29 ms·
Two parts of this short and powerful piece really leapt out at me: > all under the auspices of a hard line Republican administration > Washington under any ad
by roenxi 6y ago
Two parts of this short and powerful piece really leapt out at me:
> all under the auspices of a hard line Republican administration
> Washington under any administration will have no choice but to bail out all the state and local agencies and every insolvent pension scheme wholesale
There are underlying problems being forced to the surface by COVID that go deeper than political parties. Somewhere between the 1970s and 2000s American politicians as a class (and possibly a supermajority of voters too) have accepted that running up debt literally does not matter.
The economy is brutal. It is a fabricated social concept built on trust right up until the moment it breaks out into the physical world and things that desperately need to happen stop happening because it doesn't make any economic sense.
The persistent bailouts are making losers of people who make good long term decisions. Sooner or later, nobody will be left who makes good long term decisions. Such people have been exorcised from the financial industry.
- gold_standard 6y ago>Somewhere between the 1970s and 2000s I think you'll find it was precisely 1971.
- AlexanderDhoore 6y agohttps://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- ghj 6y agoSome of the arrows are so randomly placed it reminds me of: https://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations https://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kjh2110/the-10-most-bizarre-correlations https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kjh2110/the-10-most-biz...
- gassius 6y agoThey all seems to point to 1971, nothing random about that I understand that correlation != causation, but it also seems obvious that getting out of Bretton Woods has some major impact
- voldacar 6y agoAgreed that many of them are spurious (or the cause of other things that probably have no causal link to Bretton-Woods, such as no-fault divorce or the war on drugs) but there are still a lot that do seem to have a sharp discontinuity at 1971, particularly income vs productivity, and CPI, which is actually a more frightening chart in my opinion
- pjc50 6y agoThe "oil crisis" was a couple of years later but could be seen in the production figures from 1971. I find it odd that it's not mentioned. Oil was far more important for the US economic miracle than gold!
- api 6y agoI too have mused endlessly about what happened in the early 1970s. It seems like we really, really went off the rails in so many ways at that time. I love that site for its graph collection but I am not convinced of its hypothesis (nor do I completely dismiss it). The end of super-cheap easy domestic oil has long been my go-to hypothesis for what happened around 1971. Monetary systems and policy are social constructs, but energy is physically fundamental. Everything that has happened since then including reckless monetary policy and wage stagnation could be argued to be symptoms of the rising real cost of energy. By real cost of energy I mean physics, EROEI. Wage stagnation happens because without super cheap energy the actual physical cost of providing increasing living standards to a huge number of people become too high. Even if they live lavishly, a smaller number of rich people don't consume nearly as much energy as a huge number of middle class people. As a result the rich are not affected. Reckless financial and monetary policies can be explained by politicians who don't understand physics trying to get the magic unicorns to come back. If either solar/wind + batteries or some form of nuclear power can be made to scale well enough, we may see a return to the post-war era. Otherwise we will not, and returning to the gold standard (or Bitcoin) won't make much difference. I'm pretty optimistic about renewable power. I glance at this every once in a while: http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.aspx http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.aspx During the day California often runs on >50% solar/wind. Two decades ago that was a small single digit percentage. It's pretty spectacular. If we can scale storage similarly and then if the costs of both continue to fall for a while due to industrial scaling of production, we could be back to the 50s but with a renewable instead of non-renewable basis. A fusion breakthrough or finally figuring out how to safely and sustainably scale fission would have a similar outcome. BTW: I also wonder if you can explain the Chinese miracle in energy terms. China just decided to chase growth and fuck the environment, so they went wild with cheap coal. The magic was not only using cheap coal but doing so with no scrubbers (which consume a surprising amount of power) and no other energetically costly environmental controls to speak of, maximizing physical EROEI. They lifted vast numbers of people to middle class status and became a superpower at the cost of accelerating climate change and air that burns your eyes.
- aa66tt55rr44 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1970_United_Kingdom_general_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1970_United_Kingdom_general_el...
