10 ms·
Also, as absolutely reprehensible Apple's similar actions are, Zoom canceled _a US based account_ because of a Chinese request. It's one thing to be all "we co
by monocasa 6y ago
Also, as absolutely reprehensible Apple's similar actions are, Zoom canceled _a US based account_ because of a Chinese request. It's one thing to be all "we comply with local laws", and another to enforce one country's geopolitical aspirations across international borders.
Like, I think companies should take a stand and both aren't acceptable, but Zoom takes new, additional steps here.
- HALtheWise 6y agoMost US companies that I am familiar with apply US laws to all their users, at least to some extent. For example, I don't think that YouTube will allow you to post a blatantly copyright-infringing video, even if your account declares a country that doesn't enforce US copyright laws. Similarly, I suspect that Facebook would take down a page for a terrorist group, without needing permission from the country they are based in. I'm curious if you know of counterexamples. I'm not necessarily saying that US and Chinese laws are equivalent in this sense, but it does seem like something of a double standard.
- whiddershins 6y agoNot exactly, because if you are based in a certain country, you must follow their laws regardless of where the user is. Plus obeying local laws in regards to local residents, which don’t apply to this allegation. So, by this logic, Zoom’s actions only make sense if they are based in China.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoZoom can choose to ban / block whoever they want for whatever reason they want. Can’t they? They’re not required to do business with any particular individual by statute, are they?
- jbay808 6y agoI think the above discussion is about whether they have to, not whether they can. Zoom can ban all of their users if they want to, but presumably they only will do so if pressured, because businesses want users and also suspending accounts is bad press. By the way, you're also allowed to be outraged by what a business does even when that business is acting within its rights.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI get the feeling there is no bad press in this context. Zoom gets lots of free press exposure and gets to point out how they are improving.
- katbyte 6y agoI didn’t really care until now - and I won’t use zoom for any more personal conversations and am about to email my employer to move away from Zoom for this reason. So yes bad press?
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoOnly if their daily / weekly / monthly active users decreases
- komali2 6y agoNope! As a US company though of course they're not allowed to refuse to do business with someone based on gender, religion, or ethnicity though. However it's still unethical.
- modeless 6y agoUS companies may enforce US law but they're not hiding the fact that they're US companies. Zoom claimed not to be a Chinese company while enforcing Chinese law for US users.
- fossuser 6y agoYeah, but this is the mistake they’re acknowledging with a promise to build out the system to only suppress the mainland China citizens specifically. My point is that this is not acceptable either.
- usaar333 6y agoIt's not really a "mistake". They were aware they lacked functionality to region block meetings and rather than reply to the Chinese government that such a request will not be possible to comply with for x days until feature is developed, they opted to suppress US users. That sets a bad precedent for future ambiguous issues.
- alasdair_ 6y ago>Yeah, but this is the mistake they’re acknowledging Out of interest, did they fix their "mistake" and reinstate the accounts?
- thedudeabides5 6y agoGreat question. Will show where they land. Still waiting to see if China will show NBA games while Daryl Morey remains unfired. https://qz.com/1730643/china-asked-nba-to-fire-daryl-morey-for-hong-kong-tweet/ https://qz.com/1730643/china-asked-nba-to-fire-daryl-morey-f... How long is the west going to pretend it doesn’t see where this pattern of bullying ends...
- silentsea90 6y agoAfaik, they have reinstated the accounts
- hrktb 6y ago
- rayiner 6y ago> I'm not necessarily saying that US and Chinese laws are equivalent in this sense, but it does seem like something of a double standard. And that’s perfectly fine.
- joyfulmantis 6y agoThe idea that your country knows best and that your countries companies can feel free to ignore other countries laws while operating in them is -- imperialism.
- GhostVII 6y agoI think it is fair to say that the laws in the US are objectively better than in China. The US does not put hundreds of thousands of people in camps because of their religion, or heavily censor the internet, or kill hundreds or thousands of civilians to suppress pro-democracy protests.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoYou’re on shaky ground there. The US does imprison more of its citizens on a per capita basis than any other comparable nation. The US isn’t the moral beacon it was billed to be. I’ll stop there.
- komali2 6y agoAnd the USA did allow violence against democratic organizers last week. But those same organizers weren't shipped to Guantanamo for indefinite periods of time for "reeducation." The USA suffers from some of what it accuses the PRC - it is still not the PRC.
- katbyte 6y agoThis. As outraged as I have been by America’s actions towards their protestors it’s honestly a lot different then HK let along tiananmen square (which my iPhone refuses to recognize.. well that’s fucked up yet expected I guess, and least Taiwan and 🇹🇼 Are there) Trump is doing trump but a lot of politicians and others have spoken out and marched - would that happen in China?
