20 ms·
Relevant context: recently, former Reddit CEO Ellen Pao called out Reddit for their policies after Reddit did a statement on Black Lives Matter: > I am obligat
by minimaxir 6y ago
Relevant context: recently, former Reddit CEO Ellen Pao called out Reddit for their policies after Reddit did a statement on Black Lives Matter:
> I am obligated to call you out: You should have shut down the_donald instead of amplifying it and its hate, racism, and violence. So much of what is happening now lies at your feet. You don't get to say BLM when reddit nurtures and monetizes white supremacy and hate all day long
https://twitter.com/ekp/status/1267689503797342208 https://twitter.com/ekp/status/1267689503797342208
- astronautjones 6y agoshe is completely right
- purephase 6y agoYeah, TD alone was huge in 2016-2017 and was a huge contributor to the dynamic we have in the world today. Ellen is 100% right here and Alex did absolutely nothing to address it. Good on her for publicly calling it out.
- dstaley 6y agoSteve Huffman has been the CEO since July 2015. Ellen was calling out Steve, not Alexis.
- frakkingcylons 6y agoAlexis was on the board and still had an active role at the company despite not being CEO, for example, firing a popular moderator and and letting the blame fall on Ellen Pao: https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/13/details-emerge-about-victoria-taylors-dismissal-at-reddit/ https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/13/details-emerge-abo...
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoYou're giving a message forum way too much credit for Trumpism in the United States. Do you actually think that social media is representative of a majority?
- JoeSmithson 6y agoSteve Bannon has spoken about specifically targeting Gamergate for political recruitment, I think the role of Reddit in radicalizing young men is quite important, actually. I don't think you could write a reasonable history of the last 10 years of US politics without reference to Reddit, Twitter, Facebook and 4Chan.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoTo be fair: that doesn't mean social media has any relevance, just that some people on both sides think it does.
- mst 6y agoRight. Dig into campaign actions and - as an example - it looks a lot like the trump campaign won wisconsin with robocalls more than with social media. Hard to tell for sure, of course, but the recent blanketing of facebook with political advertising doesn't seem to have achieved that much except for buying Brad Parscale a ferrari. Social media does presumably have some effect but I'm not sure how you'd tell how much/how little compared to other approaches for reaching people.
- boardwaalk 6y agoThey didn’t say it was? Ideas don’t reach a single person — someone that follows these forums — and then stop. They continue spreading and they might moderate when they do but they still have some center.
- kube-system 6y agoSocial media is wildly influential. At this point, it is likely more influential than any other form of media. Reddit is the #2 social media platform by traffic in the US, after Facebook.
- xnx 6y agoMy feeling is that the world at large underestimates the impact of social media and Hacker news overestimates it. Not sure how to rate the infulential-ness of different media, but Fox News was HUGELY influential to the voters that decided the last presidential election: https://www.vox.com/2019/3/4/18249847/fox-news-effect-swing-elections https://www.vox.com/2019/3/4/18249847/fox-news-effect-swing-...
- WorkingDead 6y agoRight, the healthy discussions over r/politics is what they should encourage. /s
- staycoolboy 6y agoYes, /r/politics is an echo chamber. But there is an enormous difference between that and T_D. I don't ever recall seeing posts on /r/politics being stickied that called for violence, whereas that happened routinely on T_D. Your comment is not sarcastic, it is misleading, misiniformed and ultimately destructive.
- WorkingDead 6y agoBS. The only difference between the two discussion groups is that TD dropped all the pretense. I have seen the same kinds of things that are loosely defined as 'calls to violence' in both places.
