12 ms·
Good decision. Then do the same thing to AWS and Amazon's media branch, and then go undo the whatsapp acquisition. Then stop platforms from subsidizing competin
by Barrin92 6y ago
Good decision. Then do the same thing to AWS and Amazon's media branch, and then go undo the whatsapp acquisition. Then stop platforms from subsidizing competing products while they charge competitors high fees like Spotify vs Apple Music.
The increasing trend of large tech conglomerates to use one money printing product like AWS or search or the Apple Store to tactically snipe competitors to destroy or acquire them is absolutely abysmal in the long run. I don't care if it increases consumer prices by 10 cents or whatever, it's time to look at the long term health of the ecosystem overall. It's really the private analog to a state capitalist country subsidizing its own firms while foreigners have to compete on a one-by-one basis. Everyone considers that to be detrimental when it happens between two nations, I don't see why it's not detrimental when it happens in the tech industry.
- mrharrison 6y agoThe counter argument is that the US needs to keep FAANG companies large as a weapon/counter measure against large rival Chinese companies.
- ambicapter 6y agoDepends on if you want one very large but somewhat lazy defender or a swarm of small, fast and aggressive defenders.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Barrin92 6y agoPeople used to make this exact argument in the 80s when it came to Japan, and even when it came to the Soviet Union[1]. There were countless of people who had already written off competitive markets in favour of supporting domestic industry. In the car industry people actually listened and enacted domestic protection, what did that get the US? Two lost decades of shoddy cars. Have Japanese conglomerates overtaken the world? Nope. I think it's an absolute smokescreen and such a blatant attempt by Facebook to use nationalism to protect their status. In the long run we're better served by trusting in innovation than trying to protect domestic business. It was always the right bet. And if China continues to prop up giants they'll just stagnate. The reason they caught up in the first place is because, for at least a short time, they allowed free-wheeling fierce competition. [1]https://www.econlib.org/archives/2009/12/why_were_americ.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2009/12/why_were_americ.htm...
- w7 6y agoI think there is a profound difference between car companies, which produce a "dumb" item that's consumed, and "big tech" companies which have shown they can have a major cultural and political impact both domestically and abroad because their business is information itself. It doesn't make sense to discount an argument because of a similar one which applied to something almost completely different.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoCar companies haven't had a major impact on American culture and politics? Have you been to an American city or suburb?
- throwaway3563 6y ago> because their business is information itself No they haven’t, not in that way.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y ago> In the car industry people actually listened and enacted domestic protection, what did that get the US? Two lost decades of shoddy cars. Have Japanese conglomerates overtaken the world? Nope. Toyota, Honda, Nissan - they pretty much dominate global car sales, but that’s because they had a better product.
- iratewizard 6y agoWhy is Facebook included in that? If Facebook disappeared tomorrow, dopamine addicts would switch to a different drug and your 3rd cousin would have to put more effort into bothering you.
- nojito 6y agoDisagree. Google is far worse than Facebook. The amount of hackers ok with what google does is just sad.
- oars 6y agoCould you elaborate how Google is worse than Facebook? I thought the general (hacker) consensus was that Facebook has much more negative impacts on society.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoThat's (IMO, obviously) mostly driven by cognitive dissonance. Google provides such a useful product for nerds, that it must be an OK company, right? Whereas FB is for social connections, which are often less important to many hackers than access to information.
- Aunche 6y agoFor better or worse, social media is here to stay. Do you prefer Facebook or TikTok?
- andreilys 6y agoAll those sound great in theory if the US was an isolated nation. However all these companies compete on a global stage. You better believe that Huawei, tencent, Alibaba are going to take advantage of weakened US companies.
- thekyle 6y agoI think the EU provides a pretty good example of what could happen. They seem much more aggressive with anti-trust and as a result they aren't very competitive on the global tech stage. There are a handful a tech companies from Europe that operate globally, but they're usually niche (Spotify, Minecraft, Qwant).