- chrismcb 6y agoThere are like three small companies that aren't signatories of the Berne convention. So YouTube is probably don't the right thing in regards to copyright ( with the exception of possibly some differences on what is public domain) While your point about following us laws are valid, copyright was a poor example. But there is also the issue that most us companies are actually us companies and still need to follow us laws.
- ddrt 6y agoYou want to talk copyright and IP violations with the context putting China as the victim? That’s... actually laughable.
- tekknik 6y agoAt some point the US will wake up as a nation and realize this is a new kind of war. Why suddenly is there a lot of pro chinese statements around the internet where there was none before?
- jackson1442 6y ago> For example, I don't think that YouTube will allow you to post a blatantly copyright-infringing video, even if your account declares a country that doesn't enforce US copyright laws Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't the data held to US law if it's stored in the US? I'm pretty sure the federal government wouldn't take kindly to me storing petabytes of copyrighted works in the US, regardless of whether my clients are in Chicago, South Africa, or Taiwan. Zoom's datacenters are theoretically in the US, therefore the regulations US consumers should be held to are US regulations. If they want to play the "we follow local laws" card, they could have restricted the meeting in China only. For the record, I think what the CCP is doing here is reprehensible, but I'm just trying to add my perspective on this specific issue.
- iforgotpassword 6y agoGoogles Servers aren't exclusively located in the US.
- paranoidrobot 6y agoIt's definitely a US law applies everywhere thing for US based companies. Amazon, IBM, and Microsoft apply DMCA takedown requests to servers hosted physically outside of the US.
- atoav 6y agoWhere you can see this most clearly is nudity. Traditionally europe had a more liberal approach when it came to nudity — that was until US platforms came in with their prude nipple policing.
- shoulderfake 6y agoNot Twitter!
- GekkePrutser 6y agoNor reddit by the way! I think platforms are OK to publish this as long as it's behind an "NSFW" wall/toggle. But platforms like Facebook choose not to have one (not to mention that the policy of real names isn't really compatible with posting NSFW content)
- bad_user 6y agoUS copyright is enforceable overseas due to trade agreements. As a US citizen do you think you can infringe EU's copyright law? It is true that US's culture has spilled into the terms of use of some of these services. I still remember the "napalm girl" being censored on Facebook for public display of nudity. However these aren't examples of individuals being targeted by the US government. Also just because there are instances of other companies having a negative impact on foreign users, it doesn't make this particular instance any less bad. It's a logical fallacy to imply otherwise. Fuck Zoom. Fuck the Chinese administration. There, now go say that in China without fearing for your life or that of your loved ones.
- ridewinter 6y agoBeautiful use of strong language.
- TheKarateKid 6y agoThere are plenty of countries that US copyright law is enforced on a US company's platform even though there are NO trade agreements with the US with respect to copyright. Otherwise, piracy would be allowed to be hosted in numerous countries. It's a blatant double standard.
- hn_check 6y agoUniversal Copyright Convention (UCC) and Berne Convention. This covers the vast majority of the world.
- loceng 6y agoI'm okay with double standards that are because we need to treat freedom and democracy differently to the threat that tyranny is.
- TheKarateKid 6y agoThis double standard is an excellent point. For example, US companies have no problem enforcing US copyright law in countries that have no such laws or trade agreements with the US. Otherwise, piracy would be allowed on sites like YouTube as long as the uploader was from one of these countries. Yet, US laws of free speech no longer seem to matter if the user is in an oppressive country. The selective enforcement of US law to non-US users is a terrible double standard that needs to change.
- joyfulmantis 6y agoIf you read the zoom blog post they admit they made mistakes as they did not have the ability to block meetings by region. They have absolutely no desire to enforce chinese laws globally. From their blog post "We strive to limit actions taken to only those necessary to comply with local laws. Our response should not have impacted users outside of mainland China. We made two mistakes: We suspended or terminated the host accounts, one in Hong Kong SAR and two in the U.S. We have reinstated these three host accounts. We shut down the meetings instead of blocking the participants by country. We currently do not have the capability to block participants by country. We could have anticipated this need. While there would have been significant repercussions, we also could have kept the meetings running."
- monocasa 6y agoI guarantee the Chinese authorities know his IP and could have blocked him at the great firewall. This was absolutely a punitive measure to restrict his speech globally.
- anonymousab 6y ago> They have absolutely no desire to enforce chinese laws globally. I do wonder about this. Given how many core product developers they seem to have in China, if the CCP demanded they... 'enforce their values' globally, or else, I don't think they'd be in much of a position to say no.
