21 ms·
Gravity Is Not Like the Other Forces
- m3kw9 6y agoCan someone explain Why there is gravity without drawing on math?
- koheripbal 6y agoWe don't really know, even if we DO use math. It's just a fundamental property of the universe that has no explanation (yet). String theory tries to formulate why... but that's all just theory for now.
- Extigy 6y agoImagine that you are standing on the equator of Earth, facing North. Now imagine a friend is also standing somewhere on the equator -- not too far away, but a fair distance -- also facing North. Now, if you both start walking you'll find that you begin to move closer together. The distance between you shrinks as you walk, until eventually you meet at the North Pole. The "force" that is pulling you together is like gravity in that it is caused by the curvature of the Earth's surface as you travel across it. With gravity the curvature is intrinsic to space-time itself and is affected by mass. Generally more mass means more curvature. So if you sit two objects in space, at rest with respect to one-another (but still travelling forwards in time), you will find they are pulled together and eventually meet in the same way you and your friend were pulled together and met at the North Pole. You might ask why mass affects the curvature of space-time? That I don't know the answer to.
- machiaweliczny 6y agoIm fine with curvature analogy but why things "move"?
- chousuke 6y agoAnswering a "why" is a bit difficult when it comes to reality. It's just the way it is, and if it were different, you would be asking why it is that way instead, if you still existed at all. If you're instead asking what causes the "force" you feel as gravity, then I suppose that can actually be usefully answered with the usual disclaimers about scientific models being only as good as their predictive power. Fortunately, one can accurately explain many phenomena with Newton's theories and even more with general relativity. My own (layman) understanding is that the attracting effect of gravity is caused by the shape of spacetime itself; all objects within spacetime generally move "straight", but they must also conform to the shape of spacetime. However, those objects also affect the "shape" such that very massive objects have a macro-scale noticeable effect on the trajectory of other objects. and effectively what is "straight" is dependent on the local region of spacetime. I like to visualize it as a straight line on a piece of paper and how that line changes shape as the paper is bent.
- phn 6y agoI know this is tangential, but as lay person regarding physics I am stuck on the following thought experiment regarding gravity: We know about gravitational potential energy. We harness it all the time with dams and whatnot. Generally speaking, when we lift matter high above, we get some of the used energy back when it falls back down. But when we talk about sending say, a spaceship into space, it may fall on a different planet, with a different gravity (a function of the planet's mass), changing the amount of energy yielded by the fall. The question is: Where is the energy stored in the meantime? Where does the extra energy, if the ship falls into a heavier planet, come from? It seems that the energy is being stored somewhere, and that matter itself allows us to tap into that, but is not the place where it is stored. Is there anything I can read to better understand what we know about this?
- simonh 6y agoThat turns out to be a really interesting question. In physics the gravitational energy of a massive body is considered to be negative. That takes a bit of getting used to. If you consider the universe after the Big Bang, it consisted of extremely thinly dispersed clouds of hydrogen and helium atoms. Over billions of years these collapsed into galaxies and stars. During the process of that collapse these atoms accelerated towards each other, impacted and heated up considerably due to the release of kinetic energy. This kinetic energy has to come from somewhere, so we consider that the energy of the gravitational field of a star or planet is negative energy. It's an energy deficit. As an side, it is estimated that if you add up the energy in star, including the matter it's composed of, and deduct the negative energy of it's gravitational field they cancel out. It seems likely that the net energy of the universe may well be very close to zero. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-energy_universe
- goldenkey 6y agoI am happy that you provided the only realistic answer here. Gravity is the negative to light...radiation pressure pushes and gravity pulls. We live in a yin yang universe. Like Alan Watts would say, the universe is in the middle of cosmic dance, and eventually all positives and negatives will neutralize and we will be back where we started. This bides well for cyclic theories of cosmology. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_pressure https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_pressure Radiation pressure - Wikipedia
- exabrial 6y agoI always find it interesting we have the photon for light, electron for electricity, but no particle for gravity.
- snarf21 6y agoInteresting.... I wonder if it is just a matter of time and focus.
