12 ms·
BHP to destroy at least 40 Aboriginal sites, up to 15K years old, to expand mine
- redslazer 6y agoWhile the destruction of these sites is most probably not a good idea and there is an open question regarding the fairness of native title negotiations between mining companies and the local indigenous people it should be noted that: "They are also unable to raise concerns publicly about the expansion, having signed comprehensive agreements with BHP as part of a native title settlement. BHP agreed to financial and other benefits for the Banjima people, while the Banjima made commitments to support the South Flank project." From the sounds of it the two parties have agreed to the situation and now one party is attempting to escape its part of the agreement through the use public opinion.
- noobermin 6y agoThat's good. Onerous one sided agreements are terrible especially when one part has so much power over the other.
- waheoo 6y agoPersonally I dont give a fuck what the indigenous people want or have done. I want those historical sites preserved. No mining company or contract is going to sway that opinion.
- NoPicklez 6y agoBut they are historical due to the aboriginal inhabitants of that land at that time. How are the owners of that land who are aboriginal not have a right to allow the removal of such places if agreed?
- waheoo 6y agoSame way if you own a terrace house in downtown Sydney youre only allowed to do certain things to maintain the historic nature of the buildings. Same way we say you cant dump chemical waste on land you own just because you own it. We place restrictions on usage rights all the damn time.
- lurker42 6y agothankfully your opinion is irrelevant in this instance.
- happytoexplain 6y agoWhy insult the parent so sarcastically? Why tell somebody their opinion doesn't matter, ever?
- BubRoss 6y agoWere you upset about this before the article?
- yongjik 6y agoIf some house in Greece is sitting on the ruins of the classical era, and its owner sells the house to some mining company, can't people protest the impending destruction? It doesn't seem right to treat 15K-year-old archeological sites as sellable goods. It should belong to Australia and mankind.
- dependenttypes 6y agoI think that in some countries at least the moment that an archeological site is discovered it becomes property of the government.
- deviation 6y agoThe aboriginal elders of that area have already signed and agreed contractually to monetary benefits and agreed to support BHP's expansion. I'm aboriginal myself, and I'm sad to see these sites torn down... But as the traditional land owners, it was their land to sell. Fair game, though a sad game.
- dependenttypes 6y agoI think that these should be designated as world heritage sites, rather than as a property of a specific group that is free to destroy it at any time. Anyway, it is not like there leaders of communities have never been corrupt.
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoCapitalism for me, nothing for thee
- magicsmoke 6y agoExactly, does getting designated a world heritage site mean getting UN funding to preserve it and make up the opportunity cost of not selling it? If not, it's just wealthier countries patting themselves on the back for being such good custodians of world heritage while pushing the actual unseen costs onto the economically impoverished. If someone actually cares enough about the site, raise the money to buy it up and preserve it however you like.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago> If someone actually cares enough about the site, raise the money to buy it up and preserve it however you like. This is what has happened. It’s going to be preserved as an open cut iron ore mine.
- adrianN 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Heritage_Site#Consequences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Heritage_Site#Consequenc... > A listed site gains international recognition and legal protection, and can obtain funds from among others the World Heritage Fund to facilitate its conservation under certain conditions.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoContext: these Aboriginal sites are basically caves, trees and rocks showing signs of former habitation, with the most significant artifact uncovered at the site below being a length of plaited human hair. I'm no fan of open-pit mining, but BHP is not exactly nuking the Parthenon or the Taj Mahal here. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/may/26/rio-tinto-blasts-46000-year-old-aboriginal-site-to-expand-iron-ore-mine https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/may/26/rio-t...
- drevil-v2 6y agoNuance, and some might say the truth, is the first casualty of a propaganda war.
- neRok 6y agoI'm a draftsman that works for a construction company that builds a lot of the infrastructure for these mines. Recently I was looking at some maps with a civil draftee, and I asked him what all the red dots were all over the map. He said they were all Aboriginal heritage sites. There was a lot of them, scattered everywhere. It was like the map had chicken-pox. So whilst I think it is important to protect this history, some of it can't be that important. I imagine that is what the traditional owners also thought when they signed the agreements. The article mentions "significant cumulative loss", which would become a problem when you sign away the rights to the lot. But in the case of the cave that Rio Tinto destroyed, surely that was significant enough to protect and work around. I know that it wouldn't take long to design around such a requirement, which makes the outcome even more disappointing.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI’m a boilermaker who isn’t getting any younger, working in Launceston operating a laser cutter, considering getting in to steel detailing / 3D modelling. Any advice?
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoWhy the down votes cunts?
- blackrock 6y ago.
- el_dev_hell 6y agoShot in the dark: you didn't read the article and reacted to the clickbaity title?
- henearkr 6y agoBHP should offer scientific and technical support, as well as time, to study the sites before they are destructed. If this is done seriously, the cultural heritage could actually be augmented, by the knowledge, even after the physical destruction of the sites.
- prawn 6y agoNot sure if you read the article, but it mentions BHP offering 3D scanning, drone imagery, etc to capture digital versions of each location for archive. Any loose, physical items would be removed to their staff encampment and then a museum.
- henearkr 6y agoI was thinking about even deeper investigation, like DNA sampling, other chemical analyses in particular in the ground near or inside the sites. Most often, the real value of having historical sites around is that even decades later there can be complementary investigations that were not thought of in the first place.
