8 ms·
Well, sorry to be blunt but that's fucking stupid. Contrast that with my experience with Unions in Sweden; and that is that they basically don't exist except t
by dijit 6y ago
Well, sorry to be blunt but that's fucking stupid.
Contrast that with my experience with Unions in Sweden; and that is that they basically don't exist except to ensure that workers rights are not infringed.
So they'll be involved in a termination, or help negotiate overtime pay.
There is no such thing as a "union job", it's just having what's referred to as a "collective agreement".
- teekert 6y agoYeah, this, same in the Netherlands. Where a large company tends to put share holders first because that is where the CEO's bonus depends on, the unions put the employees first. I see it almost a necessary thing to keep the balance. But the way I see it, with the very little workers rights there are in the US the anti-union movement has basically won there. Reminds me of that quote [0] or this meme [1]. Yeah, you don't need a union, it's a privilege that your boss can fire you on the spot without proper reasoning. It's also a privileged for a woman to get 2 weeks of paid pregnancy leave (can you even walk normally when you're expected back at work?). Working on chemo sounds great as well. Keep telling yourselves that you don't need unions. I feel American work culture completely ignores the fact that the vast majority of people is nice, social and wants to make nice things they feel good about, even if they didn't go to an "ivy". This attitude is reflected by employees. You would do good just being a bit nicer overall. [0] Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires. [1] https://m.9gag.com/gag/aoP1WMg https://m.9gag.com/gag/aoP1WMg
- ethbro 6y agoIn the US, a big part of the anti-union movement's success has been the fact that states retain enough autonomy to rig the rules in pro- or anti-union fashion, while also competing for business that can typically be located anywhere in the CONUS. As a result, it's a race to the bottom as governors try to pursue business-friendly policies to attract jobs. And on the other "side", to pursue union-friendly policies to attract votes. Both of which tug decisions to the extremes, the better to win their base, rather than seeking compromise that's acceptable to both parties. One reason proletarian internationalism remained a hotly debated topic in communist theory for decades.
- cool_dude85 6y agoOften, things that seem to not make sense are the result of historical practices at that workplace or others. In a situation like the comment describes, usually it's at a partially unionized workplace. If you don't have these kinds of things in the contract, what can sometimes happen is a situation where all the "monitor movers" are unionized, but then management hires a new "screen transporter" for $10 an hour who isn't in the union.
- mcv 6y agoIn Netherland, unions negotiate with employers, generally with the government also at the table, to agree on workplace conditions and pay scales that apply to the whole industry, and not just the union members. The employer gains nothing by hiring a non-union member, and besides, a non-union member can always join the union if they want to.
- piva00 6y agoThe same system is used in most of Scandinavia, the union-government-employer tripod where the government acts as a facilitator and the union and employers negotiate a collective agreement.
- ethbro 6y agoI read a study on international power polarities, and they noted that truly independent tripolar was among the most stable configurations from a game theory perspective. Broadly summarizing, the potential for the remaining tie-breaker to defect to either side tends to keep participants honest, even if they're bitterly opposed.
- elliekelly 6y agoAny chance you have the link to the study? That sounds really interesting. Maybe even worth a post of its own on HN?
- pnutjam 6y ago
- sushshshsh 6y agoSorry to be blunt but when you give unions power, this is the bullshit that comes from it
- okintheory 6y agoNo. That's what's happening in some American unions (not all!), but it's not true in Denmark (for any union!), by the sound of it from the above post, in Sweden.
- piva00 6y agoUnions in Sweden (and Scandinavia, Germany) are powerful to defend workers interests, it doesn't mean that unions are requiring to have union-only jobs or trying to micromanage the workplace. The bullshit you are seeing is from your own bubble and worldview, don't make broad platitudes out of it, that is bullshit.
- beowulfey 6y agoWhy do you trust corporation-backed power (small amount of people in charge) versus union-backed power (power distributed across many people)? I find it fascinating, particularly in a country like America where democracy is a core part of our being. Unions allow people to vote on their own preferences, then use their collective voice to negotiate. If you don’t like some bullshit union practice, then that is the fault of the people in it not the unions themselves.