- clarkevans 6y agoIn March of 1971 the house eliminated "teller votes", where representatives' votes on amendments to bills were private; the system then moved to recorded votes, initially with red/green cards, and then in 1973 with electronic votes. After March of 1971, the public could learn exactly which representatives voted for exactly which amendments. In practice, this accountability change meant that lobbyists and their clients gained knowledge of which representatives defected and which ones towed line.
- pyuser583 6y agoThis is a very unpopular opinion, but transparency is not necessarily a good thing.
- csharptwdec19 6y agoIt looks bad here because in this case the root cause is the quid-pro-quo/pay-to-play lobbying system. The transparency SHOULD be good in that it should be able to show the electorate whether reps did what they said they would. In reality it is, as mentioned above, instead used to appease a small but powerful body of the electorate.
- stronglikedan 6y agoIf I had to pick between transparency and lobbying (in its current form), I'd take transparency.
- war1025 6y agoThe person saying transparency wasn't a good thing was saying that because transparency allows for more efficient lobbying, it has resulted in a more easily gamed system. The tradeoff they are pointing out isn't "transparency or lobbying" it's "transparency + rampant lobbying vs secrecy + less effective lobbying"
- TeMPOraL 6y agoRelated: there's a reason lack of transparency in individual voting is critical for fair elections.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoThat is interesting. Though is appears to try to tie unrelated things together. For example, incarceration rates are related to the War on Drugs that started around that time - which isn't related to the gold standard. The War on Drugs was declared in 1971 but it wasn't monetary policy.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI think History has shown that Nixon was a bad president on many levels.
- chrisco255 6y agoWell yeah I think even I bought into it at some point. The line would go "as long as our debt to GDP ratio stays relatively steady, we'll be ok"...but what happens if another great depression happens and the growth dips 10-15% and flat lines from there? Then your debt will grow faster than your GDP and eventually it will crush the economy. All the uncomfortable conversations about complex trade-offs and budget cuts have got to occur and nobody is wanting to have that convo. I think it started in the 60s with the Vietnam War, the Space program and Johnson's great society programs. And then Nixon took us off the gold peg, and we were free to print as much as we wanted. MMT is pretty scary to me. It's never really been tested long term at scale and mainly exists as a theory. But I know that's the end game for the Fed and that's the trajectory we're on.
- RobertoG 6y agoThe public debt is just the accumulate of past deficits. If the Fed is owning the debt you are paying interest to yourself. The only risk is inflation and this is not something to be worried at the moment. MMT is only a description of how the systems work. But if by "test it", you mean that the Central Bank is backing the public debt, Japan have been doing for, at least, twenty years.
- joejerryronnie 6y agoWhy do you think we maintain the world’s largest military by orders of magnitude?
- averros 6y agoEconomy is NOT a social construct, fabricated or not. Economic laws are direct consequences of physical laws (i.e. scarcity is the result of Fermi statistics which makes material things to take space and of the no-cloning theorem which means the material things cannot just pop into existence because somebody wished them), or otherwise rather tautological mathematical statements (for example the first welfare theorem or the law of comparative advantage). Economy doesn't require humanity or consciousness to exist, it's a resource allocation and optimization algorithm. So is political means of acquiring wealth - this is known as intra-species aggression and is common to all social species; this is another, older, and less efficient, algorithm for resource allocation. Basically, every time politicians and their enforcers barge in to "fix" things they break the efficient algorithm (aka "market economy") to replace it with the older one (aka "the biggest ape gets to boss others around"). And, yes, it doesn't make any economic sense. "Bailouts" are nothing more than taking from many people by force and giving to few politically-connected ones. It's just indirect form of force: instead of simply looting, they print more money - but everybody else is prevented by force by doing the same, so they have no choice but to see the value of their money to decline and be transferred to the recipients of new money.
- crocal 6y agoI have to disagree. Economy is the interface between producers and consumers of resources. It’s big time a social construct, and therefore the subject of political action. Importantly, the idea that state intervention is bad for the economy as a universal rule is simply wrong. In the long run, history clearly teaches that mixed economy work (e.g. a la Keynes), while laissez-faire (e.g. a la Friedman) or centralized economies (e.g. a la Communist) don’t. Striking the right mix requires society input in the form of political debate. We desperately need this to happen now in the West. While I have nothing about Jeff Bezos as a person, but billionaires simply should not be allowed to exist. They are the symptom of a « Laissez Faire » system in terminal state.