- close04 6y agoOr really difficult math. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton
- auntienomen 6y agoWe haven't observed the graviton, but it's something theorists routinely discuss. Basically, any quantum theory of gravity that reduces to general relativity in its classical limit will pass through a semi-classical regime where it's well-approximated by gravitons.
- bardworx 6y agoThere is a hypothetical particle named Graviton that would be the force carrier for Gravity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton
- martincmartin 6y ago"In theories of quantum gravity, the graviton is the hypothetical quantum of gravity, an elementary particle that mediates the force of gravity." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brummm 6y agoTechnically, the photon is also the particle for electricity, not the electron.
- tzs 6y agoImagine some kind of alien life form that arose and evolved in intergalactic space. They evolve intelligence and start developing physics. Their physics knows about electromagnetism and maybe the strong and weak nuclear forces, but they have never seen any sufficient concentrations of mass to notice gravity. They would still know about mass but for them it would just be a property of matter that determines how strongly it reacts to force. Their model of how force works would be that for each kind of force there is some kind of charge. How much of that kind of force you have between two bodies is determined by how much of that kind of charge each has and how far apart they are. How each body responds to that force is determined by its mass. Mass and charge are independent for all of their known forces. You can have two bodies with the same mass but different charge for a given kind force, or two bodies with the same charge for that force but different mass. Eventually they would discover gravity and I think it would immediately stand out as fundamentally different from the other forces because its charge is not independent of mass. You double the gravitational charge on a body you also double its mass. You double its mass you also double its gravitational charge.
- gpderetta 6y agoIt is not so different. To double the electric charge of an electron you also have to double its mass.
- rcxdude 6y agoYes, but particles like muons exist with much larger mass but the same charge.
- saalweachter 6y agoRandom question: do any particles exist with less mass but the same charge as electrons?
- some_furry 6y agoNo: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elementary_particle#/media/File:Standard_Model_of_Elementary_Particles.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elementary_particle#/media/Fil...
- markkat 6y agoI’ve long thought gravity is more likely to be the product of space between masses, not something that alters it. My thinking is the “alteration” of we perceive as gravity is lopsided entropy due to a field with a gradient of space. I wrote this thought experiment years ago, which was the start of this way of thinking: http://corpusdord.blogspot.com/2006/02/matter-space-and-time.html?m=1 http://corpusdord.blogspot.com/2006/02/matter-space-and-time...
- jcims 6y agoMaybe gravity is just diffusion of energy as it tries to smooth the tremendous discontinuities between its condensed form (mass) and free (?) form (vacuum).
- rurban 6y agoThey should have started with Newton, not Einstein. Heisenberg is also missing. Newton was so excited to detect this new supernatural attracting force over great distances to hold the planets together, as clear proof that God exists. Mechanics cannot explain contact-less attracting forces, in mechanics there are only repelling forces, caused by direct contact. Newton never gave up and disappeared into this gravity=god hole forever. Quantum-mechanics had the same problem, as Heisenberg detected. The dual nature of particles and waves don't hold for gravity, there cannot be a gravity particle as counterpart to the attracting force. Einstein was the same opinion, but still the Boor folks had their way. Even the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosenstein Paradoxon, which disproved causality in the standard model, was explained away. Same for black holes, the mysteriously postulated dark matter and more.
- ganzuul 6y agoIf you are OK with reversing time then mechanics can explain attractive forces. It then becomes a question of why our perspective is one-sided.
- rurban 6y agoNobody is ok with reversing time. Minkowski limit, yes. Reverse for sure not.
- mnw21cam 6y agoNope, still repulsive forces. Think about it - two balls head towards each other, collide, and move away from each other, having experienced a repulsive force. Reverse time, and it looks exactly the same. Or more mathematically, force is measured in Newtons, which is kg * m / s / s. Reverse the sign of the seconds part of that, and, oh, it's squared so it ends up being exactly the same.
