14 ms·
In Washington State, where Amazon is headquartered, there is a recent law that makes noncompete agreements unenforceable for employees with incomes at or below
by karaterobot 6y ago
In Washington State, where Amazon is headquartered, there is a recent law that makes noncompete agreements unenforceable for employees with incomes at or below $100k per year (RCW 49.62). The original threshold for this was $180k, but Amazon lobbied to change it, presumably because too many of their employees would have been covered under it. Makes sense from their position, but it should be known that they lobby to limit the legal protections of their own employees.
- ponker 6y agoAmazon limits cash Corp to $160K and pays the rest in stock so the law might have covered 100% of their employees. Would have expected to see them quickly take that to $190K though.
- tylerhou 6y agoSeriously doubt that stock is not counted as income for the Seattle law, as stock vesting is reported on your W2.
- meddlepal 6y agoPretty sure this depends on the types of stock that are granted (e.g. RSU vs ISO).
- re 6y agoAmazon grants RSUs which are absolutely counted as compensation/earnings for the purpose of this law. https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=49.62.010 https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=49.62.010
- tekknik 6y agoBut only in the year they were vested. If you’re not in an vesting year then it doesn’t count.
- DavidPeiffer 6y agoLast week there was discussion either here or on reddit that Amazon has a hard cap for salary compensation at ~160k in the Seattle area. Dropping the threshold from 180k to 100k would cause everyone who has maxed out their salary at Amazon to have enforceable non-competes. I'd be curious what types of jobs at Amazon were immediately under the 100k threshold, and what percent of the total Washington state Amazon workforce has a salary of 100k+?
- flattone 6y agoIm curious about 100+ distribution too. Live in amazon area, cant imagine a single employee making under 100k, even 5 years ago
- amznthrwaway 6y agoNon-tech roles.
- throwawaygh 6y ago$100K isn't what it used to be. In addition to inflation^1, the death of pensions means that salary and other liquid compensation is now a much larger percentage of total compensation. For example, in our state, teachers and government employees receive a full pension after 20 years of service. That pension pays out 1/2 of some average of their previous few year's salary. Even if you retire making a relatively modest $60K/yr, that pension is still worth north of $50K/yr over those 20 years. Salaries that don't include pensions aren't nearly as generous as they sound. $100K/yr without a pension is comparable to $40K/yr with a pension. -- 1. Including absolutely incredible housing price inflation in major cities like Seattle which typical measures of inflation don't properly capture).
- xur17 6y agoThis begs the question - wouldn't it be advantageous (recruiting wise) for governments to stop offering pensions, and instead increase base pay?
- baybal2 6y agoWhat other states in US have don't enforce non-competes? Adding some context: as I understood, L1B is a "transfer" visa for "existing" employees, which under "existing" often mean record of employment being outright forged, or being put on very low key position with explicit intent of later L1B transfer. L1B is supposed to be of lesser value than L1A, which opens much more options for an employee/corporate serf to away. I believe the change is due to the later being a much easier door to US for a lot of people from low income countries where Amazon runs captive outsourcing centres. They didn't want people to scout for another, better jobs around the moment they stepped into US, even if that mean the next hiring company had to do its own L1 for them.
- pscoutou 6y agoCalifornia. https://www.upcounsel.com/non-compete-california https://www.upcounsel.com/non-compete-california I remember Apple and Google getting into trouble over non-compete several years back.
- wpietri 6y agoYup. And it's one of the big reasons that Silicon Valley is a force in the world. Without the "Traitorous Eight" and the Fairchildren, things could have turned out very differently. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traitorous_eight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traitorous_eight
- tekknik 6y agoI don’t this is true. With rent prices in SV getting out of control people have started leaving the city, with most heading to texas or further east. If the decision to live/work in CA was based around the protections provided by CA then why is the exodus starting?
- wpietri 6y agoOff the top of my head, a few reasons: After 60 years of growth we're hitting practical limits in terms of finding space for people. The technology we have created has made distance less important. And between outsourcing, tech oligopolies, and "blitzscaling" (where VCs burn money to destroy competition), it has lately become harder to jump ship and start a company. Plus we're really talking about processes on different scales. Individuals moving elsewhere doesn't say much about the pace of creating companies to pursue novel innovations. I'll also note that CA not having non-competes makes it easy for people to leave and start companies elsewhere. The real question is whether those new companies will create dynamic local scenes of their own, in the same way the Fairchildren did here. If they don't, and if Silicon Valley keeps being a hub of innovation, that's a great sign that banning noncompetes still matters.
- xenocyon 6y agoShould WA's 100K cutoff be taken to imply that noncompetes are legally enforceable for people who earn more than that?
- xapata 6y agoTo an extent. The boundaries aren't thoroughly tested in court.
- walshemj 6y agoAnd it seniority not just $$ that is one of the key tests ie for a director or C level.
- tzs 6y agoThere are three terms that definitely make a noncompete unenforceable if any one of them is satisfied. If none of them are satisfied, then enforceability would be determined the same as it would have before this new law. The first term is that it is unenforceable: • Unless the employer discloses the terms of the covenant in writing to the prospective employee no later than the time of the acceptance of the offer of employment and, if the agreement becomes enforceable only at a later date due to changes in the employee's compensation, the employer specifically discloses that the agreement may be enforceable against the employee in the future or • If the covenant is entered into after the commencement of employment, unless the employer provides independent consideration for the covenant. The second term is that it is unenforceable: • Unless the employee's earnings from the party seeking enforcement, when annualized, exceed one hundred thousand dollars per year. The third term is that it is unenforceable: • If the employee is terminated as the result of a layoff, unless enforcement of the noncompetition covenant includes compensation equivalent to the employee's base salary at the time of termination for the period of enforcement minus compensation earned through subsequent employment during the period of enforcement. So...if you earn more than $100k, and you were properly notified of it when hired (or paid to accept it if it was added on later), and you are not leaving due to a layoff or they aren't willing to keep paying you while the noncompete runs out, then it might be enforceable.
- aledalgrande 6y agoIt's still shocking to me how lobbying is legal in the US. Corporations can affect any aspect of your life.
- wutbrodo 6y ago> shocking to me how lobbying is legal in the US. Lobbying is legal in most (all?) of Europe too. It's a slippery activity to pin down, not amenable to banning because it consists of nominally innocuous activities. You can put degrees of limitation on activities that reduce what you'd call lobbying, but I don't see how you could make it fully illegal.
- aledalgrande 6y agoI thought giving gifts etc was illegal in Europe, but apparently not?
- dodobirdlord 6y agoIt's (basically) illegal in the US as well.
- grecy 6y agoI really love how "bribery" has been re-named "lobbying" and everyone is OK with it.
- andersonvom 6y agoLobbying itself is not bad: legislators need information to make decisions about things, and lobbying provides them with it. The bad, and frankly unbelievable part, is the whole "money is speech" and the fact that it's OK for lobbyists to just transfer money in many different forms to politicians as a firm of persuasion to vote for/against certain pieces of legislation.