- sushshshsh 6y agoAsk any nurse, plumber, or teacher in the United States if they really feel they have the power to replace union reps that are perpetuating such practices. Power perpetuates power
- cool_dude85 6y agoNow ask any engineer in the US if they have the power to replace management that perpetuates bad practices.
- philwelch 6y agoWell if you live in Sweden maybe being a unionized software engineer isn’t that bad. If you live in USA it’s another story. Sweden has different history, culture, and labor laws than US and so Swedish unions don’t work the same way as US unions.
- jcims 6y agoFor years now I've seen comments like this from Europeans every time unions come up in conversation online. You all need need to come work for a large union in the US. They are just not the same thing. I've had direct or indirect experience with Teamsters, CWA, NEA, IBEW and UBC. You can dress it up however you like but there are definitely 'union jobs' with all of the connotation that brings. Yes there are benefits to the worker (esp when your job puts you in harm's way). Yes collective bargaining is awesome. Unions, if run well, are fantastic. In my opinion we tend to mess them up.
- dijit 6y agoThis is the same argument I see americans make a lot. "Unions are bad!", no, the concept is fine, you have some bad ones. "Police are bad!", no, the concept is fine, yours are just untrained and overburdened. "Public transport is bad, I need a car!", no, the concept is fine, you just have bad public transport and that forms your opinion.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWe don't have 'some bad ones'. We have a different definition and different goals for them. The unions are trying to pad jobs and pay, while keeping employees safe. Too much under one umbrella perhaps. But not just stupid American's who do it wrong. US unions are doing a great job, but to the wrong ends.
- KorfmannArno 6y agoPlease give an example of good public transport. (I'm living in Germany)
- forgingahead 6y agoYou don't need to be rude to the parent poster. They have real experiences of a union in their company. You have examples of unions in your country. Who is correct? If your answer is yourself, then you're not understanding the point or the concern that people who are against unions have. It doesn't matter if Sweden implemented it well and somewhere else implemented it poorly. Bottom line is that the poorly-implemented scenario can happen, does happen, and in fact happens more often than anecdata of "oh no true union does that". Unless you can propose a foolproof way that the "wrong way" is always prevented, then you will get opposition to your beliefs. Calling people or things stupid doesn't solve that.
- thomasahle 6y agoThe way to prevent "the wrong way" is to have a collaborative relation to the unions, rather than one of all out war. Don't like your deal, which doesn't let everyone move tables? Negotiate a new one. Maybe you can offer them something they'd rather want instead. Having a let hostile environment also let smaller, more agile unions thrive, instead of forcing them to all join together.
- koheripbal 6y ago...and this is one of the main problems with online advocacy. You can say "unions are a no brainer - America is so backwards not to have them". I can say "unions are awful and poisonous to a company." ...and given the different definition of "union", we are each correct within our national context, but often incorrect when saying it online. US unions != EU unions.
- omginternets 6y ago>There is no such thing as a "union job", it's just having what's referred to as a "collective agreement". I won't retort with a similarly vulgar comment because: 1. we probably agree on the value of unions 2. I understand your exasperation with American ignorance and cultural bias on the subject 3. it's not constructive However, it brings me no joy to assert that you are dead wrong. Union jobs can and do exist in places. The deleterious nature of these jobs is a subject of frequent debate in France: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permanent_syndical https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permanent_syndical
- strictnein 6y ago> "I understand your exasperation with American ignorance and cultural bias on the subject" "Ignorance and bias" is apparently now equivalent to "decades of experience that differ from your preferred reality".
- omginternets 6y agoNice try, but no. The issue is literal ignorance of how things work outside of America (as you damn-well know). Unions in America are clearly a dumpster fire, but only someone profoundly ignorant (and arrogant, to boot) could claim that unions are a failed concept.
- willmacdonald 6y agoI think that unions in Sweden would be better classified as Professional Societies. There are unions for different professions, and they help with training, education, discounts etc. A lot of people in UK and America unions are associated with striking miners etc.
- dependenttypes 6y agoYou are lucky to be living in Sweden then. My experience from other EU countries is that unions are leeches that once in a while defend "high-ranking" union members that did something bad from being fired. (although admittedly it is not nearly as bad as what GP described)