12 ms·
> ...zero-click results have cost Wikipedia’s English language subdomain tens of millions of organic visits. > ...Google was able to steal over 550 million cli
by crazygringo 6y ago
> ...zero-click results have cost Wikipedia’s English language subdomain tens of millions of organic visits.
> ...Google was able to steal over 550 million clicks from Wikipedia in six months...
"Cost"? "Steal"?!
This would make sense if Wikipedia were ad-supported. But Google saves Wikipedia money by requiring less servers to support traffic. And Wikipedia is open content, you literally can't steal from it -- being open content was part of its original mission statement!
I personally love it when my search results just give me the answer I'm looking for, so I don't have to click through to Wikipedia (or any site) and wade through a page to try to find it, and maybe it's there or maybe it's not.
The idea that Wikipedia's success ought to be measured in pageviews is deeply misguided. The more its content spreads and is reused across the world, online and offline, the better it is for humanity.
And to be clear, this certainly isn't any kind of "embrace, extend, extinguish" strategy on Google's part. Wikipedia isn't declining or going away. Every time you need to read an actual whole article, you still go there. This is solely about convenience in getting quick facts.
This is good -- not bad, folks.
- moneywoes 6y agoDoesn't less page views also mean less donations?
- UncleMeat 6y agoThat's possible, but not the argument being made here. This is a hypothetical loss. And it doesn't change the fact that if you have open content then you have open content.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thesimon 6y agoDon't they have more than enough money already?
- dawnerd 6y agoThey surely would if they weren’t needlessly adding terrible UX “features”
- simonklitj 6y agoInterested. What UX "features" are you referring to?
- iso-8859-1 6y agoVisualEditor is not worth it. It's being touted as a massive improvement, but which editors is it really catering too? Most valuable content in Wikipedia is written by a minority! By spending too much money on VisualEditor, you're optimizing for people who are barely adding value anyway! The money could have been spent on an interactive markup tutorial instead. That would be way cheaper, because it has a linear flow. It would also have been easier because it isn't as performance critical, as it doesn't need to load millions of time per day, only as part of the onboarding process. If you compare Wikimedias spending 5 years ago to what it is now, it has ballooned in such an excessive way if you put it in context. Wikipedia isn't providing double the value of what it was 5 years ago.
- zozbot234 6y ago> VisualEditor is not worth it. Surely it's "worth it" if you want the site to be usable by novice users. This is about optimizing for reach and intellectual diversity, not just "people who are currently adding value". > Wikipedia isn't providing double the value of what it was 5 years ago. Wikimedia supports other projects besides Wikipedia itself, and the value it provides has not just doubled but plausibly grown by an order of magnitude compared to its early days. Wikimedia Commons and Wikidata are hugely beneficial to the Internet community, and Wikivoyage is not far behind.
- anchpop 6y ago> Most valuable content in Wikipedia is written by a minority! By spending too much money on VisualEditor, you're optimizing for people who are barely adding value anyway! Maybe this wouldn't be the case if pages were less complicated to edit?
- marcinzm 6y agoThe Wikimedia Foundation has a mission of, in part, disseminating information. It's mission is NOT "get as much donation money as possible." If the loss in donations allows for their mission to be done more efficiently then that's a net gain.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoPossible, but Google's also donating to Wikipedia itself: https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/22/google-org-donates-2-million-to-wikipedias-parent-org/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/22/google-org-donates-2-milli...
- freediver 6y agoThis is just a smokescreen. If we assume, very conservatively, that Wikipedia content outright satisfies 1% of Google searches (through info boxes, Wikipedia widget etc), thats would be worth 1% of $100bn+ of revenue Google generates from search = $1bn. Even if a fair thing to do would be to split that revenue, Wikipedia should still get $500mn in that arrangement. So a $2mn donation is just a smokescreen. Google is extracting extraordinary value from Wikipedia, and just because it is 'free' doesn't mean it shouldn't fairly give back.
- nxpnsv 6y agoMaybe. Maybe not.
- boogies 6y agoThe Wikimedia Foundation is not underfunded at all. What does worry me is that less page views may mean less engagement in the form of checking sources, flagging problems, and making edits.
- KorfmannArno 6y agoThere must be a bigger movement around contributing to Wikipedia, including financial rewards.
- thomasahle 6y agoI'm pretty sure financial incentives are the exact opposite of what Wikipedia needs.
- boogies 6y agoAddendum: their revenue was actually following an upward trend as of their last report: https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fundraising/2018-19_Report#Key_Stats https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fundraising/2018-19_Report#K... But the number of new registered users and the number of user edits are both decreasing: https://stats.wikimedia.org/#/all-projects https://stats.wikimedia.org/#/all-projects
- jeffbee 6y agoServing pages to logged-in users is very costly to Wikimedia. Edits are even more costly.
