7 ms·
You know you're cool when you need a lawyer to change jobs. I think it would be reasonable to allow non-competes, however, the company should have to keep payi
by jedberg 6y ago
You know you're cool when you need a lawyer to change jobs.
I think it would be reasonable to allow non-competes, however, the company should have to keep paying you your full compensation (salary, stock, bonuses, etc) for as long as they keep you from being employed.
Sure, give the old employer veto power for a new job as long as they keep paying them for the lockout period.
- randall 6y agoThis is a good call. Or (at a minimum) some agreed upon fraction of salary.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoCan’t be a fraction. Full comp. That’s what you were worth to them, that’s what you’re worth to not go somewhere else.
- saagarjha 6y agoWhat if you’re entertaining an offer that doubles your pay?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoLots of nuance, but that’s a legitimate comp floor depending on the garden leave requirement, the legitimacy of the offer, etc.
- shefsjsba 6y agoIt should be whatever is highest between your current salary and the new job offer.
- Thorrez 6y agoThat sounds abusable. You get some company (possibly owned by a friend of yours) to offer you a massive salary, then your original company has to pay that massive salary for 3 months or whatever. Then as soon as you start at the new company, they fire you.
- clarry 6y agoThat sounds like a feature to me. Noncompetes are terrible, and you should be prepared to pay out of your nose if you want to keep an employee off the market. As long as you're not forced to pay that money, it's all good. It just means that the employee can actually switch jobs immediately (for a better pay or not) unless you're willing to pay them however much they're willing to stay out of the market for. Say I make $100k today. I get an offer at a place I really like, for $150k. I'd really like to go there, but they're also a competitor. I offer to stay home for $200k, and if you don't want to pay that much, then I go to work for $150k.
- sgift 6y ago> That sounds like a feature to me. Then just be open about it and say you want to remove non-competes. Nothing bad about it, but inventing clauses which makes them effectively forbidden, but not really just clogs up courts.
- Thorrez 6y agoOk, so what you're saying is you want the employee to be able to optionally enter a non-compete at quitting time at a price the employee negotiates to, as long as that price is at least the employee's previous salary. That sounds like a reasonable proposal.
- psanford 6y agoThat's fairly common in investment banking and is called "gardening leave". My understanding is that in banking you get your salary but not your bonus during the gardening leave period.
- derex 6y agoHow does it work if the former employee is on work visa? Do they still sign a no-show contract with the former employer?
- MagnumOpus 6y agoThe employee would just have a very long notice period - so they are officially employed under the same contract as before, but the employer might revoke their access and say they don't need to show up. (And of course the contract would prevent them working or consulting for another company without their employer's agreement during the notice period, just as it did before.)
- drevil-v2 6y agoI have never seen Gardening Leave used in this manner. Usually (and I know this from personal experience) if you are senior enough you have a notice period of 3-6 months and under normal circumstances you are expected to do a proper handover before leaving. Sometimes they don't want you to come in to the office or have access to the corporate network/data but they still want access to you in case they need it. Non-competes are usually 18-24 months and I don't think anyone is going to pay that for you to sit on your butt.
- piva00 6y agoNot in the US but in Sweden a NCA is enforceable only if the employee is being paid (up to 60% of the former salary) during the whole period of the NCA that can last up to a maximum of 18 months.
- derivativethrow 6y agoTwo Sigma regularly pays people 12 - 24 months to do nothing after they leave in lieu of them taking an offer with anothing trading firm, if they were working in strategy or research roles.
- bassman9000 6y agoThis is not uncommon in FinTech and big funds/banks. You basically take a 3-6 month vacation, all paid, before actually leaving. Yo do not engage, and are not allowed to engage, in any meaningful work in the meantime.
- amurthy1 6y agoI think the bigger issue is the ambiguity of what constitutes a violation. As written in the article, this guy was under the impression that what he was doing was acceptable. If it's perfectly clear what it covers, then the employee can decide whether it's acceptable, try to negotiate it, or decline the terms, just like any other provision in a contract.
- paxys 6y agoNot going to happen since Amazon is 100% not doing this to protect any proprietary knowledge, but rather as a threat to other employees who may be thinking of leaving.
