14 ms·
"To make this possible, Free/Basic users seeking access to E2EE will participate in a one-time process that will prompt the user for additional pieces of inform
by fsflover 6y ago
"To make this possible, Free/Basic users seeking access to E2EE will participate in a one-time process that will prompt the user for additional pieces of information, such as verifying a phone number via a text message. Many leading companies perform similar steps on account creation to reduce the mass creation of abusive accounts."
Perfect instrument to collect more personal data.
- rootsudo 6y agoZoom is evil. Also, fun note - just noticed Eric Yuan posted that and also created Zoom. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Yuan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Yuan Eric S. Yuan (Chinese: 袁征; pinyin: Yuán Zhēng; born 1970) is a Chinese-American billionaire businessman, and the CEO and founder of Zoom Video Communications, of which he owns 22%. No wonder why they have to play party with CCP.
- skrebbel 6y agoWait, your point is that Zoom is evil because the founder is Chinese?
- m-p-3 6y agoBecause of its inevitable ties and implicit subservience to the CCP.
- pesfandiar 6y agoThe only "relevant" information found in the quote in the GP comment is the nationality of the CEO. How does one jump from the CEO's nationality to inevitable ties and implicit subservience to CCP?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- briandear 6y agoNationality is not a race. Nationality implies a connection with a specific country. And when that specific country is a vast wasteland for human rights and privacy and civil liberties, then yes, it’s relevant.
- jatone 6y agoignoring the quote for a second we know a few things about this CEO and zoom. 1. zoom's application is sending data to Chinese servers separate from the application functionality servers. 2. the CEO is from china, I'm going to assume he has relatives in china. 3. we know CCP is a completely fucked up government with an absolutely horrible history of civil rights violations, genocide, etc. I wouldn't put it past CCP to be pressuring the CEO by threatening relatives who live in china. this wouldn't be unheard of for CCP. add the the unnecessary data transfer to chinese servers makes it look really bad. its a fairly reasonable conclusion to draw that the CEO is compromised if all the above holds true. more extreme conclusions could just as easily be drawn from that same data that he is literally a foreign agent for china.
- shaan1 6y agoVery true.
- pesfandiar 6y agoI find myself agreeing with most of your points. I mainly took issue with taking a shortcut from "being born and raised in China" to being a hostile Chinese agent (and we don't even know if the CEO has relatives in China that can be leveraged anyway).
- mcbutterbunz 6y agoDidn't Zoom block a US based activist on the request of the Chinese government? I'm not arguing that there is complete subservience to the CCP but this censorship seems like a line was crossed. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/11/technology/zoom-china-tiananmen-square.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/11/technology/zoom-china-tia... Edit: Let me also state that I'm not entirely sure what OP's argument was, considering the comment was deleted. I'm merely stating that there seems to be some cooperation with the CCP and Zoom.
- pesfandiar 6y agoI'm aware of Zoom's track record, and it could certainly be scrutinized, criticized, or even boycotted. What we have here is going from "CEO was born and raised in China" to "No wonder why they have to play party with CCP" and "inevitable ties and implicit subservience to the CCP". I can't see the logical connection in the absence of other information. Don't you see a problem with assuming someone's motives purely from their country of origin?
- g-b-r 6y agoIs it licit to at least keep it into account? Or we need Xi Jinping's permission?
- admax88q 6y agoYeah what the fuck, that was some weird casual racism you don't expect to see on HN.
- rootsudo 6y agoI disagree it's "racism." It's how the CCP operates. We can say the same story for different super powers from previous times. People suspected German Ambassador to USA for being a bosch spy. Founder of a communications company isn't that far off. Huawei is a great example. Founders of a company control the companies direction.
- hakka-nyu-su 6y agoExcept Eric is not any sort of govt or party representative. He is a naturalized American of Chinese ancestry. In history, this kind of scapegoating was counterproductive.
- anonymousab 6y agoThe CCP can and will exert pressure on family members to get expats and former citizens to do what they want. They're not the only country to do so, not by a long shot, but they are particularly brazen about it. Though I think the CEO is less relevant than the critical amount of developers Zoom relies on that are directly living under and subject to CCP malfeasance.