- boogies 6y agoWhat I'm trying to communicate is that Wikimedia has challenges, possibly exacerbated by Google's behaviour, but the challenges are not money. Wikimedia is not a for-profit corporation, it's a non-profit with a mission to collect and distribute knowledge. Google distributes pieces of that knowledge, but does not contribute to the collection of new knowledge.¹ Wikimedia has all the money it needs, and is getting more money from more people all the time. It does not have all the contributions it needs in the form of new knowledge, and by many measures the new knowledge it gets is decreasing. tl;dr The monetary cost does not really matter 1. It does contribute money, which Wikimedia does not need.
- toohotatopic 6y agoOr worse: less active users who edit content. Up until now, an edit was one click away. Now, it's not only one more click away but wikipedia has no way to communicate that editing the result is possible at all.
- KorfmannArno 6y agoWikipedia's editing software also makes editing very difficult.
- Gunax 6y agoI sympathize with Google here. The fact is there can only be 10 hits on the first page for each query. There isn't a correct query result. Any addition necessitates removal of something else.
- noiv 6y agoCheck out search settings allowing up to 100 hits per page.
- Swizec 6y ago> I personally love it when my search results just give me the answer I'm looking for, so I don't have to click through to Wikipedia (or any site) Except for the very frequent times when Google’s summarization engine conveys the opposite point than the text was making. I’ve had lots of cases where google reassures me that something is possible (like an iOS feature) because it takes a Yes from paragraph 2 and then procedure from paragraph 10. Click the text and it starts with “You can’t do this but there is this other thing you can do” Both google’s fault and the seospam answer stuffing fault where they put multiple answers on 1 page. Very frustrating
- gabbagandalf420 6y agoCould you give an exact example?
- eitland 6y agoI have one from yesterday where I tried to figure out if I could connect Files on my iOS to a webdav server. According to Google that seemed possible. While I don't use Google much more (except the last few days to figure out if the improved quality I've seen and heard about is true) I have enough experience from the last decade to not immediately believe them. That said, their attempts at artificial intelligence can be funny sometimes: https://erik.itland.no/more-fun-with-google-mixing-images-from-different-sources https://erik.itland.no/more-fun-with-google-mixing-images-fr... So much for the filter bubble were you only get interesting and relevant but not thought provoking results ;-)
- Jasper_ 6y agoHere's one I ran into last year. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ECqxWUJU8AA28sQ?format=png https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ECqxWUJU8AA28sQ?format=png
- lelandbatey 6y agoHere's an example where the results seem to imply that I can "Chromecast to my Roku". https://i.imgur.com/hVHKAKW.png https://i.imgur.com/hVHKAKW.png In reality, Roku uses a similar and half-compatible implementation of the Chromecast standard, but it isn't supported in all the same places you can Chromecast, and you'll frequently experience hiccups like the Roku only streaming in SD or 720p instead of 1080p or 4k. This is partially the fault of the site sharing this information, as they're not presenting this in the most clear way either. However, when Google chooses to try to automatically answer my question, they become responsible for that answer, and when that answer is misleading, it annoys me.
- thayne 6y agowikipedia is probably not the best site to use for that argument for the reasons you listed. But the article also mentions weather.com, which is ad-supported, and zero-click answers can come from other ad-supported sites as well.
- bawolff 6y agoI agree its not stealing (the mission is to collect and disseminate knowledgge, not to drive page hits), but the main workflow to get new users is somewhat disrupted by more queries being answered by google.
- nend 6y agoAs the article points out, the problem isn't specifically that this harms Wikipedia, it's that this practice harms pretty much every for profit business that Google does this to. Pretty much every company in an established space that Google has entered, is losing traffic and thus revenue due to this practice: Yelp, any flight/hotel/tourism based company, video hosting sites, weather data sites, the list goes on and on. Google is staking it's claim to content and data. It's legal, and provides short term benefits to users. But in the long term decreases competition and entrenches Google further, which is bad for users.
- troughway 6y ago>Yelp You had me feeling bad until I came across this.
- Kye 6y agoIf they do it to Yelp, imagine how bad it is for Yelp's less awful competitors. You can't ignore the iceberg just because the tip is a jerk.
- jgalt212 6y ago> But in the long term In long term, there won't be free content for Google to scrape and display in search results knowledge graphs as ad supported / free content businesses shut down. Of course, google can create its own content and does so to feed the knowledge graphs, but it's way more expensive to do so. And the math might not be worth it for google manufacture from scratch all this content. So then folks won't use google, but will they go direct to Yelp 2030? Will there be Yelp 2030?