- JackFr 6y agoJeff Bezos became a billionaire by making the lives of Amazon’s customers better. Sam Walton did more to improve the lot of poor families than most government programs. (Those guys at least built something. Why does no one complain about America’s grandpa Warren Buffett. He just shuffled around money, plays with warrants and options (while telling others not to) and makes a couple hundred million by going to Congress and talking his book. )
- pjc50 6y ago> running up debt literally does not matter. The creditors don't seem to mind it either, happily buying hundred-year bonds with near-zero interest rates. Also remember that every "saving" is also a "debt" on the other side of somebody's ledger. Quite a lot of that corporate and government debt is "savings"; $270 billion of it is owed to Apple alone. http://thewire.fiig.com.au/article/2018/04/24/how-apple-invests-its-$270bn-cash-stockpile http://thewire.fiig.com.au/article/2018/04/24/how-apple-inve... > The economy is brutal. It is a fabricated social concept built on trust right up until the moment it breaks out into the physical world and things that desperately need to happen stop happening because it doesn't make any economic sense. This was one of the questions that Keynes explored - how it is possible to have productive capacity idle because there isn't enough credit for people to buy the products. It's also the idea behind a lot of the "green new deal" schemes; do things that need to be done but don't offer a specific return, but benefit society and the planet as a whole. > The persistent bailouts are making losers of people who make good long term decisions How, exactly? What "long term decisions" would not have been worse off if the 2008 bailouts hadn't been made and a large chunk of Western retail banking had gone insolvent, tying up accounts until it could have been resolved? There is an important difference between "this business is no longer viable", and "this business is perfectly viable in the future but is experiencing a temporary shock which its cashflow and trade credit cannot cover".
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoThere's a difference between the world as we know it cannot exist without banks as we know them,and banks cannot exist without the people who led us into this mess. There must be strict liability against those whose bad decisions lead to incalculable suffering for countless people. Hard stop. We can debate the specific consequences (banned from positions of authority, fines, debt, prison, etc). But we must not allow those with demonstrable bad decision making abilities to continue to play roulette with the lives of others. Likewise, good decisions cannot be allowed to justify or excuse bad ones.
- roenxi 6y ago> How, exactly? [0] Uber, an 11 year old company, IPO-ed in 2019, losses were >1/3 of their $14 billion revenue that year. There is a level of crazy afoot there. The shares being worth money to anyone is alarming, and indicative that something is very broken. Large amounts of debt is an obvious answer to 'where did the money to fuel this bonfire ultimately come from' > Also remember that every "saving" is also a "debt" on the other side of somebody's ledger. And if the money on the debt side isn't used prudently, both the debtor and saver end up with nothing at the end of a sad story. The saver loses out more, because they could have been living it up with more resources, rather than directing them to the debtor. What the loan is used for in real terms (useful infrastructure, vanity projects, wasted, etc) matters. I don't mind what the accounting identities do if I get a nice place to live, cheap electricity and lots of food. But the loans at the moment aren't going towards big construction in desirable areas, nuclear power plants and securing food supplies. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uber
- rbanffy 6y ago> all under the auspices of a hard line Republican administration This only means "socialism for the rich, brutal unregulated capitalism for everyone else, because it's their fault they aren't rich anyway".
- commandlinefan 6y ago> good long term decisions I'm starting to wonder if good long term decisions aren't things like learning to grow food and stocking up on ammo at this point.
- N1H1L 6y ago> The persistent bailouts are making losers of people who make good long term decisions. Sooner or later, nobody will be left who makes good long term decisions. Such people have been exorcised from the financial industry. Could be used for the environment too. Unlike money, CO2 and temperature are real things, and rather than worrying about imaginary stuff like money, it would be prudent to be fiscally conservative regarding our carbon budget.