- vvG94KbDUtRa 6y agoI don't agree with you, but even if I did, the "pretense" being referred to is "we don't actually want violence inflicted on the other party". I'd say that's a pretty important pretense to keep
- jacobolus 6y agoThe “only difference” between a group of fascist white supremacists who fantasize about violently exterminating their perceived enemies and a bunch of ordinary people in a community organized around discussing newspaper/news magazine articles who are scared about the growing threat of fascist white supremacists and want them voted out of office and removed from positions of power is that the former have “dropped the pretense”? I guess that’s one way of looking at it...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- MuffinFlavored 6y ago> Yeah, TD alone was huge in 2016-2017 and was a huge contributor to the dynamic we have in the world today Can you elaborate as to why? I'm not really sure how a subreddit is responsible for hate + violence + racism. How does freedom of speech/thought only work one way?
- sfkdjf9j3j 6y agoIt was by far the largest online conservative community, and it funneled people into even more extreme communities. I don't really get bringing up the freedom of speech angle here - r/the_donald has always aggressively deleted posts and banned users for expressing anything but complete loyalty to Donald Trump.
- metalchianti 6y agoThis opinion bothers me. TD was always an explicitly pro-Trump subreddit. You expect anti-Trump content to be modded or removed. The modus operandi of /r/politics is much more nefarious. It is branded as a general politics-related subreddit but content that doesn't fit the left-leaning narrative is removed for ambiguous reasons.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y ago> content that doesn't fit the left-leaning narrative is removed for ambiguous reasons it's much narrower than that: whatever doesn't fit centrist Dem narratives is removed
- lksaar 6y agoYou'd expect mods of t_d to not partake in smear campaigns against survivors of a school shooting, actually remove calls for death of various politicans, not telling people to harass journalist and maybe remove blatant fake news.
- metalchianti 6y agoStraw-man. I never said TD was moral--just consistent with their ruleset.
- at-fates-hands 6y agoYou're saying Reddit has that big of an influence on how people see and interact with the world as opposed to say Identity Politics which by its very nature puts different groups into direct conflict with each other and where "cancel culture" came from??
- meowface 6y agoI think if TD were banned in 2016, there's a decent chance the world would look even worse and more polarized today, due to the backlash and chain reactions that would have occurred. Picture "TOP SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY BANS SUPPORT OF THE PRESIDENT" headlines running for months. Picture Trump bringing it up in hundreds of speeches and tweets, demanding regulation and saying how unfair it is that he and his supporters are being censored and silenced and attacked by Silicon Valley and the left. (He's already doing that, but this would give him way more ammo.) Picture he and his supporters pointing to it as evidence that The Elites and the liberals and the tech industry are out to get him and out to get half of the country, and that only he can defend their liberties and bring our country and corrupt establishment back from the brink. Also, all of those users would just flock to alternative off-site communities that make TD look like a bastion of reason and civility by comparison. Huffman's not in an easy position, here.
- vegannet 6y agoI don’t think this alarmist view makes much sense because all of that has happened, and more. The Right (the group of angry young white men inhabiting r/the_donald not conservative voters) spend every moment outraged about censorship and supposed sleights against them — real or not. Everything you describe is happening every single day and has been since before Donald Trump and will continue after him. If the_donald had been shut down it would have been a positive, without question.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- meowface 6y ago> Everything you describe is happening every single day and has been since before Donald Trump and will continue after him. Yes, it has been and it is and it will, but everything is relative. No matter how bad a bad situation is, it can always get worse. You may not like the US now, but for all we know you could be begging to return to June 2020 when June 2021 comes around. Every little thing like this increases his odds of re-election and the odds that people will think he's right or at least has a point. If reddit bans the subreddit for him and his supporters and doesn't ban any others, that could actually turn some non-Trump voters into Trump voters, and definitely increases the odds that his people will get out and vote. >spend every moment outraged about censorship and supposed sleights against them — real or not Sure, but then here they would have a real sleight, a real example of censorship, and a concrete and empirical thing to be outraged about, as well as a coherent and persuasive argument about the larger implications of the censorship and potential future risks they may face. It's the perfect way to empower them and bolster their intensity and their numbers. He is very good at taking inflammatory stories, running with them, and getting other people fired up about them, too. He is extremely persuasive not only to his base, but also can be to some people who are closer to the middle. Reddit banning the subreddit and not allowing another one be created for him would be an escalation and a turning point. It's a major line in the sand, and would be a major talking point for him. It may sound alarmist, but I'm saying this because I am genuinely alarmed at what could have happened and what might happen in the future. His supporters exist in the tens of millions, and they're going to talk with each other one way or another. If they're unable to talk with each other or about him without being banned on popular websites, they're left with no choice but to instead do it on insane cult-like conspiracy theory websites (trust me, if you think TD is bad, just try looking at some of those sites), where they'll be increasingly polarized and will increasingly believe even more dangerous and extravagantly false things. The more large organizations try to restrict a particular group, the angrier they get and the more they feel like powerful forces are out to get them and that there's an organized conspiracy behind it. It's like trying to push an air bubble out of some material - you just end up displacing it, and if you apply too much pressure, the thing's going to pop. Also, as other commenters have pointed out, there are lots of very polarized and even extremist people on the opposite side, and if reddit removes one side and does nothing to the other, then all of the above gets amplified even more. I honestly agree with how Zuckerberg and Huffman are handling this. They both clearly personally dislike Trump, but they understand the big picture. It's kind of like geopolitics.