- thoraway1010 6y agoGoogle's ad network provides a lot of support to these "free" content options. Google is not bad at creating own content, the amount of data for example they can slurp up from phones running google maps is pretty darn high. Our local govt has traffic sensors for the highways - huge bucks to install / maintain etc. I can get more granular traffic that is more current from google for free. If you are going to compete with google in a data management / collection business, you are going to be playing with firm with pretty deep ability to ingest and process data.
- the_duke 6y agoI personally don't like the short Wikipedia excerpts. I almost always want more information, and Google tries to make the Wikipedia link as unintuitive as possible in order to keep the user on Google property. What's more, showing the info box means that the real article link is removed from the results list. Edit: to clarify, I do find the blue Wikipedia link decidedly small and I often have to actively look for it instead of it being an intuitive click and clear on first sight, especially on mobile. WRT to the results, they do indeed seem to appear now, but often not in the first or second position. (I do remember that not being the case previously, but I admittedly might be mistaken)
- crazygringo 6y ago> Google tries to make the Wikipedia link as undiscoverable as possible Huh? If I search for "who founded the new york times", then immediately below the three-line snippet answer, is a big (not small) blue link to "The New York Times - Wikipedia". In fact, it's literally the easiest, most prominent thing on the page for me to click on. Google is helping to guide me on to visit Wikipedia for more info. I think you're confusing the short excerpts (with have a clear, obvious Wikipedia link) with Google's Knowledge Graph results, which is a different thing and is based on many different sources.
- kortex 6y agoFascinating, quoting the query changes results. Pipes represent the search field: __________________________ |who founded the new york times| __________________________ > Search Results > The New York Times/Founder > Henry Jarvis Raymond [link to google query |Henry Jarvis Raymond|] > The New York Times was founded as the New-York Daily Times on September 18, 1851. Founded by journalist and politician Henry Jarvis Raymond and former banker George Jones, the Times was initially published by Raymond, Jones & Company. > The New York Times - Wikipedia [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times] > People also searched for... ___________________________ |"who founded the new york times"| ___________________________ > Henry Jarvis Raymond [link to google query |Henry Jarvis Raymond|] > People also searched for...
- batmansmk 6y agoReducing traffic to Wikipedia reduces donations, contributions, brand awareness. Grabbing Wikipedia's added value is like stealing candies from a child.
- xyzzyz 6y agoWikipedia does not need any donations. If they Wikimedia Foundation puts its cash reserves into safe low yield investments, it’ll be able to run Wikipedia for decades. Of course, it won’t pay for salaries of the current WMF employees, but Wikipedia does only need a few of them.
- levthedev 6y agoI have to object to this. Wikimedia as of their audited 2019 financial statements (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/3/31/Wikimedia_Foundation_Audit_Report_-_FY18-19.pdf https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/3/31/Wikim...) already has ~$53m in short term investments, leaving ~$101m in "cash and cash equivalents", which notably often includes Treasury bonds, CDs, etc, anyways. So they are likely already investing all of their cash into safe, low-yield investments already. Even if they weren't, the ~$154m they have free for investments, would only gross ~$1.2m in 10 year Treasuries, or at most $5-6m in relatively higher-yield investment grade corporate bonds. Looking at their expenses in 2019, even if you cut donation processing expenses to $0, cut awards and grants to $0, cut travel and conferences to $0, strip out depreciation and amortization, and cut their $46m payroll in half to $23m (which at a fully loaded cost of $200k/employee, is only 115 employees for one of the most widely used websites in the world), you would still be looking at annual operating expenses of ~$45m. There is absolutely no way that Wikipedia/the Wikimedia Foundation could survive without any donations - they have $154m between cash and investments, and would need to support $45m in annual operating expenses, even with these fantastically high budget cuts. That means they'd need to net, after taxes, almost 30% return on their assets every year, just to tread water, and only after cutting their budget essentially in half. Wikipedia has 51.1 million articles in 291 languages, is something like the 5th most visited website in the US, 10th in the world, and they manage to do this without running any ads. Can't we be thankful for the incredible human library of knowledge they've built, and chip in a few dollars if we are able, instead of complaining and telling them they should not accept donations?
- onetimemanytime 6y agosemantics...if I read an article on Wiki I might actually send them $50 too. That sustains Wikipedia
- trianglem 6y agoThis line of thinking only works in the case of a non profit like Wikipedia. What about the countless other for profit sites that are taking a hit because of AMP?
- coding123 6y agoWell, let's ask Wikimedia if it's good or not, because they're the ones affected.
