12 ms·
Intermittent fasting works – not only for weight loss but also for heart health
- reidjs 6y agoI love-hate online nutrition articles like this. They all tell you to stop snacking, don't drink soda, limit carbs, etc and then have some little gimmick. The quirk on this one is that occasionally you skip breakfast, too. Makes sense to me. It's just nice to read an article that's not about covid or BLM.
- andrewbarba 6y agoNot that it matters, but Covid made the cut here.
- wenc 6y ago> The quirk on this one is that occasionally you skip breakfast, too. I've done intermittent fasting (IF) for the past 5 years. Apart from a black espresso every morning, I skip breakfast all the time (not just occasionally). Skipping breakfast is a psychological trick (that doesn't work on everybody, but works well enough to make a difference). The real goal is to entice oneself to eat less by eating fewer meals in a day. As someone who has practised IF for 5 years, I find I haven't really lost any weight (a benefit claimed by many IF practitioners). That said, I haven't gained any either -- blips on the scale around Thanksgiving and Christmastime automatically flatten within days. To be absolutely honest, I can't tell if IF actually works, but the routine hasn't been onerous to keep up, and over the past 5 years my health has been mostly the same, no big changes. But perhaps the counterfactual is that if I didn't practice IF, I would've been worse off. (I don't care to test the counterfactual)
- AnonC 6y agoMy experience with 16:8 IF has been almost similar. I skip breakfast too, and found that to be the easiest to follow with a black coffee (very light by normal standards). I can’t tell either if it works to provide any claimed benefits. But I’m used to it and psychologically feel better, especially not eating for several hours before bedtime. I attribute the weight loss I experienced to cutting out processed foods and cutting out oils (I do consume these once in a while, and when I do the scales show me I’ve fallen off the tracks).
- dingaling 6y ago> Skipping breakfast is a psychological trick Perhaps, but for some people it's also a physiological risk. I eat about 1200 calories for breakfast as my body otherwise cannot function for the day. Whether fasting is appropriate depends on one's body composition, daily exertion routine and physiological factors. For most people I'd recommend exercise instead of fasting.
- sutterbomb 6y agoDiet is so much more important for weight loss / maintenance than exercise. You can obviously have a healthy diet that does not include IF, but for most people they need to do something about their diet, and can’t just add exercise.
- xpe 6y agoFor most people, I tend to agree. A big part of The Obesity Code is unpacking the reasons why. One of the reasons is debunking the perception that weight loss is simply about calories in and calories out. Another part of the story is showing the feedback cycles between glucose, insulin, and insulin resistance. I made a line art drawing as a gist, here: https://gist.github.com/xpe/8d5c6243fba454e5987e87e9bc461a58 https://gist.github.com/xpe/8d5c6243fba454e5987e87e9bc461a58 I already pasted it into another comment, so I don't want to exceed my line art threshold here.
- cachestash 6y ago> I eat about 1200 calories Do you have a medical condition? that's a lot of calories to take on for Breakfast, that's almost half my daily quota.
- lloeki 6y agoA typical cereal serving is 45g, which is a very small volume, the box I have in front of me tight now tells me it’s 250kcal. It’s super easy to eat muuuuch more than that because carbs are so satisfying they’re downright addictive. Two bowls of cereals can fly very quickly into one’s belly, pour in some milk and the tally easily crosses the 1000kcal mark.
- codernyc16 6y agoHe lost 45 lbs, that’s what probably removed his sleeps apnea. Not because of some other magical ability of intermittent fasting. One of my friends also lost a lot of weight and his apnea went away, he went off of his CPAP machine.
- pwdisswordfish2 6y agoApnea can lead to binge eating, so it may be the apenea was in part responsible for gaining the 45 lbs!
- johnchristopher 6y ago> Apnea can lead to binge eating How so ?
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoNot OP. I've an issue with sleep related binge-eating: fullness induces sleepiness, so when I'm awake at night and want to be asleep I'll eat - basically an extra meal. Alcohol too. For me the root issue is other mental health problems. Sleep problems can readily lead to weight gain. I can see how apnoea that exhibits as waking up a lot might lead someone attempting to fall into heavier sleep by overeating. IF, paired with lots of exercise, was working for me before the current crisis.