- justicezyx 6y ago> The CCP can and will exert pressure on family members to get expats and former citizens to do what they want. Could you give a few such cases?
- mthoms 6y agoHere's a bunch. https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/01/31/china-families-interpol-targets-harassed https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/01/31/china-families-interpol-...
- rootsudo 6y agoWhile I understand that on the surface seems "bad", you have to understand the CCP taps into people worldwide, and while I don't know his position per se, or finances -- or connection with China today. It doesn't paint a great picture, especially with espionage and CCP tactics. Look at previous German and USA interference w/ GE, Bosch, -- it's the same story. Except now it's highlight as "bad" to point out that connection.
- ilikehurdles 6y agoI'm disgusted that in 2020, Americans continue to use the same racist, unfounded smears againts people based on their ethnicity just as they did when they were throwing Japanese-Americans into internment camps.
- smt88 6y agoThere are plenty of HN users who won't (or wouldn't, in an ideal world) use any US-based software because of NSA interference. The issue is national origin, not ethnicity. Japanese Americans were thrown into camps for the same reason, but we're not talking about jailing anyone here. We're talking about avoiding a specific product. Another difference is that Japanese Americans were put into camps regardless of how many generations removed from being Japanese they were. No one is arguing that CCP has control over Chinese Americans whose ancestors immigrated here in the 1800s. It's about people who literally grew up in China and/or still have close family there for CCP to threaten.
- justicezyx 6y ago> The issue is national origin, not ethnicity. Japanese Americans were thrown into camps for the same reason ``` Of 127,000 Japanese Americans living in the continental United States at the time of the Pearl Harbor attack, 112,000 resided on the West Coast.[9] About 80,000 were Nisei (literal translation: "second generation"; American-born Japanese with U.S. citizenship) and Sansei ("third generation"; the children of Nisei). The rest were Issei ("first generation") immigrants born in Japan who were ineligible for U.S. citizenship under U.S. law.[10] ``` From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_Americans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment_of_Japanese_America... What do you suggest? Should there be a upper limit on the generations to be considered not originated from a nation state? According to what happened to WWII Japanese ethnic Americans, that number seems have to be > 3? And remember that what happened in WWII Japanese internment camp is an evidence that "national origin" as an association was plainly wrong, from the same wiki page: ``` In 1980, under mounting pressure from the Japanese American Citizens League and redress organizations,[30] President Jimmy Carter opened an investigation to determine whether the decision to put Japanese Americans into concentration camps had been justified by the government. He appointed the Commission on Wartime Relocation and Internment of Civilians (CWRIC) to investigate the camps. The Commission's report, titled Personal Justice Denied, found little evidence of Japanese disloyalty at the time and concluded that the incarceration had been the product of racism ``` Emphasis on the last statement: `the incarceration had been the product of racism`.
- throwaway9482 6y agoA lot of Chinese values are at odds with American values. Someone who is genuinely pro-Chinese values threatens things we often take for granted here in America
- crazygringo 6y agoUnfortunately, I have to post this comment again, from just 3 days ago [1]. Also remember that Eric Yuan is an American citizen, not a Chinese citizen. He switched. Original comment: When will this meme die? Zoom is NOT a Chinese company. It is incorporated in and headquartered in the US. Like any American company ever, it follows US laws in the US, and local laws in other companies where it operates. End of story. Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? At the end of the day, they're a public, profit-driven corporation trying to make lots of money across the entire world. It's not like they're secretly and nefariously doing the CCP's bidding, which seems to be the veiled suggestion people keep making. Seriously, every time someone brings up that Zoom is "really" a Chinese company, it comes across as borderline racism or conspiracy-mongering or both. And while I'd usually never comment on someone using a throwaway account, in this case when you're pushing these kinds of shady "stronger than the more-commonly-discussed" insituations, I think using a throwaway here is representative of exactly the kind of astroturfing that spreads malicious rumors without evidence. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23510886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23510886
- throwaway9482 6y ago> Yes their culture certainly has stronger cultural internal ties to China, due to the number of Chinese employees, but what has that got to do with anything? A lot.