- bArray 6y agoDisclaimer: Zero formal background in Physics, but I want to learn. It has always felt like gravity is the result of some other "thing" going on. There are two reasons for why I believe this: 1. Gravitational waves are weird, the idea that the resulting force of gravity can travel away from where it was created. I can't think of any other examples where something similar happens with another force without something "carrying" it. 2. At lot of the issues we have with our current models come from gravity. If it be on the quantum or Universe scale, our picture of what we believe gravity to be seems to be limited to our localized experience of it. I sometimes try to run through a thought experiment where I try to imagine how gravity, space and time may behave at the very edge of the Universe, because things there surely must seem weird. If space and time cannot be created or destroyed, what is being "traded" to expand the Universe? An alternate idea I've had is that the Universe is not expanding outwards, but expanding inwards, where galaxies roughly stay where there are and the properties of space-time between them changes. We always imagine the Universe in the three dimensional space we experience it in when thinking about gravity, but the quantum scale seems to suggest there must exist other spatial dimensions. Just some brain farts anyway, any reading material people can point me towards I would be highly appreciative :)
- macspoofing 6y ago>Gravitational waves are weird Are they though? I know there is a lot of math behind how exactly gravitational waves behave making specific predictions that stem from GR, but even in the Newtonian sense, something like gravitational waves would necessarily exist. That is, even under Newtonian laws, if a body emits a force like gravity which drops in strength with distance, and if that body moves back and forth in relation to you, you would necessarily experience waves of force.
- codethief 6y ago> That is, even under Newtonian laws, if a body emits a force like gravity which drops in strength with distance, and if that body moves back and forth in relation to you, you would necessarily experience waves of force. Not if you take the term "wave" literally. Any action in Newtonian gravity is assumed to occur instantaneously, so while an observer far away from that body would certainly see the gravitational pull varying in time, this would not be the same as a wave traveling through space.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Gravity Breeds Singularities Gravity or GR? Is there even any reason to take singularities seriously? Aren't singularities simply places where GR as a theory falls flat on its face and therefore singularities don't actually describe any physical phenomena?
- codethief 6y agoThe short answer to your question is: We don't know.
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoI think the big reasons gravity is different are as follows: * very weak (many orders of magnitude less strong than the other forces) * no positive/negative mass 'charges', the gravitational force is attractive only. * works via curvature of spacetime (according to Einstein), instead of the exchange of force particles (e.g. instead of by jiggling fields)
- klank 6y agoYou last point is not necessarily a description of gravity, but a description of the models we use to reason about it.
- bollu 6y agoI put in the work to study GR from Susskind' theoretical minimum (fantastic lecture series: https://theoreticalminimum.com/courses/general-relativity/2012/fall https://theoreticalminimum.com/courses/general-relativity/20... ). I still don't understand GR. Yes I can now say "oh gravity is '''just''' curvature on a lorentizian manifold", but what in the world does it _mean_? My current picture is something like this: A Lorentizian manifold looks locally hyperbolic, so we need to imagine a light cone. Now the curvature of this manifold tells us how we need to distort light cones at different points to build up the full space. How the fuck do I visualize this? Is there some way to embed this in low dimension to play with it? For example, to understand regular curvature, you can play around with a sphere and a cone to get a feel for curvature ~= angle deficit ~= loopy deficit ~= holonomy. I don't know how to visualize the curvature of space-time, and I'm completely unconvinced I actually understand it beyond squiggles on paper. I'd love a way to embed and visualize this. Please tell me if you know how! As an aside: It is definitely possible to get a feel for _hyperbolic geometry_ by playing HyperRogue: (https://roguetemple.com/z/hyper/ https://roguetemple.com/z/hyper/) --- A free roguelike set in hyperbolic space. What I don't grok at all is the _curvature_ across hyperbolic spaces, analogous to how a sphere has _curvature_ across flat spaces. I'd love to know how to get a feel for this.