- tossout99 6y agor/conservative seems to be taking on the role of T_D now, unfortunately.
- jdhn 6y ago/r/conservative isn't taking on the role of T_D, but it is taking on the role of unironic right wing boomerposting. I don't even go there anymore because the titles always seem to be variations of "EPIC ownage of LIBTARDS" and circlejerks in the comments, and very little discussion about actual conservative principles.
- devnull3456 6y agoIs TD responsible for the cities currently being burned down and looted?
- luckylion 6y ago> Yeah, TD alone was huge in 2016-2017 and was a huge contributor to the dynamic we have in the world today. Surely you mean "the dynamic we have in the world of reddit today", right? Otherwise, that sounds Bill-Gates-Is-Transmitting-Corona-Over-5G-Towers level insane. It's not the smoldering powder keg in the middle east, the long looming conflict between the US as the sole imperial super power and the up and coming China contesting their role in SE Asia etc, no. It's really TD, a subreddit where Trump fanatics post memes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ralusek 6y agoReddit is responsible for the fact that 24% of people killed by police are black?
- beefalo 6y agoDepending on how many police officers are subscribers in the_donald, possibly.
- stronglikedan 6y ago> 24% of people killed by police are black > African Americans, however, account for 24 percent of those fatally shot and killed by the police despite being just 13 percent of the U.S. population. As The Post noted in a new analysis published last week, that means black Americans are 2.5 times as likely as white Americans to be shot and killed by police officers. [0] [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/07/11/arent-more-white-people-than-black-people-killed-by-police-yes-but-no/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2016/07/1...
- jedmeyers 6y ago> black Americans are 2.5 times as likely as white Americans to be shot and killed by police officers. If we are going into this statistics: using your terminology, how much less likely that a “black American” will commit a crime that causes arrest (or a police interaction) than a “white American“?
- ilikehurdles 6y agoHere's a relevant totally hypothetical "long con" involving Ellen Pao's hiring-and-firing and re-hiring of the original founders: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the_best_long_con_you_ever_pulled/cszjqg2/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cs78i/whats_the... The hypothesis is posed by Yishan Wong, an ex-CEO, with responses from Altman and Ohanian. edit: I made a mistake understanding this story. Please see the correct timeline in geofft's comment.
- geofft 6y agoRelevant, but I think the timeline is a bit subtler than that. (Mostly, the CEO referenced in that story is Wong himself, not Pao.) - Reddit was acquired by Condé Nast in 2006. - Founders Alexis Ohanian and Steve Huffman left in 2009. - Yishan Wong became CEO in March 2012. - Reddit raised its Series B in September 2014, led by Sam Altman. Wong was one of the investors. - Wong resigns in November 2014. Ellen Pao becomes interim CEO and Ohanian becomes executive chairman. - Reddit introduces an anti-harassment policy and bans fatpeoplehate and other subreddits in early summer 2015. - Later in the summer, Victoria Taylor is fired. Users hold Pao responsible, she apologizes for how it was handled, and she resigns on July 10 under pressure from the board. Huffman becomes CEO. - One day later, Wong writes the above post. - One more day later, Wong reveals on Quora that Ohanian, not Pao, fired Taylor.