- xwowsersx 6y agoHow is it racist to suggest that Zoom has Chinese influences (seemingly not farfetched based on the equity ownership mentioned above and not at all disputed based on the technicality of Zoom being a US company)?
- maxmcd 6y agoIt is not racist to suggest that the Chinese government influences companies. It is racist to suggest that Chinese people are automatically predispositioned to certain actions.
- dang 6y agoYou started a wretched flamewar with this post. That was vandalism. Nationalistic and ethnic flamewar will get you banned here. So will personal attacks and insinuated slurs. People have been hounded off this site in the past by comments along these lines. That's shameful, and we want no more of it. No, we're not defending communism or the communist party. We're trying to defend Hacker News against (a) mob behaviors and (b) self-immolation. Here are some recent comments about this, which include other links to plenty of past explanations. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20mob&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- Nextgrid 6y agoTheir argument doesn't make sense. The objective behind verifying accounts is to prevent spammers creating lots of spam accounts and using those to spam. However, spammers rarely care if their spam is encrypted, so putting E2E behind verification won't do anything as far as spammers are concerned - they'll happily keep spamming using the unencrypted accounts. There's some other reason behind this that isn't about reducing spam.
- damanamathos 6y agoI think their concern is paedophile rings using large group E2EE for live child abuse with completely anonymous accounts.
- calvinmorrison 6y agoOnly 4 comments in and we hit one of the four boogymen of the civil rights apocalypse. How many comments until we get to domestic terrorism or illegal drugs?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> one of the four boogymen of the civil rights apocalypse The public is willing trade away privacy in exchange for protection from certain categories of risk. Instead of denying that, one can lean into it by ensuring strict definitions and enforcement options within those categories while preserving full privacy for those without. Arguing pedophile rings and terrorism are a cost of a privacy policy is a good way to sink that policy.
- aspenmayer 6y agoI would make a cogent argument to rebuff your straw man, but it's not worth my time if you don't share a priori assumptions with me about E2EE being uncrackable. It's just math. I don't see why the talk of trade-offs even is relevant to the discussion. People will use secure tools with E2EE or they will suffer the consequences of not doing so. Doing illegal things is already illegal. Banning or watering down E2EE so that it becomes no long E2EE is throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- m3kw9 6y agoYou also signed up an account for banks, they collect a ton of data on all your payments, got a problem with that? You gonna say yeah Zoom is not a bank, but your prose is the data collection part
- identity0 6y ago> Why care about privacy in one area when this completely unrelated area does it worse?
- bravoetch 6y agoIt's perfectly ok to be against data collection in any form even when you are subjected to it on another service. Just because someone is subjected to data collection knowingly, does not mean they condone it.
- yellowapple 6y ago> You also signed up an account for banks, they collect a ton of data on all your payments, got a problem with that? Yes.
- starpilot 6y agoFirst rule of HN commenting: Assume bad faith.
- duxup 6y agoWhile I share your distaste for such assumptions. I believe Zoomed has earned the privilege of folks being highly skeptical of their actions / motivations.
- Aunche 6y agoIs there any E2EE app that doesn't require verification? Whatsapp does. Even Signal requires a phone number.
- 2StepsOutOfLine 6y agohttps://riot.im/ https://riot.im/ lets you sign up without even an email
- pdkl95 6y agohttps://otr.cypherpunks.ca/ https://otr.cypherpunks.ca/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-the-Record_Messaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-the-Record_Messaging
- jokowueu 6y agoRiot/matrix
- captn3m0 6y agoThreema.
- fsflover 6y agohttps://matrix.org https://matrix.org
- alecmg 6y agoTox.chat with added bonus of no central server
- SomeHacker44 6y agoDiscord recently demanded my cell phone number to be able to type messages. I declined, contacted customer service, who offered no other way to authenticate. I will not be using Discord anymore and will recommend to everyone I know to avoid it as well. There is no need to use my cell phone or any telephone number when you already have a means of communication via email or any other channel.
- 0xy 6y agoIf you live in the US, burner SIMs are cheap and anonymous.