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoSure, I can explain how to visualise it (I think :) ) First off, a note: lots of people think they know how to visualise GR, but actually don't. For example, explaining with marbles falling down curved rubber sheets doesn't help, because you're using gravity (the marble being pulled down) to explain gravity. And if you think you can just explain it with geodesics along a curved rubber sheet with a heavy weight in the middle, then think about how to explain why a stationary object falls towards the heavy weight. Anyway, here is how to visualise it: Imagine you are driving a car along some surface. We require that each wheel rotates at exactly the same speed with respect to the surface. Now imagine there is a decreasing curvature gradient from left to right across the path of your car - in other words the surface below the left wheel is curving faster than under the right wheel. Seen from above, the left wheel has extra distance to travel in the vertical direction than the right wheel, to achieve a given horizontal distance. This causes the direction of the car to turn slowly to the left - in other words the car is 'gravitationally attracted' to the left - i.e. towards the region of greater curvature, i.e. towards the attracting mass. To explain why static objects are gravitationally attracted to a mass, you just have to realise that according to Einstein, there are no such things as stationary objects (in some sense). Rather, even a 'stationary' object is travelling rapidly through spacetime. To go back to the car metaphor - the car is not stationary, rather it is always driving forwards (through spacetime). Some notes on this - think about what a bizarre, weirdly-shaped surface the car must be driving over. You can also think of the car front axle as being a wavefront of light. And finally - if you think this explanation is too bizarre, don't blame me, blame Einstein. Personally I don't actually like GR as a theory due to how weird it is.
- scotty79 6y agoI don't understand why people think that gravity should be describable by same math other forces are. Why should there be a quantum gravity field or quantum mediating particles for gravity? As far as we know gravity is just acceleration due to non-flat shape of space(-time). Why would that have anything similar with exchanging photons, gluons or other bosons? I understand how you might think there's a quantum math for a field. But how can there be quantum math for acceleration?
- joeberon 6y agoQuantum physicist here. The reason is not that we _want_ to describe both gravity and the standard model using the same formalism, it's that currently general relativity and the standard model are actually fundamentally incompatible and the most obvious way to come up with a model where there are no incompatibilities is to try to describe both using the same mathematical framework. >Why would that have anything similar with exchanging photons, gluons or other bosons? You make it sound like it is obvious that the strong force would be mediated by gluons or the electromagnetic force by photons, but it actually isn't at all, and it is only relatively recently that we have started describing all forces as being mediated by these so-called "force carriers". It is not obvious at all that there are any photons at all involved in, for example, two magnets repelling each other, or in electromagnetic induction of a current.
- scotty79 6y agoThank you for your response. What's the source of incompatibility between standard model and general relativity? Gravity is about acceleration and flow of time. What's the problem with plugging general relativity in place of classical dynamics whenever you care about flow of time and acceleration in quantum physics? As if those gravity and other forces and particle had nothing to do with each other. Why does general relativity is more incompatible with quantum mechanics than with fluid dynamics for example? My understanding is that general relativity says that gravity is not even a real force. It's just a function of acceleration caused by misshapen space-time (deformed by mass/energy). Some other things I don't understand... How gravity is considered to be a fundamental force, while Pauli exclusion principle is not, despite the fact that it can keep neutron stars from collapsing. Is it because there's no hope for finding mediating particle in the math that describes the principle because the math is too simple?
- tempodox 6y ago... and then there are the neutron stars, exquisite perversions of physics where atom cores are packed so densely that the electrons have to form a cloud layer around the star.
- saagarjha 6y agoNot around but inside the star: collapse to degeneracy doesn’t mean that the whole star behaves like a giant atom with electron cloud around it. Most of the electrons are captured by inverse beta decay, anyhow.
- hektorrr 6y agoI would describe myself as a hopeless philosopher in terms of physics. I like to theorise about the nature of everything in universe. In no circumstances I'd say I know what I'm talking about. I'm aware that I lack a lot of knowledge in this field, which actually makes my journey pretty amazing through the learning about the complexity of the universe. These few words just to let you know that whatever you read here it might be a complete nonsense and it's not even a pseudoscience but some fantasy/fiction reflections. I'm most amazed by the nature of tri-dimensional space itself. Back then, there was popular belief in Aether - the substance that carries wave of lights. To be honest I tend to believe such 'thing' could explain many of the most weirdest questions that appears in my head. I wonder if it's possible that the Aether is the space itself. And the space is the Aether. Tiniest, basic 'particles' that are frame for everything else. There would be no 3-dimensional space without at least 4 of such Aether quants. Also for example photons don't just 'fly' through space, but jumps from one quant of Aether to another one. That's how they 'fly' in straight line. That's why when the space is curved they will follow that curvness. And the gravity is not just a curved spacetime but something like an atmosphere made of Aether quants that are repelled by the particles containing Higgs boson. Which naturally makes the Higgs boson the only particle that can interact with Aether. I know that so far none experiment has confirmed the existence of Aether. But I can't let go the feeling that we are missing something here.