- wnevets 6y ago> I personally love it when my search results just give me the answer I'm looking for This is one of the things I love about google as a user. Googling "what is my ip" or "how many inches in a meter" used to require you to visit some random website filled to the brim with ads.
- ebg13 6y ago> filled to the brim with ads You let yourself see ads on the web?
- dontblink 6y agoIts funny to note that many people here complain about Google preventing page views, but have no restraint in doing the same by blocking ads. Pot meet kettle...
- smt88 6y agoThese are not comparable practices. Google is a search monopoly. Republishing search results to keep users on Google (rather than the publisher) is literally stealing content and the pageviews the content generated. As a user, blocking programmatic ads (such as those served by ad marketplaces) is the only way to browse the web safely. Websites are free to use affiliate links, subscriptions, donations, non-marketplace ads, or any other safe monetization strategy. I will not apologize for blocking the unsafe monetization strategies.
- a1369209993 6y agoSpecifically, we already know how to display ads: <a href="..."><img src="..."/></a> Anything which uses javascript to display ads is by definition malware, and should be treated accordingly.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoBlocking ads doesn't prevent page views, it prevents viewing garbage along with the pages.
- georgeecollins 6y agoGoogle is selling ads against free content created in Wikipedia, and Wikipedia sees none of that. That isn't fair to Wikipedia and it would be catastrophic for many for-profit websites.
- reaperducer 6y agoCan't Wikipedia just change its terms of service or licensing if it thinks this is a problem? You're either free for all, or not.
- georgeecollins 6y agoHow would changing there terms of service prevent Google from doing this? If that worked, don't you think Yelp would do that?
- ProAm 6y ago> But Google saves Wikipedia money by requiring less servers to support traffic. it would be nice if this was a two-party agreement. Google is forcible changing or dictating any potential business model changes Wikipedia might want to make.
- buboard 6y agowikipedia is also losing editors and fact-checkers. It also degrades its image -- why would i contribute my time so that google exploits it to become richer? this is bad
- chimen 6y agoWikipedia relies on donations. With 0-click the visitor never lands on the page and I'm sure that also impacts the results of their campaign.
- 48309248302 6y agoDo you think that Wikipedia doesn't want traffic? When people land on Wikipedia it creates brand recognition and the opportunity for them to ask for support from those visitors, which is what keeps Wikipedia going. Some of those users will edit pages while they are there. What Google is doing is terrible, especially for smaller sites. Those sites depend on traffic to survive. AMP makes things even worse, because now the visitors never actually go to the website's own independent servers, even if "the content" loads, and Google dictates how the sites have to be built. Web publishers are in the process of losing control of their websites and independence.
- pcmaffey 6y agoGoogle is monetizing Wikipedia's content. Even if that content is "free", selling it to advertisers counts as stealing.
- putlake 6y agoThis is really quite short-sighted. Sure, customers like this in the short term. But this hurts the website owner. e.g. 1: You are a restaurant or retailer and your potential customers search Google for your hours of operation or phone number. Google shows them the answer so they never come to your site. So they don't see that you have a free delivery offer during the Covid crisis. And you can't market to them via any campaign that retargets visitors to your site. e.g. 2: You are a publisher that makes money from ads, like say CelebrityNetWorth [1]. Google steals your content and you never get the traffic you'd like to monetize. This is HN so there will be scorn for the ad-fueled business model. But they serve a need. It's one thing for the market to punish ad-monetized sites, it's quite another for Google to steal from them. e.g. 3: You are Wikipedia. While your content is free, you rely on community contributions to grow. If someone never visits your site, they don't learn about your mission, don't learn that they can contribute. Your corpus stagnates. The only reason Google gets away with this is because they are stealing pennies from millions of people rather than millions from a single entity. Indie content creators do not have the resources to fight Google on this, because G offers them an all-or-nothing option[2]: you can either be in Google search results or not. And no one can afford not to be. Google has been so emboldened that they now change the content and user experience _on the website_.[3] Consumers click through to your site and Google will scroll them to a specific section, and highlight that in yellow. Not only does Google control who gets to your site via the search monopoly, but they steal your content, and control how people experience _your_ site. [1] https://theoutline.com/post/1399/how-google-ate-celebritynetworth-com?zd=1&zi=vwe2r7dc https://theoutline.com/post/1399/how-google-ate-celebritynet... [2] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/6229325?hl=en https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/6229325?hl=en [3] https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/4/21280115/google-search-engine-yellow-highlight-featured-snippet-anchor-text https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/4/21280115/google-search-eng...
- m463 6y agodo you remember when amazon had it's own wikipedia redirector? It was something like www.amazon.com/wikipedia/<rest-of-url> and any book that would appear as an ISBN would be clickable to the book page on amazon for purchase. It was actually kind of cool