- xster 6y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/3d2hv3/kn0thing_says_he_was_responsible_for_the_change/ct1ecxv/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/3d2hv3/kn0t... is also Yishan calling out Ohanian for reference.
- DonaldPShimoda 6y ago> Later in the summer, Victoria Taylor is fired. Celebrity AMAs just haven't been the same since. She was, in my opinion, one of the best parts of any of the default subs back then. It was very unexpected when she was suddenly gone with no reasonable explanation, and all the AMAs right around then were absolutely garbage. She did a lot for /r/IAmA.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hart_russell 6y agoBut that's why she was ousted: https://www.wired.com/2015/07/reddit-ceo-ellen-pao-steps-down-huffman-replacement/ https://www.wired.com/2015/07/reddit-ceo-ellen-pao-steps-dow... Turns out only allowing speech that you deem acceptable makes for a pretty boring internet forum.
- kube-system 6y agoThis one seems pretty decent.
- pstuart 6y agoThis site one is one of the best. If political dialog could be moved to a peer site it would be even better. I'm guilty of engaging in discussing politics here (and tried to do so in a factual and respectful manner) but it's pointless. It just becomes people talking past each other and generates arguments rather than dialog.
- benji_is_me 6y agoThis is precisely why I browse Lobste.rs. It's just like HackerNews but without the political posts.
- rabidrat 6y agoIt's getting pretty exciting now! I can't wait to see what happens next.
- hellomyguys 6y agoIsn't that Hacker News? I'm assuming you aren't a regular user of Reddit as almost all of the subreddits I've used are heavily moderated?
- adventured 6y agoHN allows a very wide swath of opinions without over-moderation. I've seen arguments commonly from every ideological & political segment, even though HN leans left (because its userbase foundation derives from the Bay Area, which is 95% left leaning). You see Capitalists here, you see Communists, you see conservatives, you see liberals, you see libertarians, you see every flavor of Socialist, you see everything inbetween. You can argue for most points of view here, so long as you remain within their decency guidelines. Obviously HN won't tolerate certain extreme ideas that involve genocidal camps, killing people, violence or racism, that you might see bubble up out of eg the pro fascist or pro communist camps. If there are 20 slices in a gradient of political ideology in the US (as an example), HN will allow you to very freely argue 18 of them, only dropping the extreme left and right (both of which commonly involve arguing for murder, racism, genocide, oppression, gulags, forced re-education camps, violence and countless other horrible things). If you go into the largest political sections of Reddit arguing strongly (but decently) for Trump, you'll get moderated because the mods won't like you. That doesn't happen on HN, Dang will mostly leave your opinions alone (you will get downvoted though), so long as you are arguing in a way that isn't belligerent.
- nilkn 6y agoThis is just scape-goating and finding something recent to blame for a situation that has been going on for 150+ years. Besides, it was effectively shut down, and all that did was lead to the creation of thedonald.win, which by all appearances seems to be thriving and growing rapidly, probably much faster than Reddit itself grew when it was founded. To blame the situation on a forum is to misunderstand that the country is filled with people with these viewpoints regardless (and it has been for far longer than anyone today has been alive).
- braythwayt 6y agoThat sounds like you’re saying that it’s a waste of time to ever try to change anything because, well, “history.” Feel free to disabuse me of my misconception if I misunderstand. But it sounds an awful lot like what some people say when you try to call out racist cops: “We’re just scapegoating someone for saying aloud what all the police are thinking. It’s a waste of time.”
- cheeze 6y agoAgreed. Pretty bad take. "We shouldn't try to make improvement because it's always been that way and there are more causes than just this one!"