- johnchristopher 6y agoBut sleep apnea doesn't wake you up enough to get out of bed and start eating like pulling all-nighters or insomnia do and going to sleep with a full belly won't prevent flesh/muscle collapsing that causes sleep apnea although I can see how the body burning energy to digest + endorphin from a good meal might help falling asleep faster. > IF, paired with lots of exercise, was working for me before the current crisis. You mean the pandemic/lockdown ?
- 6y ago
- chx 6y agohttps://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2018-05/esoe-cif051618.php https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2018-05/esoe-cif0516... warns you intermittent fasting diets could increase diabetes risk. I wish I had data from before but after I attempted intermittent fasting I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. It's possible I had it before, I alas haven't had blood work done for a few years prior. I changed my diet, never attempted fasting again and the 6.8 HbA1c dropped to and stayed steady at 5.3 almost immediately.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoInteresting... that sort of makes sense to me maybe because by going for longer periods of time without resupply (and carbs / sugar), seems like you'd be putting more strain on your systems to keep yourself in equilibrium (blood sugar and otherwise) longer, wearing out that capacity more quickly.
- danielheath 6y agoFasting will make any deficiencies in your blood sugar regulation very, very obvious.
- marttt 6y agoI've been worried about this as well. A lenghty Harvard blog post from 2018 indicates that a 8-hour 7am-3pm feeding period gave better health-related results than an 12-hour 7am-7pm feeding period. In other words, 'timing is key': https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/intermittent-fasting-surprising-update-2018062914156 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/intermittent-fasting-sur... Interestingly, the researcher doesn't discuss skipping breakfast. I've been skipping for several years with a somewhat uneasy feeling and a growing phobia for diabetes. I'll probably try the 3pm/7pm to 7am fast instead; maybe my body doesn't tolerate skipping breakfast as well as I would like it to.
- andreareina 6y ago... in rats, doing alternate-day fasting. Regardless, good on you for getting better.
- pbhjpbhj 6y ago
- AnonC 6y ago> How do you start? Agatston told me to start by skipping one meal a day, usually breakfast. (Yes, you can have black coffee in the morning, into which he adds ghee, a type of clarified butter, and coconut oil to reduce hunger pangs. It’s not your typical cup of coffee.) This may be ok to start with, though black coffee by itself has the ability to kill hunger without these crutches. Adding ghee or coconut oil in black coffee means it’s no longer effectively zero calories, and this is not technically fasting. Same with adding sugar to it. You can skip breakfast and have black coffee, black or herbal teas and water — all these are effectively zero calories. One point this article doesn’t address in the 16:8 scheme is the frequency of eating within the eight hour eating window. Is it ok to have three meals and snacks within that window? Should it be two meals with a good gap between them? I’m sure these variations also determine if it works for weight loss or other benefits. Intermittent fasting with 16:8 makes it easier to consume lower calories. Weight loss typically follows if activity levels are maintained the same or increased (to compensate for a lower basal metabolic rate).
- raincom 6y agoblack coffee + ghee/coconut oil is part of keto. He must be doing keto + IF.
- AnonC 6y agoAgree. That sounded like “bulletproof coffee” with some changes.
- Roritharr 6y agoHaving done keto for a long time I can only recommend two options besides Tea. 1. Become a weird coffee person and put some nerd energy into it so black coffee doesn't taste disgusting on it's own. James Hoffman on YouTube is a great way into this. 2. Eschew the coffee and take a teaspoon of MCT Oil before your can of zero-calorie Energy Drink (Coke Zero Energy is my favorite atm). It may be dirty and people are going to tell you Aspartame is evil and is going to make you hungry(it really might, but you are still hours away from your window so black/white discipline is easy to keep alive), but for me it worked much better than dreading the coffee in the morning.
- donniefitz2 6y agoFor anyone interested in more info about IF, Dr. Jason Fung has a great book about it. https://www.amazon.com/Obesity-Code-Unlocking-Secrets-Weight/dp/1771641258/ref=sr_1_5?dchild=1&keywords=Jason+Fung&qid=1592111190&s=books&sr=1-5 https://www.amazon.com/Obesity-Code-Unlocking-Secrets-Weight...
