4 ms·
Imagine: "A 20 yo runs across highway in heavy truck traffic, dies". Well, yes. There is an obvious risk, and you either acknowledge this risk and act according
by nine_k 6y ago
Imagine: "A 20 yo runs across highway in heavy truck traffic, dies". Well, yes. There is an obvious risk, and you either acknowledge this risk and act accordingly, or get struck.
Fortunately, if you do a very bad investment, you can sell all your assets, go bankrupt, and keep your life. Too bad the poor guy chose to take his life. But this again looks like not doing enough homework.
This is very sad. I wish these things were written in large red letters on the signup page for a trading account, and one would have to type them in first person, like "I realize that I can lose all my possessions as a result of a bad trade" (no copy-paste allowed) to even accept the terms of service.
[Edited: spelling]
- loeg 6y agoThis is pretty tone-deaf.
- nine_k 6y agoPlease notice how highways are full of warning signs and barriers that prevent you from accidentally running across them. Same with construction sites, or heavy industrial plants. Maybe other risky places should have more warning signs, so that an optimistic 20-yo would have to stop and think before acting.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoSo if there are warning signs you're okay with allowing someone with no income to leverage to the tune of $700K? I think this is the basis for the accusation of tone-deafness.
- nine_k 6y agoPlease note that I did not even say anything about taking the leverage, only a about signing up. Power tools have safety feature; the leverage tool should, too. AFAIK Robinhood won't allow you to make a naked call, you have to show that you have enough to pay. Either their safety feature failed (very bad, needs fixing and constant checking), or the poor trader used something else as a collateral, and that could be an important part of the tragic outcome.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoNoted. Thanks for clarifying.
- chii 6y ago> no income to leverage to the tune of $700K? if robinhood is willing to take on the risk of a counterparty bankruptcy, i don't see why not. Robinhood is on the hook for lending the margin, not the boy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AlEinstein 6y agoWhat’s heartbreaking is that he didn’t trade any leverage at all. He executed an options spread that was worth about $700k on each leg. Due to the nature of buying and selling options, the app showed his position as short $700k because the long leg hadn’t settled yet. All he needed to do was wait and he would have seen the balance go back to what he expected.
- unnameduser1 6y agoTo give a bit perspective: in many countries there are mostly no warning signs and barriers on highways. Sometimes a few trees, the occasional speed limit sign and warning of steep slopes. Only on places where accidents are so common they add barriers to prevent cars going into oncoming lanes, but that doesn’t prevent accidents from happening. It’s tragic that the 20yo died, many sites warn that trading is risky. What they shouldn’t allow is to trade with more money than you can prove to possess.
- egypturnash 6y agoExactly the kind of comment I expected to see at the top when I clicked on these comments, really. HN loves to assume that everyone is a perfectly rational person who has infinite time to read and comprehend all minutae before doing anything, and anyone who fails to do this clearly had whatever happens to them coming.
- nine_k 6y agoA person who goes on to operate a large table saw, very rational or not, should read a manual, and become acutely aware that cutting off their limbs is a very real danger. Anyone who sells access to such a tool should make sure of that happening. That's my point.
- vmception 6y agoHow exactly? Even that whole tweet thread is placing blame on Robinhood who offers worse and less margin/leverage than normal brokers? If there is energy to direct, it has more to do with people that don't have a self preservation instinct and deciding whether we actually want to add one back to them. Very different than misattributing disdain towards the action they ascribed to their suicide. It is pretty tone deaf to get this mixed up.
- dragosmocrii 6y agoThat's a great idea! Even Github has better safety guards to make sure you don't delete a repository accidentally
- throwaway888abc 6y agoI know others who make profit from borrowing leverage and bet that Robionhood is doing same. What you propose is nice, but against platform financial interests.
- nine_k 6y agoI bet having to publicly explain real credit card interest rates, or the components of food, or conflicts of interest for top corporate officers, can be against some powerful interests. But I suppose this such cases are some of the few cases where regulations (not even necessarily state-imposed) really work in the public interest.
- closed 6y ago> But this again looks not doing enough homework. It seems naive to read a tweet with a little information about someone completing suicide, and then assume that if they had known (more) about bankruptcy they would not have done it. There are other things that we can't read out of the tweet that are really important in these situations, like access to social support.
- Barrin92 6y agohere we go again. This is like one of these "more people are killed by their washing mashines than by terrorism" takes.
- fisherjeff 6y agoI mean, I assume he lost significantly more than all his possessions
- AYBABTME 6y agoMy 1 year old has no preconception that running across the highway is dangerous, she'd do it in an instant if I let her. We'll spend the next decade teaching her that kind of stuff: - the oven doesn't look dangerous, but it's hot - this water looks like the other one, but it's boiling and will hurt - a car can drive across the street and run over you - the electric outlet looks passive but it'll electrocute you Aside for very primal fears, people aren't born with a plethora of "things to know are dangerous in the modern world". So I'm not surprised that a 20yo would end up not knowing that there's a risk and that it's "obvious".
- chii 6y agoYou're comparing a 20yr old to a 1yr old. there's some personal responsibility there - how can a 20yr old not know? The underlying problem with the 20yr old is likely mental instability and depression - far too common amongst the young. The gamble on options for a way out, and having seen this fail, decides that their life isn't worth living any more. It's a deeper problem than insurmountable debt and not knowing the risks.
- dx034 6y agoTruly understanding risk in financial markets is incredibly hard and not intuitive. We can't use our every day intuition to warn us of risks on markets (other than easy money doesn't exist). But I don't think people would appreciate if you'd need a master in Finance or CFA to open a Robinhood account.
- mlok 6y agoThis reminds me of this brilliant interview with Ricky Gervais about atheism and religion : https://youtu.be/rYnjDCZUV6A?t=43 https://youtu.be/rYnjDCZUV6A?t=43
- sytelus 6y agoI think every high school student should have one day class dedicated on following topics and so many lives would be saved: 1. Folies of investments, how you can lose everything. 2. Folies of marriages, divorce laws and how you can lose everything. 3. Folies of gambling in casinos and how you can lose everything. 4. Folies of alcohol, tobacco and other soft drugs and how you can lose everything. Each of these class should be given by 2-3 people who actually lose everything in these cases.
- unishark 6y agoAlso some exercises on how everything that sounds too good to be true is a scam.
- Apocryphon 6y agoIdeally, it would be great for a country to have systems in place so that the worst you can possibly lose is less than everything.
- joeblow9999 6y agohow would you make it so that i cant bet all my money
- unishark 6y agoTechnically I think there are lots of such laws. Like protecting the house you live in. But in the case of things like taxes and child support, you can ultimately lose a lot more than everything.
- opportune 6y agoThat would definitely fuck up the housing market for starters.
- lazylizard 6y agoThey already teach math...
- mD5pPxMcS6fVWKE 6y ago