5 ms·
And this is all because the President got mad at Twitter on the right and the left always think more government is the answer. This is what happens when you ge
by scarface74 6y ago
And this is all because the President got mad at Twitter on the right and the left always think more government is the answer.
This is what happens when you get government involvement in tech.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoNo. Nothing is ever this simple. Even cursory search would show that this is an ongoing saga linked to LEOs displeasure with encryption. I am not a fan of Trump personally, but no reason to let it cloud your judgment.
- nojito 6y agoThat's just one scenario. The more broader one is tech companies refusing to adhere to preventing federal crimes from being committed on their platforms. At the end of the day, it's expensive to police your platform so they went with the immunity route.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoYou are right. Even parent post is right in a sense that there multiple reasons. I think your explanation covers tech sector perspective ( they are in a sweet spot now and don't want to lose it ). I maintain that the main reason it is happening is the steady push to make policing easy again.
- salawat 6y agoThey're a platform, andaren'taspecifically vested law enforcement organization. Think about it. What you're really asking for there is for these companies to become part of the apparatus, which means by definition they can no longer be seen as private businesses and arguably, become unfit to do anything on. Imagine a world where law enforcement is given access to an oracle by tech companies capable of spelling out every individual who broke any law in any jurisdiction at anytime, anywhere today, so long as they use the platform. If you don't already feel uncomfortable, or see why that would impact the desirability/feasibility of the system already, you're probably not trying very hard. You're basically handing law enforcement a tool capable of handing reign of the country over to the auspices of prosecutorial discretion. The one thing that has kept LE in check has always been the high price tag of due process involved with depriving someone of their rights. This means it is strongly confined to only that potential pool of people that generally meet the criteria for clear and present threats to society (your agreement as to the priorities over time may beg to differ, bit the point is it is fundamentally limited to a very small fraction of the population). With the integration possible through tech, you cannot afford to happily hand over records in digital format. It is simply too bloody dangerous a tool in the wrong hands. Furthermore, no one wants to accept that sometimes societal goods are bundled with the empowerment of bad use cases since malicious actors are equally buoyed by societal infrastructure. I don't see people clamoring for TV manufacturers to start recording the inside of homes because there may be pedophiles in them. I don't see people swarming in droves to say "eavesdrop and surveil me" once they know that is essentially what goes on in tech. No one wants that. They grudgingly accept it because no one else wants to or can figure out how to implement something without that that also allows the type of information propagation people actually want, which is for people they want to know more about them to have greater access, and the rest to actually require substantial effort to get at that information.
- tw04 6y agoIt literally is about Trump being angry that Twitter fact checked his outright lies about mail-in voting. There are absolutely other powers that stand to benefit, or are pushing the agenda as well, but to claim it's not a result of Trump's hissy fit is ridiculous. https://deadline.com/2020/05/donald-trump-twitter-social-media-1202944096/ https://deadline.com/2020/05/donald-trump-twitter-social-med... The executive order was signed by exactly one individual who was completely open about why he was signing it.
- vorpalhex 6y agoThis was being proposed by Barr and co a few months ago, the current Twitter debacle (A tweetacle? Tweetgate?) just happens to be an excellent case to push it forward with support. Before that it was proposed repeatedly by several Democrats, especially during the Birther nonsense.
- tw04 6y agoI guess it's a good thing I already said other parties had an interest in the topic at hand. Unless you know something I don't, Barr doesn't have the power to sign an executive order. Neither do any of the Democrats. There's exactly 1 reason the executive order was signed and it wasn't Democrats or Barr, nothing I stated was inaccurate. Appreciate the downvote because you don't like reality.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI think you are assuming that the order is a cause rather a convenient excuse to pursue a specific agenda. I appreciate the approach, by a person signing it is just a convenient lightning rod. Note that it seems to be working very well.
- tw04 6y agoA convenient excuse for what? The president doesn't need an excuse to sign an executive order, he needs exactly 0 permission from anyone to do it. This isn't some new law drafted by congress that needs political cover to move through the process, it's an executive order.
- save_ferris 6y agoWhy isn't the market holding Facebook accountable for the numerous transgressions we've seen coming out of that company over the last several years? Because people don't understand or care how the money is made, which fundamentally undermines the argument that the market is always right. From broad, repeated invasions of online privacy to numerous scandals involving state-sponsored disinformation campaigns, Facebook shows time and again that they are not responsible corporate stewards of the internet. Zuckerberg has got to be one of the least popular Fortune 500 CEOs and yet he's completely invincible, investors don't want to touch him. So how do you propose to hold such a company accountable if not through regulation and oversight?
- philistine 6y agoInvestors don’t want to touch Zuckerberg because they simply cannot. He has enough shares to be unremovable.
- save_ferris 6y agoI don’t believe this is true. If an Icahn-like activist investor shorted FB and successfully triggered a mass sell off tanking FB stock, it would be really hard for Zuckerberg to survive that pressure, and he’d be financially incentivized not to. You’re right in that the board doesn’t have the power to oust him, but collective investor action could. It’s hard to find people who want to rattle one of the most consistently performing tech stocks, though. Unfortunately, I think the chance of something like this happening is nil.
- throwaway98797 6y agoDo you think zuck cares if he’s worth 100b vs 20b?
- nothisisamerica 6y agoFacebook was fined $5,000,000,000 by the FTC for what the president's chief executive of campaign's company (Cambridge Analytics) did: they used military info ops on American people in an election. And now they want editorial control over publicly owned information services? Why don't they (the installed alt-right) go claim that the government deserves editorial control of the papers as well? Clearly that's the issue needing attention here; not obstructing an obstruction investigation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica_d... and up a bit further: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCL_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCL_Group The current administration just gave away $500,000,000,000 of taxpayers' money and now won't even release the list of who took the money? And you think that the problem is Facebook's editorial transparency and lack of accountability? Kindly review https://usaspending.gov https://usaspending.gov and tell me where our money is going