- dtech 6y agoAdyen, Booking.com, ASML, Just eat, Nokia, Shazam, Skype, Zalando, Hello Fresh, Takeaway.com, NXP, Nginx, Rasberry Pi, Waze Sure, they are no Google or Amazon, but they are or were nothing to sneeze at either I'm also highly doubtful that this is mainly because of anti-trust laws. A much more likely reason to me seems that Europe is much more diversified in law and culture, a Paris company has a much harder time expanding to London or Berlin than an San Fransisco one will have for Los Angeles or New York. This naturally leads to more, smaller companies.
- enitihas 6y agoI think the combined market cap/revenue of all the companies you mention would still be less than any of the 4 biggest tech companies of the US. Even the Chinese companies are way bigger. > A much more likely reason to me seems that Europe is much more diversified in law and culture, a Paris company has a much harder time expanding to London or Berlin than an San Fransisco one will have for Los Angeles or New York. This naturally leads to more, smaller companies. I am not sure that's the case. The EU car companies had overtaken the US car companies, inspite of the above scenarios.
- chvid 6y agoEurope has plenty of very big companies. They are just not in tech (as in consumer computing, social media).
- missedthecue 6y ago>"The increasing trend of large tech conglomerates to use one money printing product like AWS or search or the Apple Store to tactically snipe competitors to destroy or acquire them is absolutely abysmal in the long run." That's literally how every company ever in any industry since the dawn of commerce has operated. You use profits to grow and diversify. You can't perform capital expenditure without capital...
- new_realist 6y agoThat’s not the anti-competitive behavior described above.
- Barrin92 6y agomy answer to that is, yes that is how every other industry operates, which is why every other industry is painfully slow. Tech was the rare exception of having the advantage of starting from a blank slate a few decades ago, and it was insanely innovative. There's no excuse to let it calcify into the state of every other industry, and I'd take your point and go further, go to every other industry and do the same. Go to telecommunications and break the big players up and create marketplaces in which small players can innovate. Do it in news media and undo that awful communications act from 96 that led to industry concentration. We need to take an activist attitude to anti-trust that actively seeks to create rabidly competitive markets which is what fuelled early tech's growth, instead of letting tech slide into the status quo. And of course all of these companies will still have access to capital. They'll just need to convince investors that their product is better.
- monadic2 6y agoEarly markets were fueled by capital, not competition. Capital needs to be reigned in with these monopolies or we’ll just sprout more. Let’s not pretend like competitive markets are possible with the kind of capital needed to compete.
- erichocean 6y ago> Let’s not pretend like competitive markets are possible with the kind of capital needed to compete. The entire purpose of injecting capital in such large amounts is to prevent competition. That's literally the entire point.
- stale2002 6y agoBoy have things changed. When the biggest complaint that people have about these companies is that their services are too good and too amazing, and that customers love them too much, that no one else can possibly provide as amazing of a service as them... Well I think that says something.
- nova22033 6y agoThe increasing trend of large tech conglomerates to use one money printing product like AWS or search or the Apple Store to tactically snipe competitors to destroy or acquire them is absolutely abysmal in the long run It doesn't matter what you think..The only thing that matters is whether they have the legal authority and can show the consumers are harmed. Amazon selling their in-house brand based on their private sales data could meet that threshold. Amazon making money on AWS, OTOH, will probably not meet that threshold.
- haecceity 6y agoAmazon just needs to release their sales data publicly if they want to use it and hope they can execute on it better.
- stickfigure 6y agoI agree, and let's not stop there! What business did Apple have getting into the music player business or the cell phone business? They already have a profitable computer business! General Electric makes appliances, lightbulbs, jet engines, nuclear plants, and a dozen other things, split them up! We can divide up the world into little boxes and carefully decide who is allowed to participate in each box. Hell, we can go back to giving people occupational surnames - if your name is Smith or Barber or Carpenter, your box is already picked out for you. GET BACK IN.
- Supermancho 6y agoNot sure what this snark gets you, other than obscure what you're trying to communicate. <It's a slippery slope to do something once?> <Apples to oranges comparison about Apple, Inc which never had close to a monopoly> <Something about the justification for breaking up a company that's also apples to oranges> <Whataboutism> <Something about central planning that isn't clear and doesn't apply to monopoly power>
- Sevaris 6y agoIt's incredibly anti-competitive behaviour and it's baffling that governments are allowing it to go unchecked. Even the WhatsApp purchase was greenlit with caveats (not combining FB and WhatsApp user data) ... which were promptly ignored by Facebook. I seriously want to know who they paid off to get that acquisition. There's no way that was above board.