- prawn 6y agoI have no expertise in this area, but my guess is that there would be millions of sites like this across Australia. Australia is absolutely massive and the indigenous population has an epic 40-80k years of history here. If you wanted to preserve everything just in case, no one could move a foot. I suspect they have preserved the key sites with the best scientific opportunities or main cultural importance, and that these are much more run of the mill. That said, mining companies make buckets of money and I have no issue with tipping the scales a bit against their convenience and profitability for something like this.
- henearkr 6y agoYes, it seems like 3D scans and drones are a bit cheap solutions, that would satisfy or impress some non-expert. If they do it on a handful of sites, chemical analysis would be a true way to show their commitment.
- prawn 6y agoFor context, I'm a Guardian reader, not overly partial to mining and love the Australian outback. The earlier Rio Tinto issue appeared to concern an older and more significant site. With this BHP case, it's hard to get a real idea of what sort of heritage sites we're talking about without details/images. If there were evocative images, I think we'd be seeing them in the article. I wondered if many in this case are not so much caves as people think of them, but very small alcoves you could store food in or maybe lie down in. The areas mined seem flatter than some of the more exciting formations in the northern WA region that don't make national park designation. I'm torn because if you need to mine somewhere, remote parts of Australia might as well be the place. But on the other hand, once you give over these truly wild areas to development, they're not coming back, especially from mining.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI live in Tasmania, grew up in South Australia. Someone once pointed out to me the scale of Australia by showing me this: https://goo.gl/maps/XuwPjHfLmqAYaRwa6 https://goo.gl/maps/XuwPjHfLmqAYaRwa6 This is the open pit iron ore mine Iron Duke in the Middleback Ranges. He quipped the plan is to “keep digging north forever.”
- prawn 6y agoI've driven past there a couple of times in the last few months (filming on Eyre Peninsula) and even something of that scale is a blip. Take away mining and grazing and absolutely massive areas of Australia would barely be of interest to humans. Iron Knob is an eyesore, but if it weren't for the roadside warning signs for the others in that locale, you might not know they were there.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoWhat have you been filming? I grew up in Port Lincoln.
- prawn 6y ago
- cies 6y ago"Australia is unable to protect 15K year old national heritage sites big mining corp plans to destroy" As I understand that for the "elders" the money may be more important than the sites, an for the mining corp the money surely is more important: this needs to be a matter of national interest.
- roenxi 6y agoIt isn't a matter of national interest because nobody in the nation is interested. Nobody has ever heard of or cares about the very similar site that is 10 km away but not on the mining lease.
- TheUndead96 6y agoThis is something worth protesting about.
- esarbe 6y agoHow come that places like these are not protected by the government? In other countries you are barely allowed to tear down houses older than a hundred years.
- NathanWilliams 6y agoOur government, like a lot of our citizens, are racist. (The government is also beholden to the mining industry...) Our PM today claimed we didn't have slavery here (in response to the BLM marches). Narrator: Australia did have slavery...
- stubish 6y agoPlans are now on hold: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-11/bhp-halts-aboriginal-site-destruction-after-rio-tinto-protests/12345566 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-11/bhp-halts-aboriginal-... I expect this means that even if it goes ahead in the future, the traditional owners will get a big payout (beyond whatever was signed in 2015)
- triggercut 6y agoImagine you had an HDD with every photo you'd ever taken, you have no backups, this is the only place these memories are stored. A wealthy individual approaches you and asks if they can buy this HDD off you for a large amount of money. You don't have a lot of money, your ability to make money is restricted and your government is always reducing social safety-nets. This proposition looks like your best chance. The wealthy individual takes your HDD, holds it for a while and then physically destroys it in front of you without regard. But it's fine... Right? It was only some plastic and metal... You can go to the store and buy a new larger HDD with all your new money.
- bottled_poe 6y agoA new hard drive, now made with 100% recycled culture.
- jaekash 6y agoReducing social benefit programs, i.e. reducing their entitlement to the fruit of the labour of others. But yeah, imagine this HDD belonged to my sibling that I have supported financially, but I cannot keep supporting them financially to the same extent I have been doing it because times are hard economically. I would somehow feel a bit bad for them, but really I can only do so much. Archaeology is not free and it requires excess resources, something which mining provides. If you destroy Australia's economy there won't be any Archaeology happening anyway. EDIT: We can all dream about what wonderful world we would have if there were no scarcity of resources, but resources are scarce. We can work to make them less scarce, and that is actually exactly what BHP is doing when they mine coal.
- roenxi 6y agoThe wealthy individual in the metaphor is quite up-front that he is buying the HDD to destroy it, and is more than willing to provide counselling and support to get you back on your feet. The alternative in the metaphor is you keep the HDD, suffer financially and the wealthy person can't become wealthy because these trades are how they make money. It is worse for everyone.
- 6y ago
- guykdm 6y agoAboriginal culture is an evolutionary dead end for humanity. It's currently dying and had no influence on culture, technology or other human things. And so, if I may be so blunt, it's heritage isn't as important to preserve.
- EndXA 6y agoIt seems that an update has been posted: "BHP agrees not to damage 40 Aboriginal heritage sites without consulting traditional owners" (https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/bhp-agrees-not-damage-40-aboriginal-heritage-sites-without-consulting-traditional-owners-pilbara https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/11/bhp-a...)