be subject to some power structure, is not racism or xenophobia. You'll get a Liu Xiaobo once in a while, but much more often you'll have people that, while easily wonderful as people per se, are disgracefully forced, or have been convinced to, do some things that they shouldn't do.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shaan1 6y agoDude, you need to think first. Handing over data to CCP ? thats genocide.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]