- at_a_remove 6y agoYou are not the first to think of this, or even the hundredth. It's been decades since I first saw it, but I did see someone propose kind of an interesting approach, for amusement: why not take the aether thing as far as it could go? Keep adding bizarre properties to it to explain experimental results. Go wild! If I recall, the end result was something very much like the properties of spacetime. But with no particles. Just ... take the particles away. You're attached to the particles. The reason you cannot let go of that feeling is that you're trying to attach your base human experience (which is largely Newtonian, low spacetime curvature, quantum effects not immediately visible, a fairly confined region of temperatures and pressures) to a domain where your base experience is completely irrelevant. All of the waves you witnessed were the disturbance of matter as a traveling phenomenon. It's what you grew up on. And so envisioning a scenario wherein the wave isn't carried on some kind of matter, however hidden, "feels" wrong. Also, don't do physics without math. If you just want to keep reaching from one analogy to another, you can build all kinds of castles in the sky, but you won't have anything at the end of it. Remember, physics is a quantitative prediction. Your concepts have no math or calculations, and so there is no measurement to contradict them. Nor can you "farm the math out" to other parties. Nobody capable of doing the math will do the math for you. If you desire to pursue this, you must begin to do the math, yourself.
- Raro 6y agoFor some context: the article only interviews quantum gravity researchers, so it has that particular slant. They are concerned with coming up with different strategies to mitigate the issues general relativity has with singularities, and these strategies range from "sensible deviations from general relativity" to "fun, but highly unlikely". In terms of how the theory of gravitation is not like the other fundamental forces, I think the most salient point was made by Sera Cremonini: gravitation is not a renormalizable theory. At least in the sense of how we have approached renormalization with the other forces. It is intrinsically non-linear, because the source is the field (and vice-versa). To get anywhere close to a grand unified theory that incorporates gravitation requires a rethink of the normalization procedure (and likely requires an entirely new geometric framework—this was a pre-requisite for both general relativity and Newton's Universal Law).
- codethief 6y ago> For some context: the article only interviews quantum gravity researchers, so it has that particular slant. I would go even further: Natalie Wolchover only interviewed string theorists and quantum field theorists. They all assume that gravity in some way or another will just be yet another quantum field theory. There is not a single piece of evidence for this, though. Personally, I also don't think it is a particularly promising approach. As Hawking so eloquently put it: > But I believe [gravity] is distinctively different, because it shapes the arena in which it acts, unlike other fields which act in a fixed spacetime background. (Hawking in Hawking & Penrose: The Nature of Space and Time, chapter 1)
- Raro 6y ago> I would go even further: Natalie Wolchover only interviewed string theorists and quantum field theorists. They all assume that gravity in some way or another will just be yet another quantum field theory. I didn't want to push that point too much. I am personally uncomfortable with the lack of emphasis on empirical evidence. However, that's not to say there can be fruitful results. In terms of re-thinking geometric approaches, I quite liked (what I understood of) Nima Arkani-Hamed's suggestion for avoiding issues with localization. Similarly for Penrose's twistor theory.