- kyle_morris_ 6y agoI’ve been thinking a lot about how humans evolved and how differently we do some things. Is there consensus on the eating patterns of prehistoric humans? My understanding of how humans evolved to eat is pretty limited, but I would guess unintentional intermittent fasting would have been commonplace in humans over the past few hundred thousand years. There seems to be consensus that eating a large variety of foods is great for you, but is shifting your eating pattern, or even grazing, better than eating at the same time, the same amount, every day? Does your ancestral background impact how frequently you eat? Similar to how some cultures are lactose intolerant due to historically not having access to cows, could similar issues present based on how frequently we eat? I’d love to find resources that have dug into those topics if anyone has recommendations.
- tinco 6y agoIn general animals exposed to nature live shorter, not longer lives. It might be worth investigating, but I've not seen anything to suggest we might become healthier by restricting our diets to food available to effectively poor people. Besides the obvious not eating food that we already know is unhealthy and eating significantly more calories than we need.
- humanlion87 6y agoI have been following IF on-and-off over the past few years. It has helped me lose weight initially and then maintain it at a good spot. I have not done detailed before and after blood work to know whether it has had other effects. But one problem I have started having recently is acid reflux and acidity. People immediately pounce on this and tell me that skipping breakfast is what is causing increased acidity levels in my stomach. And my doctor is also suggesting that I do not skip breakfast. The problem is I do not have any concrete evidence for either case (skipping breakfast causes/does not cause acidity). I am hoping to get my acidity issues under control first and then maybe give IF another shot to see whether the acidity issues return. Just wanted to throw out there that different people might have different experiences with IF and it is very important to listen to your body.
- bmd3991 6y agoBinge eating can cause acid reflux, so I wonder if it’s a similar mechanism. Something about eating so much food in a small window maybe (?) doesn’t give your body time and space to digest it properly
- humanlion87 6y agoThat's an interesting point, never thought about it that way. Need to read more about it! If that is the case, then going back to IF might be a problem for me :). Currently I am back on 3 meals a day (12:12) and have eliminated certain types of foods that could cause acidity. And it's working for now.
- doubleunplussed 6y agoWhy not have breakfast but skip dinner? Eating close to bedtime can cause reflux and FWIW I had less reflux when I fasted after 4pm.
- elric 6y agoI suspect the reason why it's common to skip breakfast in 16:8 and not dinner, is because of social pressure. It's much more common to have dinner with friends than breakfast. Skipping breakfast is way easiet for many people.
- jasonlfunk 6y agoMy experience with IF has taught me that I’m much better at complete denial, rather than moderation. So if I want to reduce my caloric intake it works better for me to say No to everything for 16 hours and only eat for 8, then to try to just eat less and in moderation all day. It also applies to carb and other reductions. If I allow myself any bread, sweets, etc, I will eat too much. It’s easier for me to eat 0, then it is to only eat a little.
- Roritharr 6y agoSame here, years of people telling me drastic diets are "unhealthy" etc. kept me from playing to my strengths of just doing the extremes for long periods of time instead of fighting constant urges while balancing them with a moderate calorie intake. I think most (healthy) people should try fasting for 5 days to see how your body responds. It won't kill you, but many people are terrified of the thought of not eating for 12 hours.
- londons_explore 6y agoLots of people I speak to seem scared of accidentally loosing too much weight and starving to death... I don't really understand it though... Between 'too heavy' and 'too light' exists 'just right', and it's pretty hard to miss...
- copperx 6y agoLike the people that are afraid to lift weights because they might get "too bulky." The human mind is bizarre.
- dorkwood 6y agoI once fasted for about a week while suffering an illness that wouldn't let me keep any food down. I only drank water during that time. To my surprise, after several days of not eating, my hunger disappeared completely. It was scary, but also eye-opening. The experience taught me that hunger is not the "you require food right now in order to survive" signal that everyone thinks it is.
- elric 6y agoFor anyone interested in weight loss and heart health, please remember that both are impaired by not getting enough sleep. Studies have shown that you're way more likely to over eat if you get less than 7 hours of sleep a night. Source: "Why we sleep" by Matthew Walker.
