7 ms·
The website is down, but yeah, offering customised ISO files with Windows and some tools is clearly a breach of license. You can't just take a paid OS distribut
by jeroenhd 6y ago
The website is down, but yeah, offering customised ISO files with Windows and some tools is clearly a breach of license. You can't just take a paid OS distribution, add some config and plonk it onto github.
There's been people patching and customising Windows for many years, but most of the time that was done in the form of gaining an official ISO, patching it with a program on your computer and then using that to install. With that model the user is the one violating the license, not the distributor, though often these configurations used the official Windows API for OEMs so it was legally grey enough that I've never heard of any lawsuits.
If these people just provided an exe and some patch files to turn an official ISO into the same thing as they offered on their website, they'd likely be in the clear.
I'm not entirely sure what the point of the project is though, loads of pentesting tools only run well on Linux and there's plenty of Linux pentesting kits already. Why not just run Kali in a fullscreen virtualbox and be done with it? Or load Kali into WSL2, assuming Microsoft has fixed the hardware access limitations in WSL1?
- lostgame 6y agoI’m not sure, but is Windows 10 not slightly different from previous releases insofar as you can directly download the ISO for Windows 10? Unless you had an MSDN subscription it was a little more difficult to grab an ISO back in the day. Of course, it’s still illegal to modify and upload the modified version...but you’d think the patcher would be an even more obvious route than normal these days if it’s so easy to download an ISO. I’m not a Windows person, could somebody explain this a little bit better for me?
- joombaga 6y agoAs I understand it the ISO you get without an MSDN subscription is missing a bunch of updates.
- gruez 6y agoIs that really an issue? With windows 10 there's a new version out every 6 months, so it's never going to be that out of date.
- qilo 6y agoYes, now Microsoft allows everyone to download ISO. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10ISO https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10I...
- user5994461 6y agoThe ISO is provided so you can download to your Windows 7 PC and upgrade in place to Windows 10. I did it on my old laptop, works well. Microsoft really wants Windows 7 to go away and they actually give the tools to do so. I think it's great!
- effingwewt 6y agoRespectfully disagree. This is a story of a personal laptop of mine. Upgrading from Win 7 to win 8 with paid upgrade sometime after win 8 was 'stable' The upgrade tool works fine until it doesn't. When it chooses not to work, it will have you DL the upgrade files, as well as updates to OS, this can take forever and is a major point of failure for techs. (random hangs, reboots, loops, you name it) But the really evil bullshit actually happens on successful upgrade. Oh that tool that said your laptop could 'upgrade fine' now can't, so sick of the BS revert to old installation. Jk to find its no longer a valid bootable os now. had to repair win 7 installation to make bootable and was asked for product key... what? entered mine, sticker still gleaming on my laptop... Microsoft says invalid key! No worries, must be an accident, call MS CS. Am told that upon upgrading even though incomplete, I had willingly surrendered my old product key and it could never be used again. Ok... ask MS CS rep to please issue a new one? He says happily, but they no longer sell keys for windows 7, I could either buy an enterprise edition from them for if I remember correctly $7-800. In shock I looked it up and found at bestbuy for i think was 120...was advised to purchase from bestbuy as MS couldn't offer me the same( incidentally not long after this was when they extended the EOL timeline for win7). Screw all that noise, I just ran a SLIC and never thought about it again, laptop's still chugging along today. So personal anecdotes whatever, but I have worked on far more than my share of PCs, and upgrading became so convoluted early on it was invariably 100x faster and easier to backup and clean install. Even when everything 'just works' when upgrading, sometimes it doesn't. You will have errors everywhere, random hangs reboots etc. It's infuriating and it has persisted as an issue from Win XP to 10.
- p_l 6y agoGetting legal windows ISO download has been possible since at least Vista, though it wasn't as easy as it is now. The issue is that ninjutsu essentially provided a hacked up image to download, a derivative product, which they didn't have a license to distribute and thus copyright bit them in the arse.
- jeroenhd 6y agoCopyright law does not grant you tge right to spread something you downloaded even if it was free. The original rights holder may decide who can and cannot host what part of their product for what reason. Free software usually permits you to redistribute the software you download, but there's no such freedom in closed source software. This is part of the "free as in speech" qualifier of open source software. Microsoft does allow you to download the ISO for free, which is why I don't understand why they didn't include a patcher either. Looking at the official twitter account for the project, it seems like the project maintainers (and likely their users) reside somewhere in the Middle East, given that they seem to speak Arabic. Perhaps the average Internet near the project's target audience are low enough to warrant uploading a customised, minimised ISO? I don't know, a patcher seems like a better choice to me. Maybe they'll switch models now because of the takedown?
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Copyright law does not grant you the right to spread something you downloaded even if it was free. Software source code is copyrightable (to a large extent, for the past 30 years) in the US, but a program exe might not be as there's no artistic expression at all in the bit pattern alone. So an exe might just fall under license terms. Source: I have successfully filed software copyrights and trademarks.
- mrkstu 6y agoAn OS iso is going to have a multitude of copyrighted assets beyond complied programs.
- sjwright 6y agoThat's so wrong it's almost painful. Copyright is the only reason why anyone pays attention to the license associated with compiled software. What would be the point of a license for an artefact not protected by copyright? It also is absurd to suggest that there is artistic expression in source code but not in a direct translation of that same artistic expression. And it's also worth remembering that binaries contain more than just executable machine code—they also contain strings, bitmaps etc. Are you claiming that strings and bitmaps cannot be copyrighted too?
- happycube 6y agoWindows 10 is de facto shareware at this point. If you don't provide an activation code it simply puts a nag text on the bottom right. ;)
- belorn 6y agoBut that is not what the DMCA copyright claim says. It does not complain about redistributing the files of a paid OS. The complaint is explicitly about providing a tool to work around technical restrictions, so "just provided an exe and some patch files" will not make microsoft happy. A common copyright claim of someone sharing copies of proprietary files would not make news. Using the DRM circumvention provision in DMCA is a bit more rare. My guess is that the technical restrictions being alluded to is the advertisement and telemetry that is baked in. There are comments here that speculate about the issue being the creation of a derivative work. If the claim had said so it too would be interesting as the line between operative system and user space is always a bit blurry and people been arguing what is what for decades.
- smolder 6y agoThis is a bad move for MS. It's user hostile enough to have telemetry and ads in the OS in the first place. If they fight against people's efforts to make it usable again, they lose market share, developers/power users lose interest in the platform, less software gets bought from and made for their store, and so on. I think what they really need is a pro version of Windows that attracts pro users by removing the bullshit to start with. That shouldn't be exclusive to Enterprise.
- Ntrails 6y ago> It's user hostile enough to have telemetry and ads in the OS in the first place. I may be alone, but I think those two things are very different classes of feature, and am very relaxed about the former as an opt out.
- opan 6y ago>You can't just take a paid OS distribution, add some config and plonk it onto github. I believe the issue is with licensing rather than cost here. You haven't been given a license that permits you to change and redistribute the software (as you would were it free (as in freedom) software).