- TheMightyLlama 6y agoI would like to join in with many of the statements in this thread describing a joint lack of understanding of the physical universe as well as a deep fascination with it. I certainly count myself among those ranks. In watching way too many YouTube videos on quantum physics and gravity I began to create a model of how the universe works at the very small scale and after a while something occurred to me. We know that the path of a photon can be bent if it passes near a black hole. The key being that spacetime is being somehow consumed by a black hole and the photon is being dragged towards it. Thus, its path appears bent. I thought that similar effects should happen with volumes of a lighter mass. Perhaps with the same mechanism. Neutron stars would have a smaller effect on photons, and a more measurable effect on heavier particles and molecules. Neutron stars would also somehow 'consume' spacetime. Just at a lower rate. Thus heavier particles would escape. So too with the earth. Only, in this case, the mass of the earth is small enough that molecules can escape all on their own. So, what is gravity? Gravity in this model is the effect of spacetime being consumed. By analogy the spacetime is like standing under a shower. We are glued to the earth because we cannot gain enough purchase against the torrent of spacetime being consumed by the mass of the earth. Which brings me to the second question. Well, this is where actually having some physics would be useful. But after many drunken bouts of thought, I'm convinced that this spacetime consumption is down to [color confinement](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_confinement#QCD_string https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_confinement#QCD_string). Anyway, enjoy. If nothing else, this should at least be useful for some sci-fi anti-gravity mechanism.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joquarky 6y agoI've often wondered if mass can locally affect the rate of expansion of the universe, causing gravity as a side effect.
- Balgair 6y agoGreat questions/ideas! To maybe nit-pick a bit to help out: Space time is not 'consumed', it's just curved in 4-D. The Einstein Field Equations are a very good model of what we think is occurring. Photons are massless, hence why they can travel at light-speed. Their energy is the thing to worry about when doing GR.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jscipione 6y agoSince reading Brian Greene’s books I have a question that I can’t seem to get an answer to. If there really are extra curled up dimensions and the graviton is not connected to the brain of the 3 extended dimensions in our Universe and is therefore free to travel into and out of the curled up dimensions then why does gravity obey the inverse square law? Shouldn’t we be able to detect the extra dimensions by the effect of gravity diminishing faster than inverse square as the gravitons go into and out of the extra dimensions? The inverse square law of gravitational propagation indicates that there either are no extra dimensions or that the graviton is also connected to a brain that prevents it from entering and exiting these extra dimensions. Since the other 3 forces also obey the inverse square law the extra dimensions might as well not exist making the conclusions of string theory invalid. What am I missing?
- simonh 6y agoThis experiment has actually been done, measuring the precise rate of diminishment of gravity over very short distances. So far as we can tell gravity does follow an inverse square law, and the precision of the experiment means that if it does deviate from inverse square, the extra dimensions can be no bigger than around half the width of a human hair. Any bigger than that and the experiment would have detected the deviation. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/string-theorys-extra-dime/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/string-theorys-ex...
- JimBlackwood 6y agoNo, what you’re saying is correct. If the inverse square law was obeyed perfectly, space would be restricted to 3-spatial dimensions. The extra spatial dimensions are usually theorized to be extremely compact so the effects of a higher power law (the inverse square law can be generalised to 1/r^(n-1) with n as your amount of dimensions.) can be neglected. Of course, to prove it you’d have to at some point measure these effects, and there is some evidence that the inverse square law breaks down. (https://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0307284.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-ph/0307284.pdf)
- jscipione 6y ago
- weeboid 6y agoAhh, a primary favorite. "Gravity is the grand leviathan of forces". It is my personal belief that, as light and energy were shown equivalent, the third leg of the stool will emerge; that gravity and mass are equivalent. Not as we understand them now; but as mc^2 understood light/energy equivalence. Final thought exercise: is it possible, that gravity does not exhibit the same behavior everywhere in the universe? That gravity may have states.
- tia4tia 6y agoWell, some people say so, others say different https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity
- emsal 6y agoTheoretical physics is sporadically coming back into my mind again after a lot of time learning CS and Stats. I'm wondering now, is the goal of theoretical physics sort of like the goal of topological data analysis[0]? Reading about things like how Max Planck came up with quantum theory to explain the measurements of black body radiation reminded me a lot of the ML task trying to fit a model to data. My bias is definitely showing here but is this a useful framework to be able to think about these things? [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_data_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_data_analysis
- logicallee 6y agoWhen thinking about gravity versus other forces, consider how weak it is. Under you you have Earth weighing 6.6 sextillion tons (5.97 x 10^24 kg). It is 260 billion cubic miles (1 trillion cubic km). All that generates 1g of gravity. A basic fridge magnet (not even neodymium) easily generates a magnetic force that can lift several times its own weight. It overpowers the sextillion tons 3:1, no contest.