- Jommi 6y agoThis book? https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/ https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/
- badrabbit 6y agoIf you can break your carb addiction the rest is not that hard. It was very similat to quitting cigarettes for me. Cut off carbs for a few days, it will feel horrible until day 3, then you almost feel euphoric but you still have an urge. Keep it up for a week then you start replacing the old habit with a new one (intermittent fasting with keto diet for example, or cardio). Even when I slack off, so long as I don't touch carbs I can just cut down on food intake or workout a little bit and I will have so much more energy. If I actually workout properly, people will notice changes in my energy level and attitude. It's really insane why it is so hard to make simple changes with immense benefits like this. I feel normal after stopping cigs and other vices but I am telling you, cutting out or extremely reducing carb intake has had the most impact on my life. If I didn't know better I'd be calling carbs an addictive harmful drug (in reality, our modern way of life that requires minimal carbs for fuel and healthy bodies that are energy efficient are causing a conflict with traditional meals and ingredients). Once you get some control/discipline over what you eat, controlling when you eat is a lot easier in my experience. When it gets hard to stick to the diet, intermittent fasting can compensate for lack of good calories.
- Kiro 6y agoI don't understand the 16:8 idea. I would still eat 3 meals, just with dinner a little earlier. 8 hours window feels too big to be called fasting.
- globular-toast 6y agoEven a "normal" 3 meal pattern involves fasting overnight. That's why we call the first meal breakfast. This is just extending that overnight fast to 16 hours. I think if you tried to eat 3 meals in 8 hours you'd eat smaller meals. Otherwise you'd be stuffing yourself full.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoNot necessarily. IIRC, food leaves your stomach within 2-5 hours, and it varies depending on person and what the food is. I'm gonna guess you could fit in a light breakfast and a fairly decently sized lunch and dinner in that 8-hour window.
- a-saleh 6y agoDamn you paywall, I did wanted to read this! :D I am not certain how generalizable this is. Because this sorts of diet research relies most often on self-reporting, I mostly read it by prepending 'People exist for which ...'. And that is good to know, and hopefully they are not outliers by too much, but it probably won't be silver bullet for everybody. I.e. I remember hearing two twich streamers talk about their diets an one said how she really enjoys intermittent fasting, while other mentionsh how he needs to eat something at least every four hours, or he literally sees his apm in Starcraft drop :D
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 6y agoI lost a little over 50lbs a number of years ago, following a 5:2 diet. Quite frankly, I found it pretty horrible. Selecting 2 days in which you won't eat (much) is pretty tough, and the obvious candidates would be your working days, but you should expect to be grumpy AF during them in all honesty. These days, I generally stick to a 16:8 approach of IF (I typically eat between 13:00-21:00). I find that it works pretty well for me. I should note that I'm very active (exercise every day, running, cycling, or lifting weights), and that I still typically eat 3 meals, albeit within a smaller window. I think being sceptical of food science is smart, so all I can say is that it works for me.
- xvilka 6y agoThere is also antifragile[1] theory of fasting - body metabolism needs randomness to prosper. So the idea is to not only do intermittent fasting, but also do it randomly, randomly change your food habits, etc. Of course, even with randomized food rations you need to keep them healthy. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13530973-antifragile https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13530973-antifragile
- HiddenCanary 6y agoAt university I used to intermittent fast as a side-effect of laziness to cook breakfast. Nowadays I've read the benefits of it and trying to replicate that but I just get severe headaches when trying to do it. Anyone got any tips for avoid thing that?
- wahern 6y agoTwo of the most common culprits to rule out would be 1) caffeine withdrawal and 2) dehydration. People often don't drink as much, or not at all, when they're not eating, and many don't even realize it. When I work an all-nighter (36+ hours without sleep) I don't have much of an appetite the next day and so tend not to eat anything. Because I'm not eating I'm also not drinking much, which I like because I'm prone to slide into a salt+soda spiral. But if I don't force myself to drink fluids I often end up with a raging headache. I'm not much of a breakfast eater and during periods when I drink a lot of caffeinated soda I often get headaches from the caffeine withdrawal, especially on the weekends as I tend to only drink soda when working.