- StanislavPetrov 6y agoIt sounds to me like what he's saying it that its a waste of time (and often counterproductive) to try to silence voices that you disagree with. They aren't simply going to vanish because you've silenced them on your platform.
- Voloskaya 6y ago> Besides, it was effectively shut down, and all that did was lead to the creation of thedonald.win You don't end up on thedonald.win by chance, you go there purposefully. For a long time /r/t_d wasn't quarantined at all meaning anyone browsing /r/all would see their posts all day long (since they were pretty good at mass upvoting their own posts for that purpose). I don't think anyone advocates for entirely banning this community from the internet, freedom of speech is still important, but just not have it in a place where it might get surfaced and advertised to people that weren't looking for it. So to me, thedonald.win and /r/t_d are very different.
- koheripbal 6y agoI'm confused. T_D was shut down. The sub was quarantined, then hidden, and finally all the mods were removed and the sub was more-or-less locked. Does she mean that it should have been done sooner?
- na85 6y agoShould have been done in 2016.
- snapetom 6y agoI'm confused, too. Shortly after Pao left is when all the quarantining, admin interventions, bannings, and 18+ warnings popped up on reddit. It was clear that reddit felt going mainstream was the only way for profitability. When Pao said: "Ultimately, the board asked me to demonstrate higher user growth in the next six months than I believe I can deliver while maintaining Reddit’s core principles." Some, and I agree with them, interpreted this as Pao being the one that actually tried to keep reddit more of a discussion/free-speech site (the "core principles" she referred to), and the mob was wrong all along. Therefore, on the surface, either we were completely wrong, or Pao is changing the narrative today. Either way, and it goes without saying, there's far more going on here than anyone outside of the board room knows.
- downerending 6y agoSuspect she's more just looking for something to complain about. In any case, T_D is indeed gone, and no doubt the world is a better place. Or something. I haven't noticed a reduction in vicious posts on Reddit, though.
- buttersbrian 6y ago> So much of what is happening now lies at your feet. I just don't know how much of a responsibility reddit has in strong-arming sub-reddits that are communities, whether we like them or not. So I struggle with Ellen's indictment. It makes it seem like Reddit is a root level cause for where we are at today -- It's not, and is only a symptom. I believe it is unfair to say reddit, and their (somewhat) hands off approach to moderation inside a "community" is somehow the cornerstone to these ills, or that it did something to 'amplify' them
- ilikehurdles 6y agoReddit, among other social media websites, has been used as an avenue for the radicalization of, particularly, young males.
- pstuart 6y agoYoung males are primed for radicalization in general.
- pnako 6y agoWhat exactly do you mean by 'radicalization'? Do young males have opinions that are fundamentally different from their fathers or grandfathers?
- ilikehurdles 6y agoThe radical right capitalized on the whole gamergate scandal to push their agendas, and their fathers and grandfathers wouldn't have generally identified as gamers.
- Avicebron 6y agoGamergate in no way was totally responsible for the election of Trump. If anything invoking that Bannon capitalized on a small fraction of people in the movement is used as a cudgel by those wishing to shove their own political agenda down "gamer culture's" throat. Feeling excluded? Why not just destroy it instead. Pathetic.
- zarkov99 6y agoEllen Pao is a con artist and a parasite. Her playbook is well known and its widespread use is responsible for more division than a silly discussion group on Reddit: Virtue signal on every platform you can get on and use the race/gender card to get jobs far beyond your actual merit and when things go sideways just double down and sue your employer as your racists/misogynists/trans phobic/homophobic/xenophobic employers. She is a disgrace.
- dang 6y agoPersonal attacks will get you banned here. No more of this please. Perhaps you don't owe a particular person better, but you definitely owe this community better if you're participating here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tootie 6y agoI don't know if it's specifically because of Ellen Pao's note, but I'm sure he is feeling the exact same thing. And I'm sure his wife is in his ear about it too. I am slightly surprised that he's washing his hands of it instead of leveraging his position to do something about it. Maybe he tried and failed behind the scenes.