- taurath 6y agoThat’s why Zuck has dinner with Steve Bannon and Trump.
- megaman821 6y agoImpressive, Zuck knew in 2014 while Facebook was acquiring Instagram that Trump would someday be President and it was prudent to have dinner with him.
- glenstein 6y ago>Good decision. Then do the same thing to AWS and Amazon's media branch, and then go undo the whatsapp acquisition Exactly. My concern is that Google is being uniquely targeted, and that breaking them up and calling it a day just exposes us to further abuses from the rest of the tech industry. At least with Google, evil is divided across five tech giants that can serve as checks against one another, instead of merely four. Similarly, I feel that the tech industry as a whole, while far from not evil, has emerged with a set of interests distinct from those of other monopolies, and helped protect the internet from being subordinated to the interests of telecoms. Which isn't to say that I enjoy monopolies, far from it. I just want to see similar willpower to break up the giants of other industries. For that matter, if we really have to go the route of the uniquely targeting a specific tech company, I would at least start with Amazon and then Facebook. Or if we thought more broadly than just tech, I would start with the oil industry giants, finance industry giants, and then telecoms, and then health insurance companies, and then Amazon and Facebook.
- Jugurtha 6y ago>At least with Google, evil is divided across five tech giants that can serve as checks against one another, instead of merely four. I find it interesting that we're reasoning in terms of balance of power, pre-eminence, and hegemony, to address issues related to a few companies. Cardinal de Richelieu sure would have found his footing. No wonder some Google had a "Head of International Relations" whose job is to deal with diplomats, the U.N and the like[^1]. I believe Condoleezza Rice is also on the board of Dropbox. [^1]: https://medium.com/@rossformaine/i-was-googles-head-of-international-relations-here-s-why-i-left-49313d23065 https://medium.com/@rossformaine/i-was-googles-head-of-inter...
- aspenmayer 6y agoWhen you have quarterly profits larger than some small nations entire yearly GDP, it’s as much a question of if you need international relations so much as it’s a question of if you would benefit from having one, and the answer is an obvious yes. They can afford the best, so they can meet with and wine and dine the best. Perhaps all this familiarity is finally breeding contempt from certain quarters? Perhaps it’s a bit of envy on both sides; nations envious of multinational profits and reach, and multinational firms envious of national self-justifying existence. I wonder how long til Starlink starts providing extraterritorial/extraterrestrial VPS?
- KKKKkkkk1 6y ago> The increasing trend of large tech conglomerates to use one money printing product like AWS or search or the Apple Store to tactically snipe competitors to destroy or acquire them is absolutely abysmal in the long run. You're confusing competitive behavior with anti-competitive. When a company throws money at consumers in order to get their business, that's competitive.
- 29083011397778 6y agoUsing a monopoly in one area (and how could it not be effectively a monopoly if it prints money) to gain marketshare in another is textbook anti-competitive practice though, isn't it? I recognize that I'm using the European legal definition, but that doesn't make it incorrect, just inapplicable in American courts.
- enos_feedler 6y agoHow much should Apple charge Spotify to build it's business on top of the infrastructure that Apple designed, developed and deployed so that Spotify didn't have to?
- hliyan 6y agoIn my mind, the cause of this sort of conglomeration is that our society is an exponential meritocracy rather than a linear one. In that the more merit (money, power, points, karma etc.) you accumulate, your ability to accumulate even more merit rises, resulting in a stratification of society that starts out slow but rapidly accelerates after a while. Best expressed as: "To turn 100 dollars into 110 is work. To turn 100 million into 110 million is inevitable." -- Edgar Bronfman, Sr.
- scarface74 6y agoApple doesn’t charge Spotify anything. Spotify hasn’t allowed in app payment for years
- ece 6y agoApple's services businesses should be next. Anybody should be able to start an app store on any platform, and services like Apple TV+ shouldn't be bundled with hardware.