- dvdkhlng 6y agoAnd don't forget that maybe more than 20% of the normal water intake are due to food, not just drinking [1], so if you eat less you need to compensate water intake accordingly. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5084017/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5084017/
- Izkata 6y ago> How do you start? Agatston told me to start by skipping one meal a day, usually breakfast. This sounds especially odd to me, as skipping breakfast has long been one of those well-known ways to accidentally gain weight... (explanation typically being that you end up hungrier at lunch/dinner and eat more over the whole day)
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoAre we sure about this? I mean, wasn't "breakfast is the most important meal of the day" an advertising slogan to sell more? Additionally: I think this probably has more to do with the person. My mother is outright miserable without breakfast, which makes sense. She is hungriest early in the day. She doesn't have much issue completely skipping dinner or eating very little the rest of the day. I'm the opposite. Eating too early means I simply eat more food that day - and I'm not even hungry the first hour or two that I'm awake. I don't see a point in eating when I'm not hungry, so I generally don't. It is much easier to simply skip food early in the day, snack on something small for lunch (cheese and bread, fruit, etc), and have a nice dinner.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoWell, at least the title is exactly informative, instead of making me guess what the conclusion of the article is about. I tried IF for a while. Had mixed results (mostly positive, just not as positive as expected). Willing to try again.
- bonoboTP 6y agoFor years I haven't been eating breakfast long before the IF craze. Mostly out of laziness. Buying all the ingredients, making sure they don't expire, preparing the food etc. is quite some time, so I gradually dropped the habit with no adverse effect. I live alone, but oh boy when people learned that I don't eat breakfast they'd get so defensive and try to tell me how unhealthy it was and how I must be underperforming because of that etc... I even got back to eating breakfast and intellectually felt good that now I'm more of a healthy normal person who does the socially acceptable normal things. After all the IF articles I immediately went back to no breakfast with no guilt. It's crazy how much of this stuff is in our head. The body is really really adaptive! If you get used to eating breakfast and suddenly skip it, you will feel like shit. But that doesn't mean your friend who never eats breakfast also goes through that every day. Or, if you always wake up at 9 AM, you may be shocked at those morning people who wake up at 4:30 AM. But probably if you followed their exact routine incl the evening routine, you'd find after a few weeks that it's not too bad. Surely there is a genetic component to it as well, but we underestimate the power of adaption and habits. And most importantly, don't be so defensive when someone tells you about a strange habit of theirs while they are visibly healthy and well adjusted. Eating disorders and sudden drastic changes are of course cause for concern, but many people have a crabs in the bucket mentality and feel personally attacked when someone does something for their own health.
- SergeAx 6y agoDelicious breakfast gives me great mood boost for the rest of the day, so I prefer to skip dinner, or at least have it early enough to have at least 7 hours before sleep.
- lucb1e 6y ago> get so defensive and try to tell me how unhealthy it was and how I must be underperforming because of that etc. I'm pretty sure I've read somewhere that the candy industry, ahem, the breakfast cereals industry's ads and sponsored "research" is behind that. Opening Wikipedia on Kellog's (first guess of where I might find sources on this): > The FTC had previously found fault with Kellogg's claims that Frosted Mini-Wheats cereal improved kids' attentiveness by nearly 20%. > In 2016 an ad telling UK consumers that Special K is “full of goodness” and “nutritious” was banned. And from one of the sources on ftc.gov: > At about the same time that Kellogg agreed to stop making these kinds of false claims in its cereal ads, the company began a new advertising campaign promoting the purported health benefits of Rice Krispies, according to the FTC. On product packaging, Kellogg claimed that Rice Krispies cereal “now helps support your child’s immunity,” with “25 percent Daily Value of Antioxidants and Nutrients – Vitamins A, B, C, and E.” The back of the cereal box stated that “Kellogg’s Rice Krispies has been improved to include antioxidants and nutrients that your family needs to help them stay healthy.” > The expanded order against Kellogg prohibits the company from making claims about any health benefit of any food unless the claims are backed by scientific evidence and not misleading. I, too, heard from my parents that "breakfast is the most important meal of the day!" and that I shouldn't skip it, and you can rationalize it with "sure, it's the first thing, a good start is half the work" or something. But that's not the same as reading the original research or at least doing a cursory search online -- something that my parents aren't used to questioning; and if they look it up, confirmation bias might play a big role. So I don't think you can fully blame the people that got defensive about this, though I am sorry you had this experience. To end on a more positive note, the European Union requires food to only make preapproved health claims. It feelt a bit like censorship or at least overreach when I first heard of this and I read that the number of claims made reduced very significantly (also correct claims, since it's now expensive to prove it truthful) if I remember correctly, but I guess this does stop a lot of this misinformation, at least within the EU. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_claim#European_Laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_claim#European_Laws)
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y ago> Although it sounds counterintuitive, long periods without eating actually decrease your levels of the “eat now” hormone ghrelin. I could not tell you if this is psychology or hormonal, but it seems to me after having done it, that the benefit of intermittent fasting is not just "fewer calories on average due to fast days" but also shifting the point at which the body starts to sound the alarms about hunger. You "get used" to not being sated, and it feels less like a problem that needs fixing, at least for a few hours longer. This happens at some level well below conscious thought.