- yorwba 6y agoChinese companies operating mostly in China have refused government requests in the past, because compliance would have been bad for business: https://technode.com/2019/09/19/tencent-alibaba-refuse-to-disclose-user-data-to-state-backed-credit-company/ https://technode.com/2019/09/19/tencent-alibaba-refuse-to-di... Of course if the CCP cared more about enforcing the law than about money, nobody could ever say no to them, but fortunately that's not the case, so there's always room to negotiate.
- baybal2 6y ago> Companies that work to suppress the rights of citizens are complicit in that suppression and its legality is irrelevant. 100% true. American corporations, and businessmen who collaborated with NSDAP in jew gassing "because it was the law," well, just did what they did. It made them genocide collaborators, and criminals regardless if they did it under the law, or not. As ancient Romans were saying "a crime can be a tiny stone in a bag of flour." Slavery is a crime, even if it is not unlawful in a last few countries practicing it. People who go rape children in places, where, well, child rape is not illegal are committing a crime. Dotcoms who go play ball with criminal states, which make a crime lawful under a law, claiming "we just follow the law!" even if the law itself is criminal, are just as decidedly criminal. A crime can not be made less criminal under a law for sane person's moral judgement. I would say, a crime that was legislated, makes it an even bigger crime. A word crime in a sense as a fault, as something objectively morally reprehensible itself underlines that a wrongdoing is discerned through a thorough judgement rejecting anything that is made to hide, "wrap around," or divert focus from the original fault.
- blackoil 6y agoSay a 21 year old Indian goes to London and drinks some whiskey, is it a crime? because, it is a crime in India!
- vertis 6y agoOr for that matter an 18 yr old US citizen visiting UK/Australia where the drinking age is different. Or the reverse of Australians using Cannabis while in the US.
- baybal2 6y agoI'd say the meaning of a crime has drifted over centuries. The criteria of a crime has shifted from something very objective, to more casuistics of all kinds. It got from something what would've gotten somebody onto pitchforks upon a first sight, to long and arduous arguing about textual meaning of laws, rather than long, and arduous moral judgement of early Greco-Roman trials
- 6y ago
- cm2187 6y agoThough frustrating, the rest of the world has had to deal with the extra-territoriality of US laws for decades now, particularly in finance. I don't think it's good. But at least it is recriprocal.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoAnd that extraterritoriality is being used to cut the countries (Iran, Cuba) off from international trade.
- nokya 6y agoYes, not only from trade, but also from humanitarian help, as it just recently happened when the USA threatened to sanction any of its "allies" who would try selling care/health material to Iran.
- theferalrobot 6y agoFor Europe: see GDPR It’s entirely common for countries to have codes that affect those outside their borders - especially ones that were agreed upon in treaty or trade deal. What is unique here is a country demanding that a non local company engage in censorship outside its territory. These two things are nothing alike
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoForcing the entire world to stop trading with a country is way more serious than forcing a nonlocal video conferencing company to suspend an account. The extraterritorial application of US economic sanctions goes way beyond anything any other country is doing to impose its laws abroad.
- theferalrobot 6y agoYou are referring to things that were agreed to in international treaties and trade negotiations - again these sorts of things are super common
- NicoJuicy 6y agoI'm against China here. But people should realize that the US law is almost forced to every online company/user.
- bad_user 6y ago1. Fuck the US government. 2. Fuck the Comunist Party of China. I don't fear for my life when saying the first statement, I've said it in the past on US soil. And I'm saying it right now on a US-based website. People fear for their lives when making the second statement, esp the Chinese. People wouldn't even be able to read it as it would get quickly censored. For this reason alone this whole discussion is completely ridiculous.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pphysch 6y agoOne of the governments you mentioned has been under constant pressure of regime change & other geopolitical oppressions for 75+ years, the other is the one orchestrating said regime changes. It's not surprising that one is more defensive than the other in this regard. Is that activist a real Chinese citizen or part of a CIA campaign bent on massive destabilizion? Everything is on the table. The US is also far more developed in its methods of political suppression. The voice of the common citizen is virtually absent in D.C. yet the population continues to play along. McCarthyism is ancient history in US politics. Such brutish displays are no longer as effective or required. But the US recently got a taste of how seamlessly the MIC can amplify its violent oppression of citizens, even as they struggle to manage a public health crisis.
- bad_user 6y agoRight, so the reason for why the CPC is oppressive towards its own people is because of the US? Got it. You're talking btw with someone born in communism, in Eastern Europe. We blamed the imperialist enemy from the west too and our government saw that enemy among our own people. Everything bad that happened was due to the west trying to undermine our efforts. All I can say is fuck the CPC and fuck you too.