- sudhirj 6y agoIsn't it conclusive already that gravity insn't a force? It works nothing like what we consider forces, and we already have models that show it's curvature in space-time, not force. A black hole doesn't exert infinite force on things, for example – one could say it doesn't exert any force at all, just curves all paths you could possibly take back in on itself.
- pier25 6y agoI could be totally wrong, but as a lay person I had the impression that gravity wasn't actually force. So the apple did not fall because it was attracted to the Earth but rather it fell because of the curvature of spacetime.
- humanfromearth 6y agoMaybe gravity is not a force in a quantum sense, but just geometry of spacetime in the presence of mass? Maybe there is no graviton and no quantum theory is needed to explain gravity. Is there any strong evidence that gravity is following quantum mechanics? Maybe a real theoretical physicist can explain.
- nightcracker 6y agoConsidering that gravity is produced by particles who's behavior is quantized, there is essentially no other option than to assume gravity must be as well.
- humanfromearth 6y agoDo we know for sure? I mean I don’t think the graviton has been observed in action yet. Let me ask another question: is space quantized?
- zackees 6y agoThis guy who wrote a book on Magnetism says that Einstein has it wrong and that only by starting over at Tesla's model and moving forward can the physics of the universe be predicted well. According to the Tesla inspired model of the ELECTRIC universe, gravity is not a fundament field itself, but an emergent characteristic of "incoherent dia-electric acceleration". The guy who said this is Ken Wheeler. Whats also interesting is that this opinion is shared by pioneer of "Low-Energy Nuclear Reaction" Randal Mills. I've been told by the people in this space that the Mills paper provides a comprehensive model that is MUCH better at predicting certain binding energy states of nuclei. In comparison to the standard models all-over the place. It also solves problem of all the dark matter in the universe, which is simply an abundance of tiny hydrogens called hydrino's which contain an electron that has lost momentum and is zipping closer to the nucleus, thus making a more elctro-neutral particle that weakly interacts with other particles (WIMPS). If anyone has doubts on the standard model, I suggest checking out "Ken Wheeler" and Randal Mills. Fascinating and deep look at a minority consensus of the universe that appears to be MUCH simpler.
- beervirus 6y agoSimpler, but not supported by any evidence. Nobody's ever seen a hydrino.
- macintux 6y agoThank you for sending me down a rabbit hole. Quite interesting to read the two incomprehensible (to me) and incompatible worlds represented by the believers and the critics on Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/BrilliantLightPower/ https://www.reddit.com/r/BrilliantLightPower/
- badrabbit 6y agoWhat does gravity have to do with energy levels? I thought it was a side effect of motion in curved spacetime (einstein theory)?
- klank 6y agoCurvature of spacetime is an effect of energy. Check out the Einstein field equations, specifically the stress-energy tensor.
- rudolph9 6y ago> The problem with a quantum version of general relativity is that the calculations that would describe interactions of very energetic gravitons — the quantized units of gravity — would have infinitely many infinite terms. You would need to add infinitely many counterterms in a never-ending process. Renormalization would fail. Because of this, a quantum version of Einstein’s general relativity is not a good description of gravity at very high energies. It must be missing some of gravity’s key features and ingredients. Is there a proof backing up the claim that “ Renormalization would fail”? I can see why people would jump to that conclusion but that doesn’t mean it’s true.
- steve76 6y agoSome people think of the electric universe. The opposite makes more sense to me. The matter wave universe. Everything up there, just what the material down here agrees upon. When astronauts travel their location reflects changes in their makeup. At some point, you just don't care what happens light years away, if it really exists or just perception overload. Chemical or molecular satellites and solar orbiters alter everything down here to say a new star exists up there. Travel there and land on very real planets, meet very real life no different than anything else. I think this ends by one day walking into a doctor's office after you already got the pacemaker or a cell phone store after you already signed the data contract. "So this is going to fix it?" > ... ... ... yeah ... "How?" > it creates a black hole. "It creates a black hole?" > yeah "Where, the phone?" > Everywhere. The Earth, the Sun, everywhere "Wouldn't that destroy everything?" > ... ... .... hasn't yet.