- arkj 6y ago>Intermittent fasting took off in the United States in part due to a 2014 TEDx Talk (“Why fasting bolsters brain power”) by Mark Mattson The link points to Michael Mosley's 2012 BBC documentary. Mark Mattson's TEDx talk from 2014 is here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UkZAwKoCP8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UkZAwKoCP8
- darepublic 6y agoThe actual title includes the phrase "works for many"
- brainzap 6y agoI would prefer we would just call it "eat less"
- meesterdude 6y agothat's entirely wrong though. Because it's not about cutting the calories of your meals in half - it's about having longer gaps between your caloric intake times, so your body goes into ketosis.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIs that what all IF it's about?
- loceng 6y agoAn accelerated version of intermittent fasting is longer term fasting - ideal minimum being 3 days, although even only being able to handle 24 hours at first is a great start; the next ideal number of days is 5 days, then 10 days, then 20 days based on different changes that occur at those periods. I always recommend people watch this by Dr. Jason Fung: 'Therapeutic Fasting - Solving the Two-Compartment Problem' - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIuj-oMN-Fk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIuj-oMN-Fk
- arcturus17 6y agoI’m all for fasting but a 20-day fast without medical supervision sounds crazy.
- loceng 6y agoI never argued no medical supervision? Many people find it much easier to take a daily electrolyte supplements while fasting, part of that is to increase blood pressure in the body - so you'll avoid the added effects and added pressure on the system of that. If you're underweight then you shouldn't be fasting, that's the main concern from my understanding. Some people may just want to make sure their blood sugar levels are healthy, perhaps along with checking for other abnormal factors. Obviously people who may be fasting to lose weight may have other dis-ease progression due to the weight or that caused their weight gain. One other problem is many people don't understand how to come off of a fast properly - and eating slowly isn't necessarily how. In reality what will happen is if you don't know what foods you're normally eating that cause irritation/inflammation in your GI tract and you return to those foods, you're in for a very uncomfortable and painful experience because the contrast from being away from those foods - from a low to no inflammation state to then introducing them again, it's not fun and I say that from experience; it's part of the process of how an elimination diet can work to help you understand what foods you can tolerate or not, or you can do Igg food sensitivity testing and save yourself a lot of trial and error time - though those tests don't account for all sensitivities, so people need to not blindly trust that they are encompassing all possibilities.