- adventured 6y agoedit: amusing, people downvoting labor liberation and freedom, amazing shit; votes for labor captivity by trillion dollar corporations then eh This is a terrible idea. You may be a lot more valuable vs what they were previously paying you. Perhaps you were being undervalued, or the new company has a need for you that places a high premium on you. So now the former company can veto your future and hold you at your previous income. The new opportunity also may far exceed the past opportunity in potential compensation (in your estimation, even if it's a wild-eyed thinking), or the opportunity is one you want to take and it's not the money driving you. That veto that is holding you in place, is a potential economic straightjacket and is also a veto over a choice to pursue a quality of life improvement by taking a better / more fulfilling job. Hyper rich corporations like Amazon will hold talent hostage just to deny them (and their expertise) from another company, which is entirely unfair to the employee in question. The tech giants already frequently roach motel talent as it is and they've been doing it for decades, I'd hate to see this practice further entrenched (and particularly against the will of the employee).
- Twirrim 6y agoWhen Oracle hired a good chunk of experienced AWS engineers to build their new cloud platform, they retained lawyers for each candidate to smooth the transition. They went in to it with their eyes open and played it safe. It amounted to little more than lawyers talking back and forth for a little bit, and coming to an agreement about what the engineers could and couldn't work on for OCI, and for what time period. I hate to think how much it was costing both companies in terms of legal fees given how many made the jump. I would imagine Google was doing the same thing, but presumably this time couldn't get to an agreement, or Amazon decided it was time to make some noise again (it seems to happen every year or so). Amazon never seems crazy enough to let it actually get to court and risk judgment going against them / their non-compete.
- PopeDotNinja 6y ago> I hate to think how much it was costing both companies in terms of legal fees given how many made the jump. A former professor of mine once said... If there's one laywer in town, they drive a Chevrolet. If there are two lawyers in town, they both drive Cadillacs.
- foobiekr 6y agoGoogle is surprisingly naive at many aspects of business. It’s quite possible they didn’t even consider doing something Oracle would have found routine.
- CaptainZapp 6y ago> When Oracle hired a good chunk of experienced AWS engineers to build their new cloud platform, they retained lawyers for each candidate to smooth the transition. When somebody else pays for your lawyer she's not your lawyer.
- twblalock 6y agoThe tech industry in California does just fine without noncompetes. In fact, lack of noncompetes is probably one of the biggest reasons Silicon Valley was able to take off in the 1950s-60s when people were constantly leaving their jobs to start new chip companies, starting with the original "traitorous 8" who founded Fairchild Semiconductor. There just aren't good arguments for noncompetes. People often bring up trade secrets, but that's not convincing -- there are already laws against stealing trade secrets, so you don't need noncompetes for that. Look at Anthony Levandowski as a high-profile example of someone who stole trade secrets in California and got nailed.
- Stratoscope 6y ago> In fact, noncompetes are probably one of the biggest reasons Silicon Valley was able to take off... Just noting a typo for anyone confused by the wording, I'm sure you meant "the unenforceability of noncompetes is..." or something along those lines.
- twblalock 6y agoThanks, fixed it. Fun fact: noncompete agreements have been void in California since the 1800s.
- masonic 6y agoThe tech industry in California does just fine without noncompetes. For years, they (led by Steve Jobs) "did just fine" because they (Apple, Google, Adobe, Intel at least) illegally acted as a no-poach cartel: https://fortune.com/2015/09/03/koh-anti-poach-order/ https://fortune.com/2015/09/03/koh-anti-poach-order/
- anon98356 6y agoThe main argument for non-competes comes from banking/professional services (thinks accountants or lawyers). It's to stop you taking all your clients with you when you jump ship. It's typically only enforced for partners or really senior managers and the theory is, it allows the company time to cement their relationship with the client while you're out of the market. I have often seen it enforced as, you can go (after your notice period/gardening leave) but you have to stay away from a set of clients for the period of your non-compete.
- perl4ever 6y ago"Why Janitors Get Noncompete Agreements, Too" https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2017/05/17/why-janitors-get-noncompete-agreements-too https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/sta... "Jimmy John’s drops noncompete clauses following settlement" https://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-drops-non-compete-clauses-following-settlement.html https://www.cnbc.com/2016/06/22/jimmy-johns-drops-non-compet...
- onion2k 6y agoI think there are some talented people who Amazon would gladly pay a salary to in order to stop competitors hiring them. A top-end salary is tiny compared to the value a good employee can bring to a competitor. Amazon would be stupid not to take that deal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]