- xyproto 6y agoBut that was a mistake, and they promptly restored the US based account?
- biscottigelato 6y agoSure, but CCP's goal have been achieved. Conspiracy theorist would validly suspect that Zoom have been working with the CCP and they have compromised and agreed to do this one time thing then back track. Getting what the CCP needs (censor Tiananman Square discussion during the peak of US/China tension) while preserving Zoom's long term business interest.
- ThrowawayBandit 6y ago> It's one thing to be all "we comply with local laws", and another to enforce one country's geopolitical aspirations across international borders. Not 'whataboutism', but just to generalise on this: The US do this all the time. I believe that in US law the US criminal law has universal jurisdiction, and they also use the fact that they are such a large and important market that companies will have a presence and assets in the US so they that they'll have to comply (which interestingly is exactly what China is often accused of doing.) Not to mention that they are powerful enough to 'suggest' how to behave to other countries, and we're also seeing that all the time. So fundamentally I think we're seeing China becoming powerful enough to behave internationally the way the US do, and that is something the US are not used to, being used to being the only superpower in town.
- biscottigelato 6y agoI think whether said law came about from a system with separations of power and a democratic process makes a big difference in palatability.
- pphysch 6y agoOpaque authoritarian oligarchy vs. Transparent authoritarian oligarchy, yadda yadda
- markdown 6y ago> It's one thing to be all "we comply with local laws", and another to enforce one country's geopolitical aspirations across international borders. The developing world has been subjected to this sort of crap for a century, at the hands of the west. I mean, the US will invade your nation and kill tens or hundreds of thousands of your people in order to kill one man. I have to click on a button on every website I visit to comply with some law in a foreign land. Look at this sort of tyranny (including all the articles in the sidebar): https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/384636/fiji-vanuatu-marshall-islands-added-to-eu-tax-blacklist https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/384636/fiji... One company deleting an account is nothing, absolutely nothing in comparison. Why the double standard?
- biscottigelato 6y agoMaybe some of us has no double standard. We are against US aggression outside of its borders, especially at tremendous cost to local civilians, local economy and US taxpayers. Also of China's, which is at the cost of human rights globally.
- Aunche 6y ago> and another to enforce one country's geopolitical aspirations across international borders What China does is small potatoes compared to the US. The US fined a French bank $9 billion for violating US sanctions.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoit is small potatoes but it's also whataboutism. the article and discussion isn't about the US. There is plenty of room to judge individual cases on their own merit. Just because this is now in the news doesn't mean we should stop discussing it or feel obligated to bring up every bad thing the US does while criticizing China/others. I personally don't think the US is worse but I think US allies are too weak to put pressure on the US to behave in a civilized and decent way. How would the arm-chair bureaucrats in Brussels even try to mitigate this: https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/international-criminal-court-condemns-us-sanctions-order-71214652 https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/international... ... we clearly need sanctions against the US but that will upset a lot of Europeans who benefit from an export economy (especially Germany) or the Poles who are ever so fearful against "Russian Agression". The problem really is that no political solutions that we could come up with is going to solve this since US will always be the stronger one for a long time. ... sanctions are a lunatic's dream which will never materialize. Americans need to step up their own game to sort out their shit politics internally first. No point talking with them about human rights when they're treating their own poor and colored population like that (or talk to them about climate change while they're poisoning the environment in their own country e.g. Flint or many other examples). Problem isn't bad foreign policy but too many truly evil people are in power their, and the general population seems to have abandoned all contact to reality, reason and common sense. The current riots in the US gives me hope knowing that not everyone is a coward. (though comparing the now to the US of the 60/70ies it is a nation of cowards). While the riots are for a "just" cause (literally reforming the police) they won't solve the US attitude toward other countries ... They still cheer for characters like Hillary Clinton, Obama, Biden, Bush and Trump. And their ignorance against "muslims", or calling poor nations "shithole countries", (again just look how they treat their own poor/homeless). There is no way that either republicans or democrats will solve this anytime soon. The current system (power structures) needs to burn down first (figuratively) before it can be rebuilt.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoI don’t remember anyone calling such actions reprehensible when people agree with laws in question (copyright, child porn, revenge porn, etc). Seems like hypocrisy on your side.
- alexryan 6y agoAn important point is being missed in this conversation. The CCP can and does threaten the lives of the family of any Chinese person who does not do as they are told by the party. This gives them "extra leverage". As the CCP ambassador to Sweeden said recently: “We treat our friends with fine wine, but for our enemies we got shotguns.”