- elliekelly 6y agoHe doesn’t strike me as the type of person to sit back and watch if he disagrees with something. If he’s washing his hands of Reddit I would venture to guess he’s explored many other avenues first.
- tw000001 6y ago> I am obligated to call you out: You should have shut down the_donald instead of amplifying it and its hate, racism, and violence. So much of what is happening now lies at your feet. You don't get to say BLM when reddit nurtures and monetizes white supremacy and hate all day long Yeah! How dare they refuse to deplatform 40-60% of the population after they've been thoroughly slandered and misrepresented as white supremacists! This kind of treatment is breeding so called white supremacy. You are forcing people to choose between "us" and "them". White supremacy is the modern day red scare - except this time the people being targeted are average middle class joes and they probably still represent the majority in this country.
- lreeves 6y agoAh yes, the "look what you made me do" defense - just as valid here as in cases of domestic violence.
- tw000001 6y agoDehumanizing someone for holding right of center views and then using that unilateral label as justification for targeting them is nothing like domestic violence. People have started throwing around the labels "racist", "white supremacists" and "Nazi" far too liberally given that these words have the power to destroy lives. When near center moderates are deplatformed and start to feel targeted for wrong think, you push them to align themselves with the extremists, the only people who claim to actually be looking out for their views and well-being. Not to mention that most of these accusations are based on glaring double standards.
- shibeouya 6y agoCriticizing the_donald but not a word about the countless antifa subreddit literally promoting arson and violence? Yeah, that does not look partisan at all! /s
- kilo_bravo_3 6y agoANTIFA broke into my house, peed on all of my pants, and now they're dead. ANTIFA made me eat too much and now I'm bloated and gassy. ANTIFA directed the last season of Game of Thrones. ANTIFA moved my coffee table and I stubbed my toe on it last night. ANTIFA must be stopped. If they start killing people they might eventually, one day, end up being 1% as dangerous as the people they're opposed to.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrischen 6y agoI'm not sure if I agree with the policies of censorship being endorsed right now. It's like the new "fighting child exploitation." To play devil's advocate, here are some potential negative consequences of censorship: 1) Censored communities may still find other uncensored platforms to move their speech to, and it may be a platform even worse for fostering "bad" speech that is hidden from the public and festers in the dark. For example, Islamic terrorists do pretty well without connecting their members on Reddit or Twitter, and as such, we don't really have an insight into the state of their thoughts. 2) Best case scenario is that banned speech and thought becomes repressed in society due to the difficulty in these people connecting/sharing ideas. This creates a latent risk as at some point all these repressed people may realize they are not alone in thought. It also delays the cure to the problem by treating the symptom. This brings me to my point that racism, bigotry, and prejudice largely stem from a lack of understanding, experience, and fear. Silencing hate speech or thought is just treating the symptom of the problem. Hiding symptoms and ignoring the underlying causes will result in the disease breeding—in the worst case in the dark—until it becomes explosive. If you address them and fight them by educating, and showing, and assuaging their fears, this will do much more than a temporary censorship will fix for the long term. Racists are people too, and often just misguided. Censorship, eradication, and vilification are only really viable strategies if you truly believe these people are intrinsically evil and irredeemable. Such tactics will just push them deeper into their entrenched thoughts and solidify their understanding that others don't care about why they think a certain way, but that it's just an Us vs Them fight (which of course they are already inclined towards). See China's handling of Falun Gong. There's no doubt that Chinese elimination strategies towards Falun Gong just entrenched its supporters and gave the Scientology-esque movement more strength than it could have otherwise derived.
- umeshunni 6y agoObligatory background reading on Ellen Pao: https://www.vanityfair.com/style/scandal/2013/03/buddy-fletcher-ellen-pao https://www.vanityfair.com/style/scandal/2013/03/buddy-fletc...
- randyrand 6y agocensoring conservative subreddits only makes the people in them more detached and more upset. It’s why Donald Trump is president right now. When will we learn?