- c17r 6y ago
- bobcostas55 6y agoIt "works" exactly like calorie restriction, there's no magic to IF. From a literature review[0]: >Twelve studies used calorie-restricted diets as a comparator to IF and found equivalent weight loss in both groups.11,15-17,19,22,27,28,33,41-43 Study duration was 8 weeks to 1 year, with a combined total of 1206 participants (527 undergoing IF, 572 using calorie restriction, and 107 control participants) and demonstrated weight loss of 4.6% to 13.0%.11,15-17,19,22,27,28,33,41-43 [0] https://www.cfp.ca/content/cfp/66/2/117.full.pdf https://www.cfp.ca/content/cfp/66/2/117.full.pdf
- xpe 6y agoIF offered better glycemic control for Type II Diabetes (see the last sentence): > Synthesis All 27 IF trials found weight loss of 0.8% to 13.0% of baseline weight with no serious adverse events. Twelve studies comparing IF to calorie restriction found equivalent results. The 5 studies that included patients with type 2 diabetes documented improved glycemic control.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIs "glycaemic control" a general benefit, or is that only good for people with diabetes (and other conditions?)? I've wondered if IF makes a difference in that way. If there's a pain au chocolat for me, and I eat it at breakfast is that different to me eating all the same food in the day but eating that pain au choc after lunch?
- xpe 6y ago> Is "glycaemic control" a general benefit, or is that only good for people with diabetes (and other conditions?)? Great question. My guess would that it would be correlated, at least. If you check this out, please share back what you find.
- xpe 6y ago> It "works" exactly like calorie restriction[;] there's no magic to IF. This phrasing is too easily misinterpreted. Saying "works" leaves ambiguity between outcomes (i.e. weight loss results) and processes (i.e. metabolic mechanisms and changes). If you said "IF showed similar results as CR in treating obesity" that is consistent with the paper. Second, saying "exactly like" in the context of statistics is an effective way to invite criticism (and not the constructive kind). From the key points on the front page: > The heterogeneity in the current evidence limits > comparison of IF to other weight-loss strategies. > Intermittent fasting shows promise as a primary care > intervention for obesity, but little is known about > long-term sustainability and health effects. > Longer-duration studies are needed to understand > how IF might contribute to effective weight-loss > strategies.
- bonestormii_ 6y agoI am strongly prone to skipping breakfast and drinking black coffee all day long, but I honestly do feel like it leaves me with less energy at the end of the day, and makes me less likely to exercise. If you are overweight, any weight loss may be good. If you aren't really overweight, eating healthy regularly timed meals and working out are probably a better bet for maintaining your physique.
- netman21 6y agoI like the explanation that IF gives your body a chance to go into ketosis. And, by extension, a keto diet provides the same benefits as IF. Combining the two is easy since in my experience you rarely get hanger pangs when you don't eat carbs.
- earthboundkid 6y ago@dang, Having this on the front page of HN will trigger some people’s eating disorders.
- Wolfenstein98k 6y agoIt works for "systems" thinkers rather than "goals" thinkers. Easier to apply a system than try to reform every habit of eating constantly. I suspect engineers and the like are disproportionately the former. (See Scott Adams for a description of the systems/goals dichotomy).
- sudhirkhanger 6y agoOne thing that IF guys try to not talk about is that the only way to lose weight is by eating less. If you eat same amount of calories with IF then you won't see the same weight loss benifits.
- slothtrop 6y agoEarly intermittent fasting is the most powerful variation, on two fronts. First, early dinner improve weight loss rate while conversely very late dinner worsen it, along with glucose tolerance. Second, consuming high protein breakfast has strong associations with weight loss and better lipid profile. You can get the best of both worlds. There's lots of research to this effect - https://www.nature.com/articles/ijo2012229 https://www.nature.com/articles/ijo2012229, https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.3000622 https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jou..., https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/127/1/75/4728738 https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/127/1/75/4728738 , https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/oby.20460 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/oby.20460, https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/104/4/1160/4557123 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/104/4/1160/4557123, https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/104/4/982/4557122 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/104/4/982/4557122, https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/11/11/2624/htm?sfns=mo https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/11/11/2624/htm?sfns=mo, https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2016182 https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2016182, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027153171400195X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027153171...
- barry27 6y agoFull Disclosure: jedimastert made a comment about milk but does not consume milk. Full Disclosure. Honestly, this site. So much pomp.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoOne day I decided to skip breakfast (I am not really hungry in the morning). I would eat at 20:00 and then at 12:00 the next day. 16 hours of fasting for a year or so (I still continue, recently gave up because of COVID but will be back when normality is back too). I was not hungry, I did not loose weight, I did not feel better or worse. I wonder whether some people are just optimized for this eating style, without specific impacts on their health or body.